Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know how to digest this feedback?

233 replies

pleasepleasemee · 04/04/2023 07:37

I play a (mixed) sport and I'm new to it. I joined a social club associated with it. Most people know each other and I'm newer. I'm one of few women. I try to attend every possible game/event (even if I'm not playing), to learn more, get to know people better etc.

The coach is someone I really really respect

I offered to help the him organise a tournament.

At our first meeting about it, he sat me down and said he was reluctant to take me up on my offer because he felt I was unauthentic around him and it made him very uncomfortable. He said he felt I was always trying to say the right thing, so that I got more opportunities to play.

He said it with absolute kindness and in the interest of improving the situation and being transparent, but nonetheless I was absolutely shocked. I'm a bit nervous around him because I respect him and because I'm the new person on the wider team but with absolutely no agenda other than to just be respectful and not piss anyone off or seem over-familiar, when I'm still new.

I'm a very extroverted person and very confident to be myself and the last thing I've ever been called is unauthentic. I have a successful career and a huge network (both professionally and socially) and the feedback I always have is that I'm down-to-earth and relatable! So this is really not something I've come across.

What was really unsettling was that he felt I was doing it to gain favour to get to play more matches, when genuinely this hadn't even occurred to me. I assumed I'd play more once I improved!

The conversation was very respectful but now every time I interact with him (which is a ton) I feel uncomfortable that I'm coming across that way again. The irony is that NOW I'm probably being unauthentic. I read into every single interaction with him now, which I never did previously.

I also feel like there are some things left unsaid as I having been reflecting on it (particularly around the misconception that I'm trying to 'suck up'). I would like another opportunity to say my piece now I've digested his feedback. I don't want to come across defensive but I do feel I was too blindsided to give a fully formed response.

I'm not sure how I come back from his now. He really did approach it very respectfully and it didn't upset me as such, but nonetheless I'm not sure what to do with the information, particularly as there was no inauthenticity intended in the first place.

OP posts:
Cherry2010 · 04/04/2023 11:55

He doesn’t know you. What gives him the right to give you “feedback” on your personality? You’re giving him way too much importance.

winelove · 04/04/2023 11:50

Just smile and go about things exactly the same way.
Volunteer when you want to and go ahead to the matches where you don't play.
You are naturally lively and outgoing don't change.
Just smile and say this is my authentic self!

80s · 04/04/2023 11:45

You're sure he doesn't like you? It's not that he doesn't know how to interact with a woman and is afraid he'll be accused of fancying you (/afraid of fancying you) or that people will think he's being nicer to you because of your gender for some other reason - so he's trying to go in the other direction and being especially gruff/giving you fewer opportunities?

pleasepleasemee · 04/04/2023 11:21

2023usernameNew · 04/04/2023 11:14

Why would an experience coach feel threatened by someone new to the sport?

there’a no chance in hell the OP would be able to take over his position or be able to undermine him.

or am I reading it wrong? What do people think he feel threatened by?

Agree. He doesn't feel threatened by me. Maybe he doesn't necessarily like my personality and having me around makes him less comfortable though.

OP posts:
WonderingWanda · 04/04/2023 11:17

He sounds like a twat. What's wrong with being polite and trying to create a good impression on people. Even if you were being helpful to try and get picked more why would that matter? He's a grown up and can not pick you.

Wheresthebeach · 04/04/2023 11:16

I think it's the 'boys' atmosphere that's threatened. Women are welcome when invited only. They can't say no women, but they can make them feel unwelcome all under the guise of 'feedback'.

2023usernameNew · 04/04/2023 11:14

Why would an experience coach feel threatened by someone new to the sport?

there’a no chance in hell the OP would be able to take over his position or be able to undermine him.

or am I reading it wrong? What do people think he feel threatened by?

Nailsandthesea · 04/04/2023 11:11

I would say
‘I’ve reflected on what you said - as I always try to take on board comments from other people. But you asked for volunteers I did so - you made an inaccurate statement regarding my intentions and I want to clarify I am keen and I want to learn more. That’s why I’m volunteering. That’s the sole reason. If you don’t want me to help, tell me. Women are underrepresented here.’ Leave it as a fact.
just state it

ProfYaffle · 04/04/2023 11:08

IVbumble · 04/04/2023 10:58

Quite often what people accuse you of is how they are behaving themselves.

Yep - agree with this. He's telling you about himself.

FinallyHere · 04/04/2023 11:08

My first thought was that he feels threatened by you, as a confident and successful woman - he doesn't want you taking over his territory

@PussBilledDuckyPlait has very probably nailed it.

He does sound very insecure. And is totally projecting his own faults in this 'feedback'.

Volunteers generally can have all sorts of complicated motivation and many do struggle to allow other people to genuinely be helpful and carry the load.

He probably expects other people to avoid having to contribute. Seeing someone who is already being given less than their fair share of opportunities volunteer to help more could well be making him afraid that you have potential to be a better, more popular leader than he is already, even if you don't ever take the opportunity.

I'm sorry you are facing this. Up to you whether you allow it to kill your enthusiasm or use it to make you stronger, whether as part of their group or elsewhere.


As one woman to another, I'd just be sure to never be alone with him and to make sure he was never between me and the door. Just sayin'

billy1966 · 04/04/2023 11:05

Wheresthebeach · 04/04/2023 10:50

He's a dick, and I think it's about you being a woman and that may make the behaviour of the group 'less laddish'.

So, you can respect his sports ability, but you need to get your head around the fact that he's a dick. I wouldn't thank him, I'd play, talk to everyone else and distance myself from him. Don't volunteer anymore, and keep your interactions to a minimum.

I would, though, because it's the sort of thing that would eat away at me, say to him something along the lines of 'considering your views, which I wholeheartedly disagree with, you'll understand if I put things on a slightly more formal footing between us as you are clearly uncomfortable with my style of communication - I just wanted to explain why I'm giving you space' - and then turn and walk away. I think you need to say something otherwise he'll just keep twisting things. And then put him in the drawer labelled 'Misogynistic Dicks', and give it no more thought.

This is good advice if you contine.

ALLIS0N · 04/04/2023 11:03

Three possibilities

  1. he hates you / all women and wants them to fuck off out of his club but he knows that’s not politically corrected so he does it in this passive aggressive way
  2. he is negging you so you end up desperate for his approval , so he has power over you, as he wants to use or abuse you
  3. he wants female volunteers to wash the kit and make tea, not do something like organise a tournament that could be seem as important / prestigious

He is 100% not a nice guy in any shape or form. He is a man who misuses the power and position he has. You need to go elsewhere or find a way to stay and minimise your interaction with him.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 04/04/2023 11:02

He’s a dick. You sound awesome. Don’t doubt yourself.

AudreyBabs · 04/04/2023 11:01

I am not sure he deserves the amount of respect you have for him. I wonder if you have put him a bit of a pedestal and this feedback could help you to realise he doesn't belong there?

I wouldn't bring this up with him again, it is likely he will see it as an opportunity for you to seek his validation, which you don't need. I understand as I would definitely want to discuss this situation further and seek closure but I honestly think it could end up making this situation worse because I don't think you will get what you're looking for.

It's easier said than done but it might be worth pulling back on the extra commitments and the emotions you are applying to this and allow the relationships to reset. Approach it in a way that allows you to be detached for a while - then you can have a bit of time to assess where you stand in these new relationships and to see who really deserves your respect and time. Focus on the enjoyment of the sport for a while (then you usually find the relationships get easier) - I hope that makes sense!

Sorry that your passion has been misinterpreted. Don't let it dampen your passion - but do let it help you to determine who deserves the benefit of it.

BenCoopersSupportWren · 04/04/2023 11:01

I wouldn't ask anyone else how you come across, and I wouldn't ask another man at the club anything. I'd ask one of the other women how they find him.

billy1966 · 04/04/2023 11:00

OP,

There was absolutely NOTHING nice about his absolute character assassination to your face.

He clearly likes a male only dynamic and his prickish way of dealing with it is to be as nasty as possible with a nicey nicey manner.

I would definitely mention it to the other person you know that clearly females are NOT welcome, and how creepy the coach has been.

You can persevere if you wish but you clearly are not wanted.

That you didn't tell him politely to go fxxk off with his unasked for critique of your character is beyond me.

How about you take him aside and do a similar job on him, his personality, his insecurities, his dislike of women, and how really creepy he comes across?

He sounds awful.

I can't believe you think he is anything other that really horrible.

His behaviour is NOT normal.

Leave a review of the club that it clearly has no wish for female members and the coaches method of deterring them is to behave in a really CREEPY manner.

IVbumble · 04/04/2023 10:58

Quite often what people accuse you of is how they are behaving themselves.

CwmYoy · 04/04/2023 10:53

Misogyny has many guises.

Hillsmakeyoustrong · 04/04/2023 10:52

I could have written your post a few years ago when I was in a muay thai club - male dominant and an insecure coach. I was always being approached to help out with interclubs, help new members and provide transport for the fighters shows. I stuck at it for 5 years because I loved the sport and most of the other members. But. My relationship with the lead coach ended up being very stressful. A constant weird undercurrent driven by small but multiple misunderstandings. I tried multiple times to 'clear the air' but soon realised that whilst he presented as a kind person (and he was extremely knowledgeable in the art) he was in fact the insincere one and uncomfortable around women. Especially successful women who took no shit. I took a year out and when I returned, I kept my distance and trained much less as I realised that I had been completely sucked into a toxic club culture. I started out like you being at every event, working hard to integrate because I loved the sport and really respected everyone's ability and wanted to be really good myself, maybe fight some, but ultimately the problem was his. I wish now that I had spent more time just pushing through and investing all my mental energy on the sport itself rather than on the club/coach dynamic but at the time felt it was dependent on having a good relationship with the coach. I'd really advise against talking about it with the other club members and asking their advice, I think you're focusing on this way too much (I get why though!) and I'd wait for him to pass another similar comment (he will) before you say something. Respond maturely at the right time. For now, think about what you would say in future and get good at the sport. Invest in relationships with the club members and just have the minimum conversations with him. Good luck.

Moveoverdarlin · 04/04/2023 10:50

But why on Earth does he feel the need to deconstruct your personality like this? We all meet people and think they’re a bit pushy, they’re a bit false, so and so can be a bit flaky, they can be a bit arse licky, but you don’t tell people!! Maybe during a heart to heart with your partner, but he’s a coach at a sports club FFS. I assume you’re paying to be there. My DH is a member of a local sports club and there are so many characters. Some are ridiculously competitive, some are useless at the sport but good fun, you don’t break down someone’s traits and pick them up on it. Personally I would leave, fuck that, I wouldn’t be spoken to like that, no matter how respectful he was. And I would say, I was quite offended when you said I wasn't authentic, I found it rude.

Wheresthebeach · 04/04/2023 10:50

He's a dick, and I think it's about you being a woman and that may make the behaviour of the group 'less laddish'.

So, you can respect his sports ability, but you need to get your head around the fact that he's a dick. I wouldn't thank him, I'd play, talk to everyone else and distance myself from him. Don't volunteer anymore, and keep your interactions to a minimum.

I would, though, because it's the sort of thing that would eat away at me, say to him something along the lines of 'considering your views, which I wholeheartedly disagree with, you'll understand if I put things on a slightly more formal footing between us as you are clearly uncomfortable with my style of communication - I just wanted to explain why I'm giving you space' - and then turn and walk away. I think you need to say something otherwise he'll just keep twisting things. And then put him in the drawer labelled 'Misogynistic Dicks', and give it no more thought.

Rosula · 04/04/2023 10:49

I took it at face value initially but now I'm reflecting on everything. I am the only woman showing up to every single event, watching every match, going all the social stuff and getting to know as many people as possible.

I wonder if there's a reason for that, i.e. that he's put all the other women off in the same way? It would be interesting to talk to some of them to see what they think about him.

Redebs · 04/04/2023 10:49

FictionalCharacter · 04/04/2023 08:17

I don’t think he was being kind and respectful. He’s attacking your personality, who you are. It’s pretty nasty to call someone inauthentic and accuse them of manipulating to play more. It’s him not you, and he may well feel uncomfortable around you but not because of you.
If he was right and it’s you, you would have noticed in other situations before now. My guess is that he feels threatened by confident women people and needs to put them down.

Yes,
'inauthentic' is not a reasonable criticism. He's a twit to use such a word.

Chipperfish · 04/04/2023 10:46

This is strange - hes a coach at a social/voluntary activity, not your manager, psychologist or educational supervisor. Absolutely no business of his to try and shape mould or critique your approach or personality, especially unsolicited.

Ignore, breezy and normal interactions, carry on as you were, volunteering and being involved as suits you. Your freezing out of situations will be noticed.
The person who is inauthentic and has an agenda is him, dont rise to it. Probably not worth rehashing the first convo but if he ever tries that shit again have a reply ready - basically setting the whole thing back on him eg questioning his authority, his intent and sheer presumption. Tempting to ask him are you negging? because this is a bloody weird level of overreach and personal critisism for a social club

Dobby123456 · 04/04/2023 10:41

Companyofwolves · 04/04/2023 09:46

Twisted AF! Assassinating your character dressed up as helpful “feedback” - keep well clear of him if I were you OP. Wouldn’t want to help him either. As for the all male dynamics - maybe there’s a reason why no other women stick around for the social bit. I’d go & do the sport bit & give any negging men a wide birth. Vile. Would really wrong foot me too. Good luck!

I'm thinking this guy posts on mumsnet in his spare time. You know, those posts that begin with 'I mean this in the nicest way ....'

Swipe left for the next trending thread