Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

That Absolutely Amazing Woman

246 replies

MrsJackRackham · 02/04/2023 13:27

I've just read about the woman who gave evidence against the killer of Olivia Pratt-Korbel. What a fucking brave and phenomenal woman. She will have to go into witness protection and leave her whole life behind but she knew it was the right thing to do. And she gave the defence lawyer a mouthful as well by the sounds of it.
I could actually cry thinking about her.

OP posts:
Americano75 · 04/04/2023 06:27

user146539089 · 03/04/2023 23:34

That’s two of us @Americano75 x

💐

SuchandSuchandSuch · 04/04/2023 05:56

nothingcomestonothing · 03/04/2023 21:51

They are not all mere well recompensed victims of circumstance and your appeals to the contrary shall not convince me otherwise.

I feel quite content to extrapolate my experience of this particular profession thank you very much.

You don't seem to understand that the barrister has no choice - they have to take a client they get offered, and they have to do their best to defend them or otherwise it could lead to an appeal and the criminal getting let off. They aren't choosing to side with the defendant.

I also agree the woman who testified did the right thing and should be proud.

But the legal system doesn't work does it? Barristers in the UK do not merely cross examine. They often assassinate the character of defendants, rape victims in particular, because they want to win. Their professional identity and their lifestyle relies on winning. Most barristers know the system is not working and chose to be part of it because they benefit from it. That's a choice. As is the adversarial (bullying) tone of many of the formulaic arguments being trotted out on this thread. I'm sorry you went through what you did hotsince82.

HowcanIgetoutofthisalive · 04/04/2023 05:45

determinedtomakethiswork · 03/04/2023 22:19

@HowcanIgetoutofthisalive there are two women. One is the permanent girlfriend and she is the one who has been criticised for looking like a WAG and has clearly been spending a ton of money on herself. The other is a woman who the drug dealer/murderer was sleeping with, along with many other women apparently. The latter woman gave evidence stating that he had murdered the little girl because she had overheard a conversation he had with another man.

Thanks for clarifying! I e not kept up to date with the case, it's just too awful.

Sceptre86 · 04/04/2023 05:09

She was dating a married, drug dealer and known hitman. She clearly wasn't bothered about his being married or that his drug dealing would have ruined other peoples lives and families. It was only that he bought the shit on her doorstep that she was bothered about. She put herself first and had some moral compass that a child being killed was her limit.

I'm not saying she wasn't brave to speak out, still many in her position wouldn't have but she's not the angel you are making her out to be. I hope she fares well in witness protection and builds a good life.

MayThe4th · 04/04/2023 04:41

Is she brave though? Or is she saving her own skin?

even the most violent criminals for the most part think child murderers are abhorrent, and would think nothing of serving a bit of justice.

the fact she was sleeping with him makes her guilty by association in the eyes of those types. So what better way to ensure her safety than to give evidence in exchange for a new identity.

had he not killed that little girl she would have continued to sleep with him. And there’s no way she didn’t know.

BlackBarbies · 04/04/2023 04:18

The thread has been derailed to the point where you can barely see comments responding to the OP. How annoying

haXXor · 04/04/2023 03:53

HotSince82 · 03/04/2023 22:06

I believe that they are sufficiently lacking in moral fibre as to make a case which may extend to a person whom they personally strongly suspect of a crime walking free from court.

it's their literal job to defend their client and, if they did it badly, their client could appeal the verdict.

What a barrister may "strongly suspect" is irrelevant to how they do their job. Only the JURY can decide the guilt or non-guilt of a defendant. If a perp walks, it's because of lack of conclusive evidence (as happened in the case I was a juror on) or because the prosecution has failed to properly present the facts to the jury.

A defence barrister sabotaging their client's defence because they thought the client did it would be equivalent to a police officer planting or destroying evidence because they thought a suspect did it. Surely you can now see how that's not acceptable in our justice system?

haXXor · 04/04/2023 03:38

HotSince82 · 03/04/2023 22:27

I don't mind of you disagree with me but surely you can see that a boxer is only at risk of injuring his opponent?

This is not the case if a barrister is successful in securing a verdict of non guilt for a guilty client. Their victims will suffer. Both on the stand if a witness and undeniably, afterwards.

The worst possible outcome is an innocent person being convicted, not a victim seeing her perp walk free. Defence barristers exist to make sure that only the guilty are jailed. In doing so, they reduce the number of appeals. When a conviction is quashed on appeal, even in murder cases the investigation is rarely reopened because the length of time that has passed makes it too hard to investigate, meaning that the perp is never found. Defence barristers should be proud of their work keeping the innocent out of jail and making sure that guilt is properly proved of those in jail.

haXXor · 04/04/2023 03:22

HotSince82 · 03/04/2023 21:33

I have a rudimentary understanding.
Enough that I am certain that I would not voluntarily enter in to a situation which would incite me, voluntarily or otherwise to attempt to defend the actions of a man which had led directly to the murder of a child

An understanding so rudimentary that's it doesn't include the "cab rank rule". I recommend not posting about things that you do not understand, you make yourself look ignorant and annoy everyone else.

www.mglegal.co.uk/legal-news/what-is-the-cab-rank-rule/

EveYorkshire · 04/04/2023 01:19

Zone2NorthLondon · 04/04/2023 00:28

Yes op posted once that was it,Subsequent post about responsibility & role barrister were actually pretty intersting
Brief interlude were we all got told off for woman baiting & woman bitching. Told we were all getting a bit too Queen B …
Then she flounced

thats how threads go, they’re maintained by those who post and read and respond. Like a real life conversation, digression occurs. It’s not necessarily wrong just depends on who is contributing

Yet you accuse me of using perjorative and prosaic terms and then say I "flounce".

A hypocrite and a bully, I'd say. Proud of yourself? Enjoy "maintaining" . . . . . or maybe "man-taining" the threads you're on.

So sad, the damage you do.

marzipansux · 04/04/2023 01:16

Fortheloveofus · 04/04/2023 00:42

As a born and bred scouser, you're whole 'we don't grass' shit is a load of shit. You'll be saying stuff like snitches get stitches next. There are people all over the world who would 'grass' up a neighbour for a minor incident and just as many who wouldn't grass up a child murderer. So please don't tar liverpool with some stupid 'we're all gangsters' deep down crap. We get enough undeserved and unwarranted bad press already without people like you perpetuating it.
And pray tell, how did your first post sound, if not really reasonable, but at least like it came from a normal-ish person living in 2023 and then morph onto some kind of Dickensian badly worded script? Half of your words were not used in context and a lot of your sentences did not make sense. You have no grasp of the English language, of how the legal system works or how valuable both prosecution and defence barristers'work is.

That said, I am deeply sorry you went through what you went through and I'm glad the twat got convicted for what he did to you. I hope you're accessing all the support open to you to help with the aftermath of such an atrocity

Have to say I agree with this. The use of flowery language became bizarre. I do agree in a small way that sometimes the justice system leans a bit too far towards advantaging the charged person.
I am always sad to hear of women being asked about the length of their skirt, why they were out late , children being asked about their understanding of sexual things etc.
There really needs to be some kind of update of the law that forbids defence barristers asking these types of questions. Would be difficult though,

GingerScallop · 04/04/2023 00:48

HotSince82 · 03/04/2023 21:27

How?

I called shame on his barrister.
And it is indeed a shame to provide a defence for such a person 's actions.

Fair and robust representation is tye bedrock of a fair justice system. No matter how rotten. Not only to avoid endless appeals but also to avoid (more) innocent people going to prison. if we say they should not vigorously defend those that are guilty, how do we know who these are? where do we draw the line? if they are ineffective counsel for most evil and guilty they will be equally ineffective foe those that are truly innocent

Fortheloveofus · 04/04/2023 00:42

HotSince82 · 03/04/2023 20:20

I feel the same OP.

I am from Liverpool and she has the city apart from the scum absolutely behind her.

We don't like people who grass on their neighbours, granted. We absolutely support those who testify against drug dealing murderous bellends.

Shame on his barrister. There is no amount of money in the world that would incite a person with a modicum of moral integrity to defend such heinous actions.

Absolutely commending that woman's courage this evening. Bravo if you are reading this 👏

As a born and bred scouser, you're whole 'we don't grass' shit is a load of shit. You'll be saying stuff like snitches get stitches next. There are people all over the world who would 'grass' up a neighbour for a minor incident and just as many who wouldn't grass up a child murderer. So please don't tar liverpool with some stupid 'we're all gangsters' deep down crap. We get enough undeserved and unwarranted bad press already without people like you perpetuating it.
And pray tell, how did your first post sound, if not really reasonable, but at least like it came from a normal-ish person living in 2023 and then morph onto some kind of Dickensian badly worded script? Half of your words were not used in context and a lot of your sentences did not make sense. You have no grasp of the English language, of how the legal system works or how valuable both prosecution and defence barristers'work is.

That said, I am deeply sorry you went through what you went through and I'm glad the twat got convicted for what he did to you. I hope you're accessing all the support open to you to help with the aftermath of such an atrocity

AnyaMarx · 04/04/2023 00:42

Zone2NorthLondon · 04/04/2023 00:23

People rarely want to associate their recreational drugs with criminality or acknowledge their own culpability in violent crime,safeguarding and exploitation. people esp the middle classes want to deny or ignore the obvious link between OC and drugs. They don’t want to think of the dirty stuff

I agree .

But this IS the reality. Just a cannabis dealer right ?

Leave them alone
It's only plants

That's what gets comments on our police fb pages. Go and catch some real criminals . Blah blah blah .

This is the reality of drug dealing and organised crime groups that deal those poor little plants .

Time people actually realised .
A 9 year old child was murdered for those innocent little plants . I do t suppose anyone is going to actually make that connection though .

I've worked in this area for almost 15 years. People do need to wake up .
Me ? I'd legalise it . It would wipe the black market out overnight . But the government is too chicken shit to act positively and always leans to the masses .

Well here is the reality . It's not nice is it ?

misssunshine4040 · 04/04/2023 00:38

User8646382 · 04/04/2023 00:06

The girlfriend did the right thing. Not that she had much choice. He knew she knew, so her life was already on the line. I suppose you could call her ‘brave’, but let’s keep things in perspective. The ‘absolutely amazing woman’ here is this poor child’s mother, who had to drag herself into court to relive the horror of what that murdering scumbag did, just to get a bit of justice. I haven’t got much sympathy left for the girlfriend of the scumbag, who knew what he was when she shacked up with him.

I’m glad she shopped him. I doubt whether she was motivated by anything more than self-preservation, but who knows? Maybe she suddenly discovered she had a conscience.

This really.
I'm not sure she had much choice as the people who care about keeping quiet knew she knew and she was always going to be a risk to them.
Hideous situation for anyone to be in regardless.

AutumnalLeaves38 · 04/04/2023 00:33

The ‘absolutely amazing woman’ here is this poor child’s mother, who had to drag herself into court to relive the horror of what that murdering scumbag did, just to get a bit of justice.

What she must have gone through, and be going through, is beyond horrific.
My thoughts to her, and her entire family.

Zone2NorthLondon · 04/04/2023 00:28

Yes op posted once that was it,Subsequent post about responsibility & role barrister were actually pretty intersting
Brief interlude were we all got told off for woman baiting & woman bitching. Told we were all getting a bit too Queen B …
Then she flounced

thats how threads go, they’re maintained by those who post and read and respond. Like a real life conversation, digression occurs. It’s not necessarily wrong just depends on who is contributing

Fortheloveofus · 04/04/2023 00:23

Firstly, for all the people complaining about the thread being derailed, you do realise the OP disappeared immediately the thread was opened about 36 hours ago, right? Although I'm sure they may be lurking somewhere, copying and pasting comments for an article somewhere.

But i would like to say how fantastically proud and thankful we should be for a woman like the witness to come forward and risk her land totally change her life in order to secure a conviction. Can't imagine what her life will be like in the future, how frightened, alone and isolated she will feel. As a woman, I celebrate everything she stands for. Yes, she might not always have made good choices about who she shared her bed with or she associated it with but remember, she didn't care about bringing the police into the picture or how, with one phone call, her life would be disrupted forever. Sad we can't give these type of people medals instead of having to hide them away from threatening scumbags

Zone2NorthLondon · 04/04/2023 00:23

People rarely want to associate their recreational drugs with criminality or acknowledge their own culpability in violent crime,safeguarding and exploitation. people esp the middle classes want to deny or ignore the obvious link between OC and drugs. They don’t want to think of the dirty stuff

AnyaMarx · 04/04/2023 00:19

I also hope this shows dealing cannabis is never a victimless crime .

So many people think cops should be out there catching "real criminals "

We'll suck this up and get real .

TracyBeakerSoYeah · 04/04/2023 00:07

Posted too soon.
Sorted one way or another because any reprisals against this brave lady has the possibility of blowing up even more things in the criminal underworld, which none of them want.

At the end of the day Thomas Cashman was a stupid twat who bought it all on himself. He should have realised that his actions could & did end up killing someone innocent.
Hence him being done for murder due to transferred malice.

User8646382 · 04/04/2023 00:06

The girlfriend did the right thing. Not that she had much choice. He knew she knew, so her life was already on the line. I suppose you could call her ‘brave’, but let’s keep things in perspective. The ‘absolutely amazing woman’ here is this poor child’s mother, who had to drag herself into court to relive the horror of what that murdering scumbag did, just to get a bit of justice. I haven’t got much sympathy left for the girlfriend of the scumbag, who knew what he was when she shacked up with him.

I’m glad she shopped him. I doubt whether she was motivated by anything more than self-preservation, but who knows? Maybe she suddenly discovered she had a conscience.

TracyBeakerSoYeah · 04/04/2023 00:01

The woman was amazing & I do hope she has a brilliant life ahead of her.
Without going into details I was always always told that harming a child was non negotiable in the criminal code, that you deserved to be grassed up.
Any known associates of Thomas Cashman looking for revenge will most likely be sorted.

Zone2NorthLondon · 04/04/2023 00:00

sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 03/04/2023 23:56

Oh stop derailing fgs!

That woman was absolutely incredible. She must have known the consequences of giving evidence, and she still did it. She also has a life sentence as a result, but because of her, justice has been done. I don't know if I could have been as brave, but I hope she knows how much she is admired.

I’ll answer were I am directly addressed that isnt a derail.it’s a legitimate response
Do take time to go back and instruct others not to derail too
Op has not returned and the thread has developed regards the role & responsibility of barristers

sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 03/04/2023 23:56

Oh stop derailing fgs!

That woman was absolutely incredible. She must have known the consequences of giving evidence, and she still did it. She also has a life sentence as a result, but because of her, justice has been done. I don't know if I could have been as brave, but I hope she knows how much she is admired.

Swipe left for the next trending thread