Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Gen Z is difficult to manage at work?

334 replies

donniedarko89 · 04/04/2023 14:20

I have noticed younger people tend to be more cynical and argumentative, with less work boundaries/respect for hierarchies (which is not necessarily a bad thing, but can come across as presumption/arrogance). This makes it more difficult to manage them at work imo.

Have you noticed any similar behaviours?

OP posts:
MidnightMeltdown · 04/04/2023 15:52

The trouble is that Gen Z are used to being pandered to. Even at university, they are babied and spoon fed, and everybody has a mental health condition.

I'm a millennial, and the way that they are treated is very, very different to how we were treated less than 20 years ago.

I wonder whether it's partly linked to paying high university tuition fees. They feel that they are buying their degrees, rather than earning them, and so they are more entitled and demanding.

samG76 · 04/04/2023 15:51

DH interviewed a candidate last week, thought she could do the job and said she should come for lunch with the (small) team to see whether they would all get on. The night before the lunch she said there was no point in having lunch unless she got a salary of at least X. DH spoke to her and said why didn't she come for lunch and show us why she is worth X. She said she hadn't thought of that. It is very entitled behaviour....

Standbyguest · 04/04/2023 15:50

Yes absolutely, I work within a team of around 10 gen z, they all want massive promotions despite moaning and complaining and not meeting deadlines, they come into work in leisurewear and crop tops (corporate office), don't seem to want to progress in terms of self development, just want the pay rise and the title. Work ethic isn't something in their vocab.

As a millennial when I think back to myself and my jobs in my early 20s it was very very different.

AlexisR · 04/04/2023 15:48

Seasonofthewitch83 · 04/04/2023 15:46

I have lost count at the amount of cover emails/letters that start with 'Hey there!' when applying for a job.

I think there has def been either a shift or just loss of skill on how to properly construct a letter/email. I wonder how much informal text/whatsapp is contributing towards this?

Or maybe just a shift to a different way of doing it than you're used to?

What is lost by saying "Hey there!"?

PuddlesPityParty · 04/04/2023 15:47

BumpyaDaisyevna · 04/04/2023 15:43

What I notice about the young Gen Z-ers I work with is how much more focussed and mature they are about their career. They all have the most incredible LinkedIn profiles showing all the amazing things they have done and are involved with, they are very proactive and there is a sense they really do fight to develop themselves and to find opportunities to do so.

When I was their age I was still like a stroppy adolescent, resentful deep down that I should even be required to work at all and taking all the many opportunities that came my way almost totally for granted.

They all seem to be much more emotionally literate than I was at that age, too.

One thing I do notice is that they can sometimes struggle to find the right tone with clients and with senior people internally. A "professional-approachable" tone can slide into "chatty" a bit too easily for some of them. As a senior person I do find it a bit jarring to be addressed on my first interaction with a young colleague as "Hey Bumpya how're you" as if there is no difference between us in the hierarchy.

I still prefer "Dear/Hi Bumpya, we have not met but by way of introduction I am {x} a junior in {y} team and I wanted to ask if you could give me your view on {z}"

I think you’re quite outdated in your view in that sense. You and the person emailing you are both just people.

Jonei · 04/04/2023 15:47

They're more confident and insist on better working conditions. Which is great.

But they're often lazy, rigid and do the bare minimum too.

Obviously I'm not speaking for all. Just the ones I know.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 04/04/2023 15:46

BumpyaDaisyevna · 04/04/2023 15:43

What I notice about the young Gen Z-ers I work with is how much more focussed and mature they are about their career. They all have the most incredible LinkedIn profiles showing all the amazing things they have done and are involved with, they are very proactive and there is a sense they really do fight to develop themselves and to find opportunities to do so.

When I was their age I was still like a stroppy adolescent, resentful deep down that I should even be required to work at all and taking all the many opportunities that came my way almost totally for granted.

They all seem to be much more emotionally literate than I was at that age, too.

One thing I do notice is that they can sometimes struggle to find the right tone with clients and with senior people internally. A "professional-approachable" tone can slide into "chatty" a bit too easily for some of them. As a senior person I do find it a bit jarring to be addressed on my first interaction with a young colleague as "Hey Bumpya how're you" as if there is no difference between us in the hierarchy.

I still prefer "Dear/Hi Bumpya, we have not met but by way of introduction I am {x} a junior in {y} team and I wanted to ask if you could give me your view on {z}"

I have lost count at the amount of cover emails/letters that start with 'Hey there!' when applying for a job.

I think there has def been either a shift or just loss of skill on how to properly construct a letter/email. I wonder how much informal text/whatsapp is contributing towards this?

AlexisR · 04/04/2023 15:45

@ChristinaXYZ Sometimes as a manger/ boss/ authority figure of any kind, it's good to be challenged and to explain your reasoning to someone less experienced. It makes you reflect on yourself and why you are doing what you do. This is about your outlook.

If you don't have time to explain then it's on you to handle that situation, and you should make time to talk to them later if they're interested. An inquisitive nature, curiosity, and asking questions, are not bad traits. You as a manger need to learn the tools to handle that when you don't have the time.

OMG12 · 04/04/2023 15:44

They have a complete lack of resilience and understanding of different perspectives. if something doesn’t accord with their way of thinking it is just wrong. Group think is the name of the game.

They think they’re special in some way and really don’t understand the concept of mucking in, or if it’s not in their job description they won’t just help out.

I would say a person in their early 20s is prob as mature as a 14 year old in the 90s.

obviously not every Gen z person is like this- some are excellent and bring a lot, new ways of doing and new perspectives. It’s just the average ones are a ball ache.

BumpyaDaisyevna · 04/04/2023 15:43

What I notice about the young Gen Z-ers I work with is how much more focussed and mature they are about their career. They all have the most incredible LinkedIn profiles showing all the amazing things they have done and are involved with, they are very proactive and there is a sense they really do fight to develop themselves and to find opportunities to do so.

When I was their age I was still like a stroppy adolescent, resentful deep down that I should even be required to work at all and taking all the many opportunities that came my way almost totally for granted.

They all seem to be much more emotionally literate than I was at that age, too.

One thing I do notice is that they can sometimes struggle to find the right tone with clients and with senior people internally. A "professional-approachable" tone can slide into "chatty" a bit too easily for some of them. As a senior person I do find it a bit jarring to be addressed on my first interaction with a young colleague as "Hey Bumpya how're you" as if there is no difference between us in the hierarchy.

I still prefer "Dear/Hi Bumpya, we have not met but by way of introduction I am {x} a junior in {y} team and I wanted to ask if you could give me your view on {z}"

AlexisR · 04/04/2023 15:40

I don't like to generalise too much but personally I have a lot of optimism and belief in our current generation of young people.

I think they have had a lot to deal with, and on the whole are emerging as a pretty well-rounded and sensible generation of young people, compared to the 2 preceding generations (one of which is mine so I am not blowing my own trumpet here!)

ChristinaXYZ · 04/04/2023 15:39

ilovemydogmore · 04/04/2023 14:23

Personally I just think Gen Z take less shit

It's this. Good for them. They are happy to put boundaries in place, won't accept bad behaviour just because someone senior 'says so', they know their value.

Whilst knowling their value is good and not taking shit on things like harrassment at work is good, completely under-mining senior staff in a slightly aggressive way based not on knowledge, not on experience but on something someone their own age has has told them (someone with equally less knowledge and experience) that they now repeat as a mantra that they don't fully understand and yet won't engage in discussion about, is not good at all.

Also on some other things insisting on hearing every last detail of their boss's reasoning behind a decision - instead of thinking: manager wants that done, my job to get it done (unless completely unreasonable or unsafe or way out of my job description).

Sometimes you don't have time to explain. Like setting up at trade fair, due to open very soon, decision made in my head based on pervious experience and on a heath and safety issue to with stability of the stand set up - gen z (first time at fair) arguing the toss over it, till almost too late to fix issue. End up fixing it myself, gen z sulking because they were not listened to (everyone since birth has listen to their every utterance like it is worth gold) and also because I had to pull rank to get it done in time.

That's not knowing your value - it is arrogantly failing to recognise 1) the value in someone else (their experience and knowledge) and 2) that like it or not the work place has a hierarchy and sometimes you have to lump it when told to do something reasonable that you don't agree with.

These issues are realtively new to the work place and getting worse.

hay5689 · 04/04/2023 15:38

The Gen Z I manage are mostly hard work. They often phone in sick and then complain when I follow the company sick policy (clearly explained in their contract should they read it), turn up late and expect to be able to stay on to make time up (doesn't work like that), and just generally have a shitty attitude towards work and customers.

That said one of them is the hardest worker I've ever come across, she's got a work ethic that will make sure she goes far in life and I have no doubt after she graduates she's going to do well because she knows she's got to work for it.

Architectahoy · 04/04/2023 15:38

onefinemess · 04/04/2023 15:35

Depends on the sector. Those who work in "non-jobs", marketing, admin, executive something-or-other, tend to have confidence which in no way matches any value they have as a company asset.

Those who work in qualified fields, think medicine, coding, engineering and the like, seem to have a much better work ethic.

"Non jobs" is pretty damn rude

But also your post is incorrect. I can assure you that Gen Z's qualified in engineering and architecture are a bloody nightmare!

Emigratingimmigrant · 04/04/2023 15:37

CeliaNorth · 04/04/2023 15:21

I’m a boomer ..... I’m perfectly capable of sending an email properly however…

Which generation do people think invented personal computers and the world wide web, and were the first to use computers in the workplace? Alan Sugar, Bill Gates, Steve Jobs and Tim Berners-Lee are/were all boomers. There were computers in my workplace in the mid-70s.

That's what I argue every time someone older does "hpw do you do x? I am just not on with that technology"😂
Like word to pdf basics ...

BlackBarbies · 04/04/2023 15:36

PuddlesPityParty · 04/04/2023 15:33

Literally! MN is soooo bad for this. When I’ve called it out on other threads they try to backtrack and say it’s not what they meant, but you just know they’d be the first to label you ageist it any generalisation about older generations are made!

It’s ridiculous tbh. Maybe I’ll wake up tomorrow and start a thread on Boomers and see how that goes down👍

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 04/04/2023 15:36

onefinemess · 04/04/2023 15:35

Depends on the sector. Those who work in "non-jobs", marketing, admin, executive something-or-other, tend to have confidence which in no way matches any value they have as a company asset.

Those who work in qualified fields, think medicine, coding, engineering and the like, seem to have a much better work ethic.

'non-jobs'

Lcb123 · 04/04/2023 15:36

Yes this is my experience. And not grateful for having a job. Having graduated and job hunted not long after 2008 crash, i feel always eternally grateful to have a job, as it was so hard to get one. Not the case now

Antiquiteas · 04/04/2023 15:35

gannett · 04/04/2023 15:23

I recognise this type of male grad from MY generation, when I was in my early 20s. That was 15 years ago.

It's not really a generational thing, it's a male thing, but also a class thing (have certainly seen expensively educated young women do this too).

I didn’t link it to being Gen Z, just young male entitlement. It does my head in. They think what they’re saying is revolutionary and as a mere woman in her 30s I have clearly never settled upon such an excellent idea, and that I must bow down and listen to them immediately.

I don’t, obviously. I ‘call out’ the behaviour for what it is: entitled rudeness. Once I’ve done that I offer them the floor to share more of their groundbreaking ideas, which is always very awkward for everyone. Except me, I rather enjoy sitting back and watching them intently as their regret becomes more apparent.

raincamepouringdown · 04/04/2023 15:35

Suspect many younger people have realised that all the 'trickle down' economics is total bs, and that 'working to live' is more important than 'living to work'. Sensible, frankly.

Hollyhocksarenotmessy · 04/04/2023 15:35

I like our gen z trainees. They are genuine and want to learn. Nice people.

You have to pile on the reassurance for a couple of them if you have anything critical to say, lack of confidence on their part, but I think previous generations would have felt their anxiety but not let you know about it.

Lockdowns had a big impact on them.

Managers have short memories about how their generation were like when starting work. I don't think much has changed.

onefinemess · 04/04/2023 15:35

Depends on the sector. Those who work in "non-jobs", marketing, admin, executive something-or-other, tend to have confidence which in no way matches any value they have as a company asset.

Those who work in qualified fields, think medicine, coding, engineering and the like, seem to have a much better work ethic.

DogInATent · 04/04/2023 15:34

Gen Z takes less shit, and there's an older generation that's cruised through management and struggles when they have to step-up. Part of it is 'management inflation' that means charge hands are called supervisors, and supervisors are called managers. It's created a tier of nominally management that don't have either the skills or authority to manage. I suspect Gen Z are quicker to see weakness in this.

ScentOfAMemory · 04/04/2023 15:34

The attitude to mental health on this thread is disgusting.

PuddlesPityParty · 04/04/2023 15:33

BlackBarbies · 04/04/2023 15:32

Gen Z this and Gen Z that. But if I start generalising the older generation I’ll get told I’m ageist. Okay😅

Literally! MN is soooo bad for this. When I’ve called it out on other threads they try to backtrack and say it’s not what they meant, but you just know they’d be the first to label you ageist it any generalisation about older generations are made!