Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Gen Z is difficult to manage at work?

334 replies

donniedarko89 · 04/04/2023 14:20

I have noticed younger people tend to be more cynical and argumentative, with less work boundaries/respect for hierarchies (which is not necessarily a bad thing, but can come across as presumption/arrogance). This makes it more difficult to manage them at work imo.

Have you noticed any similar behaviours?

OP posts:
CeliaNorth · 04/04/2023 20:06

My key takeaway, which in hindsight is quite obvious, was that historical events will shape a generation.

For example for Boomers it will be the industrial unrest of the 70s

For older boomers, born from 1945, it's likely to be the Suez crisis and the Hungarian Revolution of 1956. Plus the memory of rationing, and bomb sites, which were visible into the 1960s.

For younger ones, the building of the Berlin Wall in 1961, the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962, the assassination of President Kennedy in 1963, the Prague Spring of 1968. Plus the revolution in pop music from 1963 and the Summer of Love in 1967. I was born ithe middle of the boomer era and those events, which happened when I was a child and in my teens, and which I have clear memories of, shaped me far more than things which happened when I was in my twenties.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 04/04/2023 19:58

Graduates coming my last organisation expect a career path to CEO in 5 years but none of the actual hard work/graft thanks very much. Nope spend those 5 years working on their personal "brand " instead.

But certainly super super confident. On the surface anyway.

Dreamlight · 04/04/2023 19:57

We have a range of ages in our office from mid to late fifties all the way through to early 20's.

We have a complete plain in the arse mid forties person, where everything is a problem, nothing is done well, and they just do not want to be part of the team.

We have 3 early 20's people, one of whom is excellent and a truly nice person. One who has a VERY inflated opinion of themselves and thinks they are utterly irreplaceable and know enough after 6 months to become a senior in their role. The last one is lovely but cannot settle to anything, flits about doing a bit here and there, cries mental health issues at the drop off a hat and discusses her gynae problems with anyone who will listen.

We have literally had to tell the last 2 to wear appropriate clothing, not to take 2 hour lunches, not to pass notes about a colleague between them, to work the hours they are paid for, to accept meeting requests, to not cry in front of clients, not to interrupt meetings, stop gossiping. We've had to deal with them getting upset because they know that there had been a meeting but don't know what it was about...... The list goes on and on. Absolutely no social awareness at all and it's tiring.

All age groups have problem people, but I have never before had to deal with the crap that our two younger members have thrown at us.

Lemonyfuckit · 04/04/2023 19:49

Womencanlift · 04/04/2023 14:46

One of the most interesting training sessions I once went to was how to manage inter-generational teams. My key takeaway, which in hindsight is quite obvious, was that historical events will shape a generation.

For example for Boomers it will be the industrial unrest of the 70s, Gen X are the generation who started school with pen and paper and left with the internet really kicking off, Millennials it is 9/11 and also the 2008 crash where it started to become obvious that a job wasn’t for life and for Gen Z’s there is limited research so far but obviously covid/lockdowns will be their main generational influence as they are entering the world of work while sitting in their bedroom with little side by side training/support in the same way their colleagues did when they were starting their careers

Was quite thought provoking and made me think how different life experiences can shape what is important to you and your career as well as your general outlook

This is really interesting and I totally get what you're saying re this take away being fascinating but also quite obvious once you think about it!

HinnyInDevon · 04/04/2023 19:48

I had a complaint of bullying because I told a Gen Z that my ASD was diagnosed. They had self diagnosed their ADHD (I didn't know this. It came up in conversation as they specifically asked about my symptoms / traits!)

Next thing I know I'm being told by HR that the Gen Z colleague complained about my "formal diagnosis" being "privilege" and that they identified as ASD. Apparently I was "showing off" about my formal diagnosis.....

😳 they asked about my traits. They then use that information to self diagnose and then I get called a bully.

OhcantthInkofaname · 04/04/2023 19:42

DorisParchment · 04/04/2023 15:09

Oh yes, the “anxiety” if you tell them they have done something wrong. Followed by a complaint of bullying.

AMEN!

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 04/04/2023 19:16

I have two young colleagues who bring their anxiety dogs to work with them. Lovely dogs but definitely something I hadn't experienced before in the workplace.

ChaToilLeam · 04/04/2023 19:10

I mostly find them lovely, bright and friendly. But the lack of resilience is definitely a theme, and I notice that for a few, it’s clear they have not really heard the word “no” before.

Each generation has its ups and downs, I suppose. Some of the hardest people I ever had to manage were older, clearly hated their jobs, but weren’t prepared to do anything constructive about it. They made it miserable for everyone else too.

WimbyAce · 04/04/2023 19:02

I have come across some that are lazy, arrogant, disrespectful, borderline rude. But on the other side of the coin I work with some wonderful young people, a breath of fresh air tbh that bring new ideas and enthusiasm to the team. So it's swings and roundabouts.

begoneday · 04/04/2023 19:00

Lots of anxiety and calling in sick due to hang overs with no regard to how this impacts their co workers but generally friendly and easy enough to get on with. I work with a lot of them and the lack of resilience is a common trait but they are generally a sweet bunch.

HinnyInDevon · 04/04/2023 18:59

@Peckhaminn I loved your post about "making your own way in the world"

Is there any advice you'd give me on how I can help my DS have the same sort of attitude / energy? I'm a little worried as he was such an unwell baby - I've probably done "too much" for him. He's only 6 so I have time to fix it 😂 he's very independent e.g just unpacked his own bag from holiday. He has a lot of ambition and dreams about careers and traveling.

Thanks! X

OneMoreCookieMonster · 04/04/2023 18:39

I'm not sure I completely agree. I manage a large team ages 68 down to 19. From a variety of social and cultural backgrounds.

There's the great, the somewhat great, mediocre and down right fuckwits among them. But, they do generally participate positively amongst each other and get the job done.

Since the end of lockdowns and the return to "normal" it has been a veritable nightmare in regards to recruitment and working expectations.

I'm finding everyone of all ages but especially the younger ones are entitled, unrealistic (working hours and wage expectations) do the bare minimum and expect high amounts praise, a huge increase in sick days and personal time off for appts that should be done in their own time, won't take criticism and lack any real resilience. Every issue is a mental health crisis and the push for a proper 'work life balance '. They all deserve the best pay and promotions for doing fuck all.

  1. Manage your own expectations and be realistic
  1. Travelling to work is necessary as are the hours as contracted.
  1. The wage is realistic and suited to your experience and follows the industry standard (in most cases)
  1. Sometimes you have to work harder and longer to meet a deadline and keep clients. They do pay our wages after all. And, you may have several projects going on simultaneously. Its called multitasking, get use to it.
  1. Not every little thing is a mental health crisis, it's called a bad fucking day and do you know what it's normal experience anxiety, nervousness and you can feel down?
  1. I'm not your mother and will not ever give false praise, ask you to 'please' to what your hired for or thank you to do your job. That's what your pay is for. I will coach and mentor you and give you honest feedback for your growth and perosnal development. But, I won't blow smoke up your asshole. I will promote those who show excellence and potential and nothing less. And, the thanks I will give are to those who have gone above and beyond without compliant or seeking rewards.
  1. Get the fuck over yourself. I'm having a bad day too but you don't see me crying or throwing a tantrum. (Yes, I can see the irony here as I rant away)
BlueHeelers · 04/04/2023 18:38

they know their value.

My experience of them as undergrads is that they sometimes overestimate their value. Or rather, they are unprepared to accept that those who teach them or supervise their work, do know more than them. Some of them lack humility and curiosity about knowledge and experience beyond their own horizons. These two things are connected.

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 04/04/2023 18:30

I’m millennial and I love working with Gen Z - fresh ideas that are not constricted by bad habits, amazing skills around managing time & effort and I find them less problematic than my or older generations to be honest. They usually have huge respect for individuals (well maybe not systems and hierarchy, but that can be taught) and they are generally realistic people.

CandlelightGlow · 04/04/2023 18:24

the same stuff*

CandlelightGlow · 04/04/2023 18:24

I just don't understand judging an entire demographic of millions of people under one umbrella.

People moaned about the stuff from my generation (millennials) especially graduates.

If you feel like people are consistently treating you or your employer with little respect, have you ever thought of examining what you may be doing that could be warranting that lack of respect?

Echobelly · 04/04/2023 18:23

I'm not a manager so I wouldn't know. I think it's complicated - yes, taking less shit and not just doing things because 'that's how it's always been done' is good.

I do think some who have started work in the last two years may not understand certain things people take for granted as understood - for example I've heard of younger people missing out important calls that have been in the diary for a while because they've made a (non-essential) appointment at that time and it's not that they're being deliberately awkward, they just haven't absorbed there's an expectation that work takes precedence in working hours and life has to work around that, not the other way around.

So maybe new entrants need this spelling out, like 'You can make appointments for your equivalent of "lunch hour" when you're free and block it out in your diary, but please don't make discretionary appointments at a time when you have been asked to be on a call.

Hidingawaytoday · 04/04/2023 18:21

I manage a Gen Z, they've only worked in retail before so has needed a bit of handholding with a few things (dress code, various bits of etiquette etc like not needing to tell me he's going on lunch, just stuff most people need to know when they start) but has also discovered an error in an invoice from a supplier that meant we were being charged more than we should be - both my manager and I had missed it. He pointed it out to us, queried it with the supplier, and sorted it out, all in his first week.

Teateaandmoretea · 04/04/2023 18:21

Gen Z are harder to manage, but millenials and late Gen Xs are poor managers to each other, nevermind adapting to Gen Z. The combination of the two is a recipe for disaster, it is better to let Gen Zs manage each other.

😂😂

Love it. The thing is mumsnet thinks easy to manage means blindly obedient. People who challenge and think for themselves are generally easier to manage than passive doormats.

Gen x, manage gen x and millennials. I love my two millennials, such great hard working guys.

TottyKnickers · 04/04/2023 18:17

For secret Santa last year my GenZ office worker wanted to know if anyone had any allergies or intolerances. We all laughed but it was thoughtful I supposed

ValancyRedfern · 04/04/2023 18:17

I've been a teacher for the last 20 years and teens in the last 5 or so years have become much less resilient and give up the minute something gets tough. They are very aware of their rights and largely oblivious to their responsibilities (e.g. my Yr 11 class are currently giving me the silent treatment because I refused to put on a revision class during the Easter holidays, some even refused to write a word in their mock exam in protest). As result they seem so much more miserable than previous cohorts. It's a real concern.

weightymatters73 · 04/04/2023 18:06

My Boomers/ gen X are all menopausal at the moment....spending a lot of time "calming frayed nerves"

Boomer - Gross misconduct for being drunk at work, didn't seem to understand that (repeatedly) having a bottle of wine at lunchtime wasn't appropriate, and serious mistakes as a result led to dismissal.

Gen Z - My only grievance for "discrimination". I didn't and hadn't, she appealed, 2nd manager said we didn't and hadn't. She went to a solicitor who told her not to be so stupid, she then resigned (thank God) and her partner then phoned me demanding to know why I'd fired her and telling me he was going to take us to an employment tribunal for mistreating her.....never heard any more.

Gen Z - constant sick leave, all days and half days, constant headache, tummy ache, and the best one "Mum says I'm too ill to come in today". Resigned as she thought we were being too hard on her when her manager told her to take paracetamol and stay for the afternoon when she "wasn't feeling it today" and wanted to go home.

I also have multiple gen Z's who work hard and are an asset to the business.

Fimofriend · 04/04/2023 18:00

In my last job the co-worker I shared an office with was late at least twice a week but usually left at the usual time anyway. She wasn't sick often but absolutely had to stay home if her children had a cold or a headache. She had to leave early if there was an event at school or her kids needed a lift or the neighbours' kid needed a lift. That happened quite often. She couldn't do new chores as it made her feel uncomfortable. She wouldn't drive the mini bus. The first half year she worked for us I had to handle her phone calls as she didn't feel confident speaking English over the phone. Her husband was English! Luckily, our crappy manager put a stop to that in the end after she had been asked to do the phone calls when I wasn't around. Then suddenly she agreed with me that my co-worker was taking the piss. We didn't have a dress code so my co-worker showed up in hoodies, jeans and sneakers even though most of our other co-workers wore uniforms and she did get some surprised looks from visitors.

She was 55 years old. Her children were teenagers. There are total assholes in every generation.

Oldraver · 04/04/2023 17:57

We have a 22 year old at work and he will not pass up an opportunity to tell you are wrong, I was even told I was using the wrong music download service. It's fucking tiresome

Catspyjamas17 · 04/04/2023 17:56

DD1 (17) got an employee of the year award in her part time job, so I assume she isn't lazy, arrogant and difficult to manage.

I thought the OP's description sounded rather more like some older male employees I've known rather than young people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread