Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know how to digest this feedback?

233 replies

pleasepleasemee · 04/04/2023 07:37

I play a (mixed) sport and I'm new to it. I joined a social club associated with it. Most people know each other and I'm newer. I'm one of few women. I try to attend every possible game/event (even if I'm not playing), to learn more, get to know people better etc.

The coach is someone I really really respect

I offered to help the him organise a tournament.

At our first meeting about it, he sat me down and said he was reluctant to take me up on my offer because he felt I was unauthentic around him and it made him very uncomfortable. He said he felt I was always trying to say the right thing, so that I got more opportunities to play.

He said it with absolute kindness and in the interest of improving the situation and being transparent, but nonetheless I was absolutely shocked. I'm a bit nervous around him because I respect him and because I'm the new person on the wider team but with absolutely no agenda other than to just be respectful and not piss anyone off or seem over-familiar, when I'm still new.

I'm a very extroverted person and very confident to be myself and the last thing I've ever been called is unauthentic. I have a successful career and a huge network (both professionally and socially) and the feedback I always have is that I'm down-to-earth and relatable! So this is really not something I've come across.

What was really unsettling was that he felt I was doing it to gain favour to get to play more matches, when genuinely this hadn't even occurred to me. I assumed I'd play more once I improved!

The conversation was very respectful but now every time I interact with him (which is a ton) I feel uncomfortable that I'm coming across that way again. The irony is that NOW I'm probably being unauthentic. I read into every single interaction with him now, which I never did previously.

I also feel like there are some things left unsaid as I having been reflecting on it (particularly around the misconception that I'm trying to 'suck up'). I would like another opportunity to say my piece now I've digested his feedback. I don't want to come across defensive but I do feel I was too blindsided to give a fully formed response.

I'm not sure how I come back from his now. He really did approach it very respectfully and it didn't upset me as such, but nonetheless I'm not sure what to do with the information, particularly as there was no inauthenticity intended in the first place.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Stewball01 · 08/04/2023 06:58

This.

ACTIVE123 · 07/04/2023 11:09

This has made me cross.

It sounds like you're a strong, successful, confident woman and although I agree with you I don't think he's intimidated by you. I do think that sometimes men struggle with women that are like this. He's probably a nice guy and won't think of himself as misogynistic, but sometimes men struggle when they come across someone who acts like you have and they can interpret as loud, a bit much and maybe inauthentic! This is because it doesn't fit in with their stereotype of what a woman should be and act like.

If this is more of a male dominated sport and he is genuinely trying to encourage more women, he should be celebrating you, encouraging you to get more involved, invite more female friends. It's not always easy for women to join male dominated spaces and feel welcome.

Regardless of whether what I have said above is true or not. I get the impression he just doesn't like you. It's not always easy to hear that, especially if you've always been popular and never had issues like this before. It's absolutely his issue not yours and unfortunately no matter what we do in lifewe will always come across people, who for whatever reason we don't click or gel with.

You have a choice to either accept it and chose to forget it/ put it aside. Or you can go back to him with a more considered response like the one you've put on your post and explain to him how he's made you feel, but you run the risk of potentially making the situation worse/turning it into a bigger deal. Personally I'd be tempted for the second option, not because you have a chance to change his mind (as I think he's already made up his mind about you and once people do that it's generally hard to change/ convince them otherwise), but more for your own benefit as I would want to have my say and get my viewpoint across.

Regardless of what you chose to do, do not let this person affect your behaviour or take you away from a sport you enjoy. Keep being you and accept that you can't control what other people think.

Noodles1234 · 07/04/2023 07:28

Any club where sport or say drama - pitching to be lead in a play etc a lot of people will do anything to be main person, on the team or main part of a play etc. people that run these groups are often put under a lot of pressure from people to get top billing. So I imagine he was just being wary for anyone offering to help (he or she have learnt in the past and now wary of anyone offering help).

for you it was a natural way to learn more and meet people, probably from your work if you want to learn you out the effort in.

its just a clash of ways to fit in, think nothing of it and carry on, I agree they may also feel threatened by you (unintentionally).

you would not believe how some adult people want power trips even say in a local running group or even a kids dance group etc.

Decorate · 06/04/2023 20:04

What cherry blossom said.

I think he knew this would throw you and you'd overthink it.

Don't know why but I can guess. Almost why doesn't matter: see it for what it is and find a way not to overthink people like this (I reckon this is not a first).

Dora33 · 06/04/2023 18:58

A chat that would have involving suggesting he maybe let people get to know him first. That he didn't need to feel he had to rush into helping.
Whether he should have been told how him being a bit of an eager beaver, was coming across, I don't know.
While some people saw him being a positive addition, others felt differently and didn't change their opinion as the guy continued on in the same style.
I don't know what sport you are doing but as mine involved men & women, I found the men would be more inclined to voice opinion / feedback and then move on.
So I can believe the coach didn't have any anti- women / ulterior reasons for giving you this feedback.

burnoutbabe · 06/04/2023 17:38

I imagine whatever you'd / we'd say in that circumstance wouldn't be that the bloke was inauthentic or sucking up. Just that they were a bit full on and should hang back a bit in volunteering, let others have a go.

Bunce1 · 06/04/2023 14:53

pleasepleasemee · 06/04/2023 13:51

But what would/should the chat with your new member have been, that wasn't just attacking him for being a particular personality type?

I agree with this and also think that probably other members have said to the coach- can you have a word please as we are finding her too much.

Ellyess · 06/04/2023 14:18

Cherryblossoms85 ·
My pleasure. I am 100% sincere as always.

pleasepleasemee · 06/04/2023 13:51

Dora33 · 06/04/2023 12:37

Some times a new person to a group/ club sport can come across as over enthusiastic and full on without meaning to. If the team is long established, it can be hard to become part of it where people automatically perceive a new person as belonging.
Volunteering to help at the tournament must have triggered him to how he was already was perceiving you.
I have been part of a team a long time and some team members much longer than me. New people are welcomed but it does take time for people to establish themselves as part of the team.
We had 1 guy turn up and immediately was full on and he did did rub some members up the wrong way with becoming over involved. He was a nice person, just very enthusiastic. It probably would have helped if someone had a chat with him early on.
Stay doing your sport and the coach will hopefully see the positivity you will bring to the team & club.

But what would/should the chat with your new member have been, that wasn't just attacking him for being a particular personality type?

OP posts:
Cherryblossoms85 · 06/04/2023 13:07

@Ellyess Why thank you!

Ellyess · 06/04/2023 13:05

Cherryblossoms85 · 06/04/2023 10:01

Don't overthink it and don't respond or follow up. He's just another dickhead.

As I tend to write a lot - it's a result of my profession and writing reports, research etc. - I just had to quote Cherryblossoms85 because I do so much admire her succinct and so accurate advice.
Please take it. She is absolutely right!

Ellyess · 06/04/2023 13:00

pleasepleasemee I'm really sorry you've met one of these carefully concealed evil people.

You have reacted absolutely normally. You have believed him.
However, you should not have believed him. You should ignore anything he says about you. Do not even discuss it with him.

He might think he is right, but for some reason he has construed your positive attitude this way. It is his personality that is abnormal and nothing to do with you. Maybe he is a covert misogynist, I don't know, but covert narcissist is more likely. I have met, through my profession (now retired), many people like him who decide they 'know' someone and can 'read' all that person's actions accurately. They always 'read' negative traits in people. They never get it right. You could say some may be on the Autistic Spectrum, but in my experience AS people are not like this. The ones I worked with were just narcissists who liked power, liked tormenting people and making them miserable, and of course thought they themselves were always right, always perfect and above everybody. They torment people and disguise it as being helpful.

He likes power of this I am sure.

You really need to realise that this is not a good man. Stop believing him. Indeed stop giving him space in your head. Don't interact with him, just strictly on a 'need to' pragmatic basis. You told us how so many people you know see you. Well, is the majority wrong and he right? I don't think so! Especially as many others know you better and over a longer time. I noticed he picked on you the moment you volunteered, but you had not been able to volunteer on other things. He was waiting to trap you. I don't know why. I can guess, from experience, but I think you have been very unlucky to meet him. You will not be the first or last woman he has abused this way.

You will not change him and honestly I think he will use his position to make your time there miserable. You can try just carrying on and avoiding him as much as you can. I can't see it changing while he is the coach. I think he is actually a bully.

Your choice is to carry on and avoid him, only acknowledging anything he needs to say as a Coach, and never be alone with him. Or you could leave and that is a shame as it's not your fault. This is bullying. Do not think of it any other way. I am so sorry. Try and ignore him as far as is practical.

By the way, of the group he helped out who thanked him and he responded but not to you, were you the only woman?

Dora33 · 06/04/2023 12:37

Some times a new person to a group/ club sport can come across as over enthusiastic and full on without meaning to. If the team is long established, it can be hard to become part of it where people automatically perceive a new person as belonging.
Volunteering to help at the tournament must have triggered him to how he was already was perceiving you.
I have been part of a team a long time and some team members much longer than me. New people are welcomed but it does take time for people to establish themselves as part of the team.
We had 1 guy turn up and immediately was full on and he did did rub some members up the wrong way with becoming over involved. He was a nice person, just very enthusiastic. It probably would have helped if someone had a chat with him early on.
Stay doing your sport and the coach will hopefully see the positivity you will bring to the team & club.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 06/04/2023 10:54

There’s not many women.
I wonder what he’s said to the others to keep them away

Royalbloo · 06/04/2023 10:04

Just because someone wants to give you feedback, doesn't mean you have to take it. Maybe give him some back?

Cherryblossoms85 · 06/04/2023 10:01

Don't overthink it and don't respond or follow up. He's just another dickhead.

ichifanny · 06/04/2023 09:58

Sounds like you have triggered something in him or you intimidate him in some way . It’s not you , I’m unsure what you being ‘ authentic ‘ has to do with helping out at a sport ? Surely all the participants aren’t of the same personality type and 100% themselves ?

Companyofwolves · 06/04/2023 09:55

Ps why can’t you say what the sport is?! Wld it be that outing??

Companyofwolves · 06/04/2023 09:53

If he welcomes other new male members’ contributions, gives them more opportunities than OP, & responds to their texts (& not OP’s) whatever his reasons are he is blocking you.

What are the reasons why new members don’t go away to the tournaments which require overnight stays & what is the setup there? Ie do people stay in accommodation themselves like a premier inn or are they hosted at some sporting facility? Do people share rooms? Is it true all newbies don’t go to these or has he said that just to deter you?
Are these essentially a reason for a group of men established over 10yrs to go away on a jolly/piss up/social gathering & who doesn’t want you to see what they get up to or that if you went it would be difficult because of what they do socially when there? Or is it a committed sporting event with no down time & all about the sport?

You said at some socials the wives & partners sometimes go. Are you single? It shouldn’t matter but there is always a dynamic change if there’s a) a sole woman in a group of men & b) a single woman in a group of predominantly attached men.
Is there much difference in age, class, race, culture? All of these things obvs affect dynamics. Is he trying to preserve an all male group & just refusing you access?

If so why the hell does he keep inviting & putting out requests for volunteers?

Maybe someone with some insider info can help? Is it about personality that he’ll only welcome people on a similar wavelength who he’ll know will get on with the group?? It does sound like a boys club & not something I could be dealing with tbh. Clearly the social opportunities are limited by this & for whatever reasons he does t want you into the inner circle.

Obvs that takes time generally but he’s a complete negging weirdo to have attacked your personality to justify it. I’d want to leave personally!

senua · 06/04/2023 09:17

I'm still wondering about the tournament. Such things usually need an army of helpers, not a committee of two. What do the rest of them think of the coach refusing an extra pair of hands?
But be careful of insisting too much that you be included - that's a sure fire way to be given the rubbish jobs that nobody else wants!

I think that you need to get some of the other females on board, get them turning up to socials. If they start complaining about everyone's personalityHmm then you know it's just sexism.

SewingLife · 06/04/2023 09:06

The best bit of advice I’ve ever heard about feedback is treat it as a note someone has given you. Reflect on who is giving it, why, what their motivation might be and then decide to keep it and act on it if it serves you or let it flutter away if it doesn’t. For what it is worth, you sound lovely and he sounds like he could do with not uttering every thought that enters his head!

pleasepleasemee · 06/04/2023 08:24

@UhLaLa - to be honest I've never really thought about it until this conversation with hun.

I was only speculating re changing the dynamic. It wasn't something I've been aware of before.

It's a group of men, some of whom have known each other a decade. A whole mix of personalities but importantly, they all know each other well.

I'm both a woman and new to the group. So I think inherently it can't be exactly the same as if I wasn't around.

I can (and do?) adapt to some extent. I don't join in with 'inside jokes' or banter, because I don't know everyone well enough yet. But I do chat to everyone a lot. But I'm just speculating that my presence maybe changes things?

Somewhat separately, I'm naturally just a really effusive and enthusiastic person and I think that he/they have misconstrued it as fake, or maybe just simply find it annoying?

I hadn't really been conscious of it until this conversation with him.

OP posts:
Bunce1 · 06/04/2023 08:19

Hmmm.

this stood out for me in your post I took it at face value initially but now I'm reflecting on everything. I am the only woman showing up to every single event, watching every match, going all the social stuff and getting to know as many people as possible

you sound intense and a mismatch for the current club culture.

I don’t disagree that maybe the coach is threatened by you or it is sexist behaviour.

my sons sports club has a number of parent helpers. A new parent joined with their son. And was at every match and bending the ear of the coach and got there early to help and stayed late to help and texted these longer super enthusiastic texts. For example- coach with say “Game this Saturday at 11, who can make it?” And most of responses are juts their child’s name and maybe a thumbs up or down emoji. The new parent will write a few sentences about why they can or cannot attend. It is juts so intense and reads it as annoying. Relationships take a bit of time and the coach found the person to be a real try hard. They didn’t and don’t fit the culture. The culture is more relaxed and organic and the belonging happens but at a different and more relaxed way.

from you’re descriptions you sound like a Tigger and he’s much more of an Eyore. You clash.

Ukrainebaby23 · 06/04/2023 07:59

Ah, he wants volunteers how will do things how he wants it, not have opinions or suggestions that he can't control.
If u want to continue playing and there's no other local option, I'd back off and stick to playing regular games for now, don't do the after match socialising but stay friendly with others who don't mix with this guy.

Just try to avoid him basically for now.

UhLaLa · 06/04/2023 07:17

pleasepleasemee · 06/04/2023 03:09

We are encouraged, repeatedly (by him) to do both those things. Lots of the guys do it. I'm the only woman who does (mostly).

Are your other social circles rather mixed, more female or more male, I’m writing this but thinking the answer is actually probably not relevant.

Putting aside for a moment that you are a female and all others are male. How are all the other relatively new people who also attend all the matches as you, all the social event’s etc? What are their personalities?

You say you change the dynamic. Again, try to forget the gender for a moment, looking in detail at the interactions, behaviour, conversations, is yours pretty much the same as many of the other people?

I read a book once, it was talking about racism, discrimination, to be honest, can’t remember the detail. The suggestion was if there are certain dynamics in a larger group, and if someone from a completely different culture comes in there is a logic in that the new person might need to assimilate to the larger group. It’s not feasible that the whole group will assimilate to the one individual. It’s not necessarily discriminatory, misogynistic, racist etc…

You pointed out a few times that you are the only female, you change dynamics potentially, you are very extroverted, confident, successful. Again, forgetting for a moment the genders, what is the dynamic in the group and does your individual behaviour differ relatively largely from everyone else’s behaviour (personality wise, there not necessarily being right or wrong, more how it fits with the group)