Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be sad dd still isn't in a graduate job 5 years later?

135 replies

tinyelephantlargeant · 02/04/2023 18:47

Dd is 27 and did her degree in biology, with a placement year in a chemistry based laboratory.

She has been working in retail ever since. She has been looking and applying, but says nothing much comes up and when it does there is no luck.

I'm aware she is a grown adult and can do what she wants, but me and her dad financially supported her the whole of university and we are a bit sad that she is still just in retail, it's not as if she is overjoyed with it either.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Dixiechickonhols · 02/04/2023 20:53

Is it worth her exploring ASD diagnosis. If she is diagnosed it may open doors in terms of guaranteed interviews if she meets criteria and/or accommodations at interviews.

JudgeJ · 02/04/2023 20:51

slowquickstep · 02/04/2023 19:04

Too many graduates chasing too few jobs, Happens when too many go to uni, the flip side is not enough trade apprenticeships and too few trades, that's why qualified trades earn a fortune and many with degrees don't

Perfect answer, the rush to go to Uni for whatever subject at the expense of a worthwhile apprenticeships is something that needs reversing, not referring to the OP's daughter's subject which is a traditional degree area. I always remember my boss cursing about his son going to Uni to study Golf Course Design which seems an ideal subject for a 50/50 practical/academic apprenticeship with a worthwhile award at the end.

beeboop2018 · 02/04/2023 20:50

Annasgirl · 02/04/2023 19:03

There are loads of vacancies in lab tech in Ireland. Also in pharma companies. I don’t know anyone with a science degree who is not working in the field if they want to. Would she be willing to emigrate?

I second this. I'm lab based and so much work in science fields in Ireland.

DontMakeMeShushYou · 02/04/2023 20:49

I'm not sure why people are suggesting teaching as you've already said she's not really a people-oriented person.

What about looking at laboratory technician jobs and perhaps working up from there?

waterrat · 02/04/2023 20:48

Being a neurodiverse adult and not having that understanding about herself will massively hold her back (speaking with direct knowledge here ) and is linked to mental health problems if it goes unsupported

Its quite likely if she is constantly told to smile more and is put on backroom duties thst there may be neurodiversity here and ahe could learn how to work with it rather than constantly feel she is failing

BridieConvert · 02/04/2023 20:46

I'm 32. I have a (basic) science degree. I was in retail until I was 28 and then got the job I'm doing now. Not a graduate job, not remotely linked to science. Pay is abysmal. Degrees aren't the be all and end all nowadays, I regret going to uni and not doing something vocational instead.

Bananananas · 02/04/2023 20:46

She might like to look at some of the open university courses to top up her knowledge. A diploma (2 years part time or 1 year full time) in a more specialist subject - or just as a subject refresh - may help her step out of retail. It will also demonstrate to new employers she's been motivated to progress a career.

MumOf2workOptions · 02/04/2023 20:45

getintoteaching.education.gov.uk/funding-and-support/scholarships-and-bursaries?funding_widget%5Bsubject%5D=biology#funding-widget

If you scroll down to "biology secondary school"

Bursary £20k

waterrat · 02/04/2023 20:45

Please on your daughter's behalf OP if you think she is autistic do follow this up urgently. It should have nothing to di with having changed colleges you can refer her yourself and look into autism in women and help hwr get a diagnsis

MumOf2workOptions · 02/04/2023 20:44

@tinyelephantlargeant

How about she writes off to places to do some unpaid volunteering/ placement to get some recent experience and then hopefully if roles come up she'd be considered?

5 years is a long time to be out the loop isn't it? Her other option is to do a PGCE to teach

PurpleBananaSmoothie · 02/04/2023 20:34

She needs to be looking at non-graduate roles. She’s been out of university too long for a graduate role. Admin roles, temp roles. My first job was a 3 month temp contract, my dad didn’t really see it as a real job but I was there for 18 months and had a lot of responsibility (far more than I was paid for) by the time I left. I took another two contract roles after that and was on temporary or fixed term contracts for about 2.5 years.

I would look at admin roles in civil service or NHS, something where she can make sideways moves as well as progress. If she seeks an ASD diagnosis in adulthood, these employers should both be in positions to provide accommodations for her. I would also look into career coaching for her, you can get ones that specialise in public sector and they can assist throughout the application process and interview process. I used a career coach to make the jump from my last job to this one and it was helpful to see how he reframed skills that I already had as the skills listed on applications.

boschbabe · 02/04/2023 20:31

Try the pharma industry. There’s a wide variety of roles with good career potential and good wages. Getting in the door is probably the hardest part but once in and you get a better idea of what each function does, you can move around or move to another company.

MabelMoo23 · 02/04/2023 20:27

Jellycats4life · 02/04/2023 19:10

There must be something holding her back. Possibly autism, since it was mentioned when she was younger and then no one could be arsed to follow it up.

Speak to any autistic adult diagnosed late in life and they’ll tell you a story about doing well academically but never quite living up to their early potential; feeling like a failure.

How is she with friendships? Relationships? I bet being stuck in a dead end job isn’t the only dissatisfaction in her life.

I have ADHD, diagnosed at 45 - and you literally have hit the nail on the head and described exactly how I feel about my life. I’ve never quite made it. Always had great things said about me, but never ever been promoted, always not quite reached where I wanted to be - and I do feel like a failure. That’s exactly how I feel, and it breaks my heart

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 02/04/2023 20:26

A few people have suggested teaching, but honestly if she doesn't have strong interpersonal skills, then teaching is not a good idea. It's not just a default job for those who fail to get grad jobs. She'd probably get a place on a PGCE, but that doesn't mean it would be a sustainable career long term.

Others have given great advice about possible options e.g. within the NHS. The thing I would say is that having done a biology degree, but a chemistry placement, she may look unfocused/uncommitted to potential employers- and her theoretical knowledge and skillset may not match very well.

I also agree with those who say the more years you spend out of science, the harder it is to get back in- in some areas technology etc can move on quickly.

I think you also do need to be in the right area of the country for some jobs.

It's obviously more debt and expense on top of her degree, but I do think a masters (ideally in what she actually wants to do) would help. Is it an option for her to do this part time whilst working?

LadyLapsang · 02/04/2023 20:20

Are you in a position to underwrite her financially or offer a financial safety net?When DC graduated, he initially took an interesting although low paid intern role, I think he started on 16K. We stood guarantor for rent although he could have lived at home, however, he managed independently, he had the shoebox room in his flat share with higher paid friends. When I was young I knew I had to stand on my own two feet and sadly I think it makes you risk averse.

foggywoods · 02/04/2023 20:20

If she is interested in pathology and forensics she could look at CSI roles. You don’t need to be a graduate but it helps as most of the competition have degrees. There are downsides as there are in any job but there is a lot of variety and it’s better than being stuck in a lab doing the same thing all day. I know several people who have moved from forensic labs to become CSIs and from what I have heard the CSI roles pay better.

Bananananas · 02/04/2023 20:17

Easterfunbun · 02/04/2023 19:00

If I was her I would be applying for NHS band 2 admin roles (very much sought after) and then she can apply for a lab assistant role, there are so many ways around this.

I'd go this route too. Get into a generic healthcare admin post - retail has a lot of transferable skills - and work the career path out via experience

Thriwit · 02/04/2023 20:17

Oh, and as for people skills - tbh that’s not one of my priorities when looking for new grad lab analysts. As long as they don’t come across as overly argumentative or similar - my primary concern is that they can do the practical work, have a decent standard of written English for writing it up, are capable of following procedures and have an acceptable amount of motivation/enthusiasm (i.e. they’re not lazy).
As for being different - every lab I’ve ever worked in has had a relatively high proportion of neurodiverse people (myself included) so I wouldn’t really think anything of that.

Sickoffamilydrama · 02/04/2023 20:16

tinyelephantlargeant · 02/04/2023 19:03

Not a people person in the sense she is quite blunt but polite of course. It's quite hard to explain. There was suspected ASD in year 11 but then she moved to college and it was never really considered again. I do think it's possible so just wanted to mention so you don't think she is just some rude person who needs to work on how to be around people. She is very polite, but I just find people think she maybe isn't super friendly at first impression?

She works as a custom assistant though so she obviously isn't incapable!! But her constant feedback is to usually smile more and subsequently she is usually put on restocking.

Maybe she needs to re-explore an ASD diagnosis, if she is autistic she will have to work that much harder to appear warm & approachable & honestly the work for her to do that might be too much for her mental health and could still be unsuccessful. A bit like someone working on being less deaf/blind.

My DD is autistic and very much wants to be social but it takes a lot out of her.

Others have had good ideas about routes into lab work.

PieonaBarm · 02/04/2023 20:15

What about a company like Key Forensics or Cellmark? They run Forensic Laboratories and process crime scene stains/exhibits and have labs up and down the country. Many Police Forces and Defence Solicitors out source to them?

cezanneondemand.intervieweb.it/keyforensicservices/en/career

www.cellmark.co.uk/careers/

MediumDwarf · 02/04/2023 20:14

To get into Pathology she will need hospital laboratory experience. There are very few posts, and so competition is tough. As someone said above the route tends to be taking a Lab Assistant role in a hospital path lab to gain the experience, and then applying for the scientist role. Most applicants do this and so unfortunately she is unlikely to be shortlisted for a Scientist role in a path lab if she has no hospital lab experience.

Also criteria is strict. If her degree is ‘Biology’ and not an IBMS accredited Biomedical Science degree she would need to take additional modules, or even a different course. Once in post there is also a registration portfolio to complete to gain HCPC accreditation- a lot of those currently working as lab assistants will have completed this already and so as before, competition is very, very tough!

If she is serious about this careerI recommend the first step is to direct her to the IBMS website to see if her course is accredited and identify any modules she may need to take.

https://www.ibms.org/resources/documents/list-of-ibms-accredited-universities-offering-top-up-modules/?preview=true

’Pathology’ is also large department and each hospital can be different in that not all hospitals provide the same services, they may send samples to another hospital lab. Definitely ensure when applying for assistant roles to make sure the application is tailored to the department. E.g whether Microbiology, Blood Transfusion, Blood Science, Haematology or Cellular Pathology/ Histopathology.

List of IBMS Accredited Universities offering Top-Up Modules

https://www.ibms.org/resources/documents/list-of-ibms-accredited-universities-offering-top-up-modules/?preview=true

Truckinghell · 02/04/2023 20:11

Get her to look at CRA roles (IQVIA, Syneos, ICON, Parexel). The world is absolutely desperate for them, and someone with a biology degree is likely to be considered. That would be a foot in the door to clinical research which is a good and interesting career.

If she cares, that is!

Hankunamatata · 02/04/2023 20:09

Lots graduates I know are taking lower paid roles to get experience and get a foot in the door of chosen sector if they can't get graduate positions.
She could look at nhs laboratories.

MojoMoon · 02/04/2023 20:08

She should still be able to access her uni careers service - sounds like she might benefit from some professional help with identifying options, perfecting applications and interviewing.

I see so many dreadful applications from grads - such a shame they don't use the careers service to review applications and learn how to do them properly

NotCopingWell1 · 02/04/2023 20:07

I'm wondering if she really knows what she wants to do? The grad market gets more and more competitive, and you've got to work your ass off to get a decent grad job. I applied for grad schemes and was lucky to get one. Not sure what I would have done otherwise. Probably stayed in part time retail and looked for other jobs but abandoned the grad scheme idea. But after this much time I wonder if she isn't too sure what she wants to do and therefore can't evidence the relevant experience she's had (some of which will likely need to be recent, but it could be volunteering) or can't sell herself really well at interview because her heart isn't in it?

I wonder what she wants long term? She could climb the ladder in retail if she likes it and/or is comfortable in that sector if she needs a higher income to do the things she likes.