Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Told to 'be kind' to trouble causing SIL.

508 replies

OooWhatAWhopper · 03/04/2023 06:54

Brother has asked if SIL can come & stay with me for a while. Apparently her mental health is bad & she 'needs a rest from the stresses of life'. SIL & I don't get on, she has constantly attempted to sabotage family relationships & in my (bitter) opinion, her failing MH is well deserved karma - the scores of people she has upset has finally resulted in her being isolated & being given a wide berth by everyone.

I've said 'no' & I mean it & will stick to my guns, but what has really pissed me off is DB saying: 'you being nice about this will be ever so helpful to me'. It feels like a veiled threat, 'if you don't forgive & forget then you're the bad one'.

For context, just a few of the things SIL has done within the last 5 years. And this is just the tip of the iceberg:

  1. Reported me to the police in lock down 3 times (I didn't break any rules).
  1. Put my boyfriend on a dating site. This caused a lot of upset, she said it was a joke.
  1. Refused to allow me any time alone with my dying mother. She knew when I'd be visiting the hospice, because I needed to arrange childcare, & would always be there & refuse to leave the room.
  1. Funeral cars only had room for our dad & my siblings & I, but she made such a fuss, I let her have my place & drove myself.
  1. Has publicly made fun of anything positive in my life. New hair do, new glasses, kids achievements, my postgrad graduation etc.

I've been grey rock with her for 2 years now but it's not been easy to do because she's constantly tried to push into my life. I refuse to be labelled as 'bad' if I won't 'be kind' to this person. AIBU? And how on earth do I voice my position in a calm & rational manner to my DB? Ordinarily I have no problem being assertive & sensible but I'm bordering on loosing my shit over this, hence needing some perspective before screaming 'no way' at him & looking unhinged.

OP posts:
Twofortheteam · 03/04/2023 12:17

Like everyone else here, no way in hell would I let this person stay.

Here’s a different suggestion though: simply don’t reply. By asking you for this service they have given you power, while they wait for your answer. Once you answer (even ‘No’) you hand the power right back to them, to reply back to you with argument or whatnot.

There’s nothing wrong with (and nothing more infuriating for them) than for you just to ignore the request.

You can do that forever: if the matter is raised, just change the subject.

That way she doesn’t come to stay, and you can’t be accused of having said no. Eventually they’ll stop asking. And you still hold the power.

By the way: if you feel you “should” reply (out of some misguided need to be ‘polite’, simply remember that is simply them making you feel you should. And they don’t have the right to oblige you to do anything. Nor do they have that power in your head, if you don’t give it to them.

tl;dr: harness the infinite power of silence.

Thehonestbadger · 03/04/2023 12:17

Maybe this is just me (luckily my SIL is a nice person) but I would absolutely balls out tell my brother what I thought in your situation. F*ck his thinly veiled threats.

‘Absolutely not DB, with the best will toward you in the world SIL is awful and frankly I’m not shocked her mental health is failing I fully believe that’s karma coming back at her for not being a very nice, OR KIND, person. Actions speak much louder than words and her actions towards me have been rather s*it !’

That being said I’m older than my DB by 8 years and he’s quite an easy going guy, our general rapport would allow me to be quite direct like that and whilst he no doubt wouldn’t like it immediately he would, if SIL were actually a nightmare, get over it. Yours might not.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 03/04/2023 12:14

WhenDovesFly · 03/04/2023 07:21

Be frank with your brother:

"My own mental health has suffered over the years due to the way SIL has behaved towards me. Has anyone shown any consideration to me? No, it has all been minimised and treated as 'joking'. I don't feel charitable enough to help out so please do not ask again as the answer remains 'no'."

This is a very good response.

whynotwhatknot · 03/04/2023 12:12

He hasnt been helpful to you why should you do anything for him

she clearly does have problems narcissitic ones-shes ran out of people to get attention from so now its back to you

i dont even kniow how you look at your brother after everythign shes done

StaunchMomma · 03/04/2023 12:08

I don't see what your brother said as a threat but it is most definitely emotional blackmail and you're right not to tolerate it.

I'd just reiterate that it's an incredibly firm no, state 'here are my reasons' and list the bloody awful things she's done, exactly as you did for us above.

She sounds like an utter shit.

MzHz · 03/04/2023 12:04

SIL/ BIL know full well what she's done sorry meant to say this to @Hudsonriver

Denial. They are in such a deep state of denial that they absolutely DON'T accept or 'know full well what they have done'. If they had ANY level of conscience, they would not have done any of this in the first place.

DB is an enabler, she will have gaslit him and he's had to accept it or the alternative is that he recognises what an awful person he has saddled himself with and to unsaddle himself he has to blow his life up.

This request from DB would make me see him in a different light, and yes the calls to grey rock him are bang on the money. He is now part of the problem.

I have a situation in my family in that I don't see my mother. I've been really honest and open about it with my aunt/uncle over the years and how utterly devastating it was to have suffered at her hands. Every Christmas however my uncle asks if I have spoken to her with the 'oh what a shame' tone in his voice.

I dunno why I'm always surprised he says it. I really MUST be ready next Christmas and remind him why I had to make the decision to cut her out of our lives again.

PrettyMaybug · 03/04/2023 12:04

NO NO NO NO NO NO NO!!!!!! She sounds like a nightmare @OooWhatAWhopper Sod your fucking brother, if he is so desperate to help the poor iccle wumman, let him take her in!

As
AmandaHoldensLips said at 08:49

Suggested message:

"You know she’s done some pretty nasty stuff to me, right? Maybe it would be better if she went to stay with one of her friends. You know, somebody who actually likes her. Or does she not have any? But it's a no from me. Don't ask me again."

Say this. ^

You said this would cause a load of shit and bad feeling, but so what?!!! As I said, fuck your brother, he is taking the piss. Let HIM put up with her. Don't be a doormat, and DON'T be made to feel guilty. Sounds to me like a long break from your brother - AND your SIL - would be a good thing for you.

LookItsMeAgain · 03/04/2023 11:56

I've read 200 of the posts (and I'll go back and read the rest as soon as I've posted this) but I'd imagine that she has said and done some terrible things over the years.
I would pick the top 3 of these, preferably the ones that there is zero ambiguity around that cannot be refuted or dismissed and use those as my examples of what she has said/done over the years.
I would also suggest that you (as calmly as you can muster) suggest that it is HE who should be nice and helpful to you, all being considered because it is HIS wife that has been causing the issues between you. You may want to refer back to a time before she came on the scene to show the difference in the relationship between siblings.
Lastly, I 100% agree with mentioning in the message that it would be against guidelines/be unprofessional to treat a relative with mental health issues but you can suggest that X, Y or Z who are in their own Integrated Care Board area be their first port of call if she is requiring of medical attention.

You're doing brilliantly I might add. Your brother...not so much.

MzHz · 03/04/2023 11:55

maybe@Hudsonriver but being authentic to yourself feels better - especially knowing you get painted as the bad person whatever you do, so no change there.

The thing with abusive and toxic/narcissistic people is that they will keep pushing your buttons and won't stop. maybe it is to satisfy their need to be a victim and make you the villain, but they pick on people they think are weak and will not resist or stand up to them. They see you as a 'mark' somehow.

I found when I had finished therapy from my ex and family and their toxicity, that I had almost like a zero tolerance of narc force field around me and literally nobody tries anything on with me at all nowadays.

So zero tolerance for BS does work. and yes, even biting back DOES have it's uses.

dramalessllama · 03/04/2023 11:51

DisforDarkChocolate · 03/04/2023 07:29

You need to start grey rocking your bloody brother. He's being fecking ridiculous.

Came her to say exactly this. He is the bigger problem here.

Whichnumbers · 03/04/2023 11:50

'you being nice about this will be ever so helpful to me

Tell db

IUts not a case of being nice about this and helping you, we genuinely don't get along and if someone is having mental health problems the last place that will be good for them is to be stuck with someone they don't get along with. You'd be better finding someone that does get along with her (by the sounds of it that'll be like finding rocking horse shit) so she can recoup - or send her to an airbnb near the coast for a few days

Frozendaquiri · 03/04/2023 11:43

You're a saint OP, I'd have probably exploded!

Hudsonriver · 03/04/2023 11:40

MzHz · 03/04/2023 11:30

Admittedly completely projecting here, but i'm willing to bet that all of us in a similar situation will have tried the pragmatic, oh I'm so busy, I can't accommodate due to x, y or z.."

This approach of course is so polite, dignified, and completely unrelated to the actual root cause which is behaviour so fucking heinous AND WORSE enabled by others who are supposed to look out for us on some level.

We end up being reasonable, rising above, turning the other cheek and being a better person.

What does it actually achieve? the square root of nothing. the person with the appalling behaviour is NEVER even encouraged to face any kind of consequence of their actions.

SO I say now, CAUSE the arguments. Go Nuclear, Raise your voice and tell them to FTFO with their 'Be Nice' bullshit. Give them a taste of their own medicine.

There are far too many people who should treat us better, albeit merely civilly but won't and us turning the other cheek just gives them another cheek to slap.

@OooWhatAWhopper your brother has let you down time and time again by enabling her behaviour, and now he's being used as a narcissistic tool by her to pull you back in again so she can hurt you some more. Fuck that Noise.

I am speaking as one who very nearly died due to MH issues, I have a huge amount of sympathy for those who struggle. I however despite being as ill as I was never used it as a weapon of torture or cruelty to others. Her MH is not a licence to abuse others.

YANBU.

The issue with going nuclear is that it's a trap.
Op has done the correct thing and grey rocked the SIL.
Although technically grey rock is usually a short term measure before going LC/NC.
Do you think going nuclear will get them to " see" the error of their ways?
No
SIL is manipulative and knows and chooses to behave the way she does.Op has grey rocked so now BIL ( flying monkey)is hoovering on her behalf to draw the OP back into the game where SIL can behave badly to her.
Short sharp no is all that's needed.
No drama etc
SIL/ BIL know full well what she's done.
All that will happen if you explode, list the faults is "Op is an awful person , poooor SIl the victim"

No one is saying be nice, just say no and walk away.
Maintain your firm boundary

" Don't mud wrestle with pigs, the pigs like it "

Shz · 03/04/2023 11:38

No is a complete sentence.

Is the brother asking your to look after your SiL her husband? If so why can’t he look after her?

Failing that they can make arrangements at a private care facility. This woman has intentionally caused you a lot of upset distress and turmoil to the point you have grey rocked her and now the expectation is that you just let this poisonous person into your home with your family and kids?

NOPE

If you want a gentle get out then you can always says things are really difficult right now and you are not in the position to care for anyone else.

Ursualesther · 03/04/2023 11:35

Given your feelings towards your SIL

surely you’d be one of the last people that could assist with your SIL’s mental health

very baffling he even thought of you!

MzHz · 03/04/2023 11:30

Mirabai · 03/04/2023 11:16

No don’t even get involved into a discussion of her behaviour past or present. That will simply lead to arguments.

Just say that you cannot accommodate her due to workload and family commitments and just repeat it.

Admittedly completely projecting here, but i'm willing to bet that all of us in a similar situation will have tried the pragmatic, oh I'm so busy, I can't accommodate due to x, y or z.."

This approach of course is so polite, dignified, and completely unrelated to the actual root cause which is behaviour so fucking heinous AND WORSE enabled by others who are supposed to look out for us on some level.

We end up being reasonable, rising above, turning the other cheek and being a better person.

What does it actually achieve? the square root of nothing. the person with the appalling behaviour is NEVER even encouraged to face any kind of consequence of their actions.

SO I say now, CAUSE the arguments. Go Nuclear, Raise your voice and tell them to FTFO with their 'Be Nice' bullshit. Give them a taste of their own medicine.

There are far too many people who should treat us better, albeit merely civilly but won't and us turning the other cheek just gives them another cheek to slap.

@OooWhatAWhopper your brother has let you down time and time again by enabling her behaviour, and now he's being used as a narcissistic tool by her to pull you back in again so she can hurt you some more. Fuck that Noise.

I am speaking as one who very nearly died due to MH issues, I have a huge amount of sympathy for those who struggle. I however despite being as ill as I was never used it as a weapon of torture or cruelty to others. Her MH is not a licence to abuse others.

YANBU.

Bearpawk · 03/04/2023 11:28

Just say no, don't apologise.

Is this your DB's wife? He's struggling with her so trying to palm her off on you?

Apairofsparklingeyes · 03/04/2023 11:27

My advice is to say ‘ I hope SIL will feel better soon but I’ve already told you that she can’t stay here. I’m not prepared to discuss this any further’

It isn’t a good idea to list her past actions or give any reasons, just stick to saying a very clear no.

MuchuseasaChocolateTeapot · 03/04/2023 11:24

Doesn’t she have her own family and friends? She sounds awful. Why would you want to be working in the MH sector all day then come home, to your refuge, to deal with it all evening and weekends?

Bollindger · 03/04/2023 11:23

Just keep repeating.
I can't help.
I know you are trying to help SIL but I know my house is not the correct answer.
I hope you find away to deal with this.
I am doing you a kindness by saying no as SIL actually need to be were she feels safe and she has shown she has a problem being with me.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/04/2023 11:23

You're very welcome, @OooWhatAWhopper; I use it in circumstances like this myself, and also find it handy for when it's the questioner's own behaviour at issue ... "Why would you choose to behave like this?", etc.

PritiPatelsMaker · 03/04/2023 11:19

OooWhatAWhopper · 03/04/2023 11:14

Thank you so much everyone. I've copied & pasted a lot of the fantastic advice & wording into a notepad doc & will be using it.

I'm also really grateful for the moral support & understanding & love offered about mum's death. What an amazing bunch you all are.

I think your grey rock approach has worked for you so far, I wouldn't be offering up any information that thru can argue with now.

Twillow · 03/04/2023 11:16

Second copying the list and spelling out what she has done.
Sounds like your brother wants to offload her tbh.

Mirabai · 03/04/2023 11:16

OooWhatAWhopper · 03/04/2023 11:11

I like that. A lot. I could really make that approach work. Thank you!

No don’t even get involved into a discussion of her behaviour past or present. That will simply lead to arguments.

Just say that you cannot accommodate her due to workload and family commitments and just repeat it.

OooWhatAWhopper · 03/04/2023 11:14

Thank you so much everyone. I've copied & pasted a lot of the fantastic advice & wording into a notepad doc & will be using it.

I'm also really grateful for the moral support & understanding & love offered about mum's death. What an amazing bunch you all are.

OP posts: