Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just let them all go? (Long Residency Battle)

87 replies

RuinedMyFamily · 04/04/2023 16:42

2017 split with now ExH due to his violence and control. DC was a toddler.

Early 2018 he took me to court initially for full residency with no visitation for me. He was awarded supervised contact, this was supervised by his family.

6 months later he was given unsupervised daytime contact which eventually built up to 2 overnights EOWend and 1 night for tea.

2019 he took me to court for more contact again and was granted 1 overnight in the week, another teatime and 2 nights EOWend (so 4 in 14)

He completely disappeared from our lives from 2020 until early 2021 stating covid was too dangerous. He had daytime contact only for 2021.

Overnights restarted again mid 2021.

Last year he took me back to court again for another variation and was awarded the other teatime as an overnight, so now has 5 in 14.

He’s issued papers again and is now again asking for full residency with EOWend visitation for me. This is what he’s been trying for all along.

DC is now 8, almost 9 and this is what they want. To live with dad and see me at weekends only. I know that if ExH gets residency I will never see my DC again, ExHs parting shot to me in the initial court proceedings where that my DC would eventually hate me as much as he hates me. But proving parent alienation is like finding hens teeth, my solicitor whose been by my side through all this has never successfully in her 20 year career proven PA.

This whole process has cost me over £30k, I can’t keep fighting it. Even if he doesn’t get residency this time, we’ll be dragged back again and again until he gets it. And I keep thinking of all the things I could have had with that money; a mortgage/secure home for DC, a once in a lifetime holiday with DC etc.

He’s never paid me a penny in maintenance because CMS cannot find an income for him and he knows he’d get around £500 a month off me, that with his savings (which I know he has) he’d never have to work again. That’s his aim all along, he refused to work when we were together and has always told me he hates working and doesn’t see why he should have to do it.

I’d never not pay for my DC.

So I’ve said that I will walk into that court and offer to hand DC over to him, I’ll pay my maintenance each month and fight to see them as often as I can, but I can’t keep going back and forth to court, it could cost me another £10-15k and I just can’t afford that. And that’s without the mental toll the repeated court appearences, cafcass involvement, having to get paperwork off school and the GP and everyone else (DC has a minor medical issue) takes on me. And the time off work, I take it as either unpaid leave (to save my AL for using with DC) or AL which means less time with DC. I just can’t do it

But if I do that, I’ll lose my extended family over it.

Both my parents have said I’m giving up, that they’d never give up no matter how much the mental or physical cost. That they’d keep fighting and fighting and fighting to prove to DC that they love them and their rightful home is here with me.

They don’t get when I explain that it’s the emotional cost of repeatedly having my parenting examined, it’s the emotional toll of being undermined, it’s the time off work and my employer while understanding not getting the process either and a change of manager meaning I have to explain the whole process and the whole sorry scenario again. They don’t get that I am scared to even take DC away in this country in case I’m accused of kidnap and lose my rights to see them. They keep repeating the MN line of “abusive men give up when the hardwork starts” well this one hasn’t, he’s been consistent and done everything right, some would even say he’s a fantastic dad.

They’ve told me if I hand DC over then they’re disowning me, and will tell everyone they only have 2 grandchildren instead of 3 because to them I’m giving up on DC, so they’re giving up on me.

And I’m at the point of thinking “f**k em all” and to let it happen, because my self preservation is worth more. But I hate them for it to.

So ExH not only got residency but he’s destroyed me and my family in the process.

I know IABVU but I don’t have a choice or unlimited money.

OP posts:
landbeforegrime · 06/04/2023 04:43

i haven't read the full thread. i don't think you should give up. your dc is too young for wishes and feelings to fully dictate the outcome. your concerns are valid. your dc will know in the future that you did or didn't go to court over this and that alone might make a difference to your relationship down the line. can you apply to Advocate and see if you can get a pro bono lawyer? you need to consider asking for a s91(14) order as well by the sound of things - that would put an end to coming back to court, although no idea if you have the grounds for it but sounds like you have been to court a lot and that's not good for dc's stability. issue with a cafcass s7 report is if they go against you then you are pushing water uphill but it sounds like it would he useful to put this to bed once and for all whether change of residence/ shared care is appropriate, followed by s91(14) order. parental alienation is hard to prove but a child the age of your dc not wanting to live with their primary carer is a cause for some concern and i don't think cafcass would ignore this. anyway, speak to your sol about these things if you can but consider looking for pro bono options as well because the costs sound extreme and it's wholly unfair on you and dc to live like this with constant threat of being taken back to court so hopefully if this is his big push it will end with a barring order so he can't keep bringing it back. very best of luck.

nomoremerlot · 06/04/2023 04:14

Blimey this makes my blood run cold!

Nothing I can add, but I'm so sorry this is happening.

Doyoumind · 05/04/2023 23:07

Don't give up. You need to fight or your child because your dc doesn't know what's best for them.

I've been through court more than once for child arrangements and I know how utterly stressful and expensive it can be, but persevere.

I'm not convinced a sensible judge will give your ex residency. You have a strong case consistently being the main caregiver.

I know you fear he'll take you back to court again but isn't there something the judge can do to prevent this?

Stay strong.

Solasum · 05/04/2023 22:51

Please don’t give up on your child OP. It sounds very likely that once your ex ends up lumbered with all the hard work, he will give up, which will potentially leave your child without an education, without proper medical attention, poorly nourished and chronically underslept, plus thinking that their dad finds them a nuisance and their mum has abandoned them. Never stop fighting. One day they will see your ex for what he is.

Dartsplayer · 05/04/2023 22:42

Look up McKenzie friends in your area. Much cheaper than a solicitor if you feel you can't represent yourself. I'm rooting for you

Changechangechanging · 05/04/2023 22:41

Any support to be found at MATCH Mothers?

I am sorry you are experiencing this. I fo think you need to consult another solicitor (or more). You can ask them to be realistic in the circumstances. He is clearly abusive and your children need you.

Try to take care of yourself.

RuinedMyFamily · 05/04/2023 22:36

Womens Aid discharged me a year after the split, they felt they couldn't help in my situation.

I do want to keep fighting but I can't afford it. If I have to do it alone I'll just not turn up for court, I don't have the confidence to face him alone, as it is now my solicitior sits in the seat closest to him. I also wouldn't have a clue how to speak to the judge or how to prepare for court. Plus i have to hold down a job.

On the maintenance issue, he lives out of his parents and/or girlfriends bank account, CMS could not find a regular income for him, they have a watch on him and I get a letter occasionally saying they've found an income and I'll recieve X amount then a few weeks later I get another email or letter saying he's no longer in work or earning money so I get an award of £0 before the first payment. He's either working cash in hand, temporary jobs or just living off his parents.

As for his parents they're fairly well off, both retired in their 40s, 2 houses (and the second one isn't rented out of anything they literally live in both), decent cars etc. They're defnitely funding some of him.

OP posts:
Frogger8395 · 05/04/2023 22:23

Hes using the court to abuse you further. Women’s aid can help you with a free solicitor who specialises in this.

Dartsplayer · 05/04/2023 22:13

RuinedMyFamily · 04/04/2023 17:42

@Theunamedcat Dad doesn't make them go to school, dad doesn't make them tidy up, dad is fun, dad doesn't take them to the dentist or make them do homework, dad gives them whatever they want all time, dad doesn't take them for bloodtests for their medical issue (I try and make it as pain free as possible with emla cream and always get them a treat after but dad doesn't take them at all so it doesn't compare)

Don't give up OP. I went through this with a family member last year. Kids wanted to stay with Dad because there were no rules in his house and they could do what they wanted. Judge ruled that children live with Mum and have contact with Dad as it wasn't in the children's best interests not to have rules. You need to do this for your DC. You can also get an Order so that Ex can't keep applying to Court constantly

trythisforsize · 04/04/2023 23:23

Repeated reports to the police about the violence, all recorded incidences were in the initial cafcass report but according to cafcass they were only against me not DC so don't count.

Don't you qualify for legal aid as a victim of domestic abuse?

Confusedx1000 · 04/04/2023 23:16

Have I written this post in my sleep? This is scarily close to my situation.
With regards to my own, my ex would constantly feed our child crap, let her stay up as long as she wanted, do all the fun stuff that wasn't the monotony of the regular monday-friday.. he became her preferred parent. She ended up moving in with him at 5 years old because she 'hated me', 'didnt love me'. She only wanted her dad. It was the worst decision I ever made letting her go.

Also, my parents told me to fuck off forever for letting her go with him but now are best friends with the twat after calling him a pedophile and pervert for years. They also tried to find out why he was fired from an old job CONVINCED it was because he was a dirty pervert!!

Maybe just like yours as mine, the parents are just as bad as the other parent.

maddening · 04/04/2023 22:37

Could you find a forensic psychologist to prove parental alienation by ex?

DumpedByText · 04/04/2023 22:25

Don't give up, keep fighting, you can do this. It's better to go through this yearly than lose your precious boy.

Get a different solicitor who specialises in family law.

RudsyFarmer · 04/04/2023 21:46

Why would the court award full
resudency? Surely if they were going to agree anything it would be 50/50?

Dogstar78 · 04/04/2023 21:40

I am so sorry you are going through this. I have been in a similar situation.

Sounds like you need a new solicitor or rep yourself. Two points to note.

  1. If he can't prove an income. How can he support them? I know you say he has savings this is not sustainable. So he'll have to state his income.
  2. He needs to prove he has a satisfactory plan of how he will do all the things you list, school, appointments etc when he has never had consistent care.

Those were the two main things that went in my favour. The judge could see this constant court action was a feature of the coercive control I had pit in my evidence. He said if he saw my partner back in court, he'd take away all the custody.

Good luck and hope you have some friends in real life to support you. I am sorry your parents are being the way they are in your time of need.

RedHelenB · 04/04/2023 21:10

RuinedMyFamily · 04/04/2023 17:42

@Theunamedcat Dad doesn't make them go to school, dad doesn't make them tidy up, dad is fun, dad doesn't take them to the dentist or make them do homework, dad gives them whatever they want all time, dad doesn't take them for bloodtests for their medical issue (I try and make it as pain free as possible with emla cream and always get them a treat after but dad doesn't take them at all so it doesn't compare)

If these are the reasons they give to CAFCASS then there's no way they'd change residency

Atnilpoe · 04/04/2023 21:07

Your ex can’t just de-reg DC from school - because you have PR too, and so you would just take it straight back to court for a prohibited steps order - and a judge would decide whether or not it was in the child’s best interests to homeschool them.

Un7breakable · 04/04/2023 20:57

Dibbydoos · 04/04/2023 19:24

This is a battle and l'm roiting for you OP. Perseverance beats resistance every time. You sound like you've been resisting, but surely you're the one persevering so you should win!

Your DC is a little young to be given 100% choice here. Why don't you agree 50:50 instead of fighting full custody? Thrash it out, final agreement, end of. Your DC will get to an age when they see they are being coerced but to speed it up, maybe put a tape recorder in his stuff or a mini camera somewhere so you can record/see it. Appreciate it can't be used in court if it was a criminal case, but why can't it be used in civil court. You're protecting your DC.

And put HMRC onto your DH. How is he living if he's not working? How is able to provide for your child? His savings would probably prevent him from claiming but you never know. AHs like him will try it on in every area of their life so he may be signing on....

Best of luck, you don't need to give up yet. Your solicitor says there's a chance but that doesn't mean it's a foregone conclusion.

Do not hide recording devices. This would be looked on very poorly in court.

samantha0709 · 04/04/2023 20:49

You will look back and regret it if you hand DC over. It must be so incredibly hard to keep fighting this. Lose the lawyer if it's too expensive. Represent yourself.
If you can't 'fight' with all guns blazing then just show up. Don't hand DC over. Explain how exhausted you are from all of this. Be there, do what you can.
At least you wouldn't have 'given up'.

AllOfThemWitches · 04/04/2023 20:40

Fucking hell, you poor thing. I went through court with my ex and I understand how exhausting it all is, I developed severe anxiety as a result but I agree, don't give up even if you have to self represent. You'll never be able to relax knowing your child is being neglected and one day, your child will hopefully understand.

carly2803 · 04/04/2023 20:33

self represent OP. Do not give up

if it is a choice between self representing or giving up - what are you losing?

we are rooting for you.

Explain to your child in child friendly language, why mummy does "boring" things, why you want to see them as much as daddy etc. do not give up

bigbabycooker · 04/04/2023 19:31

Have you tried discussing with your son, OP?

I mean, I have a 5 year old DD and she is very capable of understanding that although I am the more boring parent, I have her best interests at heart. Your DC seems a bit limited in their understanding of the parental dynamic. Could you take them to family counselling? Then in later life you can tell them that you tried to keep hold of them in the court and you took them to a counsellor to help to communicate how much you love them and want to support them.

I'd ask your parents to fund this one.

Dibbydoos · 04/04/2023 19:24

This is a battle and l'm roiting for you OP. Perseverance beats resistance every time. You sound like you've been resisting, but surely you're the one persevering so you should win!

Your DC is a little young to be given 100% choice here. Why don't you agree 50:50 instead of fighting full custody? Thrash it out, final agreement, end of. Your DC will get to an age when they see they are being coerced but to speed it up, maybe put a tape recorder in his stuff or a mini camera somewhere so you can record/see it. Appreciate it can't be used in court if it was a criminal case, but why can't it be used in civil court. You're protecting your DC.

And put HMRC onto your DH. How is he living if he's not working? How is able to provide for your child? His savings would probably prevent him from claiming but you never know. AHs like him will try it on in every area of their life so he may be signing on....

Best of luck, you don't need to give up yet. Your solicitor says there's a chance but that doesn't mean it's a foregone conclusion.

YoBeaches · 04/04/2023 18:42

There's no valid reason though for the court to reduce your contact to any less than 50%z

There's no abuse, neglect or danger from you, then whilst an 8 yr old might say that's where they want to live, in the balance of the current set up there is no benefit to the child to do appease that.

It's not in the child's best interest to not see you, therefore the court can award up to 50/50 for the non resident parent of that is in the child's best interest which has to be evidenced.

So you do need to go through this. Once you are at 50/50 it's really hard to come back from that without clear and specific evidence of abuse, neglect danger or harm etc.

50/50 is the norm these days in the absence of any of those things.

Hankunamatata · 04/04/2023 18:36

Would representing yourself save money?

I'd go and agree 50:50. Week at yours and week at his. You may give him rope to hang himself if he isn't making dc go to school or taking care of his basic needs