Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother and SIL pushing us out of children's lives

107 replies

AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 11:00

Sorry, this will likely be a long read! My brother and SIL have two DCs who are my parent's only grandchildren and mine and my DB's only nieces. Since the children were born my side of the family have felt very pushed out of their lives, in favour of SIL's family. They're a large, extremely close knit bunch (at each others houses 24/7 or on facetime constantly). At the baby shower for the first born, SIL's mother refused to engage in conversation with our family, and the rest followed suit. Considering her lot made up 90% of those in attendance due to the sheer size of their family, this made us very uncomfortable, like lepers sat in the corner. In hindsight this was a massive indication of how we were going to be treated moving forward.

Since that point we have had to fight for every second we've been allowed to spend with the children. We put in all the effort as they refuse to come to any of our houses as it's too much effort (they don't drive but we all live a short bus journey away and have offered lifts and purchased car seats to help with this. They've taken us up on this offer once). When we arrange to go to them they regularly cancel at the last minute, or generally make you feel unwelcome once you are there. SIL will suddenly have loads of jobs to do, or will sit in the corner on facetime to her family. When it comes to Christmas and birthdays we are never taken into account when planning family visits and are told "sorry, we're doing this and that with SILs family, so you'll have to drop in in the evening midweek", despite the fact that we all work and the children are in bed for six/seven o'clock.

She doesn't work and spends her weekdays at her family's house as they also don't work, so is literally with them from early morning until DB gets home from work. My parents are heartbroken and don't feel like grandparents. On top of this, DB will call them and ask to borrow money as when and they need it and they always give it to him, despite the fact that they don't really have it to lend out. He's absolutely shameless paying pitiful amounts back each month, whilst they both splash the cash they do have on crap they don't need. I don't believe this is a factor in them not wanting to see us, as DB has been like this since he was a teen and doesn't see anything wrong with treating people like that.

I've raised this problem with him in the past, in as polite away as I possibly can, asking him to include our DPs more and try and make seeing them a regular thing. Even if it's just to invite them up for a couple of hours once a fortnight. SIL had an extreme reaction to this and decided I was banned from seeing the children at all. She calmed down following this but my DPs are now scared to say anything that could be taken negatively in case their very limited contact with the children is taken away all together (on average they currently see the children for a couple of hours, at DB's house, around every 3 months).

It feels like a lost cause and I'm at a point where I feel like I just can't be bothered anymore. I'm sick of getting upset about it and seeing my parents so upset about it too. If I say something I risk her flipping her lid and stopping any of us from seeing the children at all. I have one of my niece's birthday presents sat here days after the event because, according to them, they've been too busy with SIL's family for me to even drop in for ten minutes to give this to her. Ahead of one of their birthdays last year my DPs suggested throwing a small party at their house, on whatever day at the weekend works best for DB and SIL, to allow our family to see the children and give gifts etc, but this was refused as they wanted to see SIL's family both days.

Would IBU to just cut contact, keep a distance and post presents to them in future (despite the fact they live a 10 minute drive from us)? Or should I bite the bullet and raise this again for the sake of my parents (and risk SIL losing her shit again and banning contact all together?) I just feel like I can't win!

If you've made it this far, thank you for reading!

OP posts:
Okaaaay · 03/04/2023 12:37

This is so hard OP - we have a similar issue in our family. There are some painful truths for all about this - manipulation, selfishness, control, adult children just not caring about their family / liking their family / not wanting to make effort / not respecting their contribution, being babied by their parents on one side and wanting to pursue that.

A couple of thoughts - the children are key here and it’s sad they don’t benefit. From this, they will learn that not all family matters which is sad. It would be a good approach to continue sending cards / gifts to the children and hoping that your name continues to be spoken based on this. With regard to the adults, I would suggest sitting with your parents and acknowledging the really sad truths above - they are unlikely to be grandparents in the way they want to be. Say the worst case out load, feel the pain, consider how to let it go and stand in support of the children in the small ways they can. Keeping banging against a close door as you are is not helpful to any of you (or the children sadly), long term - and it’s desperately sad for your parents. I’m so sorry, this is really difficult.

There is also the option to have it out with your brother, though this is likely to severe all contact sadly.

AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 12:36

TitterYeeNot · 03/04/2023 12:23

So does SIL and her family not work because her parents made loads of money? Why does your DB need to go begging to your parents? Can’t he ask his wife’s family for money?

I feel very sorry for you and your parents. SIL sounds awful.

SIL hasn't worked since the first child was born. She did start working a few hours a week a little while ago (one shift) but packed this in quite quickly as it was "too much." Her family members have taken a similar path but I try not to judge as I don't have children and have no idea what it's like balancing childcare and work and any effect this has on finances. DB has always had an irresponsible attitude towards money and SIL seems very much the same, spending it whilst she has on pointless things (in my opinion) with not much thought given to the future or budgeting. One of her parents works, the other doesn't. They certainly aren't made of money. I don't know if they don't ask SIL's family for money because they don't have it to lend, or if it's because they wouldn't dream of taking the approach to paying it back that they do with my DPs with hers.

OP posts:
BubziOwl · 03/04/2023 12:35

Your brother and SIL sound awful. But I find with people like this, if you want to see the children and have a relationship with them then you just have to play along. It's unfair and so difficult, but your brother and SIL aren't suddenly going to become nice people so I would really try to just keep the peace and make the best of it Sad

Pollyputthekettleonha · 03/04/2023 12:32

I think I would continue to make an effort to see the children and building relationships with them in this situation, but really lower my expectations. I.e. arrange to see them but half expect them to cancel and have an idea what you would do instead that day if they do cancel. If you get there and SIL ignores you, well focus on the kids and don't worry about it. Don't give DB too much headspace either, easier said than done I would think though.
In terms of birthday gifts as it's a ten minute drive could you make up some excuse about how you were passing and just drop in unannounced at a time you think they would be in? How do you think that would go down?
I think you should back away from getting involved with the relationship between DB and your parents though. I don't understand why they are handing over money when he makes so little effort but ultimately that's up to them, and I think only they can sort it out with him. Sounds like your nieces don't have the best role models in their own parents and I think they need some better people in their lives. So I wouldn't give up altogether but try to accept that your DB and SIL are how they are and make the best of it.

Anonymouseposter · 03/04/2023 12:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I hope you never find out that it’s not that straightforward. People aren’t robots programmed by their parents. I would suggest the parents try to detach and enjoy spending their money on themselves but I daresay they will be punished further for it. OP, you can’t do much other than remain polite, send birthday gifts to the children and try to detach.

TitterYeeNot · 03/04/2023 12:26

Feelinadequate23 · 03/04/2023 12:11

@TomatoFrog bore off with your armchair judgements of OP’s parents. Some people are just bad eggs and no amount of parenting will sort them out. I’ve seen it with a few people I know, excellent parents with good morals etc, one of their kids just goes rogue. Adults are responsible for their own actions and you can’t blame all adults’ faults on their parents!

I second this. The parents sound nice and DB comes across as a sociopath.

TomatoFrog · 03/04/2023 12:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

krustykittens · 03/04/2023 12:24

We are in a similar situation OP, and there really is nothing you can do about it. DH has one brother and he has married a woman who spends all her time with her family - we don't get a look in. He does whatever she wants. We have no relationship at all with our nieces but if the parents will not support a relationship when children are young, there really isn't anything you can do. We used to send gifts and cars and we didn't even get a thank you. We gave up in the end. There has been no fighting, no rancour, SIL just has no interest in anyone outside her own family.

TitterYeeNot · 03/04/2023 12:23

AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 11:56

We grew up working class, with DPs as hardworking, supportive role models. I've got the life I have now as a result of watching them work to provide for us. SIL comes from a similar background/circumstances.

So does SIL and her family not work because her parents made loads of money? Why does your DB need to go begging to your parents? Can’t he ask his wife’s family for money?

I feel very sorry for you and your parents. SIL sounds awful.

Beautiful3 · 03/04/2023 12:14

We had similar happen too. In the end we stopped posting birthday, easter and Xmas presents. We just messaged saying x presents and cards are at grandmas. This kind of forced them to visit, to collect them.

Feelinadequate23 · 03/04/2023 12:11

@TomatoFrog bore off with your armchair judgements of OP’s parents. Some people are just bad eggs and no amount of parenting will sort them out. I’ve seen it with a few people I know, excellent parents with good morals etc, one of their kids just goes rogue. Adults are responsible for their own actions and you can’t blame all adults’ faults on their parents!

TomatoFrog · 03/04/2023 12:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Showmethefood · 03/04/2023 12:04

Ok - so this is what I would do. Stop contacting and wait for them to initiate contact. In mean time - open up a savings account and put money in it as and when. Wait until the kids are 16 and write a letter addressed to them and give them the money as a gift. You’ve tried and this is not your fault. Hopefully they will still let you see them as they grow but if not you are still doing something for them.

WheelsUp · 03/04/2023 12:04

This situation has arisen because your brother is lazy and a user. He'd be like this regardless of who he married and I wouldn't blame you if you just let the situation go. There are no words that will make him change or see the light.

Your parents choose to be used for money and there's nothing that you can do about that either. They need to come to the realization about their son which may not even happen.

Their only chance of a relationship with the grandchildren is if the couple split up and your brother decides to use your parents as childcare. He'd have to go to court to get some parenting time but it sounds like he would be the type to outsource his time with the kids.

AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 12:03

GooglyEyeballs · 03/04/2023 11:58

I know it really hurts, DH and I went through something similar where his sister deliberately started ostracizing us from the family once she had kids. It was so hurtful as we really looked forward to being an aunt and uncle but in the end we walked away because what else could we do. Save yourself the stress and hurt of it all.

This is exactly how it feels for us! Has anything improved since you walked away? Did they make any effort to encourage contact once you stopped making the effort or is their no relationship at all now? I'm just curious as to whether this could help in our situation.

OP posts:
AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 12:01

Landndialamrhf · 03/04/2023 11:53

Have you asked him or her?
hey db and sil we’d love to see you more, but feels like we may have done something to offend / upset you
im sorry if I have, can we talk about it because I’d love to have a closer relationship with you

This is very much along the lines of how I approached it last time, which resulted in her attempting to ban me from seeing the children. I was told that we hadn't done anything to offend or upset anyone and then when I suggested he makes a bit more effort with our DPs (maybe letting them visit once a fortnight) as they felt pushed out the message was passed onto her and she lost it. This is why I'm worried about raising the subject again.

OP posts:
GooglyEyeballs · 03/04/2023 11:58

I know it really hurts, DH and I went through something similar where his sister deliberately started ostracizing us from the family once she had kids. It was so hurtful as we really looked forward to being an aunt and uncle but in the end we walked away because what else could we do. Save yourself the stress and hurt of it all.

AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 11:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

We grew up working class, with DPs as hardworking, supportive role models. I've got the life I have now as a result of watching them work to provide for us. SIL comes from a similar background/circumstances.

OP posts:
Landndialamrhf · 03/04/2023 11:53

Have you asked him or her?
hey db and sil we’d love to see you more, but feels like we may have done something to offend / upset you
im sorry if I have, can we talk about it because I’d love to have a closer relationship with you

AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 11:52

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

They can’t be shocked that their lack of parenting brought them to this.

I certainly wouldn't say there has been a lack of parenting on my parents side. Myself and my other DB are hardworking and (I like to think) kind people. My parents were always quite strict and we always knew what was expected of us. His behaviour didn't go unnoticed or unpunished growing up, it just seems that none of what we were taught actually sunk in with him.

OP posts:
Ktime · 03/04/2023 11:51

marzipansux · 03/04/2023 11:46

This sounds pretty awful. Why can't you just ring your MIL?

Why would OP call MIL when they barely speak to her?

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 03/04/2023 11:50

marzipansux · 03/04/2023 11:46

This sounds pretty awful. Why can't you just ring your MIL?

Because it's her DH's bloody mother and it's HIS job to communicate with his family about their joint children. Children and planning and soft skills like keeping in touch are not bloody 'women's work'.

TomatoFrog · 03/04/2023 11:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

marzipansux · 03/04/2023 11:46

Kentlassie · 03/04/2023 11:17

I can see why you are upset and frustrated. It’s tricky. SIL is very close to her family, and your brother isn’t making much effort with his.

I am sure my ILs feel similar- they have met my youngest (8 months) twice, but we have seen my parents 3 time in the last week. DH doesn’t organise anything with them, and they barely speak to me so I only try to arrange things periodically. My oldest DC has a birthday coming up. I’ve been asking DH for WEEKS to ask his family when they are free and he just won’t, so I’ve gone ahead and made plans with my family.

If you want to maintain a relationship I would be available. Send the presents, don’t make seeing them a condition on children getting presents. Be available the surrounding weekends for birthday fun etc. When we recently couldn’t do the one weekend MIL wanted to visit, she said she would see us in July instead….

This sounds pretty awful. Why can't you just ring your MIL?

hallodarknessmyoldfriend · 03/04/2023 11:45

I would drop it and not post any gifts either.

Your DP's relationship with your DB is theirs to manage, so I would stay away. As painful as it is for you to watch, it's their decision to keep giving him the money.

I think this is more on your DB than SIL, it sounds like he has no interest in your family other than using you for money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread