Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Gen Z is difficult to manage at work?

334 replies

donniedarko89 · 04/04/2023 14:20

I have noticed younger people tend to be more cynical and argumentative, with less work boundaries/respect for hierarchies (which is not necessarily a bad thing, but can come across as presumption/arrogance). This makes it more difficult to manage them at work imo.

Have you noticed any similar behaviours?

OP posts:
Aoife1999 · 05/04/2023 07:10

In my experience many of them play the MH card if they don’t like feedback or they claim discrimination for ridiculous reasons or look to take paid leave for for problems they claim company have caused & everything is offensive in some way. Never had this consistent issue with boomers/millennials & for context I’m talking about a private sector large company over period of several years.

Beantag · 05/04/2023 06:58

Thehonestbadger · 05/04/2023 06:10

I had this conversation the other day with SIL who hires graduates.

I mean, the starting salary at most non multinat firms (small to medium places) is around £20k around here which is the same as when I was starting. I’m a young millennial (30) and honestly I wouldn’t work any FT job nowadays for less than 30k I mean you have to understand what you’re asking of people in a time/money exchange. You cannot realistically live or build a life for yourself on 20k. You certainly can’t rent a studio/1bed in our city on that. They would laugh at you!

I think millennials were the very last of the ‘if I just work super flat out maybe one day I’ll be able to afford to buy a house’ generation. Gen Z seem to have given up, there’s a ‘IDGAF’ attitude coming from them because they’ve pretty much resigned themselves to the fact that all the ‘life goals’ of the generation before them will only be achieved by having parents who can afford to help them, winning the lottery or inheriting. So they are now motivated by different things. Social lives, experiences, well being…they just want to enjoy their lives.

It seems to me that the older generations totally broke the system and are now livid at the younger generation for holding their hands up and saying ‘yeah this game totally sucks I’m not playing’ and walking off. It’s important to remember that people don’t owe society their compliance in behaving a certain way. I also, sadly, think it’s so broken at this stage it’s totally irreversible and we are now strapped in for a wacky ride.

DH is a doctor and they just released stats saying in the near future basically no junior doctors will be working full time anymore, they’re just not willing to do it for the compensation and the way they are treated, which would be fine, other than they also released figures showing mortality rates for patients rise drastically whilst being treated by doctors who work LTFT 👍🏻
So basically the NHS is going to be even shorter staffed and patients even more likely to die.

woooo

Junior doctors get paid 30% less than their previous counterparts, not surprised they don't want to overwork themselves in a broken system for less money than their predecessors. Current consultants were happy to pull the ladder up behind them and not fight for better conditions.

Oblomov23 · 05/04/2023 06:47

This thread is interesting. Ds1 is going off in September for his Uni work placement. I wonder how he'll get on.

magicthree · 05/04/2023 06:36

Albiboba · 05/04/2023 06:31

Your experience of like 3 bloody young people in your office is not a behavioural pattern of a whole generation. Omg I don’t know why so many people are refusing to accept that.
You’re actually the one who comes off as entitled, lazy and ill-informed if you genuinely think your narrow experience is somehow representative.

Hilarious how long this thread has gone on for, yet how many people were whinging on the ageism thread only a few day ago!
Pot, kettle.

The point is that DdraigGoch is not the only poster to say this. If one poster had complaints then fair enough, but there are so many on this thread, and people I talk to in real life all say the same thing. I don't know why you are refusing to accept that!

Albiboba · 05/04/2023 06:31

DdraigGoch · 05/04/2023 05:41

It's one thing to refuse to do unpaid overtime. It's quite another to insist on finishing on time every day despite being habitually late.

Your experience of like 3 bloody young people in your office is not a behavioural pattern of a whole generation. Omg I don’t know why so many people are refusing to accept that.
You’re actually the one who comes off as entitled, lazy and ill-informed if you genuinely think your narrow experience is somehow representative.

Hilarious how long this thread has gone on for, yet how many people were whinging on the ageism thread only a few day ago!
Pot, kettle.

ThatsAboutEnoughOfThat · 05/04/2023 06:16

Nope, the Zs in my team work their arses off and get shit done. What they don't do is fuck around dragging out their hours to appease the old culture of presentism.

We are fully hybrid, I don't give a shit when or where they do their work (some like to be in the office and some prefer WFH), as long as we get everything done on time and they turn up on the one day a week we all need to be in the office together to show the dinosaurs we all exist.

To be fair ALL of my team work this way and I have people varying in age from 19-60. I am 47 (so Gen X) and the Manager.

I have two sons who have been raised to think the same way. Get your work done, don't buy into corporate bullshit, get paid what you are worth and be prepared to walk away.

Thehonestbadger · 05/04/2023 06:10

I had this conversation the other day with SIL who hires graduates.

I mean, the starting salary at most non multinat firms (small to medium places) is around £20k around here which is the same as when I was starting. I’m a young millennial (30) and honestly I wouldn’t work any FT job nowadays for less than 30k I mean you have to understand what you’re asking of people in a time/money exchange. You cannot realistically live or build a life for yourself on 20k. You certainly can’t rent a studio/1bed in our city on that. They would laugh at you!

I think millennials were the very last of the ‘if I just work super flat out maybe one day I’ll be able to afford to buy a house’ generation. Gen Z seem to have given up, there’s a ‘IDGAF’ attitude coming from them because they’ve pretty much resigned themselves to the fact that all the ‘life goals’ of the generation before them will only be achieved by having parents who can afford to help them, winning the lottery or inheriting. So they are now motivated by different things. Social lives, experiences, well being…they just want to enjoy their lives.

It seems to me that the older generations totally broke the system and are now livid at the younger generation for holding their hands up and saying ‘yeah this game totally sucks I’m not playing’ and walking off. It’s important to remember that people don’t owe society their compliance in behaving a certain way. I also, sadly, think it’s so broken at this stage it’s totally irreversible and we are now strapped in for a wacky ride.

DH is a doctor and they just released stats saying in the near future basically no junior doctors will be working full time anymore, they’re just not willing to do it for the compensation and the way they are treated, which would be fine, other than they also released figures showing mortality rates for patients rise drastically whilst being treated by doctors who work LTFT 👍🏻
So basically the NHS is going to be even shorter staffed and patients even more likely to die.

woooo

DdraigGoch · 05/04/2023 05:41

Albiboba · 04/04/2023 21:49

It’s funny how many times posters are throwing around “entitled” and yet by the same breath so many of the managers on this thread complaining that gen Z apparently won’t stay late, and work for free, ultimately for the benefit of their manager.

Who’s really the entitled one in this situation??

It's one thing to refuse to do unpaid overtime. It's quite another to insist on finishing on time every day despite being habitually late.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 05/04/2023 05:37

Some are great, but there’s a lot of anxiety, crying at any kind of feedback, mental health days, parents ringing in sick for them instead of themselves. Also we have had to repeatedly stop some from filming ‘a day in the life’ videos for tik tok, in the office (large financial organisation).

It’s easier for the good ones to stand out than it was in my day.

DdraigGoch · 05/04/2023 05:28

Its about time we had a change to punitive sickness policies and corporate bullshit and performance management.

God forbid people are expected to actually do the job they are employed for. Genuine sickness is one thing, but there are a lot of piss-takers around (in any generation) who treat it as extra annual leave.

I know someone who will stretch out paid sick leave for as long as he can get away with (recently spent six months off with a "bad back" but found plenty of time to improve his golf handicap). No one at work likes him, because they have to take up the slack.

Phoebo · 05/04/2023 03:51

Chooba · 04/04/2023 14:22

Nope, but I think it depends a bit on sectors. I find those hanging in there for retirement with no inclination to change/evolve much harder.

That's a really good point. It's not just gen z, but I find it rude and irritating how much people are on their phones. You're there to work, I personally am finding it quite a problem

imjustanerd · 05/04/2023 02:56

Chooba · 04/04/2023 14:22

Nope, but I think it depends a bit on sectors. I find those hanging in there for retirement with no inclination to change/evolve much harder.

This with bells on

Abcdefgh1234 · 05/04/2023 02:51

I’m HR and yes gen z make me got massive headache. they talk about mental ilness soo much, anything can shake their mental ilness. They cant take feedback. They want more pay less work. Too much work equal slavery. I’m sorry i’m millennials and i found them really annoying. I’m sure not all of them. But most of the gen z i work with are.

JimmyDurham · 05/04/2023 02:30

This is every generation. I recall this being said when I started work in the 70s about the now derided boomers.

magicthree · 05/04/2023 01:38

Fifi1010 · 04/04/2023 17:29

I'm 30 and I love their attitude. They haven't bought into the corporate drone mindset. I definitely think I'm more gen z spirited. A job is a job for me it's definitely not my entire life.

I'm a boomer and that has always been my attitude, along with most of my friends - it's nothing new.

Having said that, it is possible to think of a job as only a job but still treat it as a privilege rather than a right, turn up when supposed to, not take sick leave willy nilly, not to collapse when someone tells you that you are wrong, and not think you know everything on the first day.

Bintymcbintface · 05/04/2023 01:35

PinkTonic · 04/04/2023 20:55

I have a few in my team and they are different. I put in a daily catch up first thing for their benefit as they need the support, and that’s when I can make the time to be available, but they struggle to get online in time. They always log off on the dot however busy we are, it genuinely doesn’t seem to occur to them to put in a bit of extra time when needed and that this might be a give and take arrangement. They also have time off sick for the slightest reason and last week one of them sent me a text at 4 in the morning to say he was feeling ill and didn’t bother to contact me the next day. To me they act like teenagers and don’t understand the basic mores of the workplace.

What's wrong with finishing work when your contracted hours are up? Are they paid for any overtime or just expected to suck it up and work for free?

magicthree · 05/04/2023 01:28

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/04/2023 21:20

I’m on the cusp of Gen X and Baby Boom. Ds is Babyboomer. Neither of us remember any of this. My siblings are Boomers.

We had central heating. Walked to school 5 minutes away. I wore trousers to school, as did my sister who was 7 years older than me.We had carpets and sat on sofas.

Your experience is not mine of living in a house with/ being on the edge of the Babyboomers.

Some Baby Boomers were born in the 1940s and some in the 1960s. Obviously those at the latter end are going to have a different experience to those at the beginning.

JudgeRudy · 05/04/2023 01:23

I kind of get what you're saying. I think are harder to manage........ if you are still managing the way you did in the 70s and 80s!
One thing I will say is difficult to 'stamp out' is over sharing and personal boundaries. I don't want to hear about the lad Mellisa gave a BJ, or tell you how much I weigh or exactly where I live. I do think it's good that they're at ease with all 'levels' so don't feel nervous (or subseriant) when speaking with the MD. They're also not afraid to leave at 5 when they're paid till 5!
I've moved around a lot job wise. I think that helps me reset my attitude. I am about to start a new job. It's in a role I've never worked in and a sector I've never in. I'm determined to go in with a bit of GenZ attitude....with my Gen X life experience. I think I'll be straight forward and a dream to manage....but k said that last time 😉

magicthree · 05/04/2023 01:16

ScentOfAMemory · 04/04/2023 15:34

The attitude to mental health on this thread is disgusting.

I find that those who are so invested in their own mental health don't care about anyone else's. They need time off to deal with their own, but apparently those who have to take over their job in their absence are supposed to merrily accept this as a fact of life. Mental health is an overused excuse for anything these days. Everyone gets anxious, everyone gets down - it's not poor mental health, it's just normal.

People taking the piss regarding their mental health are only making it hard for those who have a genuine diagnosed illness.

Turnipp · 05/04/2023 01:11

I study and work with Gen-Z, and I am a millennial. I go to a very MC Uni but work in a very WC profession, and I think it's more of a class issue than a generation. But I find they're pretty judging on class factors and are ageist - I get called a boomer and ageist comments about being old, and I am in the late 20s, and if I am honest I just remind them that they will be that age, at some point. Referring to class at Uni, I hear a lot "Oh that place isn't very nice because there all dumb people". And I go well I am from that area, if I am honest and I know this sounds petty, but I use their comments to achieve higher marks on my course to make a point, lol. But I think sometimes with some, some have never had to have to work because their parents have paid for everything, and when you try and be realistic with them on things because you're using your years of experience, they can often think you're criticising them and I don't think a lot of them have ever been criticised by their parents and it's a constant daily battle of validation. And it's tiring, I can't wait until I leave uni now.

retrosteamband · 05/04/2023 00:25

I disagree - I’m gen z. My department has a clear grade structure and staff within it are very gradist, ie anyone regardless of age is expected to follow the hierarchy and power structure. You can’t speak to your manager’s manager for no reason, for example, as they’d angrily tell you your manager should be dealing with this as it’s not in the senior manager’s remit.

also I’m a manager and older yet junior people at work tend to be very set in their ways and resistant to change to the extent that they underperform compared to people that are less static in mindset

Allblackeverythingalways · 04/04/2023 23:51

Our gen z has come into his own.
It was hard at first, he'd cry in the manager's office whenever he was reminded that turning up 15 minutes late every day was unacceptable.
He'd cry whenever his performance was criticised (which was often, he was very lazy at first)
He was miserable and hated being in the real world. We are a relaxed company. Give and take. (Not the fake give and take that only favours the company either)
He now works hard and seems proud of his performance, he's doing brilliantly!
Still has more time off sick that my entire department, but at least he's starting to fit in properly.

Florenz · 04/04/2023 23:18

Gen Zers need to realise that work is for work. You go in and work and then go home and you get paid at the end of the month. No they shouldn't work unpaid hours. No they shouldn't work through their unpaid lunch breaks, or even their paid morning and afternoon breaks. But the other hours they are at work, they should work.

hay5689 · 04/04/2023 23:09

Albiboba · 04/04/2023 21:49

It’s funny how many times posters are throwing around “entitled” and yet by the same breath so many of the managers on this thread complaining that gen Z apparently won’t stay late, and work for free, ultimately for the benefit of their manager.

Who’s really the entitled one in this situation??

I'd be happy if mine turned up on time. I don't expect anyone to work for free but I do expect a full shift which I don't think is unreasonable. Plus when they are actually there a lot of them give just about the bare minimum and everyone else picks up the slack.

Twatalert · 04/04/2023 23:01

FragranceFree · 04/04/2023 22:54

My kids are all much more boundaried than me (I've worked hard to allow them those too) but I think they will all be really good employees.

Generally speaking though, YANBU.

It means they won't be people pleaser and that's great. You can have good boundaries and still not be overly entitled with inflated confidence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread