Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to take banned food into EU?

216 replies

Hatehairdressers · 03/04/2023 18:17

We’re flying into Europe on Thursday staying in an AirBnB in an area where shops are going to be very shut for Easter (at least until Saturday).

My plan was to pack a bit of food to see us through a couple of meals - I’ve packed a picnic bag in our hold luggage full of long life stuff like pasta, tuna, and sweetcorn; brioche rolls and hot dogs. Chocolate bars, tea bags and some UHT milk. Applauded myself on my forward planning.

Then I realised we’re not in the EU any more and half this stuff is banned.

AIBU to take it anyway?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BertieBotts · 06/04/2023 20:11

Last year we were pulled over for a random check when driving into France. I had a large bag in the front seat with pasties, sausage rolls, bacon. They asked us to open the boot probably to check for hidden people, and they sent a sniffer dog around the car. Nobody mentioned the bacon, not even the dog.

BertieBotts · 06/04/2023 20:08

Phew! Well try not to murder anyone with your gorgonzola OP and enjoy your holiday Grin

Scot75 · 06/04/2023 19:04

😂

Hatehairdressers · 06/04/2023 19:00

Update! We’ve arrived in NORWAY…yes I KNOW it’s not in the EU, I forgot! But the same rules apply in so far as Brexit means that the UK is subject to the same customs restrictions as the rest of the world whereas EU countries are exempt.

There’s a few places open but nowhere we could buy food for self catering I’ve seen - e.g the airport only had confectionary and drinks.

Sailed through customs with zero checks…which is just as well as despite clearing our hold luggage of contraband I forgot I still had some bits from our UK picnic lunch in my hand luggage and I’ve inadvertently smuggled in a piece of Gorgonzola.

Anyway I’m off to make a tuna pasta bake.

OP posts:
puttingontheritz · 06/04/2023 18:49

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 04/04/2023 14:17

This is untrue. Ascension Day , Christmas Day, Easter Sunday in France, everything is shut, even garages ( though still take card sales.). Many supermarkets and other shops still don’t open on a normal Sunday, either.

Well that's only slightly embarrassing I guess, because that used to be the case about supermarkets, I would say that it hasn't been for about 20 years though.

The only time all supermarkets close in France for a bank holiday is 1st May.

Everybody in France would know that. I could post loads of links to open supermarkets, my local one was open Christmas morning, if you know about France you know that the meal may well have been done the night before and people are out and about going to the next meal, Ascension is just another day these days, and as for Easter Sunday, it's not even a holiday in any sense, it's just a Sunday. Here's just one example that shows just that.
https://www.carrefour.fr/magasin/antibes

Giveaschitt · 06/04/2023 11:24

IAmInMeHoop · 04/04/2023 10:08

You may be thinking of the temporary rules that allowed more exemptions, that are now ended.

You can take a certain amount of fish, shellfish, eggs, and honey. You may not take any products containing meat, or dairy. The only current dairy exemption is for infant formulas, special foods and special pet foods for medical reasons.

There are currently no exemptions for dairy chocolate in the rules, which you can read here: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32019R2122&from=EN

and explanation here:

Except under Annex III in the very document that you've linked to where under "7. Exempted products" it literally lists "chocolate with less than 50% milk or egg" as an exemption..... (and I've just checked, the milk chocolate we're taking to Spain this weekend is 14% milk solids so well within the limits)

notimagain · 06/04/2023 11:12

tiger2691 · 06/04/2023 10:38

The whole thing is perverted

Maybe but the potential for these type of restrictions/checks are what happens when you end up outside a customs union/area/block - the decision to do that was made in Westminster.

We're probably lucky that so far at least travellers from the UK are not facing the sort of restrictions/checks so far at least that you get going into the US or Aus....

The whole thing is a real PITA for those trying to trade UK>EU or EU>UK and even individuals trying to do simple stuff like post presents UK> EU or vice versa are finding it more complex now.

Frankly ATM passengers are generally sailing through the process, hopefully that will continue.

tiger2691 · 06/04/2023 10:38

The whole thing is perverted

ItsRainingPens · 06/04/2023 08:46

By coincidence, yesterday in the office a colleague was telling the tale oh how a friend of his had been stopped entering the Netherlands with a cheese sandwich

RosaBonheur · 05/04/2023 22:51

theemmadilemma · 05/04/2023 09:44

Ahhh Mumsnet for the win.

FFS she's not talking about taking items that cause a problem over the boarder. Clearly none of you have ever smuggled food across a boarder. lol

OP, I flew into France for years with a hold case stuffed with English Sausages and bacon. Never once had it checked. I realise that was under the old rules, but frankly from my POV very little in terms of checks has changed for Europe. So I see no reason it wouldn't all sail through fine.

Kind of missing the point here.

Under the old rules it was completely legal to bring a suitcase full of bacon and sausages into France. Now it's completely illegal.

I still bring bacon and sausages into France when I drive through the Eurotunnel but it is illegal and if our car was searched these things would be confiscated. I wouldn't even try if I was travelling by plane or Eurostar.

HermoineFairfax · 05/04/2023 21:10

Hatehairdressers · 03/04/2023 18:56

Fuck it, I was going to bring the DC’s Easter eggs with us too. Fucking Brexit.

Best not to chance it, darling. British chocolate is a risk to the EU and they may call the gendarme. Stay safe.

Hawkins003 · 05/04/2023 20:49

Hatehairdressers · 03/04/2023 18:56

Fuck it, I was going to bring the DC’s Easter eggs with us too. Fucking Brexit.

Well did you vote remain or leave?

baffledcoconut · 05/04/2023 19:37

Is this still rumbling on? 🤣 someone posted the actual legislation further up and what would you know, you can take most of it.

notimagain · 05/04/2023 13:26

@IAmInMeHoop

It's simply not true that nobody is checking for these things. There are random checks, and there are targeted checks, where on a particular day everyone is getting searched, sniffer dogs etc.
Small chance but certainly not no chance.

I transit fairly frequently through a French regional airport and from what I've seen there's no doubt the incidence of random checks on travellers from the UK has gone up but it's still at a very very low level.

From the local media reports it would appear the intelligence led stuff is targeted at those smuggling tobacco products or counterfeit goods, ham sandwiches not so much.........................................

theemmadilemma · 05/04/2023 09:44

Ahhh Mumsnet for the win.

FFS she's not talking about taking items that cause a problem over the boarder. Clearly none of you have ever smuggled food across a boarder. lol

OP, I flew into France for years with a hold case stuffed with English Sausages and bacon. Never once had it checked. I realise that was under the old rules, but frankly from my POV very little in terms of checks has changed for Europe. So I see no reason it wouldn't all sail through fine.

IAmInMeHoop · 05/04/2023 09:39

BertieBotts · 04/04/2023 22:20

Well of course not, why would you argue with a customs officer? They aren't going to do anything, they will just throw it away, which is a bit disappointing but really no big deal. You say sorry, I didn't realise and move on. But nobody is checking for these things anyway, so it doesn't matter.

People are going on about it like OP wants to smuggle in hard drugs!

It's simply not true that nobody is checking for these things. There are random checks, and there are targeted checks, where on a particular day everyone is getting searched, sniffer dogs etc.
Small chance but certainly not no chance.

GMOOH2023 · 05/04/2023 09:32

maddy68 · 04/04/2023 18:21

There are always convenience stores open (Corner shop type places (). All restaurants will be open. Just get a pizza delivered if you want to eat in

Well I'm obviously not going to share my exact location, but I can assure you that there are no convenience stores anywhere near where I live - none - and nowhere that delivers pizza (or anything else for that matter).

There are also none in the 50 miles between here and the nearest large airport. At a pinch you could get a Starbucks sandwich at the airport, or a Mc Donald's on the way, but that isn't what OP is looking for.

How do you know where the OP is going?

RosaBonheur · 05/04/2023 07:54

moomoomoo27 · 04/04/2023 17:01

I've done it loads of times for a bunch of different countries (and even did it before we left the EU but the other way round, bringing reindeer meat snacks from Norway into the UK).

No one checks. No one cares. Even in hand luggage (although obviously there's the liquid rule, which mostly they've pulled us up on and sometimes not, but that will likely depend on the country - Germany is very strict for example).

And for Eurostar or driving they're even more lax.

Before we left the EU it was completely legal, and it still is completely legal the other way round.

BertieBotts · 04/04/2023 22:20

notimagain · 04/04/2023 13:17

@BertieBotts

But that is a safety issue and there is no safety issue with bringing shelf stable items and and out of the EU.

Maybe, maybe maybe not... regardless of what we think in the real world if you end up with a customs check you will be dealing with their rules...and that includes the restrictions of foodstuffs.

Standing in front of a customs officer and saying "Well I brought these in since I didn't see the point in that rule..." doesn't tend to get you very far.

The reality is the OP probably will be alright entering the EU but if by some small chance they get checked they have to accept they might well face sanctions...and then the responses to the AIBU that started the thread are a bit irrelevant.

If they do get sanctioned then I really hope they then don't pop up again with an AIBU of: "to think customs were being unreasonable in telling me off, fining me and removing my banned food"..

Well of course not, why would you argue with a customs officer? They aren't going to do anything, they will just throw it away, which is a bit disappointing but really no big deal. You say sorry, I didn't realise and move on. But nobody is checking for these things anyway, so it doesn't matter.

People are going on about it like OP wants to smuggle in hard drugs!

Brefugee · 04/04/2023 21:35

Plus I was imagining what I would put into my Carrefour or Edeka or REWE delivery basket…

no Edeka or RWE deliveries where i live. The best you can get is click & collect at the big REWE but it closes at 8pm. No corner shops (well, you can buy a half, or 1/4 bottle of brandy from a trinkhalle, and a packet of gummi bears)

maddy68 · 04/04/2023 18:21

There are always convenience stores open (Corner shop type places (). All restaurants will be open. Just get a pizza delivered if you want to eat in

notimagain · 04/04/2023 17:49

glasshole · 04/04/2023 17:35

You can buy food in the airport and take that with you. Expensive but they won't stop you at security for foods purchases in duty free.

Looks like from several posts that there's some confusion creeping in between security and customs.

Security don't give care about whether food and drink is compliant with customs regs at your destination.

Their job (amongst other things) is to scan bags, but they are looking for potential weapons etc. Yes they sometimes will throw away liquids, gels, pastes etc bu that's because they are for some reason not compliant with security rules.

Customs is (usually) at the far end of the journey and it's that lot that police the food regs..

So yes, you can load up in the airport with all sorts of shopping post security but that doesn't mean you are compliant with customs at destination (e.g as an extreme case you could buy a bottle of booze in an airport post security and then fly to Saudi but you won't get it past Saudi customs).

MumOf2workOptions · 04/04/2023 17:42

ButterCrackers · 04/04/2023 17:29

Why not just buy some food when you arrive. Most airports/ stations/ferry have a shop. There’s always a petrol station with a shop and restaurants and cafes will be open.

Exactly
Or email the air b n b owner and ask if you can do a hone delivery to the place or something
I wouldn't take food in for the sake of a fine or it being taken off you, what a total waste of time and money

glasshole · 04/04/2023 17:35

Hatehairdressers · 03/04/2023 18:47

I can’t figure out if chocolate is ok or not - is it a classified as a milk product?

Aren’t fruit and veg banned?

You can buy food in the airport and take that with you. Expensive but they won't stop you at security for foods purchases in duty free.

ButterCrackers · 04/04/2023 17:29

Why not just buy some food when you arrive. Most airports/ stations/ferry have a shop. There’s always a petrol station with a shop and restaurants and cafes will be open.