Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cancer but no prognosis

62 replies

ocrendby · 02/04/2023 09:56

FIL has been diagnosed with prostate cancer that has apparently got into his bones.

DH is obviously in bits about it.

FIL has refused a prognosis as he just wants to live his life.

I've done plenty of reading about prognoses for stage 4 prostate cancer and have a bit of an understanding about cancer in general. It seems to me that he may well have another 5-10 years with modern treatments.

When DH said that his dad is dying I said not necessarily and that FIL not getting a prognosis wasn't helping anyone.

I get that this is disrespectful to FIL's wishes but I'm looking at DH always worrying and almost putting his life on hold and so AIBU to feel this way?

My own DH died of pancreatic cancer so very quick after it was identified.

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 02/04/2023 11:42

Things is a diagnosis isn't a prognosis and a prognosis isn't always exact and dependent on many features and how the body responds to treatments that are or aren't available.

My mum had what was stage 4 peritoneal cancer for 5.5 years before she died.

Prognosis (statistically) would have had her dead in months. She spent over a year of that time in remission.

MereDintofPandiculation · 02/04/2023 11:06

It’s traumatic, and I don’t think someone telling me that it’s potentially such a long process it doesn’t count Fair enough. It helps me to know that the incurable prostate cancer that my DH has has a theoretical possibility of being held at bay for long enough that one of the other problems of old age with carry him off. I don't regard that as "the cancer doesn't count", and I don't think anyone has suggested that.

OliviaPark · 02/04/2023 10:58

I’m so sorry about your FIL. I would allow him to deal with this how we wishes.

There are two men in my immediate family who have had very similar diagnoses. One died within a year as it continued to spread rapidly. The other lived for 3 years, 2 of them good (the last year his health was declining quickly).

I hope your FIL is in the 50% 🤞🏻

AnnaMagnani · 02/04/2023 10:57

It might well help FIL if he is assuming he is on the verge of death.

However he has only just found out and there are plenty of appointments and opportunities for him to have more information.

Sstitch · 02/04/2023 10:57

I am in remission from stage 4 Lymphoma and was told by doctors and nurses that stages can be different for different cancers, i.e. for me stage 4 was not terminal, blood cancer works entirely differently.

That being said, I think research can often be inaccurate when it comes to cancer. I found some poor prognosis' for myself online but also a lot of other information that just wasn't accurate for me.

To the point - I do think you're being slightly unreasonable, you aren't the one with cancer and it is something that takes over your whole life and you have to cope with it your own way. I coped through humour. But, I wonder if you/with your FIL's blessing could speak to his consultant and find out for yourselves but not inform FIL or anyone else as is his wish. If that's what your DH wants of course.

Pollywoddles · 02/04/2023 10:55

It depends on the type of cancer, my father had prostate cancer but it changed to a small cell cancer, spread everywhere very rapidly and he was gone in less than 3 months. He had palliative radiation on the tumour in his brain and chemo for the others, he didn’t even manage to complete the treatment.

We were told 6 months to a year with treatment, much less without. I often wonder how would he have bothered with the treatment which he found hard and meant that he died in hospital rather than at home in his own bed which is what he really wanted. Let your FIL deal with it in his own way, just know that time is limited and make the most of it.

pettysquabbles · 02/04/2023 10:50

If FIL would have accepted a prognosis this would help all involved- not me but MIL and DH

Apart from FIL.

AnnaMagnani · 02/04/2023 10:48

Prostate cancer spread to bones would definitely be a prognosis of years.

A lot depends on the Gleason score of his prostate, a high score would be more aggressive, a low score you could easily be talking 10 yrs plus.

And with all these cancers the longer you live, the more treatments come on line and prognosis gets longer.

BeretRaspberry · 02/04/2023 10:40

My FIL passed away in February this year, after being told he was ‘terminal’ in 2004. That was with prostate cancer that had spread at the time and was inoperable. My FIL had hormone implants that I believe ringfenced it all and stopped it spreading further. He was told he’d probably have about 5 years back in 2004, yet he managed 19!

My point being that it’s not always accurate and I can understand the person who is going through it not wanting to know and to just live their life. Everyone is different and you need to respect the patients wishes.

buttercupboots · 02/04/2023 10:37

@Blossomtoes for heaven's sake where is your empathy? How is a passive aggressive comment like that helpful to a family who are dealing with a terminal cancer diagnosis? OP is fine to seek information that will effect her family on an anonymous forum ffs.

Babyroobs · 02/04/2023 10:37

Prostate cancer is one of those that people can live with for years to be honest, even when it has spread to the bones. It is usually the very aggressive form that younger men get that kills people quickly. Everyone is different though and obviously other health conditions will affect things.

Moveforward · 02/04/2023 10:33

My Dad was in pieces when Mum died quickly from cancer. He told me it should have been him as he's lived with prostate cancer for 5 years (he was given 4). At least I know.

I also help him with his meds so I know he's not on any for it. And his blood psa readings were going up last year, they took a second sample, but never got back to him. He doesn't seem bothered and has just passed another birthday in his 80s. I think he is resigned to what will be will be.

Popsicle42 · 02/04/2023 10:33

My mum didn’t want to know timescales when her cancer became terminal. I had to accept her decision. It was tough not knowing, but then you never really know anyway and I think it would be worse to be given a prognosis that is wrong so you end up feeling like you’re constantly on borrowed time.

ocrendby · 02/04/2023 10:32

Untitledsquatboulder · 02/04/2023 10:24

I guess this is all quite recent OP. Let your dh be with his father as often as he's able. Either your FiL will continue well and your dh will feel reassured when nothing much is changing bw visits or he will deteriorate in which case being with him is the right thing for both of them.

Thanks. This is what I needed to hear. You're right, it's recent and my DH needs time to process it. He will travel every opportunity for the foreseeable and I guess it will ease off a bit

OP posts:
Houseyvibe · 02/04/2023 10:31

You are correct in that prostate cancer in the bones especially in older people is very controllable and it is perfectly possible he will die with it not from it and it’s not usual to be controlled for many many years with minimally invasive treatment. Prostate in older me is often fairly slow growing.

However, I do understand that a prognosis isn’t necessarily helpful although pointing your DH to stats once the initial shock has worn off may well be. Let him process his shock but it’s highly in your FIL favour that they’ll be able to control it for a really good amount of time and his quality of life will be maintained

buttercupboots · 02/04/2023 10:28

My DF was diagnosed with prostate cancer in 2021 but wasn't able to have prostate removal as it had spread to nearby lymph nodes. He had radiotherapy in 2022 alongside hormone treatment and it seemed to be effective in that it brought his PSA levels down initially however by the end of 2022 it had spread to multiple sites in his bones.

When he was first diagnosed he was given the life expectancy of 10 years. I don't know what it is now, but he has been told that his life expectancy has significantly reduced. This is because his cancer is aggressive and spreading quickly, which is an outlier when talking about prostate cancer which is often slow moving.

He's currently on a mix of hormone treatments & steroids to try to keep it from spreading further. He keeps himself healthy and other than him seeming more tired than usual, you wouldn't know he was ill if you met him.

Essentially, from what I know of it (which is limited to what I'm told!) it depends on how aggressive the cancer is i.e how quickly it will spread and how effective the treatments are on that type of prostate cancer. Some hormone treatments/radiotherapies are incredible for some people, but not so effective for others.

Hope this helps but I'm still muddling through it myself!

OldSkoolLikeHappyShopper · 02/04/2023 10:25

My daughter’s father has prostate cancer and is refusing any treatment, even though the initial scans he had showed it was in the early stages and would be treatable. He has read horror stories about becoming impotent/incontinent after surgery and decided he’d rather be dead. No idea how long he has. It’s so upsetting as I love him dearly (as a friend), and DD will be devastated to lose him.

Untitledsquatboulder · 02/04/2023 10:24

I guess this is all quite recent OP. Let your dh be with his father as often as he's able. Either your FiL will continue well and your dh will feel reassured when nothing much is changing bw visits or he will deteriorate in which case being with him is the right thing for both of them.

LuvSmallDogs · 02/04/2023 10:24

ocrendby · 02/04/2023 10:18

My friend was given six months to live in Jan 2020 and he is still with us.
I feel that a prognosis is not actually a hard and fast rule for time, but almost a level of the doctor giving a level of how bad he/she thinks the cancer has got.
As stage 4 means it has metastasised, but actually there are levels of how far metastasis has occurred and with modern treatments the further spread of the cancer can be kept in check.
So a doctor can give you six months if there are huge metastasised tumours, or 5 years if these are minor.
If FIL would have accepted a prognosis this would help all involved- not me but MIL and DH

Right, and the times where treatment is unsuccessful, where doctors say "but this cancer doesn't usually do that o_O"? Or are we only thinking of the "good" outliers?

This is your FIL's cancer, not MIL's, not DH's. By all means, pile some more emotional labour on the actual cancer patient because you've googled and he has years left and you're struggling with your DH's emotional reaction.

Blossomtoes · 02/04/2023 10:22

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 02/04/2023 10:06

But as horrible as it is, this isn't about your DH.

It's FIL's body and health - it's up to him if he doesn't want to know.

This. I really hope my kids wouldn’t make it all about them if I had terminal cancer.

ocrendby · 02/04/2023 10:22

Sorry I just reread the OP and meant to say my own DDad died of pancreatic cancer

OP posts:
ocrendby · 02/04/2023 10:19

My friend's cancer is not prostate

OP posts:
ocrendby · 02/04/2023 10:18

My friend was given six months to live in Jan 2020 and he is still with us.
I feel that a prognosis is not actually a hard and fast rule for time, but almost a level of the doctor giving a level of how bad he/she thinks the cancer has got.
As stage 4 means it has metastasised, but actually there are levels of how far metastasis has occurred and with modern treatments the further spread of the cancer can be kept in check.
So a doctor can give you six months if there are huge metastasised tumours, or 5 years if these are minor.
If FIL would have accepted a prognosis this would help all involved- not me but MIL and DH

OP posts:
Howmanysleepsnow · 02/04/2023 10:15

I get it OP. My dad has prostate cancer. It’s spread to his lymph nodes, and probably (given the pain, he’s waiting on a scan) his bones. I’d prefer to know a timescale, as far as is possible, to make the most of the time left, but I fully respect he may choose not to know.
i understand he may live 10 years. I strongly suspect he won’t.
He might not be “dying” right now, but he is dying and I’m mentally and emotionally preparing for that. It’s traumatic, and I don’t think someone telling me that it’s potentially such a long process it doesn’t count would be something I’d appreciate.

slight hijack, but if anyone has anecdotal evidence of how long someone has lived after similar spread in stage 4 I’d appreciate it. Obviously it may be different for my dad, but not knowing is hard!

MereDintofPandiculation · 02/04/2023 10:15

It’s FIL who has to cope with this, you can’t force him to seek a prognosis. My own DH is working on the basis he’s got 20 years at least, it’s his way of coping.

So DH needs to find a way to come to terms with it. You can try reminding him of the prevalence of prostate cancer in,say, over 80s, that Stage 4 prostate cancer is aimed at keeping it at bay long enough for them to die of something else. If nothing else, FIL will be spared dementia.

Persuade DH that his best contribution is to make his remaining time with DH as good as it possibly can be.