Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give up a secure council tenancy even though I can’t really afford to

107 replies

casperz · 03/04/2023 19:22

Due to the fact that as an autistic woman going through peri menopause and struggling massively with my mental health I cannot stand the level of noise from the neighbours and their children and the anti social behaviour. It’s sensory hell living here and I can never fully relax which is making my anxiety worse. I was on antidepressants which I only started on since moving here a couple of years back but I came off them when i started HRT. Ideally I don’t want to go back on them as they made me feel like a a zombie but at the same time I can’t cope feeling on edge from hearing the constant screams (actual screams not just kids having fun) of the feral kids running amuck in the street, banging their footballs off neighbours fences and cars including my own, neighbours getting drunk ending up fighting and smashing their house up, smelling weed in my house as the neighbours smoke inside instead of outside.

Our rent is currently £450 a months and if we were to move into private rented we’d be looking at least £1000 a month. We can’t really afford this as I can only work part time (husband is full time) as our youngest dc is autistic and needs one of us around but I’m that desperate that I’m
actual willing to work nights or get a second job working weekends, missing out on seeing my husband, so that we can afford a house in a better area. My husband whilst fully understands my frustration thinks we’d be crazy to give up an affordable and secure council house. AIBU to not care and want to move?

OP posts:
areyousittingontheremote · 03/04/2023 20:42

If it's a continuous nuisance stopping you being able to enjoy your property you can take this up with the landlord.

Even if you just threaten to sue that's a whole lot of money they won't want to spend.

They can and should evict those who are causing an actual civil offense of nuisance.

To prove a private nuisance has occurred (or is occurring) the following must be present:

  • Continuous interference;
  • Unlawful or unreasonable interference;
  • Interference of the use or enjoyment of land or some right over it.

So if that's an option with any of the continuous offenders you could try putting a case together and telling the HA you've consulted a solicitor and are going to sue.

Can you speak to your HA and ask to be moved because of your autism and the fact you can't cope there?

it sounds like hell. But having a housing association home is amazing and the security you get is something private renters and home owners have less of in times like these with the massive energy hikes. The rent is also really really low and can free up money for other things.

Museya15 · 03/04/2023 20:39

Once you make that move it will be extremely hard to get back probably impossible. I rented, and it financially destroyed me I was so skint, I got no enjoyment out of life as there was absolutely no money for food, outings etc, the 80% went on rent, it was a really depressing, anxious filled time. I would not recommend it

Sometimeswinning · 03/04/2023 20:38

All these posters saying the same thing! Think of the worst etc.

In your position I would do everything I could to make my life the best it can be. Especially at home. The only post I did agree with is to work more first and see if it works or adds extra issues.

casperz · 03/04/2023 20:37

Aw a house in the middle of nowhere especially in Scotland is my absolute fantasy lol. Me and my friends often chat about what we’d do if we won the lottery or came into some money. They would buy flash cars and go on fancy holidays where as me I’d be happy to just win enough for a house deposit or for a modest house in the middle of nowhere. I’d quite happily stick with my years old Nissan car as would dh and I’d still holiday in the UK, still shop at Aldi etc as long as I could buy a house I’d be ecstatic lol.

OP posts:
casperz · 03/04/2023 20:31

I get what you’re saying @vivaespanaole I’m really sensitive to noise to and I have auditory processing disorder but in all the other houses I’ve lived in the noise from other people hasn’t really bothered me as it’s been minimal. Where I currently live though it actually feels painful at times. Which I know sounds daft but factor in hearing issues and autism well it’s very common to feel certain noise as pain.

OP posts:
Bookaholic73 · 03/04/2023 20:31

casperz · 03/04/2023 20:22

So you completely get it @Bookaholic73 It’s awful not being able to relax in your own home isn’t it.

Yes I totally get it.
I dream of living in a cottage in the Scottish highlands surrounded by only fields.

But that’s not real life unfortunately.

I imagine that most people telling you to log and report the noise and ASB haven’t had to deal with a council that do absolutely nothing to help.

OddBoots · 03/04/2023 20:29

If you would need a second job to afford it maybe try doing that bit first, see you you feel having done that for (say) 6 months and see if it is something you can sustain long term.

casperz · 03/04/2023 20:25

My dh has spoke to her before about other things but not about the tv. The last time it was about her adult son fighting and scaring our ds. She basically told my dh where to go. You can’t reason with stupid can you.

OP posts:
vivaespanaole · 03/04/2023 20:25

I am really noise sensitive and live in a 'posh area' in a detached house. All was well when we moved. But I can hear the noise from a building site, noise from home schooled children, noise from dogs allowed to bark incessantly, noise from the streets being dug up. Noise from trampolines. Noise from people who kept up at the crack of dawn and start gardening. None of it is anti social and It wouldn't be a lot for some people but I find it a lot. I'd ideally have the windows open but I cant: guess I am just saying there are no guarantees that you will find utopia wherever you go and you might be taking a huge risk.

Lovingmynewbicycle · 03/04/2023 20:24

I add my voice to those who say that you'd be mad to give up your tenancy.

Antisocial neighbours can be anywhere.

Private renting comes with high rent, minimal security, and the risk of having a useless or negligent landlord.

If you would need to get 2nd job to be able to rent privately, what would you do in retirement?

Stay put.

Keep a diary, keep reporting, call the noise emergency line when it's particularly bad.
Also talk to Shelter - they may be able to advise or support you. And keep looking for house swaps - but check our any offers you get to make sure it meets your needs.

But do NOT give up your council home!

casperz · 03/04/2023 20:22

So you completely get it @Bookaholic73 It’s awful not being able to relax in your own home isn’t it.

OP posts:
UB40andaglassofwine · 03/04/2023 20:21

Don't give up your secure tenancy OP. I did that because I was moving over 100 miles away. It didn't work out and I came back and have been in rented accommodation since.
My landlord is selling up soon and I have to find somewhere else to live. I've been so happy where I am now. I also have an autistic child and am dreading all the change in his life as he's only known this house.
If you can't get a home swap have you actually tried talking to your neighbour and asking her to turn her TV down

Bookaholic73 · 03/04/2023 20:20

I can relate so much, the noise is almost unbearable in my area too.

I’ve often thought about giving up my council tenancy too, but even with us both working we couldn’t afford it long term.

Sorry to hear you’re struggling.

Aturnipforthebooks · 03/04/2023 20:19

Would you consider getting internal soundproofing and secondary glazing?

Thelittlekingdom · 03/04/2023 20:16

I’d hang on to your secure tenancy if you can. What about noise cancelling headphones? Even if you had low music playing they’d still drown out the rest of the noise.

casperz · 03/04/2023 20:14

I know that there is noise everywhere and to be fair outside of my home eg work and out and about I cope with noise well but at home find it impossible to drown it out. I feel trapped.

OP posts:
casperz · 03/04/2023 20:13

I do get what you’re saying and I’ll certainly consider your suggestions. I’m just so fed up tonight. Currently lay on the sofa try to watch tv with cotton wool in my ears as my inconsiderate next door neighbour has her tv on full blast. All day I’ve had to put up with screaming kids and the moment they go in and it’s quiet my neighbour starts with her nightly tv torture.

OP posts:
whynotwhatknot · 03/04/2023 20:12

no way if youve been accepted and given a house youd be mad to give it up

theres noise everywhere i live in terraced its not jut so easy to leave jut because you rent/own

Aturnipforthebooks · 03/04/2023 20:08

Given your ages, it would be absolutely madness to give up a secure tenancy.

You would have no hope of retirement if you're in private rented and if one or both of you had to give up work, you would massively struggle.

Dogscanteatonions · 03/04/2023 20:05

Oh god don't give up social housing! It sounds like you'd struggle financially to keep up private renting and it would be so foolish on this climate. In my area to rent a similar property to mine it would be a minimum of £900 a month and it wouldn't be anywhere near as big/nice.

My neighbors were awful when their kids were younger but it's so much better now, barely a peep is heard. You need to do everything possible to stay where you are

casperz · 03/04/2023 19:59

My last house was actually an ex council house but on a much smaller estate. We only moved as the owner needed to sell otherwise I’d have happily stayed there as it was lovely. My husband works around 10 miles from work. I live about a mile from work and either walk or drive depending on the weather. I have asked the council if they’d move us elsewhere but they said that their policy is once your house your housed and the only way to move is to find a house on homeswapper yourself or make your own arrangements eg private rented. We don’t have an extra bedroom so that’s not an option unfortunately.

OP posts:
casperz · 03/04/2023 19:55

I was friendly when I moved here and would always say hello and chat. But we moved here during covid and things were quiet. Fast forward a couple of years and they’ve shown their true colours. As for kids growing up the kids around here who play out and get up to all sorts well they’re aged I’d say from 3 years old to 11 and there are at least 15-20 kids who play out front (often at the end of my drive) daily so it’s going to be a long time until they grow up. Ironically my ds who’s autistic makes less noise than they do.

OP posts:
TomatoSandwiches · 03/04/2023 19:53

I would try to better your home first, look into ways to sound proof, perhaps get someone in to see how to reduce the weed smell, look at vents or air con systems.

Keep a diary about anti social behaviour and report them each time.
Perhaps ask for a letter from your GP stating how negatively you are affected living there.

These things are not quick fixes but moving out and trying to pay full market rent at your ages is really not very smart.

ConstanceOcean · 03/04/2023 19:52

I was on antidepressants which I only started on since moving here a couple of years back

Where did you live before?

How far away do you/your husband work?

Have you looked into if the council will do a transfer?

Sometimes if they have a free property they will allow a current tenant to transfer their tenancy to the new house and then they’ll put the other house on for new tenants.

If you have an extra bedroom then you can also be put back on the housing list and will be high up on the banding.

I would try everything you can to stay in social housing especially if you have an autistic child which needs extra support as in the future you may need to give up work completely.

If you can’t move then you’ll have no other choice but to go private. However I know of many private properties that also have antisocial neighbours.

Thelnebriati · 03/04/2023 19:51

I do know how you feel as I've lived in a similar place myself, the trouble included having my windows smashed several times. I stayed on the exchange scheme and eventually was able to move into a slightly better area, and got a better house from there.
While I was doing that, other tenants in my old street got fed up and started up a tenants association. Its pretty quiet there now, they got the HA to move out all the worst problem tenants. I still wouldn't have stayed because the schools were terrible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread