Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think you can't be a nice person if you marry a sh*t one?

92 replies

aplateandaspoon · 04/04/2023 09:39

I know this couple, let's call her Lily who is married to Jack. I know Jack much better than I know Lily. We are not friends per se, but we see each other often as we have friends in common. I also know Jack's family very well.

Lily seems to be the most adorable lovely person, always polite and smily. But Jack is an absolute dickhead, he treats anyone in the service industry (waiters, cleaners, etc...) like they are beneath him and he is rude to them. He makes awful comments to people he knows like "oh you better get married soon otherwise people will assume you are gay"... things like that.

I know Jack's family pretty well, and I know he treats his mum really badly. He snaps at her and the way sometimes he speaks to her is shocking. Once he even let slip that he can't stand her but she helps them with childcare and with rent so he has to put up with her otherwise they will lose the money.

So going back to Lily... my question is, how can a "good" person marry someone so awful? I just think she cannot be a good person at all. If my partner spoke to people like Jack does, that would be a dealbreaker for me.

I've never tried to engage with Lily much, other than polite pleasantries, cause I don't want a relationship with them (mainly Jack) but part of me also cannot believe she is a genuinely nice person if she married someone like Jack.

So my question is, can who chooses to be partners with someone so awful be a genuinely nice person?

OP posts:
Ktime · 04/04/2023 11:39

aplateandaspoon · 04/04/2023 11:00

@KimberleyClark exactly, thank you!

At least own what you’re saying, OP.

Ktime · 04/04/2023 11:38

KimberleyClark · 04/04/2023 09:52

No one is doing that. Asking why a woman stays with a shit man isn’t maki g her responsible for the fact he’s shit.

But she is doing that. She is saying Jack is shit, ergo Lily is shit too. That’s making Lily responsible for his shitnessl

Iam4eels · 04/04/2023 11:35

Abusers and other horrible people don't walk around holding a sign and ringing their little "I'm a dickhead" bell so that everyone knows what they are. They show their best face to the world, it's only later that the mask starts to slip but by that point it's more tricky to leave.

aplateandaspoon · 04/04/2023 11:08

I guess I see choosing a partner the same as choosing your friends, you usually surround yourself with people who share similar values with you. I could never fall in love with a homophobe, I would never be friends with one either.

I would think the same way if a "really nice guy" has friends who have abused women and he is aware of it it. He can be the nicest "perfect catch" guy, but if he sees his friend spiking a woman's drink and not doing anything about it I would stop thinking he is a nice guy.

I can imagine Jack could treat Lily really badly behind close doors, or he could treat her like a queen and everyone else like shit.

I think I would find it very hard to be with a partner who treats people like that, it would be a dealbreaker for me. That's why I find it so hard to get my head around that.

OP posts:
NEmama · 04/04/2023 11:02

We've got a set of friends like this I just meet the lady for lunch without dh

aplateandaspoon · 04/04/2023 11:00

KimberleyClark · 04/04/2023 09:52

No one is doing that. Asking why a woman stays with a shit man isn’t maki g her responsible for the fact he’s shit.

@KimberleyClark exactly, thank you!

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 04/04/2023 11:00

Or alternatively it might take a very nice person with poor boundaries to be duped into being with them?

thecatsthecats · 04/04/2023 11:00

Ktime · 04/04/2023 09:49

Same old shit, making a woman responsible for a man’s behaviour.

I don't think it's that at all - OP isn't saying that Lily should change Jack. Just not date and marry him.

My own example is two women, if that helps.

I have a 'friend' who is very rude to lots of people - makes snarky comments about weight, looks, and her own superiority all the time.

She's also a lousy CF when it comes to pulling her weight in either money or tasks.

Whilst this woman isn't Hitler, I've outgrown her crappy behaviour and don't really want to spend time with her. But I have a mutual friend who is always trying to pull us together, and excuses her all the time.

The mutual friend totally babies this woman and expects me and others to pick up the slack, when most of us would happily not see her again.

The mutual friend is a 'good' person - but she's happy for the shit friend to be a rude freeloader to the rest of us.

By my lights, that makes her not that good.

Iam4eels · 04/04/2023 10:54

It's not always as simple as "just leave" though. If a relationship is abusive then leaving is dangerous, it has to be properly prepared for as this is the stage where abuse will escalate as the abuser attempts to reassert control. Legal Aid is massively restricted so there is little legal help available if you can't afford to find it yourself but don't meet the pitifully low income threshold for financial help. A flaw of the benefits system is that it forces women (because it's mainly women) to stay with their partner for financial reasons. Then there is the psychological side of it which is complex and difficult to overcome - of you have someone telling you that you're worthless, that you'll lose your children, that they'll spill your secrets and you'll lose your family/friends, that you'll be destitute, homeless, that you can't do better, etc then you're not going to have the self-esteem and confidence needed to go.

ConstanceOcean · 04/04/2023 10:48

YANBU

My friend of 15 years met a guy who was racist (and controlling) and he said she wasn’t allowed around me or my child because of it.

I assumed she would end the relationship straight away but instead she stayed with him.

To me that makes her almost as bad as him.

LuckyStone · 04/04/2023 10:14

Wow it must be nice living with such a simple worldview

gannett · 04/04/2023 10:11

I also don't assume that someone who's nasty to other people is also nasty to his/her partner. In my experience the partner often excuses them by saying "well s/he treats ME well so can't really be nasty deep down".

purpledalmation · 04/04/2023 10:11

Because when she married him he put on a 'nice guy' act. If she has children it makes it even more difficult to leave. Maybe he is nice to her and a dick to everyone else?

gannett · 04/04/2023 10:09

Well obviously it's not as simple as people being GOOD or BAD and someone who comes across as grumpy or abrasive or arrogant might well have a lot of positive points that you don't get to see when you're not in a relationship with them.

But taking out the blanket labels - if someone says or does eg racist or homophobic things, then as far as I'm concerned their partner condones and is complicit in their bigotry, and I'll treat them as such. No excuses.

RudsyFarmer · 04/04/2023 10:09

Jack might have put on his best behaviour pre marriage and reverted to a twat afterwards. Now the woman is shackled to an idiot. Kids in tow. It’s difficult to just walk away even if you’re terminally embarrassed.

Aposterhasnoname · 04/04/2023 10:08

Gosh I don’t know. Maybe he was charm itself when reeling her in, but now she too far invested he’s showing her his true colours.

Maverickess · 04/04/2023 10:05

If Jack treats everyone else like that, chances are as his wife he treats Lily worse.
But then the more we focus on the people around the arsehole, rather than the arsehole and their behaviour, the longer it goes unchallenged, which is why people like Jack go unchallenged - Lily is the easy target because she presents as nice.

TennisWithDeborah · 04/04/2023 10:04

I’ve known relationships like this. The Lily character (not always the woman) is usually downtrodden with low self-esteem. If you really like her OP, make friends with her. When he decides he’s done with her, she’ll need supportive mates.

The examples of Carrie Johnson and Melania Trump are not the same as the OP’s. They married influence/power/money, which is different. They’re both prepared to ignore their spouses’ failings because of the material advantages their marriages bring.

mewkins · 04/04/2023 10:01

Another question to ask is: does being friends with a horrible person make you horrible? If so, you need to ditch your friends 😄

Theimpossiblegirl · 04/04/2023 09:58

Of course, women who don't immediately realise their partners are abusive fuckers just aren't nice people. That's why.

I always believed it was much more complex than that, with patterns of abuse and shitty behaviour building up over time, fear of leaving, hoping they'll change, nowhere to go, no money, but nope, they're just not nice people.

I'm being sarcastic just in case my tone is too subtle.

IShouldGoToSleep · 04/04/2023 09:57

My mum married a horrendous person. He beat are terribly. He was rude, had sick views and was truly an unpleasant man. She married him young because her own mother was horrid to her and wanted her married off. She had no confidence, thought noone else would have her. At one point she tried to back out of the wedding but in the end went though with it. She tried to leave after they got married, after one particularly brutal attack, but was scared and didn't know where to go, so she called her father who took her back. After 3 kids and 15 years married to the man, she finally left.

These things are complicated.

JackiePlace · 04/04/2023 09:57

Whatever the truth of it is, couples come as a package. You can't be friendly with just one of them.
I also have a big problem with this as my sister has just married an ignorant, racist, loud-mouthed, uncouth dickhead and has given up her professional career (she was very close to qualifying as a chartered accountant) to help him in his doomed restaurant business washing dishes and prepping vegetables and such.
I do not understand this at all. She is a tad eccentric but has a heart of gold and never lacked boyfriends.

Chinuplippyon · 04/04/2023 09:57

I was going to make 2 points- both of which PPs have made very clearly already! But anyway-

  1. people are complicated. There isn't really a binary category for good and bad for most people. Actions can tip the balance but whilst Jack sounds very unpleasant, he hasn't necessarily done anything beyond the pale in lily's view. Jack may be snappy, rude, uncouth and entitled but have qualities that appeal to Lily. These could be hidden virtues such as loyalty, intelligence, humour or generosity. They could be as simple as being a good, steady provider and reliable. She may be low in self esteem and think this is as good as it gets.

  2. there can be reasons in an individual's past that inform their behaviours. Lily could have had a rude aggressive dad or an abrasive home atmosphere so has unconsciously sought out the same. Jack could have had an abusive upbringing that's led him to develop aggressive behaviour. Lily might understand that and empathise, and essentially see beyond it.

But no, I don't think it's as simple as tarring her with the same brush. She might feel beaten down, intimidated or simply used to unpleasant behaviour. She might feel she knows 'the real him' and overlooks it. She might not care as long as she has a husband present. People don't pick their own backgrounds so it depends how you see 'good' and 'bad'.

Sprinkles21 · 04/04/2023 09:56

I had an ex like this, he was verbally and emotionally abusive to me, told me no one else would ever love me not that he ever did I was a possession. You never know what goes on behind closed doors. Also she may just be *fake and actually a cow too

mewkins · 04/04/2023 09:56

A couple I know like this - the 'bad' partner started off as ok and then has become worse and more controlling over the years. They have a house and a child (he provides the most childcare and threatens to never let his child see her mum if she leaves) so she is pretty much stuck.