Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this detrimental to my kids?

93 replies

cheesegraet · 01/04/2023 23:36

I was speaking to a friend earlier and she was really shocked when I revealed that our children have never been away from us over night. They're 6 and 8.

We've also never gone out for the evening without them.
My mum has watched them the odd afternoon, but that's it.

Is this weird ?

They'd be pretty sad if we left them, so we haven't and we just haven't seen the need to.

OP posts:
JMSA · 03/04/2023 09:41

GabriellaMontez · 03/04/2023 09:34

As long as you're all happy. It's fine.

It's really not. It's possessive and weird. How would they even cope in an emergency situation?!

JMSA · 03/04/2023 09:40

Meant to say life or identity outside of your kids.

JMSA · 03/04/2023 09:39

Weird in my eyes, yes. Gosh, don't you want any kind of life or existence outside of your children? your other half must be bored stiff

Yoyooo · 03/04/2023 09:38

I wouldn't worry so much about the detriment to your children, but instead the detriment to your marriage.

I couldn't imagine a marriage without the odd date night, time to recharge with your loved one. When the children are all grown up - where will that leave your relationship

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 03/04/2023 09:37

Yes, i believe it is detrimental.

Kids aren't possessions. They deserve opportunities to develop their own relationships outside the parental unit. With babysitters, extended family, friends. They also need to learn to cope with a parent's absence.

EstherUrsula · 03/04/2023 09:34

SeeWhatYouGetWhenYouAskAStupidQuestion · 03/04/2023 09:09

My sons are adults with kids of their own now, but we never once had a babysitter for them, never went out without them, and they never stayed overnight anywhere.

In another thread you refer to “my son who lives alone”

GabriellaMontez · 03/04/2023 09:34

As long as you're all happy. It's fine.

Choconut · 03/04/2023 09:32

If you're all happy then it sounds lovely. I'm assuming they go to school so they have plenty of 'time apart' then. I don't see anything advantageous to the kids being shipped off to various people or getting random baby sitters in to look after them just because they parents want to go out. Mine stayed with relatives every now and then from about 6 or 7 onwards and had the odd sleepover with friends but it really wasn't necessary or required. It certainly didn't make them any more or any less social/confident/mentally healthy - that comes down so much more to nature rather than nurture when they're young IMO.

TempsPerdu · 03/04/2023 09:31

@SleeptightDaisy Just to say that you’re not alone in this, and I very much empathise. In our case it’s partly a side effect of having had DD late (and our parents having us late too) so all GPs are now in their late 70s and 80s and not up to doing that level of childcare. And also being temperamentally unsuited - we had my parents over just for a few hours in the evening last week and they had to be told to interact with DD. They just don’t ‘do’ kids.

I do feel that DD is missing out a bit with the relationship building side of things, but it is what it is and she is otherwise very happy and well adjusted. The strain is more on our side!

TempsPerdu · 03/04/2023 09:23

We’re kind of in the same boat OP. DD is 5 and has never slept away from home, and we’ve only managed a couple of nights out as a couple since she was born. We do have time away from her individually - I’ve just got back from a days’ break on my own - but not together.

I don’t think it’s been detrimental to DD - she is secure and well adjusted and will I imagine be fine with sleepovers at friends’ houses/school trips when she’s a bit bigger. But it has been detrimental to us as a couple and I do feel that we’ve lost touch with each other a bit, plus we have very little alone time to discuss big decisions, plans etc because DD is always around.

Our main issue is lack of childcare options - very small families on both sides, with older grandparents who can’t really cope with an overnight stay now. Only other local relative is DP’s sister, who is fab with kids, but lives in a one bed flat and is a teacher, so very busy during term time and often on holiday herself in the holidays. DD also has, and has always had, a very late bedtime (9pm or so), and we don’t really want to inflict that on whoever is looking after her. So we’re a bit stuck!

As soon as friends’ sleepovers become a possibility we will definitely be encouraging those for DD (and hosting them here), but in the meantime I’m not sure what the answer is!

Thepeopleversuswork · 03/04/2023 09:16

SeeWhatYouGetWhenYouAskAStupidQuestion · 03/04/2023 09:09

My sons are adults with kids of their own now, but we never once had a babysitter for them, never went out without them, and they never stayed overnight anywhere.

What never until they left home?

See I think that pretty unhealthy.

Tryphenia · 03/04/2023 09:14

It’s far more likely to be detrimental to you.

MrsHughesPinny · 03/04/2023 09:11

It wouldn’t be for me, personally, but the way you parent is up to you. I believe (and this is evidenced in my own DC) that it’s healthy to have time apart. For me, it’s been important to still be a person and pursue my own interests, not just be a parent. From my DC’s perspective, they are never anxious about going new places, on school residentials, to stay with friends/family etc.

First time I spent time away from my DC was four nights in NYC when he was about 7 months old. It was a challenge but the first time was the hardest and it’s been fine since.

SeeWhatYouGetWhenYouAskAStupidQuestion · 03/04/2023 09:09

My sons are adults with kids of their own now, but we never once had a babysitter for them, never went out without them, and they never stayed overnight anywhere.

EstherUrsula · 03/04/2023 09:07

Op won’t be back I reckon

Houseyvibe · 03/04/2023 08:36

I don't think that not staying out is unusual but to have never not once left your children for an evening is definitely weird and to not do it because they would feel sad is even weirder. Who is the parent here?

AnnBeloved · 03/04/2023 08:35

And I think surely it's only going to get harder to do the longer you leave it?

KnittingNeedles · 03/04/2023 08:34

They'd be pretty sad if we left them,

But why? What's "sad" about "Mum and Dad are going to a wedding/gig/party, so you're staying with Auntie overnight and we'll see you both in the morning"?

At 8, a child is approaching the sleepover age, or nights away with Cubs/Brownies, school trips, all sorts of reasons why they may be offered the chance to be away overnight. It IS detrimental to children to miss out on these sorts of life opportunities because parents are too needy or anxious to spend a few hours away from them, let alone overnight.

Hoppinggreen · 03/04/2023 08:34

It’s your choice of course and we generally take ours on holiday, out for meals etc as we want to BUT at some point you may need to or want to do it so if you have a babysitter available it might be a good idea to get them used to it gradually.
SIL was similar but then had a family emergency and had to leave her DC with someone they didn’t know well and it added to the stress of an already difficult situation

WordtoYoMumma · 03/04/2023 08:33

It's definitely unusual. I don't think it's detrimental to your kids necessarily but I do think it could be detrimental to your mental health and your relationship. I can't imagine putting my life and relationship completely on hold like that for so long.
If it works for you then it's no one else's business but it would have made me sad. DH and I are now at the point where we can go out whenever we want as the kids are old enough to be left alone, so we get lots of lovely stress free date nights and it's wonderful! We go to nicer places too now cos our budget doesn't have to pay the babysitter 😂

At some point your child may want to do a sleepover with a friend, camp with cubs, school residential and it may be harder for them if they've never been away from you I guess? Or they may just find they are ready and be fine with it.

AnnBeloved · 03/04/2023 08:33

I don't know. There isn't anything wrong with it per se but it's not how I'd do things. Do you not think they'd be sad at you going out because they have never dealt with it?

I understand feeling uncomfortable at your child spending time at a random friends house overnight who's parents you don't know but not even your own families? A school trip?

My children stay at my parents regularly and have done since they were tiny. It's great for me, no relationship right now but still me time is important! And it's honestly great for them. Not just because they have a lovely time when they are there which they do, but they are quite happy being left. They don't get upset, they have a lovely bond with my parents and other family members and in a more extreme scenario I know they'd be happy and safe with someone and somewhere they knew and trusted if something happened to me. They have a home away from home with my family and I think that's only a good thing?

As they get older like your two I'd want them to be able to experience school trips and things too. Will this not be an issue? My stepson went away on a residential when he was 9, he had such a good time. If he'd never spent the night away from his parents until then I'm not sure how that would have worked.

EstherUrsula · 03/04/2023 08:32

So guessing your children have never been on a sleepover.

Invites will come

do you think your children will be “really sad” if it’s them sleeping over at a fun party sleepover? Doubt it

Thepeopleversuswork · 03/04/2023 08:31

I don’t think it’s detrimental to the kids although the later you leave this the harder it will be.

I do however think it’s detrimental to your relationship with your partner and your own mental health and sense of self. You (or another poster), said your parents had lived like this and they were still in love etc but if you never go out or see anyone else how would you develop any perspective on your own life?

I think having no life outside of your immediate family is incredibly unhealthy.

Stickmansmum · 03/04/2023 08:29

I think it’s extreme OP. And fundamentally any sort of extreme behaviour or family set up tend not to be on the healthy side of things. Your kids need to learn to rely on themselves (mentally- of course a responsible adult will be there) for short periods initially at a young age and more and more as they get older. Just my opinion. Humans need to be under pressure a bit to learn and letting them have time away from their primary caregivers teaches them lots of tiny little lessons you couldn’t even imagine.

Number24Bus · 03/04/2023 08:27

Overnight- absolutely fine.

Evening out- unusual. Fair enough if it works for you, but maybe try a night out with your husband?

Swipe left for the next trending thread