Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I put my cat back on the expensive cat food?

87 replies

Novatherova · 01/04/2023 20:55

Hi I currently have one female pedigree cat who is 2. She is the light of my life who I love very much.

She was on Royal Canin Intense Beauty wet and dry food which was £13.50 for 12 pouches and then the dry when I ran out.

Due to cost of living Pets at Home put Price up to £16.49 for 12. My DP asked me to change the food due to how expensive.

I put her on Purina One and then Purina Mon Petit. For 48 pouches it was £18 on another website.

Since changing her coat has gone downhill and she now also has dandruff. Her fur looks shabby and I feel v guilty.

I want to put her back on Royal Canin. I also pay fee 22 per month to vets for all consultations, flea, vacs etc plus 17 for insurance. So it all adds up.

I pay it all out my wages. If I put her back on Royal Canin I won't be able to adopt a cat.

Wedding and baby on the way so I need to minimise costs. But I can't justify cutting her food that makes her healthy. When she was on it she glowed.

But my DP is adamant. I will ignore him and do what I want as I say its my money. But want other opinions??

OP posts:
Novatherova · 01/04/2023 22:39

Rebel2 · 01/04/2023 21:10

You can get a saved pack here cheaper if you look at the price per kg
https://www.zooplus.co.uk/shop/cats/cannedcatfoodpouches/royalcanincatfood/royalcaninadult/133237?variantid=133237.9&gbraid=0AAAAAD9Xn6V3legWye83na7ZRRecoOzd&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIiLODkL2JgIVSu3tCh01oQ3pEAQYAiABEgInmPD_BwE

However it's not great food due to the meat content. The other option you could do is feed a higher meat content food and add a bit of salmon oil for the omega content

You could feed this and salmon oil for about the same price

https://www.zooplus.co.uk/shop/cats/cannedcatfoodpouches/scrumbles/1175014?zootopiarec=true&cn=initial&si=3&pn=webpdp&pr=container2&strategy=18113207&rk=1-2&slot=1&pi=1175014&rri=9aa761e1-49da-456c-9d98-16dad8e83e07

This is even cheaper with a high meat content

https://www.zooplus.co.uk/shop/cats/cannedcatfoodpouches/feringawetcatfood/feringa_pouches/519350?origin=hopps&q=feringa&i=8&ro=1&ct=Cat%7CWet%20Cat%20Food

Add some dry which has salmon oil in it

https://www.zooplus.co.uk/shop/cats/drycatfood/rosies_farm/1569109

https://www.zooplus.co.uk/shop/cats/drycatfood/crave/dry/718037

Use Quidco for cash back and buy the saver packs in bulk then you get free delivery too

Thank you very much for taking the time to do that.

Could I ask how much do you feed your cat a day pl?

OP posts:
thegrain · 01/04/2023 22:25

Novatherova · 01/04/2023 21:30

I think he was just having a moan. But he doesn't look at the ingredients etc.

I get what you mean about the hobby. He's going football next week. I'd rather pay for her to be healthy and go without food myself as dramatic as that sounds.

I've felt like rubbish for weeks now over it. And it's made worse by the decline in her coat.

So basically looking for something with high meat content.

Yeah exactly how much is he spending on football. If you're not going to football then the difference in the price of cat food is just your football

Novatherova · 01/04/2023 22:06

Mariposa26 · 01/04/2023 22:01

Also a big fan of Katkin but my cat decided she doesn’t like it and won’t eat it anymore, we’ve moved onto Cool Cat Club which is also high meat content, grain free and the cats both have lovely coats and are very healthy. You can get 30 pouches for £23.99 a month and supplement with a good dry food.

Brilliant thank you all. Going to look at Katkin now. Quite a few of you have mentioned it.

OP posts:
cobblers123 · 01/04/2023 22:05

I've tried loads of different foods both wet and dry and have just ordered Meowing Heads, he loves this - at the moment - itv does seem to have a high meat content so I'm hoping he will eat it and it will improve his coat.

He also has Royal Canin Oral biscuits, he likes those but doesn't like the Ageing 12+ any more so I've half a bag loafing about in the cupboard.

Catlover77 · 01/04/2023 22:03

Cool Cat Club and Untamed are great cat foods

WeWillLookBack · 01/04/2023 22:03

We have been using Katkin for a couple of months - seen a massive improvement in our cats. They are 13 years old, their coats look amazing again and have loads of energy. It may be worth giving their trial a go. It is all 100% meat - no grain / fillers. They come frozen, so you do need a bit of freezer space (but slim sachets).

Catlover77 · 01/04/2023 22:02

Please do not give your cat anything made by Purina.

Mariposa26 · 01/04/2023 22:01

Also a big fan of Katkin but my cat decided she doesn’t like it and won’t eat it anymore, we’ve moved onto Cool Cat Club which is also high meat content, grain free and the cats both have lovely coats and are very healthy. You can get 30 pouches for £23.99 a month and supplement with a good dry food.

tomfromloveislandsbeard · 01/04/2023 21:58

I give Katkin, pure human grade meat, but for half our spoiled princess's meals.

You're meant to give a whole ouch over two meals a day, but I give a cheaper pouch in the morning and half a Katkin pouch in the evening. It's expensive so this keeps it manageable and her coat is so much better than when she was on Whiskas, she's like a different cat, happy, relaxed and silky.

ArnoldRimmerGivingQuicheAChance · 01/04/2023 21:58

Our cat (18 years old in June) is on Felix senior 'As Good as it Looks' (40g breakfast and dinner) with Royal Canin Senior dried 10g on top, also for breakfast and dinner. He also has snacks during the day.

Vet always says how good and shiny his coat is (it is!), weight is also spot on, she and has no issues with us continuing to feed him as we have done since we adopted him 9 years ago.

Novatherova · 01/04/2023 21:58

TheNoodlesIncident · 01/04/2023 21:46

I have noticed stories about cats being ill from their food but I thought that was Felix, and that was what came up when I did google it. But at least Applaws has high meat content and no grain!

We give our cat Hill's Science Plan Oral Care to reduce tartar build up on her teeth, I don't know if that's a decent dry food but it was the only one she would eat Grin Total princess, has proper carnassial teeth but wants her chicken snipped into short strands or she won't eat it. And I muggins of course I do it for her

I can imagine.

I'm the same with mine. She has us wrapped round her paws.

Sounds silly but I've honestly felt awful for weeks like I'm a bad mum for changing her food to more cost effective.

I'm glad all of you have given me tips. Thanks so much.

OP posts:
TheNoodlesIncident · 01/04/2023 21:46

Novatherova · 01/04/2023 21:33

There was big news story last year making cats very ill. Sainsburys and pets at home stopped selling it. All sorted now though apparently. Google it.

I have noticed stories about cats being ill from their food but I thought that was Felix, and that was what came up when I did google it. But at least Applaws has high meat content and no grain!

We give our cat Hill's Science Plan Oral Care to reduce tartar build up on her teeth, I don't know if that's a decent dry food but it was the only one she would eat Grin Total princess, has proper carnassial teeth but wants her chicken snipped into short strands or she won't eat it. And I muggins of course I do it for her

Careerdilemma · 01/04/2023 21:41

If you make your own you need to give the right balance of meat, organs and raw bones. I would look into feeding a raw diet. Either prepared or homemade.

Thrive is good too and can be bought cheaper from Zooplus. Because it is pure meat you don't need to feed as much. My cat is fine on two of the small tins a day and he is a big pedigree.

Salmon or krill oil are also great for their coats.

StrayGoose · 01/04/2023 21:40

@Novatherova Katkin, pure meat. £66 gets 28 pouches (400grams each) for about 56 days worth of food! My cat's fur really improved when I started her on it, as did her health. I have a link for 50% off your first box link if you are interested, dm me.

silentpool · 01/04/2023 21:40

My Persian has Applaws (or similar quality, high protein, no filler dry food) and then just raw chicken or game mince or poached chicken etc. The wet food is more of a treat as his dry food is a complete food. A 3kg bag of high quality food lasts at least a couple of months because they get full faster, than with the cheap stuff.

It's also a much cheaper way to feed the cat - as I can buy human grade meat on special for him.

His fur is lovely on that - I've found their fur gets dry on foods with fillers. If I ever buy supermarket wet food (Whiskas et ) as a treat, I soon regret it as he will immediately get a bad stomach. Not sure if that speaks to the quality of it!

TheNoodlesIncident · 01/04/2023 21:36

Would you ever just put a cat on a dry food diet?

I'm really considering buying and cooking chicken breasts (which she loves) as her main meals.

We did this to start with, the vet suggested we buy taurine and add it to her chicken to ensure she got enough. It can cause heart problems if they don't get enough essential nutrients like taurine. We got fed up doing it though, it's far easier to buy tins of proper food. Our cat gets Greenwoods and Encore.

It's best for cats to have a combination of wet and dry food as a large amount of the fluid they need comes from food, so wet foods naturally helps with that.

Novatherova · 01/04/2023 21:33

TheNoodlesIncident · 01/04/2023 21:31

What's wrong with Applaws?

There was big news story last year making cats very ill. Sainsburys and pets at home stopped selling it. All sorted now though apparently. Google it.

OP posts:
Novatherova · 01/04/2023 21:32

NamechangeAprilFool · 01/04/2023 21:29

I feed Purizon from Zooplus, it compares to Canegan which is much more expensive.

Thank you will look at that too.

OP posts:
TheNoodlesIncident · 01/04/2023 21:31

What's wrong with Applaws?

Novatherova · 01/04/2023 21:31

UndercoverCop · 01/04/2023 21:27

@Novatherova I always used the animed website, it's well known you might get it a little cheaper elsewhere but I preferred knowing I was ordering from somewhere reputable.
Beloved cat sadly died last year, he was the light of my life and the first man I lived with 😁. We will be adopting another cat in the summer after we've been away and intend to use the same approach. Previous cat was born with a serious heart condition and we were told he would do well if he made 5, he made it to 16. The day before he died he was still jumping the six foot garden fence and his coat was thick and glossy. The vet always commented that his bloods and scans didn't match the cat she saw in front of her.

So sorry for your loss xxxx

OP posts:
Novatherova · 01/04/2023 21:30

thegrain · 01/04/2023 21:19

If I put her back on Royal Canin I won't be able to adopt a cat that's ok though as you have a cat and also a baby and a wedding on the way. If it's coming out of your money then it's like if he's spending some of his money on a hobby only with a family member. If he's like this with your cat will he be like it with your kid too? Doesn't matter what the kid eats just make it cheap? That sort of thing?

I think he was just having a moan. But he doesn't look at the ingredients etc.

I get what you mean about the hobby. He's going football next week. I'd rather pay for her to be healthy and go without food myself as dramatic as that sounds.

I've felt like rubbish for weeks now over it. And it's made worse by the decline in her coat.

So basically looking for something with high meat content.

OP posts:
NamechangeAprilFool · 01/04/2023 21:29

I feed Purizon from Zooplus, it compares to Canegan which is much more expensive.

UndercoverCop · 01/04/2023 21:27

@Novatherova I always used the animed website, it's well known you might get it a little cheaper elsewhere but I preferred knowing I was ordering from somewhere reputable.
Beloved cat sadly died last year, he was the light of my life and the first man I lived with 😁. We will be adopting another cat in the summer after we've been away and intend to use the same approach. Previous cat was born with a serious heart condition and we were told he would do well if he made 5, he made it to 16. The day before he died he was still jumping the six foot garden fence and his coat was thick and glossy. The vet always commented that his bloods and scans didn't match the cat she saw in front of her.

Novatherova · 01/04/2023 21:26

MagpiePi · 01/04/2023 21:19

My very fussy cat has crave dry food and the occasional pouch of Purina. He is only a short haired moggy but his coat is beautifully soft and shiny.
I spent ages looking for high meat/low crap food and Crave came out as one o the best. I get it from Zooplus

Fab thanks so much.

OP posts:
Novatherova · 01/04/2023 21:26

sarahh96 · 01/04/2023 21:19

You might want to look into Purina. It's made by nestle who also make Felix.
There has been a lot of coverage re Felix making cats unwell.
Personally I've never had a problem with it, but I know people who have.
Pets at home do a cat food which is high in protein (40% compared to 4% protein in Purina/whiskers etc). I think it's called Bakers, not sure. Orange label. A lot cheaper than RC so might be worth switching?

Thank you will look.

OP posts: