Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know how to digest this feedback?

233 replies

pleasepleasemee · 04/04/2023 07:37

I play a (mixed) sport and I'm new to it. I joined a social club associated with it. Most people know each other and I'm newer. I'm one of few women. I try to attend every possible game/event (even if I'm not playing), to learn more, get to know people better etc.

The coach is someone I really really respect

I offered to help the him organise a tournament.

At our first meeting about it, he sat me down and said he was reluctant to take me up on my offer because he felt I was unauthentic around him and it made him very uncomfortable. He said he felt I was always trying to say the right thing, so that I got more opportunities to play.

He said it with absolute kindness and in the interest of improving the situation and being transparent, but nonetheless I was absolutely shocked. I'm a bit nervous around him because I respect him and because I'm the new person on the wider team but with absolutely no agenda other than to just be respectful and not piss anyone off or seem over-familiar, when I'm still new.

I'm a very extroverted person and very confident to be myself and the last thing I've ever been called is unauthentic. I have a successful career and a huge network (both professionally and socially) and the feedback I always have is that I'm down-to-earth and relatable! So this is really not something I've come across.

What was really unsettling was that he felt I was doing it to gain favour to get to play more matches, when genuinely this hadn't even occurred to me. I assumed I'd play more once I improved!

The conversation was very respectful but now every time I interact with him (which is a ton) I feel uncomfortable that I'm coming across that way again. The irony is that NOW I'm probably being unauthentic. I read into every single interaction with him now, which I never did previously.

I also feel like there are some things left unsaid as I having been reflecting on it (particularly around the misconception that I'm trying to 'suck up'). I would like another opportunity to say my piece now I've digested his feedback. I don't want to come across defensive but I do feel I was too blindsided to give a fully formed response.

I'm not sure how I come back from his now. He really did approach it very respectfully and it didn't upset me as such, but nonetheless I'm not sure what to do with the information, particularly as there was no inauthenticity intended in the first place.

OP posts:
pleasepleasemee · 04/04/2023 10:41

lljkk · 04/04/2023 10:23

There would be merit in asking others how you come across. I am interpreting what OP said to be "over enthusiastic." that might mean controlling & intense in someone else's eyes. I understand why OP is being deliberately vague, so vague that I am probably misunderstanding what the coach said. I also suspect something is unsaid here, which could be many things, eg. "I need to encourage others to get involved for their own good and not always have the same people volunteering. Other are discouraged or encouraged to be lazy, maybe because they feel suffocated by your strong personality" or whatever coach's thoughts are.

I'm not being vague about what he said.

Word for word it was that he felt uncomfortable around me because he felt I wasn't authentic around him and was just trying to say what he wanted to hear so that he gave me opportunities to play.

He said it in the context of planning the tournament and that he didn't feel the dynamic would work (although he ultimately took me up on the offer).

I took it at face value initially but now I'm reflecting on everything. I am the only woman showing up to every single event, watching every match, going all the social stuff and getting to know as many people as possible.

It has somewhat occurred to me that my presence might change the dynamic a bit (people sometimes bring their wives to the social stuff but no other female players tend to join), but not to the extent I'd be unwelcome or disliked.

OP posts:
olympicsrock · 04/04/2023 10:39

I think his comments were totally unnecessary. He doesn’t like you OP and finds you overly enthusiastic.

Take him off the pedestal. If you want to carry on with this activity, you need to chill out and not volunteer to help because it is not welcome - he just wanted the old hands . I wouldn’t talk about it to him or anyone else - I think that will make it bigger. Sorry that this happened to you.

Companyofwolves · 04/04/2023 10:38

I wouldn't ask about perceptions of you, I'd ask about perceptions of him - ditto.

And don’t share what he said to you either o’wise it will get back.

Itakecreaminmycoffee · 04/04/2023 10:38

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 04/04/2023 07:43

My first thought was that he feels threatened by you, as a confident and successful woman - he doesn't want you taking over his territory. I don't think you should attach too much to his feedback - this is one person, compared to many others who have said you are down to earth and relatable. His comment, based on hardly knowing you, doesn't deserve revisiting with a fuller response.

If you enjoy the club and it's a good opportunity to play the sport, just go there to participate - it's his loss if he doesn't want to make use of your offer to organise events.

First answer nailed it.

He's a misogynistic twat. He's probably used to bossing everyone around and doesn't know how to handle you as he's threatened by your confidence.

Lifeisnotfair4 · 04/04/2023 10:37

He sounds creepy to me I’d be wary of him.

senua · 04/04/2023 10:32

I am wondering about asking another guy on the team that I'm closer with, to be transparent about how I'm perceived
I wouldn't ask about perceptions of you, I'd ask about perceptions of him.Hmm
Most clubs and charities are desperate for people to step up and help; what on earth is he doing in trying to discourage you? I'm not surprised that the club is short of women!

lljkk · 04/04/2023 10:32

I guess you'll have to ask him what unauthentic means, then. It's a weird word. Insincere? Manipulative? Overbearing? Over-confident? Greedy? I couldn't make sense of it, either.

pleasepleasemee · 04/04/2023 10:27

lljkk · 04/04/2023 10:25

Maybe coach is getting feedback that OP is getting > fair share of play opportunities when others don't have spare time like OP to donate, & coach wants to create space for others to see that coach is being fair minded. A version of "Members of the PTA get all the nice treatment at the primary school" complaint. And "The coach's kid always gets picked for the football match even though that kid is useless on the pitch" etc.

I get less opportunities than everyone else! People who've been playing less time get more than I do. I assumed it was because I simply wasn't good enough yet.

OP posts:
ihavespoken · 04/04/2023 10:26

Nothing much to add other than I agree he sounds like a dick and it's not you OP - but I am agog at someone in a sporting organisation being so awash with volunteers that they can be so rude to those who do step up!
People who want to get involved and are generous with their time are the lifeblood of sports (and other) clubs and it's a sign of his bellendedness that he hasn't snapped up your offer of help. Dick.

lljkk · 04/04/2023 10:25

Maybe coach is getting feedback that OP is getting > fair share of play opportunities when others don't have spare time like OP to donate, & coach wants to create space for others to see that coach is being fair minded. A version of "Members of the PTA get all the nice treatment at the primary school" complaint. And "The coach's kid always gets picked for the football match even though that kid is useless on the pitch" etc.

lljkk · 04/04/2023 10:23

There would be merit in asking others how you come across. I am interpreting what OP said to be "over enthusiastic." that might mean controlling & intense in someone else's eyes. I understand why OP is being deliberately vague, so vague that I am probably misunderstanding what the coach said. I also suspect something is unsaid here, which could be many things, eg. "I need to encourage others to get involved for their own good and not always have the same people volunteering. Other are discouraged or encouraged to be lazy, maybe because they feel suffocated by your strong personality" or whatever coach's thoughts are.

PicnicBunny · 04/04/2023 10:18

But it’s a volunteer thing and you volunteered. What’s wrong with that? So he didn’t want you there he could have said we have enough people. What’s with the inauthentic comment. Sounds calculated, like there’s a clique there already.

BlackFriday · 04/04/2023 10:18

Who died and made him King of the World?
How DARE he criticise your personality - WAY out of line.

Dobby123456 · 04/04/2023 10:17

pleasepleasemee · 04/04/2023 08:37

I'm fairly resilient and didn't give it much thought.

Today though, he'd helped a bunch of us out with something and everyone text him to say thank you.

I was the only one who didn't get a reply from him and now I feel dreadful!

While my thanks were no more or less profuse than anyone else's, now all I can think is "oh god he thinks I'm kissing arse again". It's a bit exhausting to have to think about this stuff! I should be able to say thank you without having to consider how it's perceived.

As other posters have said, he just doesn't like you. This is a bit of a pity as you clearly like him as a coach and wanted to be part of the team like everyone else. However, it doesn't sound like there's anything you can do to change his opinion. All you've done differently from anybody else is turn up to games you're not playing in - which is what he's encouraged people to do!

Like other posters have said, what is it about him that you respect? Good team leaders don't let their personal dislikes and favourites get in the way of working well with people.

Rosula · 04/04/2023 10:15

Coach strikes me as a real dickhead. Who the hell sits down with a keen new volunteer and tells them they're "unauthentic" and trying to suck up to get more chances to play? Surely anyone with any skills in people management lets the volunteer settle in before making any sort of judgments? If he didn't want you helping, surely all he needed to do was to say something to the effect that he really wanted someone with more experience?

It's a shame, because in your shoes I would have lost a lot of respect for him. Is he a volunteer coach or paid? I'd be tempted to get myself onto the management committee and start doing something about cutting down the amount of power he has.

MsRosley · 04/04/2023 10:15

He sounds like a complete arsehole.

pleasepleasemee · 04/04/2023 10:15

On reflection, I do wonder if it was about my volunteering to help with the tournament.

It usually involves travelling for a weekend somewhere, and the newbies wouldn't usually go.

His requests for volunteers are informal (like he's asked before for people to step up with anything they can help with), so I offered this.

But given I wouldn't have been going to the tournament otherwise, I wonder if he felt I was trying to muscle my way in, and my presence would be unwelcome.

Although, if that were the case, he should've said no!

I've never in my whole life felt unwelcome/unliked. It's completely at odds with everything I've known about myself for 40 years, so now I'm questioning everything!

I am wondering about asking another guy on the team that I'm closer with, to be transparent about how I'm perceived a

OP posts:
PicnicBunny · 04/04/2023 10:14

He had to say that to you? Why? Why didn’t he just adjust and move out of the way if he didn’t feel comfortable around you. Or keep conversations short. Why say it?

I suspect he wanted to knock your confidence and enthusiasm down. He wants to be inside your head. And now he is. Don’t give it a second thought - btw the guy sounds like a manipulative arsehat, and you sound absolutely lovely.

BellePeppa · 04/04/2023 10:14

Hillrunning · 04/04/2023 07:57

I'm trying to look at this from different angles. I suppose a newbie being at everything and offering to help with arrangements so early on could come across as a bit try hard. If he wouldn't go about integrating himself into a new group in such a strong way, it could come across as inauthentic. Did you leave it that you won't help with the tournament then? I'd just back off a little and relax into the integration.

But so what? So what if a new member was putting in extra effort or being too ‘try hard’. I don’t see why that’s a problem. Surely when people start new jobs they do exactly the same thing? It’s normal and natural to put forward your best self in a new environment.

MoongazyHare · 04/04/2023 10:13

Hmmmm. Big man in his small pool sees a new member who has leadership potential and is so nice that everyone likes her - and she is a woman, shock horror. He feels threatened and therefore decides to take her down a peg or two.

He is a dick, and not actually worthy of much respect, OP. I’ll bet there have been all kinds of internecine wars between the members and Clive has won the top spot through the force of his personality, and lack of any inhibitions about putting people in their place, i.e. everyone is too afraid of losing favour, and therefore access to matches, not to concede to him. Watch the dynamics for a bit longer and see if I’m right.

Carry on being your authentic self 😁 and hope he gets an injury which means he has to give up. I’d bet cash money on your being proposed as a leader if the opportunity arose.

BillyDeanisnotmylover · 04/04/2023 10:09

Aprilx · 04/04/2023 08:02

I can also see that view point. It all seems a bit much to join a new group and then be offering to run a tournament so early on. I think I would find it a bit much too and I expect this was his angle.

Yes, I have to admit that’s how I saw it too. The op has good intentions but others, who possibly aren’t as gregarious and confident as she, are likely to see it as trying to take over or ingratiate herself.

foulksmills · 04/04/2023 09:59

pleasepleasemee · 04/04/2023 08:37

I'm fairly resilient and didn't give it much thought.

Today though, he'd helped a bunch of us out with something and everyone text him to say thank you.

I was the only one who didn't get a reply from him and now I feel dreadful!

While my thanks were no more or less profuse than anyone else's, now all I can think is "oh god he thinks I'm kissing arse again". It's a bit exhausting to have to think about this stuff! I should be able to say thank you without having to consider how it's perceived.

I hope my saying this doesn't make you feel worse OP but if this happened to me I'd be overthinking the fuck out of it!

I can somewhat relate to your situation, in that I also do a predominantly male sport, have a male instructor and have the utmost respect for him. I'd be devastated if he pulled me aside to say what yours said to you. When you respect someone you definitely don't want them to dislike you in return.

m00rfarm · 04/04/2023 09:52

I am guessing that this comment was "fed" back to him by another member and he has been embarrassed by it. Speak with him directly, and try as hard as you can to be yourself. you do NOT have to explain if you don't want to. If it were me, I would rather have my say, and then you have both had the chance to air your views.

Hoppinggreen · 04/04/2023 09:52

Anyone who tells you you are “unauthentic” is a wanker.
Having said that you sound very confident, which is not a criticism at all I am too but a lot of people (men) don’t like it. Also it can come across as arrogant or pushy.
I like the sound of you OP but you won’t be everyone’s cuppa

fleurpots · 04/04/2023 09:52

He wasn’t being kind - he really did not need to bring this up. Who cares if he thinks you’re inauthentic - he can keep it to himself surely? He’s not your boss, this isn’t work, there isn’t anything on the line.

He’s trying to put you in your place, don’t let him.