Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

As a follow on, from the original thread about dover, Chaos in Dover

87 replies

Hawkins003 · 02/04/2023 23:38

Just that really, a thread for general thoughts and perspectives about the situation

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
HermoineFairfax · 06/04/2023 17:32

Merrymouse · 06/04/2023 17:23

If the French choose to be bolshy and make things difficult for British travellers by striking, rioting, working to rule, operating at minimal staffing levels especially at busy periods, that's up to them.

No, it is up to the British government to negotiate an agreement that works, in or out of the EU. The French have not suddenly changed. We have just had years of incompetent government.

Totally agree Merrymouse. Why do the French keep voting him in? I suppose with all the chaos and violence in France at the moment, he might do the decent thing and resign. Do Presidents resign?

Merrymouse · 06/04/2023 17:23

If the French choose to be bolshy and make things difficult for British travellers by striking, rioting, working to rule, operating at minimal staffing levels especially at busy periods, that's up to them.

No, it is up to the British government to negotiate an agreement that works, in or out of the EU. The French have not suddenly changed. We have just had years of incompetent government.

Neededanewuserhandle · 06/04/2023 17:18

CrotchetyQuaver · 03/04/2023 19:18

@notimagain
Free movement of people in the EU came in in 1992. The link between Dover/France has been around a lot longer than that.
Some of us are old enough to remember travelling pre 1992 and the advent of free movement and not having any issues whatsoever. If the French choose to be bolshy and make things difficult for British travellers by striking, rioting, working to rule, operating at minimal staffing levels especially at busy periods, that's up to them.

There also never used to be the requirement for every individual passport to be stamped in and out back then either, but obviously times are different now. "Progress" and "efficiency" have made everyday life more difficult in so many ways - I spent 40 mins in a queue earlier today to speak to a real human at HMRC...

It is funny how "progress" makes things "better" isn't it? I went to France on a school trip in 1973 using a passport from the Post Office that I walked in and purchased over the counter. The French officials took a quick look at the kids on the bus (didn't ask to see passports) and we were done.

notimagain · 03/04/2023 20:07

CrotchetyQuaver · 03/04/2023 19:18

@notimagain
Free movement of people in the EU came in in 1992. The link between Dover/France has been around a lot longer than that.
Some of us are old enough to remember travelling pre 1992 and the advent of free movement and not having any issues whatsoever. If the French choose to be bolshy and make things difficult for British travellers by striking, rioting, working to rule, operating at minimal staffing levels especially at busy periods, that's up to them.

There also never used to be the requirement for every individual passport to be stamped in and out back then either, but obviously times are different now. "Progress" and "efficiency" have made everyday life more difficult in so many ways - I spent 40 mins in a queue earlier today to speak to a real human at HMRC...

Ah yes, I'm old enough to remember travelling to France in the early 70s but anyhow thanks for the reminder about how it worked.. of course don't forget there wasn't the Schengen agreement back then either so the down side of the good old days was that in theory at least passports needed to be checked at every European Border....nowadays for the locals it's definitely more efficient, especially if you live very near an internal Border like we do.

OTOH yes it's extra faff for any non-EU passport holder entering the Schengen zone at any external frontier, not just a French one, who lacks either a Schengen Visa or EU residency permit but the clock isn't going to be wound back to the 70s just because Dover can't cope.

If the French choose to be bolshy and make things difficult for British travellers by striking, rioting, working to rule, operating at minimal staffing levels especially at busy periods, that's up to them.

Glad you said "if" there because with regard to Dover and last weekend - there were no national days of action with regard to the pension reforms over the period - last national day of action here was last Tuesday, FWIW next one is this coming Thursday so it was all quiet on the manifestation/protest/riot around and during last weekend. There was no PAF (i.e. Border police) work to rule either....

Looks like a problem for Dover to "own" and sort out.

LlynTegid · 03/04/2023 19:38

We could have left the EU and had a similar arrangement to Norway. Indeed it was spoken about during the 2016 campaign.

Which would have avoided all this, and probably a part of the small boats issue.

If the capacity to check passports is not there, then sailings should be restricted. Not ideal, but no-one should be forced to wait for hours. The limited capacity because of extra time for checking is why there are now fewer Eurostar trains than pre-2021, and why Heathrow restricted summer flights last year.

CrotchetyQuaver · 03/04/2023 19:18

@notimagain
Free movement of people in the EU came in in 1992. The link between Dover/France has been around a lot longer than that.
Some of us are old enough to remember travelling pre 1992 and the advent of free movement and not having any issues whatsoever. If the French choose to be bolshy and make things difficult for British travellers by striking, rioting, working to rule, operating at minimal staffing levels especially at busy periods, that's up to them.

There also never used to be the requirement for every individual passport to be stamped in and out back then either, but obviously times are different now. "Progress" and "efficiency" have made everyday life more difficult in so many ways - I spent 40 mins in a queue earlier today to speak to a real human at HMRC...

notimagain · 03/04/2023 18:32

CrotchetyQuaver · 03/04/2023 09:59

I think it's all down to insufficient staffing levels at French immigration to process the numbers arriving from the UK?

I was in Spain last week and their immigration processes for the hordes of Brits arriving was excellent, it took no more than a couple of minutes in the queue to get stamped in or out. I think if Malaga airport immigration can get it right, I don't see why Dover/Calais can't either.

Also as an aside, there were warning signs on the motorways warning of the delays from Nottingham downwards on the Saturday...

Because as @RosesInWater has pointed out you can't compare airport infrastructure, many of which have arrangements that have been in place for years with infrastructure to cope with non-Schengen, non-EU traffic, with the set up at Dover, which up until Brexit had the relatively simply task of exclusively facilitating cursory passport checks at a internal EU/non- Schengen frontier.

Certainly having got their heads around the requirements French immigration police (PAF) are pretty quick at our local airports, so it does sounds as if there's very much a Dover factor (rumour being infrastructure).

GasPanic · 03/04/2023 17:45

WhoDatDen · 03/04/2023 16:58

Yeah I'd deffo send in time and motion to study how long it takes the French officials to look at and stamp a passport.

Then I'd look at Calais and see how long it takes British officials to do the same.

Look at both places to see how many staff are in place ie does one have more official booths.

Monitor if both places get into pickles. If so, when? What are the bottle necks. Do british officials get into a pickle in France?

I'd study how it's managed in Dover and how it's managed in Calais. Then I'd check other checkpoints France have - this is showing my ignorance as I dont know if Switzerland has one with them. Is there a bottle neck at that point too.

If Swiss dont have a checkpoint, then it's just GB. Maybe some training is needed? That applies to wherever the problem is ie Dover or Calais.

I'm pretty sure that they know exactly how long it takes to process an individual coach etc. It's an important part of their business model to optimise the flow through at peak times so they can maximise profits. After all, they don't want to turn down bookings and have spare capacity when it is most profitable for them.

This leads to three conclusions I can think of, either :

a) Something changed to affect the processing conditions relatively quickly (ie in the last few days). That could be the weather, number of staff on duty available to process, or some very recent change in the processing conditions which screwed up their calculations.

b) The number of coaches that they could handle was less that the amount that was booked in.

c) They made some sort of mistake in the calculations or didn't put in enough slack.

Maybe all three, or maybe something else I haven't thought of :)

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/04/2023 17:43

sleepwhenidie · 03/04/2023 10:21

Haven’t read the original thread so apologies if said before but in the interest of tackling the problem rather than assigning blame, surely the French could make exception to the individual passport checking for minors? I mean, what is the risk of kids spending more than the allotted days in the EU? Kids on school trips or holidays with family aren’t the ones likely to break the limits or try and stay indefinitely…this would surely have avoided/reduced the massive delays for school trips this week, which were really the source of the problem.

They used to waive them through before Brexit. I don't really think it's our place to dictate how they should manage immigration into the EU from a third country.

If the UK voted to "take back control" of our borders, surely we have to respect the fact that other countries have the right to control theirs?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/04/2023 17:39

CrotchetyQuaver · 03/04/2023 09:59

I think it's all down to insufficient staffing levels at French immigration to process the numbers arriving from the UK?

I was in Spain last week and their immigration processes for the hordes of Brits arriving was excellent, it took no more than a couple of minutes in the queue to get stamped in or out. I think if Malaga airport immigration can get it right, I don't see why Dover/Calais can't either.

Also as an aside, there were warning signs on the motorways warning of the delays from Nottingham downwards on the Saturday...

So you want the French taxpayer to pay more because the Brits voted for more passport controls?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/04/2023 17:36

Kendodd · 03/04/2023 08:51

I think 'lower your expectations' is about the most honest thing the Tories have said. We've had a Tory government for 13 years, and are no longer in the EU. We shouldn't expect a European standard of living, healthcare, environmental protections, workers rights or public services. We get what we vote for. Go us!

Yes, it's a shame that they didn't put "lower your expectations" on the side of a bus during the referendum campaign. People might have actually had a better idea of what they were voting for.

BulldogSpirit · 03/04/2023 17:32

The problem is now resolved

WhoDatDen · 03/04/2023 16:58

Yeah I'd deffo send in time and motion to study how long it takes the French officials to look at and stamp a passport.

Then I'd look at Calais and see how long it takes British officials to do the same.

Look at both places to see how many staff are in place ie does one have more official booths.

Monitor if both places get into pickles. If so, when? What are the bottle necks. Do british officials get into a pickle in France?

I'd study how it's managed in Dover and how it's managed in Calais. Then I'd check other checkpoints France have - this is showing my ignorance as I dont know if Switzerland has one with them. Is there a bottle neck at that point too.

If Swiss dont have a checkpoint, then it's just GB. Maybe some training is needed? That applies to wherever the problem is ie Dover or Calais.

Ozgirl75 · 03/04/2023 16:54

I find it so odd that there isn’t the planning in place for this. Surely it’s someone’s job to go - ok it takes X amount of time to process Y amount of people, therefore they need to turn up Z hours before the ferry so that we can process the numbers booked onto the ferries in time. It’s just maths isn’t it? There have been queues at Dover for every holiday for years, I simply don’t understand why it always seems to come as a surprise that lots of people want to go on holiday at holiday time. It’s not like they’re just turning up, they’ve got booked slots.

TezTickle · 03/04/2023 13:02

The UK refusing to put money into Dover is very frustrating as it was a known bottle neck before Brexit...so now...this was a disaster in waiting. It will happen again at the next pinchpoint ie school holidays in July.

So ok we all know Brexit means a passport needs a stamp and when you have a coach, that's a lot of stamps. How can this be fixed?

What do we need to do?

Should we perform a time and motion study on the French to see how fast they process a coach. Then it needs to feed into the ferry companies so they dont overbook. Or a timing system put in place and coaches given a slot to turn up. Again, this feeds into how long the French take. If it's one coach per hour - it needs thinking about how many French are needed per coach. Lots to think about!

The best idea would be to invest in Dover to input more booths, but I dont live down there, so not sure why this has been rejected.

wonkylegs · 03/04/2023 11:46

@CrotchetyQuaver

@RosesInWater makes one point why it's slower but also one of the main issues with Dover atm whereas before you waved through coaches of on average 50-70 people on each one, now each person has to get off and be processed individually which much slower both processing and for embarking.
Dover at Easter is the primary route for thousands of kids on school trips meaning more coaches than usual compounding the delays compared to airports.
The U.K. declined to invest in more infrastructure at the port to assist with this known problem following Brexit.
The French didn't change the rules, we did, so we can't really complain it's their fault in them making us comply with them.

SomersetBrie · 03/04/2023 11:40

itsgettingweird · 03/04/2023 11:10

The reason this won't get resolved is denial.

Well done Tobias Ellwood. He's one of a few decent Tory MPs.

Bit on yesterdays thread instead of the Rory supporters arguing why this wasn't the fault of Brexit etc we actually had posters saying the the school children's fault for having parents who could pay for ski trips when we have a CoL crisis.

We've sunk so low as a country yet people still insist on racing to the bottom Sad

With any luck in a few years bills will be so high that nobody besides Tory MPs will be able to afford any kind of trips to France.
Problem will have resolved itself.

AxolotlOnions · 03/04/2023 11:39

OhYouBadBadKitten · 03/04/2023 11:26

From the last thread, which was very long. A reminder. Back in 2020, we knew this would happen once the implementation started kicking in. Yet there was no mitigation put in place.

Between this and the strikes at the passport office, good luck with getting on to the continent this year.

This. The French have spent a fortune upgrading the Port of Calais, they were doing it BEFORE the Brexit vote as it was long overdue, we have done nothing.

Lonelycrab · 03/04/2023 11:30

Yes I'm sure Brexit adds some new problems/delays in terms of passport checking, but they aren't huge

I don’t think that’s very accurate. With a coach full of people, having to check and stamp every passport will take a long time, certainly compared with someone just walking down the aisle and simply checking everyone is holding up a passport, like used to happen. It’s a couple of minutes versus an hour or so.

OhYouBadBadKitten · 03/04/2023 11:26

From the last thread, which was very long. A reminder. Back in 2020, we knew this would happen once the implementation started kicking in. Yet there was no mitigation put in place.

Between this and the strikes at the passport office, good luck with getting on to the continent this year.

As a follow on, from the original thread about dover, Chaos in Dover
Neighneigh · 03/04/2023 11:21

Wondering if @GasPanic has had a 12 year old on a 36 hour journey, including no contact for 8 hours yesterday, like some of us. Great news that your own trips have been so good recently, well done you! How fucking marvellous. For the rest of us, yes we blame this cluster fuck of a government for it. The French are too fucked off with us to do anything to help (can't blame them) and our government is too up its own arse to care.

Michaelschenkersguitar · 03/04/2023 11:12

@GasPanic is it ok to blame the government ?

FrancescaContini · 03/04/2023 11:12

I’m laughing at the idea of the delays at Dover being the fault of the kids themselves because their parents dared to be able to afford a ski trip during this CoL crisis. DARVO in action 😂

itsgettingweird · 03/04/2023 11:10

The reason this won't get resolved is denial.

Well done Tobias Ellwood. He's one of a few decent Tory MPs.

Bit on yesterdays thread instead of the Rory supporters arguing why this wasn't the fault of Brexit etc we actually had posters saying the the school children's fault for having parents who could pay for ski trips when we have a CoL crisis.

We've sunk so low as a country yet people still insist on racing to the bottom Sad

FrancescaContini · 03/04/2023 10:56

Yes, @QuentininQuarantino The key word in what you wrote is “thought”. Unfortunately many millions of people - including those in power who should know far better - didn’t think at all. What we saw over the weekend in Dover is one of the countless consequences of this lack of thought - and yes, it’s directly affecting our children, right now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread