Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother and SIL pushing us out of children's lives

107 replies

AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 11:00

Sorry, this will likely be a long read! My brother and SIL have two DCs who are my parent's only grandchildren and mine and my DB's only nieces. Since the children were born my side of the family have felt very pushed out of their lives, in favour of SIL's family. They're a large, extremely close knit bunch (at each others houses 24/7 or on facetime constantly). At the baby shower for the first born, SIL's mother refused to engage in conversation with our family, and the rest followed suit. Considering her lot made up 90% of those in attendance due to the sheer size of their family, this made us very uncomfortable, like lepers sat in the corner. In hindsight this was a massive indication of how we were going to be treated moving forward.

Since that point we have had to fight for every second we've been allowed to spend with the children. We put in all the effort as they refuse to come to any of our houses as it's too much effort (they don't drive but we all live a short bus journey away and have offered lifts and purchased car seats to help with this. They've taken us up on this offer once). When we arrange to go to them they regularly cancel at the last minute, or generally make you feel unwelcome once you are there. SIL will suddenly have loads of jobs to do, or will sit in the corner on facetime to her family. When it comes to Christmas and birthdays we are never taken into account when planning family visits and are told "sorry, we're doing this and that with SILs family, so you'll have to drop in in the evening midweek", despite the fact that we all work and the children are in bed for six/seven o'clock.

She doesn't work and spends her weekdays at her family's house as they also don't work, so is literally with them from early morning until DB gets home from work. My parents are heartbroken and don't feel like grandparents. On top of this, DB will call them and ask to borrow money as when and they need it and they always give it to him, despite the fact that they don't really have it to lend out. He's absolutely shameless paying pitiful amounts back each month, whilst they both splash the cash they do have on crap they don't need. I don't believe this is a factor in them not wanting to see us, as DB has been like this since he was a teen and doesn't see anything wrong with treating people like that.

I've raised this problem with him in the past, in as polite away as I possibly can, asking him to include our DPs more and try and make seeing them a regular thing. Even if it's just to invite them up for a couple of hours once a fortnight. SIL had an extreme reaction to this and decided I was banned from seeing the children at all. She calmed down following this but my DPs are now scared to say anything that could be taken negatively in case their very limited contact with the children is taken away all together (on average they currently see the children for a couple of hours, at DB's house, around every 3 months).

It feels like a lost cause and I'm at a point where I feel like I just can't be bothered anymore. I'm sick of getting upset about it and seeing my parents so upset about it too. If I say something I risk her flipping her lid and stopping any of us from seeing the children at all. I have one of my niece's birthday presents sat here days after the event because, according to them, they've been too busy with SIL's family for me to even drop in for ten minutes to give this to her. Ahead of one of their birthdays last year my DPs suggested throwing a small party at their house, on whatever day at the weekend works best for DB and SIL, to allow our family to see the children and give gifts etc, but this was refused as they wanted to see SIL's family both days.

Would IBU to just cut contact, keep a distance and post presents to them in future (despite the fact they live a 10 minute drive from us)? Or should I bite the bullet and raise this again for the sake of my parents (and risk SIL losing her shit again and banning contact all together?) I just feel like I can't win!

If you've made it this far, thank you for reading!

OP posts:
Mariposista · 03/04/2023 13:50

Your brother needs to grow a pair of testicals, get his pathetic wife to get a sodding job and stop being possessive over their family.

Laiste · 03/04/2023 13:46

At the end of the day your brother is the connecting link between these children on one side, and you and your parents on the other.

How he conducts his life and how he allows/encourages/ignores his wife's behaviour is, essentially, his own business. You can only do what you've been doing and ask him for contact with his kids, and ask on behalf of your parents.

Or stop asking, and just keep posting the cards and small presents, just to keep your name 'alive' in the children's minds but there's not much else to be done.

Gladiaterf · 03/04/2023 13:44

Ultimately OP, it sounds like you don't particularly like your DB and SIL, you're judgemental about their lifestyle (very justifiably!), and you wish they were different.

You can't change them, and you can't make them act the way you want them to act.

You also can't manage their relationship with your DP.

It does sound however that your parents are enabling them to continue to behave the way they do. They treat your parents like shit - but your parents continue to give them money.

Floppyelf · 03/04/2023 13:42

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 03/04/2023 11:34

Hellfire, that is the snobbiest post I have EVER read on Mumsnet, and that's saying something. 'Frightfully common'? Do you actually hear yourself?

Hellfire isn’t actually wrong though.

Ktime · 03/04/2023 13:40

He expects my parents to support him when he requests it, whether it's financial or otherwise, he expects birthday and Christmas cards and presents for himself, he expects them for his children

Well if he won’t reasonably let his parents and sister see his children then he has no right to expect these things, either for himself or for his children.

And let me guess, I bet he doesn’t reciprocate presents to you or if he does they are little things?

HamBone · 03/04/2023 13:35

It’s lovely that you want to be a part of your nieces’ lives, but your parents and you/your DH will have separate relationships with them.

Let your parents sort out their relationship with your brother’s family and you sort out yours.

Amotherlife · 03/04/2023 13:35

Not the same situation exactly but your description of your SIL reminds me of my BIL's second wife. Everything has to be on her terms. She did come to family events occasionally but wasn't always gracious. She reluctantly had BIL's family to her place but was often semi absent or rude. Made it clear one Christmas she wanted BIL's mother and sister to leave, in their hearing. There's a ton of other things I could list. It felt like she just needed to be in control at all times. You can't win against someone like this, their need to have their own way trumps everything.

Your brother is either weak, doesn't care or likes it that way. You can't change him either.

As for your parents, that's up to them. If they wish to give him money, that's their business. If they ask for your opinion, give it. Otherwise let them make their own choices.

It's not that uncommon for grandparents to be disappointed either with their lack of contact with their GCs or with unreasonable demands from their offspring re childcare etc. IMO, best to live your own life and not invest so much into things you can't change.

As for presents, do as you feel is right. I don't know if I would send presents in that situation, especially when the children are too young to know.

AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 13:26

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I'm not trying to claim a right to them. I haven't, and wouldn't, go banging on their door demanding access to them. However, my DB hasn't said that he doesn't want to be a part of our family, or that he doesn't want the children to be part of our family. He expects my parents to support him when he requests it, whether it's financial or otherwise, he expects birthday and Christmas cards and presents for himself, he expects them for his children, but he doesn't want to facilitate us spending time with them.

I don't understand why you're so critical of my DP's parenting style or my families desire to be part of their GCs/DNs lives?

OP posts:
WonderingWanda · 03/04/2023 13:17

The problem is your db, he would be organising and facilitating your family spending time with the children but instead he is happy to default to sil who for some reason or another prefers her family. You can't change her buy you can tell him that you are all hurt he doesn't include you more. At the end of the day it isn't really her job to facilitate this although I know many women, myself included do.

IfuWannaBmyLover · 03/04/2023 13:17

AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 12:01

This is very much along the lines of how I approached it last time, which resulted in her attempting to ban me from seeing the children. I was told that we hadn't done anything to offend or upset anyone and then when I suggested he makes a bit more effort with our DPs (maybe letting them visit once a fortnight) as they felt pushed out the message was passed onto her and she lost it. This is why I'm worried about raising the subject again.

She sounds like a Twat

HamBone · 03/04/2023 13:16

I still don’t understand why you think you have any right to see these children.

I’m essentially agreeing with @TomatoFrog They’re not “your”
family.

HamBone · 03/04/2023 13:15

Haven’t RTFT, but one comment I agree with is that your parents’ relationship with their grandchildren is separate from your relationship with your nieces. They’re not an extension of your nuclear family, IYSWIM, they’re your brother’s nuclear family.

So I’d let your parents handle their relationship with your brothers’ family and you focus on yours. My eldest SIL made this mistake with her DH’s siblings, assuming that they’d be included, and it caused problems. I believe the situation has improved now that she’s backed off.

TomatoFrog · 03/04/2023 13:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Rosecoffeecup · 03/04/2023 13:10

You seem to be blaming SIL more than your DB, even though he is the one seemingly not facilitating a relationship with his family (except to take money). Your issue should be with him more than it is her.

jemimapuddlepluck · 03/04/2023 13:04

In all fairness OP, he treats you all like shit yet you still beg for scraps. Why would he change? I would cut all contact if I were you, encourage your parents to do the same. No its not ideal, those children are your family but this dynamic will never change so the options are, cut them off or suck it up. I certainly would t be 'spoiling the children' what does that teach them? Just helps to create more entitled, fucked up adults amd the world needs fewer of them.

Womencanlift · 03/04/2023 13:02

OP you could be my best friend - she went through the exact thing with her waste of space brother and SIL.

They live 10 minutes away from BF’s mum but she has not seen her grandchildren properly for close to 10 years now. Like you SIL’s family was priority. BF and her mum always had an open door, invited them over, bought presents etc but it was like banging a brick wall. Eventually my BF lost it as she was sick of seeing her mum so upset so went to their door and told them exactly what she thought of them

She knew herself it was not the most mature response but by that point she knew nothing would change and both she and her mum now feel it’s a weight off their shoulder now that the hope and expectation is now gone. For her the outburst was cathartic and she does see her niece and nephews in town and will always stop and say hello as they are much older now so are often out and about without their parents

ChickenDhansak82 · 03/04/2023 13:01

Your DB sounds under the thumb. He needs to stand up for himself and invite you round.

If he is not willing to do this then there is nothing you can do.

Your parents shouldn't be loaning money if they're upset about not seeing their grandchildren. Why don't they agree to loan money then can sort out transferring it next time Your DB and the kids are visiting...

AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 13:00

I suppose I am judging them for their spending, but only because they've borrowed large amounts of money from my parents, aren't really paying them back, and then continue to ask them for money. I don't think that tattoos and fancy kitchen bins should be their priority, but that's just my opinion. I don't judge who they spend their time with, I just think they should also make the time to see my DPs, particularly when my DP's are extremely flexible and are happy to do this in whatever way is easiest for them. I don't judge that they don't drive - I also don't drive. I also don't judge that my SIL doesn't work as how they choose to approach childcare etc is up to them, I have no idea how this should be approached as I don't have children.

OP posts:
GooglyEyeballs · 03/04/2023 13:00

AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 12:03

This is exactly how it feels for us! Has anything improved since you walked away? Did they make any effort to encourage contact once you stopped making the effort or is their no relationship at all now? I'm just curious as to whether this could help in our situation.

We haven't seen or heard from them in two years. They literally gave no craps when we walked away. It was really upsetting at first, the realisation that we meant nothing to them but as we slowly got over it we were able think a lot more clearly about how the relationship had been and now realise how spiteful their behaviour was towards us. We tried so hard to get along with them and it was completely one way before you even factor in the nastiness. It's pretty shocking in hindsight. Still upsets me on occasions like around DNs birthdays and Christmas but ultimately we're happier and healthier without the constant heartache of it. And there'll be other special people in our lives and our energy time and money is much better spent on people who value us as much as we do them. Can't wait for my sister to start having babies because I am so ready to be an amazing aunty! We're really close to my side of the family so that really helped us through it.

SchoolTripDrama · 03/04/2023 12:57

@TitterYeeNot Are you on the wind up or are you serious?!?! My god I feel for anyone being raised influenced by you, Jesus Christ on a bike. You're the type who clicks their fingers at waiting staff, aren't you??

SchoolTripDrama · 03/04/2023 12:54

@AnnoyedAuntie
There's a chance your parents could apply to the courts for access. If they can prove they have some kind of existing relationship with them, even if it's only the crumbs they're thrown every 3 months.
They don't necessarily need to employ a Solicitor to apply to the courts either, they could just get a free hour consultation then pay £250 to make an application to court then represent themselves.

Some will come on here and say "Grandparent's rights aren't a thing" etc and try laughing at me but I've been through the process with a friend and it very much IS a thing and DOES get taken seriously in many cases

woodhill · 03/04/2023 12:51

So sorry OP, it can be difficult

I feel like we always play 2nd fiddle to dsil dps when it comes to dgd. They always seem to be in first but nothing like you are describing

Feel sorry for your dps being fleeced for money

Just give them space. It's not you

FizzyWineAndCrisps · 03/04/2023 12:49

@AnnoyedAuntie You sound quite judgemental of your DB and SIL - what they spend their money on, who they spend their time with, the fact they don’t drive, the fact SIL doesn’t work. I wonder if they feel that judgement and that’s why they spend less time with you. It seems you don’t try and understand why their circumstances are the way they are.

AnnoyedAuntie · 03/04/2023 12:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

In reply to your previous post, my DPs certainly weren't authoritarian.

When it comes down to it, regardless of how my DB treats them, they would never leave any of us in a position where we were in financial trouble if they were in a position to help. My DB and SIL's money problems could easily be solved if they took better care of their finances, but ultimately they're not going to watch him struggle if they can help, much to their own detriment.

OP posts:
RosesofAmsterdam · 03/04/2023 12:42

I think your SIL is a red herring here and it's actually your DB. It's his responsibility to arrange social contact with his family. He's not arranging that as often as you'd like. There's no right amount of time to socialise with family, only what you are happy with. Maybe he's content with seeing his family every few months. All you can do is keep asking if he wants to meet up with you and try to accept if it's not as often as you'd like.

Once you have DC it can become much more difficult to arrange social occasions. Even if the physical meeting isn't hard (eg going to someone's house for coffee) you just have less headspace for it as there is so much more to have to think about and organise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread