Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Told to 'be kind' to trouble causing SIL.

508 replies

OooWhatAWhopper · 03/04/2023 06:54

Brother has asked if SIL can come & stay with me for a while. Apparently her mental health is bad & she 'needs a rest from the stresses of life'. SIL & I don't get on, she has constantly attempted to sabotage family relationships & in my (bitter) opinion, her failing MH is well deserved karma - the scores of people she has upset has finally resulted in her being isolated & being given a wide berth by everyone.

I've said 'no' & I mean it & will stick to my guns, but what has really pissed me off is DB saying: 'you being nice about this will be ever so helpful to me'. It feels like a veiled threat, 'if you don't forgive & forget then you're the bad one'.

For context, just a few of the things SIL has done within the last 5 years. And this is just the tip of the iceberg:

  1. Reported me to the police in lock down 3 times (I didn't break any rules).
  1. Put my boyfriend on a dating site. This caused a lot of upset, she said it was a joke.
  1. Refused to allow me any time alone with my dying mother. She knew when I'd be visiting the hospice, because I needed to arrange childcare, & would always be there & refuse to leave the room.
  1. Funeral cars only had room for our dad & my siblings & I, but she made such a fuss, I let her have my place & drove myself.
  1. Has publicly made fun of anything positive in my life. New hair do, new glasses, kids achievements, my postgrad graduation etc.

I've been grey rock with her for 2 years now but it's not been easy to do because she's constantly tried to push into my life. I refuse to be labelled as 'bad' if I won't 'be kind' to this person. AIBU? And how on earth do I voice my position in a calm & rational manner to my DB? Ordinarily I have no problem being assertive & sensible but I'm bordering on loosing my shit over this, hence needing some perspective before screaming 'no way' at him & looking unhinged.

OP posts:
mummywithtwokidsplusdog · 03/04/2023 08:15

Her behaviour is utterly unacceptable - you ‘being kind’ will not fix her. She sounds manipulative and your DB sounds oblivious. I think the less you can say whilst continuing to say no would for the best. You don’t need to explain yourself or give a list of examples to back up why you are saying no. Just a ‘no that wouldn’t be possible for me and my DC’ type response. Really feel for you- being part of a family needs compromise and understanding at times but her behaviour is way beyond all of that! Take care of your self 🌷

fruitstick · 03/04/2023 08:15

Flat no.

It also sounds like SIL is trying to escalate things because she's not getting a reaction from you.

It is not a good idea to spend any time with her.

romdowa · 03/04/2023 08:15

Surely this is a situation where telling him to fuck right off is acceptable. I'd have laughed at him and asked was he joking 🤣

Yousee · 03/04/2023 08:15

"I can't possibly support your wife when I despise everything about her, including the fact she is married to my brother. She's your problem. "

I cannot in a million years imagine my brother allowing a spouse to treat his family this way and in so sorry for what this dreadful woman has put you through. Those things can never be taken back or fixed.

CruCru · 03/04/2023 08:14

Shemovesshemoves21 · 03/04/2023 07:52

Fuck that. It would be a 'no' from me too! If others in the family would like to "keep the peace", suggest SIL lives with them instead - I bet that would shut them up!

In terms of replying to your brother "hi, sorry but the historic relationship with SIL means I don't have the mental or emotional capacity to have her live with me. Sorry if that doesn't help you, but I hope you find a solution".

I like this response. It’s clear but it doesn’t actually list the stuff she’s done.

Apart from anything else, having her live with someone who can’t stand her isn’t kind. It’s weird and creepy.

Gazelda · 03/04/2023 08:14

Putting two people who have such a difficult relationship in the same living space together would be very unhealthy.
Your brother has no regard for your happiness or wellbeing.

"No. I've told you that Joyce can't come to stay. She has hurt me too much. I can't help her. Don't ask me again".

Thursdayschild7 · 03/04/2023 08:14

Respectfully No. Suggest brother seeks professional advice.

NeverTrustAPoliceman · 03/04/2023 08:14

Your latest post doesn't change anything. I run my own business using a particular set of skills. I have very firm boundaries about people who would like to take advantage of that for free, the answer is either no or here is a list of my fees, terms and conditions.

I would avoid any discussion beyond "That doesn't work for me".

I hope your children are not old enough for your brother to try to manipulate them.

MoveOnTheCards · 03/04/2023 08:13

Yeah no. Just shut it down with ‘no, that won’t work’ and don’t go into the reasons.

He already knows this is an unreasonable ask, hence the ‘be kind’ gaslighting bullshit. listing reasons just gives them an opportunity to continue down that path and turns it into a discussion. There is no discussion to be had.

BlackFriday · 03/04/2023 08:12

So, if she needs " a break from the stresses and strains of life," is he meaning that he is expecting you to run around after her like a fucking maid?

Itsbritneybitch22 · 03/04/2023 08:12

Why does he want her out? Like really want her out I mean?

You don’t need to stay calm on this, he’s pushing so let him really know.

GreenSunfish · 03/04/2023 08:12

She is really dangerous. I’d struggle to be in a room with her for an afternoon in someone else’s house. No way would I let her stay. This is the first survey I’ve seen where 100% of voters have said YANBU. Even if she was the nicest person in the world it’s ok to say “no, you can’t stay with me”.

determinedtomakethiswork · 03/04/2023 08:11

All it is is she's behaving so badly in her own home that he wants someone else to take her in.

VaddaABeetch · 03/04/2023 08:11

Being a Mental Health Care Practitioner is even more reason for SIL not to come.

You can’t treat family.

ShandaLear · 03/04/2023 08:10

Ahh - sorry, cross post. In that case you could just say it is unethical and inappropriate for you to support family members in that way.

grivelling · 03/04/2023 08:10

He should be kind to you and keep her away from you. He is being a prick.

StrawberrySquash · 03/04/2023 08:09

Apart from anything if she needs a mental health restorative break, why would the house of someone she doesn't get on with serve that purpose? It'd make me miserable. Bad for her as well as you!

Madamecastafiore · 03/04/2023 08:09

Tell him you're being kind to yourself and your children and your capacity for being kind to his wife disappeared when she did (list).

Phineyj · 03/04/2023 08:09

Oh, well that makes it easier then.

Your professional insurance/indemnity/registration means you can't be in a position of providing unregistered domiciliary care.

Also you don't want to!

ShandaLear · 03/04/2023 08:08

Hi Bro, I don’t have the mental resources to cope with her. She needs professional mental health support so I suggest you get in touch with the Samaritans to seek advice.

MeridianB · 03/04/2023 08:07

OooWhatAWhopper · 03/04/2023 08:02

I'm going to get flamed for drip feeding here, sorry. I should have said in the OP that I'm an AMHP (approved mental health practitioner) qualified social worker. But that doesn't mean I offer in patient care! I live alone with my kids, home is where I unwind.

I think that might give these losers the impression that you have endless tolerance and care to give. And allows your selfish brother to believe you’d become a career for his horrible wife.

Stick with no, don’t get into detail. Ideally just block them both and enjoy the peace.

Lorry10 · 03/04/2023 08:07

OooWhatAWhopper · 03/04/2023 08:02

I'm going to get flamed for drip feeding here, sorry. I should have said in the OP that I'm an AMHP (approved mental health practitioner) qualified social worker. But that doesn't mean I offer in patient care! I live alone with my kids, home is where I unwind.

Just read this one OP! So when she reported you to the police she could have got you into trouble with your job and affected other people with MH issues.
Definitely no. It would be a lot to ask of anyone, but definitely too much given the history. You would end up blamed if she didn't feel better and its too much around a demanding job and kids.

Emotionalsupportviper · 03/04/2023 08:07

OooWhatAWhopper · 03/04/2023 08:02

I'm going to get flamed for drip feeding here, sorry. I should have said in the OP that I'm an AMHP (approved mental health practitioner) qualified social worker. But that doesn't mean I offer in patient care! I live alone with my kids, home is where I unwind.

And home is where one of you could end up being seriously hurt (literally!) if you took this toxic, spiteful individual in. I could honestly see it coming to blows if the pair of you were together under one roof for an extended period od time - or that she would call the police and say you'd threatened her, or even do something like hurting herself and saying you attacked her - she sounds absolutely unhinged..

You are very wise to stand your ground.

tiredpuppymum · 03/04/2023 08:06

It's not a drip feed because it doesn't change anything. That list is awful and I recommend you send it to him.

Twiglets1 · 03/04/2023 08:05

OooWhatAWhopper · 03/04/2023 08:02

I'm going to get flamed for drip feeding here, sorry. I should have said in the OP that I'm an AMHP (approved mental health practitioner) qualified social worker. But that doesn't mean I offer in patient care! I live alone with my kids, home is where I unwind.

That doesn't mean you should in any way be expected to overlook all your SILs previous toxic behavior & take on responsibility for her. You're a social worker not a saint!

Your job makes no difference to my opinion that YANBU