Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cancer but no prognosis

62 replies

ocrendby · 02/04/2023 09:56

FIL has been diagnosed with prostate cancer that has apparently got into his bones.

DH is obviously in bits about it.

FIL has refused a prognosis as he just wants to live his life.

I've done plenty of reading about prognoses for stage 4 prostate cancer and have a bit of an understanding about cancer in general. It seems to me that he may well have another 5-10 years with modern treatments.

When DH said that his dad is dying I said not necessarily and that FIL not getting a prognosis wasn't helping anyone.

I get that this is disrespectful to FIL's wishes but I'm looking at DH always worrying and almost putting his life on hold and so AIBU to feel this way?

My own DH died of pancreatic cancer so very quick after it was identified.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Houseyvibe · 10/07/2023 08:49

It would be insane to ask for a prognosis when his cancer is well controlled and there's plenty of evidence to suggest that it can be controlled long term. I suspect that the doctors couldn't even give him a prognosis based on their experience of seeing men living with it from months to decades.

A prognosis isn't going to help your mother in law live her life. What will help her is understanding he's living with and not dying from cancer and that unless the numbers or scans tell her differently he's going to be living with it for the foreseeable. He's certainly not going to deteriorate into serious illness if she goes out with her friends for an evening or away for a weekend. She needs support and counselling to help her live with the uncertainty, a prognosis won't help. It sounds like she's still in shock and processing it. It really is a different beast to pancreatic cancer or other more aggressive cancers and we all think the word stage 4 cancer and that it's automatically the end when actually some of them, pancreatic / testicular / some lymphoma's are really controllable if not curable at very late stages and you're far more likely to live with than die from them

ocrendby · 09/07/2023 18:23

Based on how DFIL is doing now, I could
We'll believe that he will last another few years at least. Even with pancreatic being a 2 week death sentence, we still had a good year of general poor health, pain, lethargia etc. I might be wrong but DFIL has responded amazingly well to the drugs (markers immediately went right down to levels only slightly above that over the average man without cancer) so I really get the feeling it will be something he dies with, not of. But DMIL now feels like she can't even go for an evening out with friends without him and certainly not away for the weekend which is something she used to do, so she potentially has years of putting her life on hold now. I really struggle with the rationale of not asking a prognosis as this would help her love her life in the interim

OP posts:
Minfilia · 09/07/2023 18:12

One of our family members has had prostate cancer which spread to his bones for over 12 years now!

He has had to have very regular monitoring, some sort of tablets and a few courses of chemo over the years, but his doctor basically said it was unlikely to be the thing that killed him as despite the spread, it’s slow growing and (largely) controlable.

He is 80 now!

ocrendby · 09/07/2023 18:08

So I first posted at the start of April and now we are three months on.

DFIL is doing great- he gets tired more easily but that's all so far. We are trying to spend time with him but DH has stopped dropping work commitments to be with him every week. Instead we try and see him once a month which is still tricky but better than it was before he was diagnosed.

It's hard to know what to do but we are going to assume this is not going to be as quick as pancreatic cancer was, and keep our lives going a bit

OP posts:
lljkk · 08/07/2023 20:35

hypothetical. If i had cancer I might relay remaining-expected-lifespan to DC to help them but not believe a word of it anyway.

However, if I didn't want to know the expected remaining lifespan ... this thread has convinced me i'd probably prefer to delay telling DC about the illness at all. Who wants that extra pressure of their "need to know" when you have to come to terms yourself.

We only have today and now, anyway.

CosmosQueen · 08/07/2023 19:04

My father was diagnosed at 63 with Ca prostate, told he would ‘die of something else’
For 30+ years it was controlled with hormone therapy and he refused to even talk about it.
It became evident it had spread about eighteen months before he died, he wouldn’t discuss it with anyone, not even mum.
About four weeks before he died he spontaneously fractured his hip, and basically gradually went downhill.
He was pretty much pain-free once they’d operated, and died peacefully.
I think it all depends on how much the cancer spreads and where. Certainly none of my family were able to have any conversation with dad whatsoever, so that made it incredibly difficult, but his choice.

Missingmyusername · 08/07/2023 19:02

I can see both sides to be honest. DM is sick, it’s not cancer- but refuses any intervention, however expects me to drop everything in an instant. I’ve no idea what will happen, how long it will go on for or how bad it might get. Perhaps it isn’t my business, but I think it becomes my business when care needs have escalated quickly.
I work full time and have a child. They aren’t things I can just drop.

gloriawasright · 08/07/2023 18:57

**cod liver oil

gloriawasright · 08/07/2023 18:53

AnnaMagnani · 02/04/2023 13:53

I don't know what it is about being diagnosed with cancer but people appear to be compelled to say the most absolute bonkers shite to you.

When my DF was diagnosed with cancer everyone he'd met lined up to tell him how their cousin had had a totally different cancer and cured it with green tea and incantations to the moon.

It was not helpful and he'd rather they had said nothing.

This made me laugh,my father's solution to cure my stage 4 breast cancer mets,is cos liver oil ..
I must ask my oncologist about that.
Op, I have not been given a prognosis,and I didn't ask.
But I was told that everything that is on the internet is already 2 years out of date. Treatment for cancer is always evolving as more and more treatments are out there.

Nordicrain · 08/07/2023 18:38

This doesn’t say you have 5-10 years left. It says half the people due before 5 years?

in any case this is not the time to inform your dh and fil that they are overreacting and it’s not that bad.

pineapple360 · 08/07/2023 18:36

I'm very sorry to hear this. The not knowing how long they have left is very hard.

I lost my best friend to prostate cancer, it wasn't diagnosed until stage 4. He was given 2-5 years I think but lived 18 months. It was treated with hormones and painkillers. He had a reasonably good quality of life until the last 2 months. Our local hospital runs a support group for men with prostate cancer and their families, it might be worth seeing if there's something like this for your father in law?

It helps men with prostate cancer to talk to other men about it. Its a disease that can feel very emasculating and embarrassing. It can be really hard to talk about, but when I attended the hospital group I found it refreshing how open and frank men were with each other, nothing was too difficult to talk about. It helped so much.

Haven't read the whole thread but these are good sources of support:

https://prostatecanceruk.org/prostate-information-and-support/get-support

https://tackleprostate.org

Wishing you and your family all the best at this difficult time Flowers

Quartz2208 · 08/07/2023 18:34

@ocrendby you strike me to be the type of person who simply can’t not know - who has to have all the information possible to make sure they are completely informed. My mum is like this is there is a queue she must know the reason why, how long she is going to be waiting and what her options are.

it is her way of dealing with it - this is your way of trying to deal with the news working it all out.

but whereas it may be your coping mechanism and your way of dealing with it, this isn’t your thing to deal with. Your Fil is clearly someone who prefers not to know the absolutes and to deal with each moment.

both are equally valid coping mechanisms - but it is your FIL who gets to decide how this goes here and in your relationship your DH

SquirrelHash · 08/07/2023 18:28

Haven't read the full thread but my experience is if it's not yet in brain lung liver you can go on for a good few years with modern treatments.

existentialpain · 08/07/2023 18:24

My father died of prostate cancer that had gone to bones and bowel. By the time he was diagnosed at stage 4 he had around a year left. He functioned well until the 6 month mark then started to become noticeably unwell and it was a deterioration after that.

TheLifeofMe · 08/07/2023 18:01

My father in law died of prostate cancer and when he was stage 4 he was given 12 months. I feel he would have lasted longer but he had the covid vaccine and 2 weeks later died. He was doing ok until then. Could have been coincidence but I regret now allowing the GP to persuade us to get him boosted.

Ginola2345 · 08/07/2023 17:50

Its difficult for you and your DH OP and also for your FIL and other family.

My DH has a diagnosis of stage 4 Prostate Cancer and he is not 60 yet and still working. In some ways I would like to know how long as we could plan for this and cram things in and overstretch ourselves financially if time is tight. But on the other hand he may have a few years left and be unable to work for awhile and we may end up struggling.

His brother who doesn’t make an effort to visit for several years and various groups of old friends who he previously saw only once a year if he was lucky. Have now decided they want to see him and spend more time with him on a monthly basis. For me this is really annoying as I think where have you been the last few years. Its also difficult as he does get more tired and for us to plan things around all his hospital, GP appointments, various collections and tests and around assisting our teenagers.

I think SIL is a bit annoyed as they visited twice in two months, paid to stay over in an expensive hotel (they have two kids, plenty of money and very high standards) and now six months later DH is still here. The Dr’s haven’t offered us a prognosis so we couldn’t tell them any info.

In your position I would be as supportive as poss and just go with what your DH wants to do.

ocrendby · 02/04/2023 20:16

So grateful for all the responses and accept Iabu here.

OP posts:
Cosyblankets · 02/04/2023 14:10

I've been through this with two relatives. One didn't want to know and that was the right thing for them. The other did want to know and that was right for them.
As hard as it is for us as a relative we have to accept their decision

Mollymalone123 · 02/04/2023 14:05

usually if patient is offered a prognosis then I would say not that much time.Oncologist very rarely even mention stages of cancer never mind a prognosis.It’s stage 4- my fil had prostate cancer to the bones and died within 6 months s as and that was with palliative chemo and hormone treatment.
I agree with others though-it’s your FIL’s cancer to deal with.I have advanced cancer- sadly close to stage 4 now.Im not sure if I’d want a prognosis and I’d be extremely upset if my son in law was pressing for it

AnnaMagnani · 02/04/2023 13:53

I don't know what it is about being diagnosed with cancer but people appear to be compelled to say the most absolute bonkers shite to you.

When my DF was diagnosed with cancer everyone he'd met lined up to tell him how their cousin had had a totally different cancer and cured it with green tea and incantations to the moon.

It was not helpful and he'd rather they had said nothing.

MereDintofPandiculation · 02/04/2023 13:23

’ve recently been diagnosed with cancer (not stage 4) and one of the most challenging aspects for me has been intrusive questions about the stage, size of my tumour, etc etc. It feels like people just wanted to google and find out if I was going to die. Another thing that is unhelpful is people saying "my brother in law had prostate cancer and he's fine now" .. well, yes, that's because your BIL had stage 1 prostate cancer, and it doesn't apply to my DH who has stage 4. So on the whole I can live with them googling to see if he's going to die because it stops cheery comments like that.

We all react to things differently.

Remaker · 02/04/2023 12:44

My father had prostate cancer that spread to his bones and he died 6 months after diagnosis. But one of my cousins was diagnosed with stage 4 prostate cancer about 5 years ago and he is still very well, working full time and enjoying life.

I’ve recently been diagnosed with cancer (not stage 4) and one of the most challenging aspects for me has been intrusive questions about the stage, size of my tumour, etc etc. It feels like people just wanted to google and find out if I was going to die.

In my experience you can’t know how you’ll react until it happens to you. Other people pushing their beliefs and expectations onto you when you’re still adjusting to the news is unhelpful. Also you might find your FIL’s preferences will change over time. Just give him some space and encourage your DH to spend time with him if it will make them both happy.

HuggingtheHRT · 02/04/2023 12:17

Honestly, I do think YABU OP. (Probably not intentionally and absolutely out of concern for your DH. But, ultimately, this is not your call.)

I understand that not knowing is tough for your DH. But your FIL is entitled to manage his remaining time however he needs to. A prognosis may well feel very much like a clock counting down and he would rather enjoy life without mentally ticking off the days.

I'm sorry for your news and I hope you all enjoy some good time with your FIL and he's not in discomfort.

SilverBirchWithout · 02/04/2023 11:45

To be honest you do sound a bit resentful towards your FIL and the relationship your DH has with him. Presumably you are annoyed that your DH wants to spend as much time as possible with FIL and the impact this will have on your life. This is making you focus on the lack of knowledge about the prognosis, presuming that if FIL does in fact have longer than x years your DH would not spend as much time visiting. I do think you need to let DH work through this uncertainty in the best way he can rather than focussing on the annoyance about the disruption to your existing routines. Perhaps FIL will not want the many visits DH is planning - he may want life to continue as normal as possible rather than feel DH is visiting excessively because he is dying.

Sorry if this sounds harsh, but I had the opposite issue when my FIL was diagnosed with stage 4 Lymphoma. Although no months/years left prognosis was given it was apparent from the oncologist’s letter to the GP (FIL was given a copy) that FIL only had a few months or maybe a year. DS is a Doctor and was able to interpret the contents of the letter. However my DH went into a form of denial and would not discuss with me or DS however hard we tried - reacting with anger if I tried to raise the topic. The subject of ‘how long’ was never raised by anyone in DH's family. So DH missed any opportunity to visit more (lived over 3 hrs away from us) and even didn’t acknowledge that FIL was probably dying when admitted to hospital at the end. The family only managing to get there a matter of hours before he died, it was only when I explicitly and fairly forcibly said to DH, his DB and his DS - ‘FIL is dying he may not be here next week’ (when they originally had planned to visit!)
DH’s family’s denial was so strong they were shocked when FIL died and they were left with much regret they didn’t spend more time with him the last few months - DH still doesn’t really acknowledge that DS and I tried many times to talk with him about the prognosis although he has apologised about his level of denial.
Families cope with terminal cancer in different ways, all you can do is be as supportive as possible to your DH’s choices whilst offering a dose of realism when it is appropriate to do so - ultimately it is your FIL’s decision on how he copes and lives his life day to day with the knowledge that he is dying of cancer (however long that may be).

itsgettingweird · 02/04/2023 11:44

So hers was terminal from the start effectively.

It feel odd saying she was dying for half a decade. But for me it helped me process it because I knew whatever time we had left it was years less than we would have had otherwise.

She died in her mid 60's