Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I unreasonable to have a third baby?

157 replies

To3ornot · 02/04/2023 08:39

Hello MNs

I know this has been done to death but I really need some outside perspective.

Our situation:

  • married 10 years
  • two children age 4 & 23 months
  • own house with mortgage 5 beds
  • big car (electric) so wouldn’t need to change it
  • always wanted 3
  • I’m stay at home mum
  • household income approx £90k

Both of us have always wanted three but now I’m second guessing myself. I’ve breastfed both of mine for a long time, over two years my eldest and still going with DD now at 21 months.

Ds is starting school in September and DD will go to preschool two mornings a week so I feel like I’m just getting back to myself a bit more. My eldest didn’t sleep until he was 2 and DD still not sleeping through yet.

Im just wondering if the benefit of having an extra sibling is worth it for the children or whether they would be better off us splitting our time/ money/ emotional resources between just the two of them.

If you were one of three would you mind sharing how you found it? Especially if you had this sort of age gap (about 3 years between). Or if you’ve got three how do you find it?

Im so torn because on paper it looks like a no brainier to me that we can do it but then I’m so worried about another 3 years of feeding/ no sleep and the impact on my current children plus then down the line uni fees etc. I go back and forth every day!

Is there anything I’ve not thought about?

Voting: YABU to have another YANBU to have another

OP posts:
wrigleys123 · 02/04/2023 10:00

Youngest of 3 here, there was never any food in the house!

RoseMarigoldViolet · 02/04/2023 09:56

I agree that the decision should be about you and your husband wanting a third child, not the possible benefit to your existing children.

We have a third and neither of the other two are very interested in them. There is a close bond between the first two but I think they consider the third one in surplus to their requirements. Our number 2 child would probably actively say that he wishes we hadn’t had the third!

We are certainly noticing the cost element now that we are into the teenage years. University is very expensive.

specialk9 · 02/04/2023 09:55

I'm one of three and I have three.

My childhood was great, I am the eldest though. I am close to my two siblings. I don't believe they have suffered any ill effects being 1of3. My Mum and Dad did separate but fortunately financially, although it wasn't as flexible, it was manageable.

My third was not planned. I wouldn't have planned to have a third. It is hard and I feel like I can never give one my full attention, well actually apart from the littlest (almost 2) as, practically, he needs the most support.

Financially we are very comfortable so no concerns there and have a good amount of savings/investments to support any change of circumstances.

I work part time. It's hectic. I am up at 6am and don't sit down until 9pm.
Our cars not big enough so some places we have to take 2 cars, we've lost our spare room (now I have to look at my washing, eurgh) holidays are a lot more expensive (most places we need 2 rooms) and I've found we've had to compromise more. But I can suffer all of these , mostly first world problems, because my third child is an absolute joy and we are all utterly besotted with him Smile

Humanbiology · 02/04/2023 09:55

Nimbostratus100 · 02/04/2023 08:43

have you thought through the environmental implications of having 3?

🙄

Mrsbclinton · 02/04/2023 09:54

I have three 2 & 3 year age gaps.

My third birth was v difficult compared to the first two & my child was a very bad sleeper. I found it took me a long time to recover from the birth emotionally & physically.

It was hard when they were small & I sometimes felt I couldn’t give them all the time & attention that I would have liked. It was exhausting!

I absolutely love having three, they get on well together and they are fantastic kids although Im probably a bit biased!!

Its busy & expensive as they get older but thankfully our finances have improved and we are managing ok.

BlueJellycat · 02/04/2023 09:50

Going from 2 to 3 isn't 1/3 more expensive or takes 1/3 extra time, that's not how it works in reality. If you want 3 do it now with the smaller age gaps.

RoseFl0wers · 02/04/2023 09:49

Nimbostratus100 · 02/04/2023 08:43

have you thought through the environmental implications of having 3?

If you’re so concerned about the environment then you best not have had any children, not drive, never use an aeroplane, and not use any electricity. Otherwise you’re a hypocrite.

OP, another sibling won’t benefit your children. Children are something a couple wants. I’m concerned that you’ve already been out of work for years and don’t plan on returning to work until your youngest (your current youngest or a third) has started school. You’re already 35 so you’d be 40 or nearly 40 by the time you get back into work. That’s a good chunk of potential earnings and career progression lost. Should anything happen to your dh (loses his job, leaves you etc) you don’t have any finances of your own.

Blossomtoes · 02/04/2023 09:48

To3ornot · 02/04/2023 09:35

Why? Surely that’s a reasonable expectation of a huge outlay? Genuinely not sure why that’s unreasonable?

Because you’re making so many assumptions. You’re assuming all your kids will want to go to university and be bright enough to do so. That the fee structure will be the same in 15 or 20 years’ time, that there will still be the same quantity of places. Why would your outlay be “huge”? Surely your kids would have loans just like everyone else’s?

owiz · 02/04/2023 09:47

Oh and to your point, no I absolutely do not think the benefit of an extra sibling (when already having one) outweighs the division of finances and parental time, and that was ultimately what made my mind up, I had to think about the kids I already had (I do work though so was l concerned about time for them).

Itsatwinthing · 02/04/2023 09:47

I had one child then we decided we wanted a second.....we had twins as babies #2 and #3. Three is hard, the lack of 1-2-1 time is hard for them too I'm sure. They are all lovely but it's very busy

owiz · 02/04/2023 09:45

Sounds like your life is well set up for it now (except the household income, it wouldnt be enough for me to consider it but appreciate for many it would be) but the main other consideration outside of finances is time, do you feel you can share your time well across 3 (likely if a SAHM) but then considering what happens if the marriage breaks down, having 3 children as a single parent is a lot more than 2 (plus the financial considerations of being out of work for so long).

Nimbostratus100 · 02/04/2023 09:43

To3ornot · 02/04/2023 09:41

Sorry to clarify quickly I didn’t mean I would ask my existing children!! I meant I as the parent want to make sure I’m making this decision with their best interests in mind as they are already here.

I have never had any intention of asking the children and absolutely would not do that.

sorry, I misunderstood you x

To3ornot · 02/04/2023 09:41

Sorry to clarify quickly I didn’t mean I would ask my existing children!! I meant I as the parent want to make sure I’m making this decision with their best interests in mind as they are already here.

I have never had any intention of asking the children and absolutely would not do that.

OP posts:
LadyKenya · 02/04/2023 09:40

They are children, they will not have the foresight to think of certain things that could happen/ go wrong. This is a decision for you, and your husband only.

35965a · 02/04/2023 09:40

To3ornot · 02/04/2023 09:35

Would you mind saying why?

Everything was just spread so thin - my parent’s time and money. Holidays were difficult because everything is centred for 4. As siblings one was always the ‘odd one out’ - the whole three is a crowd thing was very noticeable at times. There was a lot of noise and squabbling. I don’t think there’s ever any benefit to giving a child a sibling at all, it’s a gamble because there are plenty of siblings who don’t get on at all and never have.

Nimbostratus100 · 02/04/2023 09:37

To3ornot · 02/04/2023 09:27

What was your eldests thoughts on it? I know either decision I make will be for me/DH but I do want to centre my existing children in the decision if that makes sense?

dont be daft, keep them out of it altogether- no reason to involve children in this decision, and a thousand reasons not to.

What if they say yes and you go for it? And have another? It will seem like a lifetime away for them, and they could well change their minds in that time, what if they say yes and you dont ever get pregnant? What if they say yes and you have a disabled child they blame themselves for forever? What if they say no, and you get pregnant accidently?

Totally inappropriate to bring existing children into this decision

DelphiniumBlue · 02/04/2023 09:37

Sorry posted too soon.
But the point was, having a 3rd dc added so much joy to our lives. They are all grown up now, but are close, as in each others first port of call. The older ones have always involved dc3 in their lives, and continue to look after him now, helping with uni work, careers advice,that sort of thing.
For us as parents, of course 3 is logistically more difficult than 2, but it's not that much extra work, and number 3 seemed to fit in to whatever was going on, and was entertained by his siblings. We did have to think of ways to keep a toddler away from older siblings Lego building and make sure that the elder 2 weren't too impacted or restricted by the baby , but he very quickly learned how to behave so as not to annoy them.
We did have more years of night waking, in fact I had over a decade of broken sleep, but feeding a 3rd baby is really easy, and you don't have to go on for 2 years.
You sound well placed to have a 3rd, so I'd really recommend it!

Movingsoon21 · 02/04/2023 09:36

Op I see where you’re coming from but please don’t ask your eldest for their opinion on it. A five year old has no concept of what a 3rd sibling would mean over the course of their life and it’s far too much responsibility to put in their hands. This is a decision for you and DH alone and you need to own it rather than passing the buck to a child.

To3ornot · 02/04/2023 09:35

35965a · 02/04/2023 09:35

As one of three myself I wouldn’t have more than 2, ever.

Would you mind saying why?

OP posts:
To3ornot · 02/04/2023 09:35

Thank you all for such good advice and opinions - I’m reading them all out to my husband and it’s prompting good discussion

OP posts:
35965a · 02/04/2023 09:35

As one of three myself I wouldn’t have more than 2, ever.

To3ornot · 02/04/2023 09:35

Blossomtoes · 02/04/2023 09:31

You’re totally unreasonable to start thinking about “uni fees” before your eldest has even started school.

Why? Surely that’s a reasonable expectation of a huge outlay? Genuinely not sure why that’s unreasonable?

OP posts:
Quichetiger · 02/04/2023 09:32

In your situation I would do it! I would love a third but house and car too small, my career is just taking off and I have health issues that would make it hard for me. Without all that I’d love to!

Blossomtoes · 02/04/2023 09:31

You’re totally unreasonable to start thinking about “uni fees” before your eldest has even started school.

To3ornot · 02/04/2023 09:29

FFF3 · 02/04/2023 09:24

It’s not a logical decision - no argument will ever be in favour of having a third for practical / sensible reasons. I have three because we felt we wanted another. It’s wonderful, and we’re so glad we had him (just like the other two) - but three is a lot. The thing is, if you really want one more you’ll be prepared to take it all on. It’s a decision of the heart.

I think this is the crux of it isn’t it.

maybe I should give it six months and if we’re still undecided maybe it’s a no as you’re right, if we really want to be a family of five we’ll suck up the practicalities. Obviously my life would have been easier without any children at all but I wouldn’t change them for the world!

OP posts: