Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I unreasonable to have a third baby?

157 replies

To3ornot · 02/04/2023 08:39

Hello MNs

I know this has been done to death but I really need some outside perspective.

Our situation:

  • married 10 years
  • two children age 4 & 23 months
  • own house with mortgage 5 beds
  • big car (electric) so wouldn’t need to change it
  • always wanted 3
  • I’m stay at home mum
  • household income approx £90k

Both of us have always wanted three but now I’m second guessing myself. I’ve breastfed both of mine for a long time, over two years my eldest and still going with DD now at 21 months.

Ds is starting school in September and DD will go to preschool two mornings a week so I feel like I’m just getting back to myself a bit more. My eldest didn’t sleep until he was 2 and DD still not sleeping through yet.

Im just wondering if the benefit of having an extra sibling is worth it for the children or whether they would be better off us splitting our time/ money/ emotional resources between just the two of them.

If you were one of three would you mind sharing how you found it? Especially if you had this sort of age gap (about 3 years between). Or if you’ve got three how do you find it?

Im so torn because on paper it looks like a no brainier to me that we can do it but then I’m so worried about another 3 years of feeding/ no sleep and the impact on my current children plus then down the line uni fees etc. I go back and forth every day!

Is there anything I’ve not thought about?

Voting: YABU to have another YANBU to have another

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MoonSea · 03/04/2023 17:46

It sounds like you want 3 and are well off. If so go for it and don't overthink it.

I'm tempted to try for a third child but our household income is a third of yours and we have 2 bedrooms....but I think we would make it work somehow (although not trying just now)

To3ornot · 03/04/2023 17:42

threeplusmum · 03/04/2023 17:04

Why ask strangers on the internet. I'm expecting my third and its no one's business but me and my partners.

Congratulations!

Hopefully I’ve explained in my posts why I’m asking, I’ve found it really useful to think through the pros and cons. I’m not someone to make quick decisions on things that will affect my family so it’s useful for me to think through things.

OP posts:
threeplusmum · 03/04/2023 17:04

Why ask strangers on the internet. I'm expecting my third and its no one's business but me and my partners.

Dogwalker56 · 03/04/2023 17:00

@To3ornot

"This is such a lovely comment thank you so much."

You are very welcome. X

Mary46 · 03/04/2023 16:03

Hi op best of luck. I have 2. A few friends have 3. Just more juggling. I do think it depends on age gaps too. Some had a 3rd but other two at school. So bit of a breather.

Humanbiology · 03/04/2023 15:15

Children are a blessing and should be enjoyed and loved and op if you feel you have more love to give then by all means give it.

Humanbiology · 03/04/2023 15:11

Not every woman is maternal when they have and bring up their children. I however was very maternal that's why I had 4 children. You can tell by how a woman treats her children whether they are maternal or not. Some women loved carrying and giving birth but they hated what comes after that. The reality of having to deal with another human being that has come from them with their own thoughts and desires is not an easy task and you either enjoy it or you loathe it.

To3ornot · 03/04/2023 15:09

Dogwalker56 · 03/04/2023 09:19

@6namechang3

We will have to agree to differ on this. I do feel that it is preaching when the OP (who I think sounds lovely and very sensible btw) had already stated that her family do what they feel is right for their family to help the environment and that having a third child would not worry them in this respect. Still posters felt the need to raise it, push it and even pass judgement i e. implying that it lacks sense to have another child. Yes, of course I was being deliberately OTT in my list of saintly virtues but was only trying to make the point that those promoting this issue may not be as environmentally conscious as the OP in other respects so really do not need to be so judgemental. You clearly think differently and that is your prerogative.

OP I really hope that you and DH reach a decision that makes you happy. You come across as a loving, caring family and a third child would be so lucky to be part of it if that is what you choose. Good luck x

This is such a lovely comment thank you so much.

I have really appreciated all the help and advice and hearing peoples perspectives. Lots that I’d thought about already but a few things I hadn’t which has been useful to start to process.

I think if I was thinking just what I would like it would be easy and I’d have another. The thing I’m struggling with is what’s best for my DC and I think we still need some time to figure that out particularly around finances but also around having enough quality time for each so no quick decision from us I think!

Another thing I’ve taken from this thread is that there isn’t unfortunately a perfect answer here which I was hoping for! So that’s where I’ve landed for now..

Thanks again everyone

OP posts:
Dogwalker56 · 03/04/2023 14:31

fitzwilliamdarcy · 03/04/2023 14:02

That article basically suggests that if each country that has set net zero targets meets those targets, then the emissions impact of having a child won’t be as bad as it is now.

Currently, no signatory to the Paris Agreement is compatible with net zero. Some are “almost sufficient” but many are critical insufficient, highly insufficient or insufficient (https://climateactiontracker.org/countries/). That “if” starts to look seriously wobbly.

By contrast, we know that in 2023 having a child has an impact that absolutely dwarfs any other thing one can do (let alone those things in combination) (https://amp.theguardian.com/environment/2017/jul/12/want-to-fight-climate-change-have-fewer-children).

I judge the heck out of people who have more kids than the replacement level, and I really don’t feel any sense of shame in doing so.

As I stated ...just another perspective. Your link also contained interesting information such as this,

“Population reduction would probably reduce carbon emissions but we have many other tools for getting global warming under control,” he said. “Perhaps more importantly, cutting the number of people on the planet will take hundreds of years. Emissions reduction needs to start now."

and provides another argument for consideration. People need to make up their own minds.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 03/04/2023 14:02

Dogwalker56 · 03/04/2023 11:21

That article basically suggests that if each country that has set net zero targets meets those targets, then the emissions impact of having a child won’t be as bad as it is now.

Currently, no signatory to the Paris Agreement is compatible with net zero. Some are “almost sufficient” but many are critical insufficient, highly insufficient or insufficient (https://climateactiontracker.org/countries/). That “if” starts to look seriously wobbly.

By contrast, we know that in 2023 having a child has an impact that absolutely dwarfs any other thing one can do (let alone those things in combination) (https://amp.theguardian.com/environment/2017/jul/12/want-to-fight-climate-change-have-fewer-children).

I judge the heck out of people who have more kids than the replacement level, and I really don’t feel any sense of shame in doing so.

Whatthefnow · 03/04/2023 13:50

I have 4, should have stopped at 1.

Have less kids and put more into them.

SilhouettesOnTheShade · 03/04/2023 13:39

In your situation and circumstances, I don't think there's a wrong decision. You're in a financial position to have two, mentally prepared too as you both wanted three. But stopping at 2 is also fine. Go with your gut really. I have two (ds1 is 2.7 and ds2 is 9 weeks) and I just KNOW I'm done. I feel very complete. I didn't feel like this with ds1. Even though I didn't want to do pregnancy and the first year again, i just knew I wanted another. So we kept all the baby stuff. This time, I'm selling stuff as ds2 grows out of it and just feel it's right.

Dogwalker56 · 03/04/2023 13:19

@mydogisthebest

I am not that far behind you agewise. I have friends who opted not to have children (for a variety of reasons) and I respect that. I was one of three children (the youngest) and I loved my childhood. I had very loving parents and got on well with my siblings (sadly, one no longer here). I have two children and they have been an absolute joy as are my grandchildren (each child has two). I guess we each live our lives how it works for us. I love children (I was a teacher for many years) therefore I can understand others feeling the same and wanting to expand their families.
I wish you well.

mydogisthebest · 03/04/2023 12:44

Dogwalker56 · 03/04/2023 11:44

@mydogisthebest

You are, of course, entitled to your opinion as am I.
Who said it won't make any difference? I am just more open to the possibility that having children does not create the doom and gloom scenario that you believe (again, your choice!) The article (and yes, just one viewpoint among many) was interesting and gave another perspective. If you wish to stick rigidly to your point of view and not be open to other possibilities then OK.

It doesn't really matter what I think. I have no children thank goodness so am not having the worry of how shit the future is going to be.

My nieces and nephews are grown up and all say they do not intend having children so no worry about them either. 2 out of 3 nieces are too old now to have them anyway and my nephew's wife is not far off being too old.

So many people have their heads in the sand and will just continue to have 3, 4 or even more children.

I honestly think the doom and gloom scenario is definitely very real and am glad that as I am almost 70 I will not have to live through the awfulness

Bloopsie · 03/04/2023 11:50

People saying 1-2 is enough,only in the UK in Europe they encourage native population to die out and rather import people.

Where I come from families get extra payment regardless of their income from 3+ children and more from 7+ children, from school we were tought early on for our culture and langauge to survive ideally each family should have 3 children minimum,two to replace mum and dad and third to keep pooulation growth as not everyone is able to have children, accidents etc.

Dogwalker56 · 03/04/2023 11:44

@mydogisthebest

You are, of course, entitled to your opinion as am I.
Who said it won't make any difference? I am just more open to the possibility that having children does not create the doom and gloom scenario that you believe (again, your choice!) The article (and yes, just one viewpoint among many) was interesting and gave another perspective. If you wish to stick rigidly to your point of view and not be open to other possibilities then OK.

mydogisthebest · 03/04/2023 11:28

So bringing more children into the world who will almost certainly all drive, fly abroad on holidays and have children of their own doesn't make any different to the planet or climate change? Yeah right

mydogisthebest · 03/04/2023 10:55

Dogwalker56 · 03/04/2023 09:19

@6namechang3

We will have to agree to differ on this. I do feel that it is preaching when the OP (who I think sounds lovely and very sensible btw) had already stated that her family do what they feel is right for their family to help the environment and that having a third child would not worry them in this respect. Still posters felt the need to raise it, push it and even pass judgement i e. implying that it lacks sense to have another child. Yes, of course I was being deliberately OTT in my list of saintly virtues but was only trying to make the point that those promoting this issue may not be as environmentally conscious as the OP in other respects so really do not need to be so judgemental. You clearly think differently and that is your prerogative.

OP I really hope that you and DH reach a decision that makes you happy. You come across as a loving, caring family and a third child would be so lucky to be part of it if that is what you choose. Good luck x

The OP may well think they are doing a lot to help the environment but having children is one of the worst things you can do so why the need to have more than 1 or 2.

Also the rosy dream of 3 children all getting along so well is so often not true. As I said, I am one of three and hated it. I only really get on with one of my siblings and rarely see or speak to the other.

mydogisthebest · 03/04/2023 10:52

thegrain · 02/04/2023 10:15

The third might turn out to be the next big environmentalist.

The chances are they won't

Dogwalker56 · 03/04/2023 09:19

@6namechang3

We will have to agree to differ on this. I do feel that it is preaching when the OP (who I think sounds lovely and very sensible btw) had already stated that her family do what they feel is right for their family to help the environment and that having a third child would not worry them in this respect. Still posters felt the need to raise it, push it and even pass judgement i e. implying that it lacks sense to have another child. Yes, of course I was being deliberately OTT in my list of saintly virtues but was only trying to make the point that those promoting this issue may not be as environmentally conscious as the OP in other respects so really do not need to be so judgemental. You clearly think differently and that is your prerogative.

OP I really hope that you and DH reach a decision that makes you happy. You come across as a loving, caring family and a third child would be so lucky to be part of it if that is what you choose. Good luck x

TheaBrandt · 03/04/2023 08:40

Dint get the view that 3 is more “fun”. Doesn’t that depend on personality? You could have 3 dull kids in one family or 2 interesting fun ones in another.

We stopped at 2 soooooo glad we did. We like to travel though and do stuff as a family now they are teens so much easier with just 2 not to mention less expensive. We have same sex and they get on so it’s brilliant

mydogisthebest · 03/04/2023 08:35

I am one of three and hated it. Odd number means one always feels left out. I vowed if I had children I would never ever have 3.

I think you have 2 healthy children thank your lucky stars and don't take chances. Also if anything happens in the future with you or your OH 2 are far more manageable and less expensive than 3.

Lastly please think of the planet. We do not need more and more humans. If people actually cared about their children's futures they would not have more than 1 or 2

Hankunamatata · 03/04/2023 08:34

Holiday perspective 3 is a pain in the butt. You can get rooms for 2 adults and 2 children easily but nightmare at times trying to find a room for 5.

afterdropshock · 03/04/2023 08:13

My husband and I both have many siblings and wanted our children to have siblings, not just one sibling.
We have 3 children. They are all primary age now and best of friends. They play all day, never get bored, rarely use screens. There is a lot of laughter.
Of course it's more expensive but you have a lot more money than us.
Things like mealtimes and bedtimes and getting out the house are harder. But all the bits in between are easier I think. They entertain each other.
We also have pets but to me they are a nuisance and not as much fun as children.
I can't imagine life without any of them, but I always wanted three or more.