Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Gen Z is difficult to manage at work?

334 replies

donniedarko89 · 04/04/2023 14:20

I have noticed younger people tend to be more cynical and argumentative, with less work boundaries/respect for hierarchies (which is not necessarily a bad thing, but can come across as presumption/arrogance). This makes it more difficult to manage them at work imo.

Have you noticed any similar behaviours?

OP posts:
Emigratingimmigrant · 04/04/2023 16:06

Seasonofthewitch83 · 04/04/2023 16:04

I also think the newest generation of workers seem to lack social awareness/norms but I guess this is expected if they are the generation whose first working years have been during lockdown?

I had a trainee who called in sick day 3 of her new role, but the tone made me wince. If I have ever been sick early on in a job, I would have profusely apologised even though I guess...why do you need to apologise for being sick? There are so many unspoken/unwritten rules around office work in particular and I could not pinpoint exactly why the nonchalant unapologetic tone was so jarring!

Rules change with times. In few years there might not need be need for masaive apology for being sick. As you say, why do you need to apologise for being sick. Unless you eat can of twice reheated tuna on purpose 😁

joelmillersbackpack · 04/04/2023 16:06

Some of them have genuinely been a pleasure to have in the workplace, hard working, bright, willing to learn. A real treat.

And then there’s the others. So so anxious, won’t turn up for things or take things on because of anxiety. Always talking about their mental health, with the expectation that the other adults in the team should be there to hold their hand in a parental way. As if the team bending for them is always the solution to things that feel uncomfortable.

And I personally have found more than a few of them to be totally misogynistic. They expect that women at work who are mothers are totally stupid. Same for older women. And it shines through in their behaviour.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 04/04/2023 16:04

I also think the newest generation of workers seem to lack social awareness/norms but I guess this is expected if they are the generation whose first working years have been during lockdown?

I had a trainee who called in sick day 3 of her new role, but the tone made me wince. If I have ever been sick early on in a job, I would have profusely apologised even though I guess...why do you need to apologise for being sick? There are so many unspoken/unwritten rules around office work in particular and I could not pinpoint exactly why the nonchalant unapologetic tone was so jarring!

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 04/04/2023 16:02

Wedoronron · 04/04/2023 15:56

Has not been ever thus.

Older people sneering at the workshy younger people. The awful chorus of "in my day...." I remember my grandparents moaning about us and I bet their grandparents did the same.

Probably.

With social media it feels like we're constantly hearing about Millennial this and Gen Z that. Even when it comes to minor shit like the types of socks preferred by each generation. Or how they part their hair.

I remember in the 90s there'd be the odd navel gazey type article on Gen X, talk of McJobs, Elizabeth Wurtzel publishing a 'Gen X' book or two, and that was more or less it. Now it's all 'why Maltesters are problematic for Gen Z'.

IShouldGoToSleep · 04/04/2023 16:02

I have had a few really great gen z supervisees recently. But I have also had two of the most difficult supervisees I've ever had, recently, from this generation. One was particularly cocky. Thought she was god gift, even though she was brand new and most junior member of the team. Bossed everyone around, acted like she had years and years of experience when she had none. Not sure it's a gen z thing, more just different personalities. But I don't know.

Lifeomars · 04/04/2023 16:02

I love spending time with my friend's teenager, I do notice a level of confidence that I never had at that age. I also love how we just get along, when I was their age all adults were "aunty" "uncle" "mrs" or "mrs" and I felt a little in awe of them. Me and this teenager just hang out, have a laugh. I learn things from them and I like to hope they learn things from me

ChristinaXYZ · 04/04/2023 16:01

PuddlesPityParty · 04/04/2023 15:47

I think you’re quite outdated in your view in that sense. You and the person emailing you are both just people.

They are both people but they're certianly not just people - in a work context one will have more knowledge probably, and more experience inevitably, and more responsibility than the gen Z person. What the PP is expecting, I think, is that the gen Z employee sees the value in other people - those skills, experiences, knowledge and responsibilities - as well as in themselves. Speaking to someone with all that value at work as though they are just one of your mates is, well, just rude. They don't mean it to be so but it is. They just don't see other poeple's value in the same way as previous generations of employees did with the one above them in age.

And yes we've all had one boss you was over-promoted, etc. but mostly the perosn above you at work is there for a reason. More so now than for workers in the 60s when men got all the promotions regardless. Never have managers been more worth their kudos and never had they had less respect from a slightly upity gen below them!

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 04/04/2023 16:01

onefinemess · 04/04/2023 15:35

Depends on the sector. Those who work in "non-jobs", marketing, admin, executive something-or-other, tend to have confidence which in no way matches any value they have as a company asset.

Those who work in qualified fields, think medicine, coding, engineering and the like, seem to have a much better work ethic.

Admin is NOT a "non-job" - without admin (or professional services staff, as they are called) I could not do my job, no students would progress or graduate either.

DamnAllTheJellyfish · 04/04/2023 16:00

This maybe more due to her age rather than the gen z generalisation but the 15 year old Saturday girl they employed to help fill shelves etc at the place I work is the most work shy, disruptive and ignorant person I've ever met. She completely infuriates me with her disrespect, she literally has the manager chasing her around the place to keep her on task, it's quicker to do the job yourself. I witnessed her going into the back room more than 20 times during a 2 hour shift when she was supposed to be on the shop floor cleaning shelves.

Obviously not all are like this but out of ten or so employed to do this job that I have known only 1 was worth paying.

I had a Saturday job from aged 13 and worked the whole shift, doing exactly what was asked of me and asked for more jobs when I was finished without being prompted to do so.

I've worked with plenty of lazy older people too don't get me wrong but at least they have the decency to at least pretend they are working hard Grin

HollyBollyBooBoo · 04/04/2023 15:59

I'm quite inspired by them. Wish I'd been like that at the beginning of my career.

Paperbagsaremine · 04/04/2023 15:59

What bugs me is that Boomers used to be ACTUAL PEOPLE BORN IN THE BABY BOOM -1946-1964. A technical term. Most of them are retired and a lot are dead! Even the youngest are at most 10 years from retirement.

Now it just seems to be a sneering ageist term flung at anyone over 40.

It's name-calling and it reflects badly on anyone who does it.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 04/04/2023 15:58

AlexisR · 04/04/2023 15:48

Or maybe just a shift to a different way of doing it than you're used to?

What is lost by saying "Hey there!"?

I guess because if you cannot formally construct an email, it does not fill me with confidence that you know the appropriate tone to send correspondence and therefore lack that skill/experience?

99.9% of the time, the applications are for those with no/little professional experience.

LlynTegid · 04/04/2023 15:58

The lack of resilience is the main thing I notice. Appearance and lack of some pride in it is not confined to people of that age, it is a trait that has crept in over the last 15 years or so.

PuddlesPityParty · 04/04/2023 15:58

@CoalCraft if she’s 24 she’s gen Z.

There are things called micro generations where it’s the people who are in the end of one gen and start of another so me and your colleague are in a micro generation, but officially gen z.

Lifeomars · 04/04/2023 15:58

Womencanlift · 04/04/2023 14:46

One of the most interesting training sessions I once went to was how to manage inter-generational teams. My key takeaway, which in hindsight is quite obvious, was that historical events will shape a generation.

For example for Boomers it will be the industrial unrest of the 70s, Gen X are the generation who started school with pen and paper and left with the internet really kicking off, Millennials it is 9/11 and also the 2008 crash where it started to become obvious that a job wasn’t for life and for Gen Z’s there is limited research so far but obviously covid/lockdowns will be their main generational influence as they are entering the world of work while sitting in their bedroom with little side by side training/support in the same way their colleagues did when they were starting their careers

Was quite thought provoking and made me think how different life experiences can shape what is important to you and your career as well as your general outlook

That is fascinating and thought provoking.

AliceOlive · 04/04/2023 15:58

Wedoronron · 04/04/2023 15:56

Has not been ever thus.

Older people sneering at the workshy younger people. The awful chorus of "in my day...." I remember my grandparents moaning about us and I bet their grandparents did the same.

True story. It's nice to be of the age where it's my turn to do this, and I am not going to miss out on the opportunity.

Peckhaminn · 04/04/2023 15:57

I also don't put up with doing stupid amounts of overtime. I used to work with a gentlemen who was 60 odd and worked 3 hours extra a day for no extra pay. I clocked off at 6 and went home and he saw me as lazy? No, I got paid to work the hours I work, I won't do any longer than needed, I also don't put up with any shit from crap managers, maybe it's a personality trait or a Gen Z thing who knows

Wedoronron · 04/04/2023 15:56

Has not been ever thus.

Older people sneering at the workshy younger people. The awful chorus of "in my day...." I remember my grandparents moaning about us and I bet their grandparents did the same.

AliceOlive · 04/04/2023 15:56

I don't manage any, but I have found that some in this age group behave as if they are on par with everyone around them, in knowledge and life experience. Some, (not all by any stretch, or even a majority) just completely lack deference for anyone. They happily weigh in on every topic, talk over others, give advice where they have no knowledge, etc.

I doubt it's a new problem, really. But it really grates.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 04/04/2023 15:55

Womencanlift · 04/04/2023 14:25

There is definitely a level of confidence seen with the grads in our business that wasn’t common when I was the same age. In fact colleagues in the same age bracket as me have all wondered if there is a “preparation for the workplace” course that’s compulsory at university now as they seem to know so much more about the office environment than we ever did

With some, that confidence seeps through to arrogance, with some expecting to be doing the role that someone does with years of experience within the first few weeks. But I think that is individual personalities rather than the stereotype of a whole generation

I teach at a university and employability is embedded throughout the curriculum. I'm the academic lead for this. This gives students the opportunity to develop skills, experience and knowledge - and confidence - to help them move from education to employment. We start it in the first year, getting them to reflect on their skills, know their worth and be able to articulate that. In a competitive job market this is essential.

CoalCraft · 04/04/2023 15:55

The handful I've worked with have been lazy and unwilling to learn, not even putting in the bare minimum. I'm 28 so hardly a dinosaur. That said it's probably just been bad luck. One of my closest colleagues is 24 and she's fab - talented and a hard worker - but I think just outside the age range. She does lack confidence and resilience but I think that might be more age and personality than generation.

Emigratingimmigrant · 04/04/2023 15:55

As a senior person I do find it a bit jarring to be addressed on my first interaction with a young colleague as "Hey Bumpya how're you" as if there is no difference between us in the hierarchy.
I still prefer "Dear/Hi Bumpya, we have not met but by way of introduction I am {x} a junior in {y} team and I wanted to ask if you could give me your view on {z}"

There is a middle way. I don't need to introduce myself to our senior management, outlook shows quickly who I am so does my signature. Waste of typing (all about efficiency here)
I would just simply go in politely but not used phrases like "by way of introduction".

Peckhaminn · 04/04/2023 15:54

I'm 'Gen Z' and or whatever these titles mean and it's all down to how you've been brought up. My family were workaholics, worked hard for every penny they received and this has resulted in me being the same. Some of my friends, on the other hand, are lazy as anything and do nothing all day at their jobs. But they've also been spoon fed for majority of their life. I was told to 'make my own way' in the world.

OopsAnotherOne · 04/04/2023 15:52

Gen Z here, can't speak for others but I find that I tolerate less crap than some of my older employees when it comes to staying at the office late.

It boils down to the fact that I don't work for free, so if my boss expects me to stay late after work I expect to be paid for that work. Some might think this makes me "lazy" or "entitled" but I stick to my contract and work my butt off between 9-5, not doing unpaid work in my freetime does not equate to laziness or a poor work ethic - my work ethic is fantastic during the hours I'm contracted to work. It's also fantastic during the hours outside of 9-5 if I am paid for that overtime.

Expecting my employer to pay me for additional work that they ask me to do for them does not make me entitled. I've also seen older colleagues work overtime for free on several occasions and get nothing for it, no credit, no promotions, no payrise, it doesn't serve them to donate their free time and work to the company but they feel as if it shows good work ethic, whereas I feel it just shows poor boundaries and the ability to be exploited.

I have been promoted twice since my time at the company and that isn't due to me donating my free time to the company, but due to working hard, high productivity, taking the initiative etc. I consider it an old myth that staying late after hours progresses you in the workplace when actually in my experience, it's the value and productivity you present to the employer that can get you the promotions. If an employer values how much of my free time I'm willing to donate and how much work for them I'm willing to do for free over how hard working, productive and helpful I am between the hours of 9-5, they're not an employer I'd consider working for as to me, they have their priorities wrong.

That isn't to say that I don't stay in late to finish something off sometimes, but that's of my own choosing as I like to make sure all my tasks for the day are done and I don't expect to be paid when I choose to stay in late, but the times we have been asked to work late into the evening I have asked to be paid for my time and my employers have always honored this. I've had colleagues who accept the same request but do not ask to be paid for the work get annoyed at me for my "entitled" attitude - I think it's entitled of any employer to expect them to work for free, and it isn't entitled to ask to be paid for work that is expected of you.

I am, however, very responsive to correction/criticism, often encouraging it, and have worked my way up from the bottom by working very hard so not all of the stereotypes apply to me. I have worked with others my age, all but one shared the same hard-working approach and the one who didn't and couldn't put their phone down didn't last long. I do agree that there are differences in every generation, but not all of them are necessarily a bad thing.

ChristinaXYZ · 04/04/2023 15:52

I agree with you @AlexisR that they have had a lot to deal with and the world is harder to negotiate in some ways and they have been let down by parenting styles and teaching styles that worship them, then we wonder why they struggle outside of this cocoon.

The more empathetic gen Zers improve with keeping 🙂and some are very hard workers. It is all of course a generalisation but you can generalise about generations because there are fashions in schooling and parenting that many/most of a generation experience.

Gen z workers are going to very different to say someone who turned 18 in 1943 and had to serve in the army or in support services like land army. They're going to be different to the new teenagers of the late 50s / early 60s who had more freedom but who lived in fear or an unplanned pregnancy and perhaps had to give up a loved baby and some had a grammar school get out and some did not. They're going to be different to those who grew up in the early 80s with precarious job security, changing working landscape (especially if your Dad was a manual worker) but perhaps seeing more opportunities for yourself in expanding higher ed and wider range of non-manual jobs. There are generalisations one can make about these cohorts with these experiences and their resilience, their magability, their self-reliance. Accepting there are going to be pluses and minuses for each group.

Whilst gen Z are young they are likely to be the mangees rather than the mangers. They may one day make the best managerial class we've ever had! Who knows!?! But as managees a lot of them are a PIA at the mo!