Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think you can't be a nice person if you marry a sh*t one?

92 replies

aplateandaspoon · 04/04/2023 09:39

I know this couple, let's call her Lily who is married to Jack. I know Jack much better than I know Lily. We are not friends per se, but we see each other often as we have friends in common. I also know Jack's family very well.

Lily seems to be the most adorable lovely person, always polite and smily. But Jack is an absolute dickhead, he treats anyone in the service industry (waiters, cleaners, etc...) like they are beneath him and he is rude to them. He makes awful comments to people he knows like "oh you better get married soon otherwise people will assume you are gay"... things like that.

I know Jack's family pretty well, and I know he treats his mum really badly. He snaps at her and the way sometimes he speaks to her is shocking. Once he even let slip that he can't stand her but she helps them with childcare and with rent so he has to put up with her otherwise they will lose the money.

So going back to Lily... my question is, how can a "good" person marry someone so awful? I just think she cannot be a good person at all. If my partner spoke to people like Jack does, that would be a dealbreaker for me.

I've never tried to engage with Lily much, other than polite pleasantries, cause I don't want a relationship with them (mainly Jack) but part of me also cannot believe she is a genuinely nice person if she married someone like Jack.

So my question is, can who chooses to be partners with someone so awful be a genuinely nice person?

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 04/04/2023 18:16

I have known many scenarios where a genuinely lovely person is with an absolute cunt.

As others have said there are many reasons why people (and particularly women) might stay with such a person.

In no particular order:

  • Because the person is similar to their opposite sex parent and it’s what was modelled to them as a child
  • Low self esteem and thinking they can’t do better
  • Sex
  • They get something from the horrible partner that others don’t get
  • Trapped financially or a major financial incentive to remain in the relationship
  • Shared children

It’s not rocket science. People are different and have wildly different emotional needs.

2bazookas · 04/04/2023 18:09

As you know Jacks family well, why not ask them ?
Or since Jack is quite disinhibited, just ask him.

On second thoughts, is it possible Lily is autistic but masks all the tie, Jack is autistic too and thats their bond. Mutual understanding and acceptance.

mewkins · 04/04/2023 17:28

TankFlyBossW4lk · 04/04/2023 13:43

I'm totally with you, OP. It's an extension of, "Show me who your friends are, I'll tell you who you are. "

If you put up with this, there's a certain amount of acceptance of the behaviour. Worse if you feel that the person is marriage material.

But OP's friends are friends with this man. What does that say about THEM?

Antiquiteas · 04/04/2023 13:46

The barely internalised misogyny on this thread is as grim as ever.

TankFlyBossW4lk · 04/04/2023 13:43

I'm totally with you, OP. It's an extension of, "Show me who your friends are, I'll tell you who you are. "

If you put up with this, there's a certain amount of acceptance of the behaviour. Worse if you feel that the person is marriage material.

JKTrolling · 04/04/2023 13:40

This scenario is very common. Women pretending to be nice while hiding behind an absolute dick of a man. It doesn’t wash with me any more. Leave him if you think you’re such a good person.

QueenBeaver · 04/04/2023 13:11

My ex-husband was an awful man. A cheat, a liar, a womaniser. I’m none of those things, I was just young and infatuated by him. For anyone to think that I’m a ‘bad person’ is nasty and frankly ridiculous. Anyway, some of the nastiest people can put on a real show of being nice and to their supposed loved one(s) they keep them hanging on so they think they’ll change. They never do.

I’m with someone lovely now.

Mumoftwoinprimary · 04/04/2023 13:07

I think that - once invested - it would be difficult to leave a man like that.

Notbeinfunnehbut · 04/04/2023 12:43

I agree with you op because
people in toxic or abusive marriages can also be people who will ignore others bad behaviour or pretend to be nicer than they are

can be both at the same time

IAteAllTheTomatoes · 04/04/2023 12:42

Almost every decent friend I have who married/divorced an asshole married a carbon copy of their equally asshole father.

What about people in DV relationship? I'm pretty certain most of trm are decent people being abused by assholes. The abuse is zero reflection on them.

KarmaStar · 04/04/2023 12:37

Is this a real post or a bait thread from a trainee journo of a low rate publisher ?
Because it is extremely unwise to judge everybody who is with a person who is not seen as 'nice' as being unpleasant or fake as well.
Ok have outlined excellent reasons and there are many more.
It is also insulting.

Ktime · 04/04/2023 12:27

Fairislefandango · 04/04/2023 12:21

No, she isn’t. OP said ’I just think she cannot be a good person at all.’

This is making Lily responsible for Jack’s behaviour.

No it isn't. What do you think 'being responsible for' means? If someone is responsible for an accident, it means they caused it. If a parent is responsible for their child's bad upbringing, it's because the parent brought the child up badly. Suggesting that Lily is a bad person because she's choosing to be with a bad man is not the same at a as saying that Lily is responsible for his badness. She is not making him be bad. It simply means she's responsible for her own poor choice of partner.

So first you said The OP is only holding Lily responsible for staying in a relationship with someone like Jack, not holding her responsible for the fact that Jack's a bad person.

At least you admit that OP is saying Lily is a bad person.

When OP says ‘If my partner spoke to people like Jack does, that would be a dealbreaker for me.’, the inference is that she has never seen Lily pull up Jack on his behaviour. For people like you, it’s always the woman’s responsibility to keep her husband in check.

So yes, you are holding Lily responsible for Jack, just like OP.

Fairislefandango · 04/04/2023 12:21

No, she isn’t. OP said ’I just think she cannot be a good person at all.’

This is making Lily responsible for Jack’s behaviour.

No it isn't. What do you think 'being responsible for' means? If someone is responsible for an accident, it means they caused it. If a parent is responsible for their child's bad upbringing, it's because the parent brought the child up badly. Suggesting that Lily is a bad person because she's choosing to be with a bad man is not the same at a as saying that Lily is responsible for his badness. She is not making him be bad. It simply means she's responsible for her own poor choice of partner.

purplecorkheart · 04/04/2023 12:18

I know a few couples like this and at the start of the relationship the horrible partner was lovely, charming etc. It was only after the marriage that their true colours started to appear.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 04/04/2023 12:15

Well, my mum is kind and lovely and my father is an absolute dickhead.

In her case I think it was crippingly low self-esteem and no decent male role models when choosing a husband - she just thought (and still thinks) that’s how men behave and what you have to tolerate.

Whattt44 · 04/04/2023 12:12

Abusers don't show their hand immediately, they wait until they have their victim hooked and then it starts .
Why are you friends with him, doesn't that make you a horrible person?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/04/2023 12:08

If she grew up being abused and neglected, he won't seem as bad as her parent(s).

One of my exes was a terrible human being - but at the time, he at least pretended to quite like me occasionally, which is a damn sight more than my mother ever did. The only time I was ever touched as a child was when I was being hit. But he didn't do that. He could be affectionate. He wanted to touch me, spend time with me, talk, laugh, be together. So he never seemed as bad, not when his behaviour escalated, not when he began revealing the nastier side of his personality, right up to and including the day when he nearly killed me.

Yup, despite the fact that he was a horrible, nasty person, I still felt more special, more loved by him than I ever was as a child. Even when he turned and demonised me, the strength of his anger towards me counted for more than the outright absence of feeling, affection or anything resembling love throughout my childhood. Because at least he felt something.

That doesn't make me a shitty person. I'm free to actually be me with DP, who is fundamentally a good, kind, smart, sweet and funny man who doesn't see trying to be a fundamentally decent human being as a sign of weakness and I'm utterly safe with him - but I wasn't bad to begin with.

blahblahblahandblahsomemore · 04/04/2023 12:04

I don't know - one of my friends who is lovely has the vilest husband I've ever known. She just seems to be able separate his actions and behaviour from their marriage (if that makes sense).

SiSiG · 04/04/2023 12:02

I know a couple a bit like this. He’s greedy, manipulative, self-serving and generally the kind of person who’d drown his granny to stay afloat. She’s sweetness and light.

I’ve realised recently that they’re just good cop and bad cop. She benefits from his behaviour, and hers means they have an increased social circle and more people to rip off.

I don’t see either of them nowadays.

Antiquiteas · 04/04/2023 12:01

So you’re judging her because her husband is a cunt?

Women still being blamed for what men do. Brilliant.

unsync · 04/04/2023 12:00

🙄 I suggest you do some research about abuse perpetrators, love bombing and trauma bonds. Surely you realise that abusers target their victims and that they are usually vulnerable in some way?

MarieRoseMarie · 04/04/2023 11:55

I don’t think it’s every case, but I think it’s a lot more cases than people are willing to admit. I’ve met a lot of women who are married to overt racists. These men were racist when they met and are openly and loudly racist.

These women like to play that they are liberals. Black Lives Matter type stuff.

These women married them anyway.

I ended all the relationships with these women including one where years later she came crawling back alleging abuse as if that would make up for it!

Ktime · 04/04/2023 11:54

Fairislefandango · 04/04/2023 11:47

Everything that @Chinuplippyon said. It's probably relatively easy for people with a stable upbringing, loving parents who modelled healthy relationships, and good mental health, to choose a good partner. I would once have automatically judged 'Lily' without question too, but the MN relationships board has educated me.

But she is doing that. She is saying Jack is shit, ergo Lily is shit too. That’s making Lily responsible for his shitnessl

No it isn't. Being responsible for Jack's shitness would mean that she caused it. The OP is only holding Lily responsible for staying in a relationship with someone like Jack, not holding her responsible for the fact that Jack's a bad person.

The OP is only holding Lily responsible for staying in a relationship with someone like Jack, not holding her responsible for the fact that Jack's a bad person.

No, she isn’t. OP said ’I just think she cannot be a good person at all.’

This is making Lily responsible for Jack’s behaviour.

ladyofshertonabbas · 04/04/2023 11:51

Nice people get coerced into marrying arseholes. Tale as old as time.

Fairislefandango · 04/04/2023 11:47

Everything that @Chinuplippyon said. It's probably relatively easy for people with a stable upbringing, loving parents who modelled healthy relationships, and good mental health, to choose a good partner. I would once have automatically judged 'Lily' without question too, but the MN relationships board has educated me.

But she is doing that. She is saying Jack is shit, ergo Lily is shit too. That’s making Lily responsible for his shitnessl

No it isn't. Being responsible for Jack's shitness would mean that she caused it. The OP is only holding Lily responsible for staying in a relationship with someone like Jack, not holding her responsible for the fact that Jack's a bad person.

Swipe left for the next trending thread