Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable over flat tyre on car DD or DH

185 replies

Safarigiraffe · 01/04/2023 21:15

Hi DD19 came home with flat tyre after work today & husband wasn’t too happy about it & started shouting about it not at her but about the car having a flat tyre. Bit of background here - DD has paid 1700 this month from her wages/savings towards the car to pay it off & is also paying off her student finance. So DD didn’t think it was right for her to pay 100 pounds for the flat tyre but DH didn’t want to pay it as it isn’t his car even though DD is paying a lot of money towards the car to pay it off & student finance to pay that off as well. DH reluctantly paid the 100 pounds for the flat tyre but isn’t happy about it and both are not talking to the other as they both argued about it. So who is being more unreasonable & AIBU to keep out of it or just let them get on with it

OP posts:
PuddlesPityParty · 01/04/2023 22:12

TrombonesAreNotBones · 01/04/2023 22:04

Ok. My Dad would have grumbled and paid up if I had indicated I was going to be short due to flat tyre replacement. He wouldn't have shouted at me, the roads are appalling atm - potholes awaiting repair and you can't see the ones filled with rain for example.

I think DD could be a bit more mindful of not treating her Dad like a bank and DH def needs to remember that at 19 his daughter is still learning how to adult, including building up financial reserves for unexpected outlays.

Hope all calm down down soon.

get that fronting sorted, yeah

OP said he was shouting about the situation, not at the daughter. Reading between the lines at the DD not wanting to pay I would imagine she is also shouting back about the situation…

TiaraBoo · 01/04/2023 22:11

So DD didn’t think it was right for her to pay 100 pounds for the flat tyre

@Safarigiraffe Why?

Adults don’t usually say I’ve paid my bills this month, it’s not right for me to pay for my car to be fixed!

TrombonesAreNotBones · 01/04/2023 22:04

Ok. My Dad would have grumbled and paid up if I had indicated I was going to be short due to flat tyre replacement. He wouldn't have shouted at me, the roads are appalling atm - potholes awaiting repair and you can't see the ones filled with rain for example.

I think DD could be a bit more mindful of not treating her Dad like a bank and DH def needs to remember that at 19 his daughter is still learning how to adult, including building up financial reserves for unexpected outlays.

Hope all calm down down soon.

get that fronting sorted, yeah

lljkk · 01/04/2023 22:04

New tyre cost me £30 last year. £15 if they had repaired it. I'm wondering where £100 estimate comes from.

JenniferBarkley · 01/04/2023 22:04

If it's her car then she should be paying for repairs and the correct insurance.

However, since she's paying her dad back for the car, if you're financially comfortable and she's being responsible and just starting out then it would be kind to add the money to the overall debt rather than insisting she pays this month. That's a nice thing to do though and not at all necessary if neither of you fancy it.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 01/04/2023 21:57

SquareRootOfAllEvil · 01/04/2023 21:52

Ignoring the insurance implications, I don’t understand why your daughter thinks it’s your DH’s responsibility to pay? Sounds like it’s her car and she was driving, so it’s nothing to do with him.

This is what I can't get my head around. I used to have a genuine car share with my dad, I was main driver if I remember correctly but it didn't make much difference as we genuinely both drove it. I paid for tax & insurance, my Dad paid for MOT & service. We split fuel and repairs between us, because it was our car.

In this case, it appears to be the daughter's car so all costs other than fuel, a small amount of wear and tear etc. Should be covered by her.

Obviously if the DH had an accident, that's different altogether.

Pubesofsoberness · 01/04/2023 21:56

She should pay

Twillow · 01/04/2023 21:53

If she has an accident in it driving to work then she & DH will be in big trouble because she's clearly the main driver. And it's her car so she should pay - by all means help out if you are able/want to but the responsibility is hers. Life costs.

AngelDelightUK · 01/04/2023 21:52

If it’s her car then she should pay for the tyre. But you are on dodgy ground with the insurance

SquareRootOfAllEvil · 01/04/2023 21:52

Ignoring the insurance implications, I don’t understand why your daughter thinks it’s your DH’s responsibility to pay? Sounds like it’s her car and she was driving, so it’s nothing to do with him.

Safarigiraffe · 01/04/2023 21:51

goingtotown · 01/04/2023 21:50

New tyre or puncture repair?

New tyre

OP posts:
goingtotown · 01/04/2023 21:50

New tyre or puncture repair?

Safarigiraffe · 01/04/2023 21:50

TrombonesAreNotBones · 01/04/2023 21:49

DD has paid 1700 this month from her wages/savings towards the car to pay it off Who is she paying this lump to? Did you/DH buy the car for DD and she pays you back bit by bit?

DH paid for a lump sum for the car & yes DD is paying DH back for the car bit by bit

OP posts:
Greenshake · 01/04/2023 21:50

@Safarigiraffe I thought you weren’t coming back as you didn’t want to face the huge amount of people who have highlighted the blatant insurance fraud going on.

PuddlesPityParty · 01/04/2023 21:50

& if it’s your DDs car and it happened whilst she was driving then yes she needs to pay. I think the clue of whose car it really is is that she’s the one whose just finished paying it off 🙄

Safarigiraffe · 01/04/2023 21:49

ArnoldRimmerGivingQuicheAChance · 01/04/2023 21:46

So are you going to address the issue of the illegal insurance fronting that's going on in your situation?

Yes I do agree about the fronting part which shouldn’t of happened at all but that’s on them however I was asking on who should of paid the tyre & who was being more unreasonable here on the tyre

OP posts:
TrombonesAreNotBones · 01/04/2023 21:49

DD has paid 1700 this month from her wages/savings towards the car to pay it off Who is she paying this lump to? Did you/DH buy the car for DD and she pays you back bit by bit?

PuddlesPityParty · 01/04/2023 21:48

Safarigiraffe · 01/04/2023 21:33

DH is main driver to car but is on insurance so it’s cheaper for DD to drive to work and back

This is fraud.

ArnoldRimmerGivingQuicheAChance · 01/04/2023 21:46

Safarigiraffe · 01/04/2023 21:44

Why would I not return when I was just asking a question on who was being more unreasonable & as much as I agree here I don’t want to be dragged into their arguing over this

So are you going to address the issue of the illegal insurance fronting that's going on in your situation?

DoeRayMe · 01/04/2023 21:46

More info needed tbh

DD drove car and found puncture. How long was she out in the car and was it a sudden puncture or was it starting to look flat and took to shop who found puncture?

Who drove the car in the week leading up to the puncture and how far/long?

Could be the previous trips were the ones the picked up the puncture but sometimes it takes days to become evident.

Lastly who legally owns the car, assuming DD from previous posts and who drives it the most?

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 01/04/2023 21:46

@Safarigiraffe You and your DH and DD may want to look up the challenges they will face if they get CIFAS makers for insurance fraud.

userxx · 01/04/2023 21:45

I paid £36 for a puncture repair last week.

ArnoldRimmerGivingQuicheAChance · 01/04/2023 21:44

@Greenshake probably high, sadly 😞

Safarigiraffe · 01/04/2023 21:44

Greenshake · 01/04/2023 21:43

What’s the bet OP doesn’t return?

Why would I not return when I was just asking a question on who was being more unreasonable & as much as I agree here I don’t want to be dragged into their arguing over this

OP posts:
pinkpotatoez · 01/04/2023 21:44

What do you mean she doesn't wanted to pay it, will she be on the bus on Monday to work then? Confused it's her car obviously she pays it

Swipe left for the next trending thread