Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do you get your DC to be less fiendish about sugar and snacks?

116 replies

botheredbythis · 04/04/2023 15:13

12 year old DS loves sweet stuff and fizzy drinks. I'm very into healthy food, and constantly push alternatives and make homemade nutritious food for every meal pretty much.

But he's pretty wilful, he's experiencing more independence, walks back and to school/all of his peers eat a load of crap - and so we're in this place where it's really hard to manage/control/steer. Telling him he "can't" is only effective so far.

I wondered how people manage this? Should we give him an allowance per week and when it's used up, it's used up? This would work for out of school stuff, but his lunch and snacks at school come off a prepaid card - theoretically, he could still sneak crap food in as the canteen tills don't itemise everything specifically.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Franticbutterfly · 06/04/2023 10:13

My middle DC makes the sandwiches as part of her daily chores. Might as well get him used to making his lunch now as a kid, it'll save him ££££ in the future if this becomes his norm.

Ozgirl75 · 05/04/2023 20:34

It’s a hard age, and a hard time in general. I have to be strict with myself over treats as I have a super sweet tooth and a metabolism that has dramatically slowed down now I’m in my 40s. I used to be one of those “rake thin kids” who could eat anything but life and a sedentary job caught up with me and now when I eat too much fatty or sugary things I put on weight very easily.
So with my two (currently slim active growing boys) I find it hard to decide, should I let them just eat what they want while they can enjoy it? Or should I be trying to get them to understand that they just won’t always be able to eat like this?
So you have my sympathies. Giving kids a free for all over food seems like utter madness to me especially as we understand that our bodies continue to crave this food and don’t have an “off” switch in the way that they do with non processed food. Equally I do understand that giving them a bad message over restricting isn’t good either. Equally, we have way more overweight people than we do those with eating disorders - so I guess you have to look at your child and pick your “disorder” - are they more likely to be overweight or have an ED?
God this parenting is a frickin minefield!

botheredbythis · 05/04/2023 20:27

paulmccartneysbagel · 05/04/2023 19:38

If it makes you feel better OP my DD has girls in her form that take in bags of sugar and eat it with a spoon at form time 😵‍💫

WOW.

OP posts:
RumbleMum · 05/04/2023 20:16

Ozgirl75 · 05/04/2023 16:12

I can understand why you’re defensive, having read the thread. You’ve done the good and sensible thing of guiding your son to make good choices over food, and haven’t been restrictive, all the things we’re told to do! And now you’re concerned as he seems to be eating too much sugar, and lots of people here are saying “well maybe you shouldn’t have been so restrictive” - and you haven’t been!
Basically, it’s hard to eat a healthy diet these days, especially as a teen, whatever you do as a parent.
Don’t forget, lots of people on mumsnet are very weird about food as well.
It’s not silly to restrict sugary snacks - the only overweight people I know are the ones who have loads of sugary stuff at home and don’t restrict themselves at all.

Completely agree with this. I completely understand how excessive restrictions cause eating disorders, but going to the other extreme is no good. The people I know with the worst eating habits didn’t have any restrictions on unhealthy food. Teaching kids that having treats is absolutely fine but they’re not for every day is really important.

Having said that, there’s truth in what others have said about not shaming / forbidding, as it’ll only push him the other way. I think the only route is to have an adultish conversation about why it’s important not to overload too regularly on sweet stuff and that you’re trusting him to make good decisions and hope to God this phase passes - and do what you can to limit access eg fixed amount of money each week or whatever. Good luck!

paulmccartneysbagel · 05/04/2023 19:38

If it makes you feel better OP my DD has girls in her form that take in bags of sugar and eat it with a spoon at form time 😵‍💫

Raindropsonuebells · 05/04/2023 18:45

It’s 100% normal OP - he is growing up and you need to loosen the control a little . It’s good that you have taught him about good nutrition , but he is going to mix it up with the not so good for a while . All you can really do is limit the available spends though not too restrictively -and make sure the good stuff is going in at home . You do not need to know what he bought for lunch - that’s his business because he is on the way to becoming an adult and needs to make his own choices . This is just the start

GeneHuntsCowboyBoots · 05/04/2023 18:30

botheredbythis · 05/04/2023 17:31

I agree with all the well-balanced views that I need to take a more neutral position. It will be hard but I don't want to create issues, I don't want him to feel judged, and I've got a long road ahead with him and I don't want to police him. That will end in disaster.

So, I'm going to give him spending money - and when it's gone it's gone - keep cooking homemade meals, balance the crap/good snacks at home, and shut the fuck up about it.

This sounds like the best thing all round, with one last thing for you to do…try to stop worrying!😁 (easier said than done, I know). What you have posted there is a well balanced approach to it all.

I was similar growing up..ate really well at home, lots of variety like you provide but I’d eat crisps and pop on the way home from school too. I was also rake thin. I only got fat after I started dieting (restricting) in my 20’s. One of the main triggers for bingeing is previous restriction and that there starts a different cycle!

It’s hard being a parent, especially to teens who are pushing boundaries and finding out who they are, as well as wanting to fit in at the same time. And as I said before, you’re not ‘wrong’ for feeling the way you do/did -it’s what’s been pushed on us as a society for the past few decades and you just want to do the best for your child.

Easterfunbun · 05/04/2023 18:18

VERY relentless. 🍷

Weefreetiffany · 05/04/2023 18:12

If you crave sugar your body actually needs more protein.

When my vit d and iron levels are low I am also ravenously hungry for sugar and looking for the dopamine hit of a screen. Can you get his bloods tested for any deficiencies

Fairislefandango · 05/04/2023 18:11

So, I'm going to give him spending money - and when it's gone it's gone - keep cooking homemade meals, balance the crap/good snacks at home, and shut the fuck up about it.

I think that's a good plan.

botheredbythis · 05/04/2023 18:05

Easterfunbun · 05/04/2023 18:03

@botheredbythis

Also limit the spending money. My 13 year old wanted to spend 20 pounds on prime because it’s a cool drink. No chance was he allowed too. Sometimes he will just want to go to the shops to spend some money because he is bored and often they go out for a burger or a milkshake as a social thing.

All you can do is make sure his meals, breakfasts and dinners are all healthy and nutritious as well as being quite meticulous with his oral hygiene which is another thing I’m always banging on about to him. It’s a fun age isn’t it? 🤦‍♀️.

I'm really struggling with this age tbh. He just wants, wants, wants. Screen, sugar, etc etc. goes from one want to another. Relentless.

OP posts:
Easterfunbun · 05/04/2023 18:03

@botheredbythis

Also limit the spending money. My 13 year old wanted to spend 20 pounds on prime because it’s a cool drink. No chance was he allowed too. Sometimes he will just want to go to the shops to spend some money because he is bored and often they go out for a burger or a milkshake as a social thing.

All you can do is make sure his meals, breakfasts and dinners are all healthy and nutritious as well as being quite meticulous with his oral hygiene which is another thing I’m always banging on about to him. It’s a fun age isn’t it? 🤦‍♀️.

Fairislefandango · 05/04/2023 17:55

I think there's truth in this. Thank you.

You're very welcome. I found the same with my children's fussy eating tbh - cajoling, persuading and trying to manage their eating only made things worse. Being relaxed about it took the pressure off.

botheredbythis · 05/04/2023 17:31

I agree with all the well-balanced views that I need to take a more neutral position. It will be hard but I don't want to create issues, I don't want him to feel judged, and I've got a long road ahead with him and I don't want to police him. That will end in disaster.

So, I'm going to give him spending money - and when it's gone it's gone - keep cooking homemade meals, balance the crap/good snacks at home, and shut the fuck up about it.

OP posts:
botheredbythis · 05/04/2023 17:28

1930toEdinburgh · 05/04/2023 16:43

@botheredbythis

"Honestly, he gets others to buy it if he doesn't have money. Like today, on the way home from a club (where he was given a decent packed lunch), he got a friend to buy him a Fanta..."

Omg not a fanta!!

Sigh. Love a useless comment.

OP posts:
unfor · 05/04/2023 17:12

botheredbythis · 05/04/2023 14:51

@Easterfunbun But is it not ok to be "bothered" by this? Do I need to completely censor that? It does worry me. And he's particularly small for his age, and I feel conscious that whilst it's likely a constitutional thing (his dad was a late developer), it would help him to put more good stuff in his body than bad.

I think this is part of the letting go process of children growing up. When they are primary age we have so much control over their lives - what they eat/read/do/who they spend time with. When they become teens they have to start making some of their own choices and some of those choices will be....not great. My sense is that we have to let them get on with it (so long as they are not doing anything really dangerous) and trust that all the effort we put into raising them will pay off.

FWIW I think your idea of giving him an allowance and when it's gone it's gone is a good one. In your shoes I would also completely stop talking to him about food choices - just offer healthy food at home and say nothing further. A lot of parenting teenagers is about knowing when to stay silent!

Rosti1981 · 05/04/2023 16:59

Will read this thread in full later (sorry just read the first few posts) but I am in a very similar position with my 12 yr old DD and short of cutting off all spending money I feel like there's not a lot I can do. I don't want to make it forbidden but honestly the amount of rubbish she eats is horrific, and it's pretty cheap to buy a massive bag of sweets on her way home (or her friends get them and they share- huge bags though). She had a filling recently and was really shocked by it, but then a few days later was back to buying sweets and fizzy drinks...

So I am interested in all the answers you get but I feel a bit resigned to it, I mostly just ensure that her meals at home are reasonably balanced and healthy at least (but then she's pretty fussy there as well so it's not fantastic!).

Miajk · 05/04/2023 16:54

botheredbythis · 05/04/2023 15:38

Sorry, yes I probably do sound a bit defensive.

OP I know it's hard but trust me you're better off relaxing.

I have a lifetime of food issues, binge eating, going from underweight to obese to finally healthy - I wouldn't wish the hell I've been through on my worst enemy.

My mum thought she was doing the right thing but her healthy eating projecting and shaming me for eating sweets and rationing definitely made me have a horrible relationship with food.

Food is just food. Stop making it seem tempting and special. Let the kid go crazy you'll see in no time he will be much more indifferent.

Dixiechickonhols · 05/04/2023 16:49

Can you unpick what is important to him socially. Lots of eating at this age is social and he obviously wants to fit in. Going for milkshakes as an activity or if everyone at school queues at the 10 am break for a pastry he’s going to want to join in.
Agree to some then he’s not left out.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 05/04/2023 16:44

sandberry · 04/04/2023 15:37

Honestly I think the most effective way is to chill out. Hand him a packet of biscuits and let him eat as many as he likes, have soda in the fridge and let him have it with dinner, let him gorge on Easter eggs. We’ve always been extremely liberal about sugar and mine are very take it or leave it about sweets/chocolate/soda, sometimes they choose something sugary, sometimes they choose water, yoghurt or fruit with no value set on each, the choice is truly theirs. Takes a while for them to believe you really mean it but works in the long term.

Yoghurt and chocolate taste just as good as each other why pretend otherwise.

No offence but I think this would be a terrible idea.

Your kids are 'take it or leave it' as you say. My sister was like this. However, somebody like myself who has a major sweet tooth would've been super fat within months if I'd been able to gorge chocolate/biccies with no restrictions.

1930toEdinburgh · 05/04/2023 16:43

@botheredbythis

"Honestly, he gets others to buy it if he doesn't have money. Like today, on the way home from a club (where he was given a decent packed lunch), he got a friend to buy him a Fanta..."

Omg not a fanta!!

Easterfunbun · 05/04/2023 16:39

@Dixiechickonhols

Oh you forgot everyone’s kid here is skinny, sporty AND 6 foot 😜.

Whilst I have a kid who is skinny and is sporty he’s most certainly not tall for his age.

Easterfunbun · 05/04/2023 16:31

@OverCCCs

Whilst I agree to an extent there is a huge balance to be had here, what with the explosion of eating disorders running rampant amongst young people. So much so, that the NHS have now has to start implementing clinical pathways solely for eating disorders within this age category.

I am afraid that there are plenty of well meaning parents who get this approach very, very wrong with disastrous consequences. You can educate them for sure, cook healthy meals with them, encourage healthy meals, encourage them to be active with the rest of the family etc. But you cannot simply control what an adolescent eats, if you try too, you’re in risky waters.

OverCCCs · 05/04/2023 16:26

The comments about the sweets and junk food not doing commenters’ slim teenage children any harm are so concerning. They might be the fortunate ones who can keep a good weight while they’re young, growing like weeds, and active in sports, but if they’re developing unhealthy eating habits as they become responsible for purchasing their own food and making their own meal choices, they’re likely facing lifelong weight struggles once they hit their mid-to-late twenties, or at the latest early thirties.

There’s an acknowledged obesity crisis for a reason, and a large reason is simply that junk food exists that didn’t exist decades ago, pre-obesity crisis.

Like it or not, treating all food as equal and acting indifferent to a child scarfing down a bag of sweets, crisps, and other junk on a daily basis is far more likely—on a statistical basis—to do them long term harm than the odds of them developing an eating disorder.

Dixiechickonhols · 05/04/2023 16:18

I think you are getting a scewed response as it’s mumsnet and everyone has tall/skinny/sporty kids.
Meanwhile the stats are nearly half of 11 year olds are overweight so there will be lots of mums in your boat worrying about amount of junk they are eating even if they aren’t overweight.
I volunteer at a youth activity for age 10-13 and am surprised by the snacks some turn up with on a regular weeknight. What I’d put in the occasional category. So family bags of sweets or high cal expensive Frappuccino type drinks.
I’d knock off the spends so he can’t buy snacks on way home from school when there’s plenty of food at home. Make it clear he’s not to mooch off friends.
In the hols then yes have some money so he can join in eg buy a drink after activity.
I’d do it from the we aren’t made of money and there’s plenty of food at home point of view.