Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I put my cat back on the expensive cat food?

87 replies

Novatherova · 01/04/2023 20:55

Hi I currently have one female pedigree cat who is 2. She is the light of my life who I love very much.

She was on Royal Canin Intense Beauty wet and dry food which was £13.50 for 12 pouches and then the dry when I ran out.

Due to cost of living Pets at Home put Price up to £16.49 for 12. My DP asked me to change the food due to how expensive.

I put her on Purina One and then Purina Mon Petit. For 48 pouches it was £18 on another website.

Since changing her coat has gone downhill and she now also has dandruff. Her fur looks shabby and I feel v guilty.

I want to put her back on Royal Canin. I also pay fee 22 per month to vets for all consultations, flea, vacs etc plus 17 for insurance. So it all adds up.

I pay it all out my wages. If I put her back on Royal Canin I won't be able to adopt a cat.

Wedding and baby on the way so I need to minimise costs. But I can't justify cutting her food that makes her healthy. When she was on it she glowed.

But my DP is adamant. I will ignore him and do what I want as I say its my money. But want other opinions??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Oggermoller · 12/08/2023 11:58

I hope you managed to find an alternative to RC
I have two cats on wet food and this is very good quality at a budget price. High meat content, grain free, pâté style.

For my two I serve 100g per meal so will be about £60 per month if I subscribe. The foil packs cost more but are more practical for single cats.

https://www.bitiba.co.uk/search/results?ct=Cat%20Foods%7CWet%20Cat%20Food&q=Rosie%27s%20farm

Product Search - Search the store

https://www.bitiba.co.uk/search/results?ct=Cat+Foods%7CWet+Cat+Food&q=Rosie%27s+farm

TheGoogleMum · 02/04/2023 20:45

Novatherova · 02/04/2023 17:52

I'm not sure about the other issues but with obesity are they active? My one is an indoor, is semi active, but loves her food. She's roughly 5kg now.

Well I have 2 cats and 1 is overweight and 1 is OK. The overweight one is always hungry, we weigh their food out though to avoid overeating once we realised we had a problem! She got fat having all the high meat content zooplus ones so I need to choose what I do carefully

ThinWomansBrain · 02/04/2023 20:11

@TinyKitty thanks - she doesn't have exclusively cosma, I alternate it about 50/50. She likes Rosie's Farm and Wild Freedom too- but not quite so much.
She's been having Cosma so long, it didn't used to have the 'not a complete food' warning at first - I did take some to the vets with me, and he thought the balance of her diet overall is fine.

Got wise to the rice stuffed 'oriental' range too & stopped buying that.

I had fish and chips the other evening - very rare - saved her some fish and she was so enthusiastic I thought she was going to eat the box it came in.

Novatherova · 02/04/2023 18:13

LiliLil · 02/04/2023 18:01

Blink is also good and you can get a trial box, I think I got 6 pouches for a pound and a couple of quid delivery.

My master cat turned her nose up at it though.

Haha master love it!

My DP got in the spare bed last night and she was asleep on the bed and he didn't want to move her. She was right in the middle so every time he moved his leg or tried to make space she swiped him.

Good girl!

Then she came in with me for snuggles.

OP posts:
Novatherova · 02/04/2023 18:11

LiliLil · 02/04/2023 18:00

General rule as high a meat content as you can afford - and not “meat derivatives”. Cats are carnivores, the fillers, grains and sugars can lead to health issues as you’ve seen in your cat.

You need a complete food, not complimentary.

So yes, you should be reading the meat content, and looking for grain free. It’s complicated at first but gets easier I promise. Cool cats club is a good one 😊

Thank you so much.

I can't tell how grateful I am to you all. I've told DP to bog off as well.

Also, told my Mum and his Mum and they've told him to mind his own business, what is it to do with him what I spend my money on.

Yes I know that's childish but he's really annoyed me today.

OP posts:
LiliLil · 02/04/2023 18:01

Blink is also good and you can get a trial box, I think I got 6 pouches for a pound and a couple of quid delivery.

My master cat turned her nose up at it though.

Ilovemycar77 · 02/04/2023 18:01

Our three cats get extremely upset tummies with bloody diarrhoea if they touch any supermarket wet food.
wensimolt buy the royal Canin gastrointestinal complete from petdrugs online and then buy 2 medium fresh chickens a week and gently boil them. This we found a whole cheaper and their coats are amazing and tummies not upset.
win win as the digs get to have the chicken skin and we get the stock for meals :-)).
I also occasionally give them a tin of tuna.
they are normal domestic tabbies, but any cats previous I’ve never had a problem with whiskas, but these three are exceptionally sensitive.

LiliLil · 02/04/2023 18:00

Novatherova · 02/04/2023 17:57

Not heard of that before. Will look at it. Thank you.

So in a nutshell I need stuff without grains, meat 60% or over and taurine???

General rule as high a meat content as you can afford - and not “meat derivatives”. Cats are carnivores, the fillers, grains and sugars can lead to health issues as you’ve seen in your cat.

You need a complete food, not complimentary.

So yes, you should be reading the meat content, and looking for grain free. It’s complicated at first but gets easier I promise. Cool cats club is a good one 😊

Novatherova · 02/04/2023 17:59

LiliLil · 02/04/2023 17:54

Please don’t feed your cat Purina.

Theres a whole Facebook group about it and it seems your cat is already showing signs that it’s awful food.

Have you tried meowing heads? 93% meat content, and no grains/sugars. It’s on 3 for 2 at Pets at Home at the moment but you can get it on Amazon too.

That's what I'm feeding her at the moment and her fur is awful. I'm waiting to get paid on Thursday then will begin transferring her over onto cool cat. I do think I will be putting her on Katkin though.

OP posts:
Novatherova · 02/04/2023 17:57

LiliLil · 02/04/2023 17:54

Please don’t feed your cat Purina.

Theres a whole Facebook group about it and it seems your cat is already showing signs that it’s awful food.

Have you tried meowing heads? 93% meat content, and no grains/sugars. It’s on 3 for 2 at Pets at Home at the moment but you can get it on Amazon too.

Not heard of that before. Will look at it. Thank you.

So in a nutshell I need stuff without grains, meat 60% or over and taurine???

OP posts:
Novatherova · 02/04/2023 17:56

Thank you so much. I'm learning alot talking to you all. I'm first time cat mum and just learning. I didn't know this about the foods. I've looked at RC label with fresh eyes and I'm genuinely horrified. Wtf. I trusted that it was good due to the price etc. I feel quite guilty now.

OP posts:
LiliLil · 02/04/2023 17:54

Please don’t feed your cat Purina.

Theres a whole Facebook group about it and it seems your cat is already showing signs that it’s awful food.

Have you tried meowing heads? 93% meat content, and no grains/sugars. It’s on 3 for 2 at Pets at Home at the moment but you can get it on Amazon too.

Novatherova · 02/04/2023 17:52

TheGoogleMum · 02/04/2023 08:42

Can I jump on to this thread to ask if there's a good food for overweight cats? On vets advice we feed purina veterinary obesity (I do buy from zooplus, we have tried some of the lesser known brands but my cats got very fat!). My cats are indoor, we have some hairball issues that aren't too bad with current food, and in the summer they sometimes struggle with cystitis.
I like the idea of the subscription ones but not sure they are specialist enough?

I'm not sure about the other issues but with obesity are they active? My one is an indoor, is semi active, but loves her food. She's roughly 5kg now.

OP posts:
TinyKitty · 02/04/2023 12:41

You can buy ready made raw if your cat takes to it. Freezers in the pet concessions of garden centres have a small section for cats. There are some good ones online. Google for raw cat food, most of them are for dogs, but also have a selection for cats. It seems that cat owners are not their intended target (yet).

WiddlinDiddlin · 02/04/2023 12:33

For an indoor cat only using your own garden, unless she hunts out there and kills and consumes stuff regularly, you're fine to drop the routine monthly flea/worm stuff - instead, treat the house annually for fleas as a preventative with a product that lasts 12 months (or bi-annually with a 6 monthly product) then just treat topically if you find fleas. If you do find fleas or you see symptoms that indicate she should be wormed, or you know that shes killed and eaten something wild.. then worm too.

Food.. better quality foods you'll feed less of, you'll also get less output so litter will last longer. The best for many is a raw diet but that takes some research and knowledge - it can however be done pretty cheaply once you know what you're doing!

NurseCranesRolodex · 02/04/2023 12:27

My cats are both 10 and on 100% dry food. Neither have ever been unwell or overweight. We use Purina however I'm going to look into the 40% protein one in Pets at home a pp mentioned. Didn't know about the low protein content.

TinyKitty · 02/04/2023 12:20

@TheGoogleMum Dry food contributes to cystitis, I stopped it many years ago for that reason and sometimes fed half a dozen kibbles as a treat, until I came home to find blood, lots of it.

Cats are not designed by nature to eat kibble, and if it hadn't been sprayed with a flavour enhancer (the greasy residue it gets) they wouldn't choose to eat it.

Meat and sometimes a nibble at some herbs or grass, plus what is in the stomach of the creature they consume means they get what they need. I feed high meat, sometimes with added veg like Feringa or just meat like Animonda Carny.

TinyKitty · 02/04/2023 12:14

ThinWomansBrain · 02/04/2023 09:11

Thoroughly recommend Zooplus - have used them for years, always excellent value.
My cat loves cosma -high meat content, the chicken is just - chicken, it doesn't look like cat food at all. For dried food, she has concept for life.

Cosma is not a complete food. Please check your cat gets enough taurine etc.
Supplementary, complementary foods are not sufficient in the nutrients your cat needs and should be fed only as treats. Applaws, Encore (made by MPM products) and many other shredded foods are not complete. Some also contain rice but say 'grain free'.

If you buy shredded foods please check it is complete. Blink, Meowing Heads and others cost more but are nutritionally balanced.

This is a particular annoyance to me because the stuff is marketed as being good, when it is not a balanced regular food. It's a con.

TinyKitty · 02/04/2023 12:07

TheGoogleMum · 02/04/2023 08:42

Can I jump on to this thread to ask if there's a good food for overweight cats? On vets advice we feed purina veterinary obesity (I do buy from zooplus, we have tried some of the lesser known brands but my cats got very fat!). My cats are indoor, we have some hairball issues that aren't too bad with current food, and in the summer they sometimes struggle with cystitis.
I like the idea of the subscription ones but not sure they are specialist enough?

You don't need specialist food, just less. Weighloss must be slow to avoid loss of body condition. It does take a long time.
High meat content food like the ones I mentioned above. Find out the weight of your cat, and how much he/she needs to lose, get some baby scales if you don't have any.
I am doing this currently, have been since last year.

Vets are brainwashed to sell you 'special' foods. Many of them are higher fat where they should be normal food, but high meat content, close to a natural cat diet.

My cat is small and was being overfed before I got her. She was already on the good quality food, as soon as she came home I put her on Animonda Carny, then ordered a selection from Zooplus. She looks a lot less like a blob now. Also play, lots of excercise and treats come out of the daily allowance.

Absolutely No Dry food, it is too high carb, even the better ones, cats need liquid in their diet.

BillyAteMyChips · 02/04/2023 10:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sunshineandrainbow · 02/04/2023 10:27

NamechangeAprilFool · 02/04/2023 07:58

I’ve started buying the small bags in the three bag selection @Sunshineandrainbow.

I’d bought the 6.5kg bags for a few years. It lasts forever, I think a bag lasts me about four months. I now order 3 lots of the trios which lasts a bit less time /costs a bit more but it’s still good value.

Agree it lasts such a long time.
I love the trio bags too.
Had a delivery this week and tried the chicken and fish variety.
It def fills my ginger boy up, he loves the lamb and boar variety, bit random flavours but obviously works.
I must leave a review actually as been using it for years and not a brand often heard of.
Delivery is so quick too from zooplus.

Try the trio mixed pack op. It is so good. And I don't worry too. Much about the quality of wet food I give as this is so high quality.

www.zooplus.co.uk/shop/cats/dry_cat_food/purizon

ThinWomansBrain · 02/04/2023 09:11

Thoroughly recommend Zooplus - have used them for years, always excellent value.
My cat loves cosma -high meat content, the chicken is just - chicken, it doesn't look like cat food at all. For dried food, she has concept for life.

pottydimley · 02/04/2023 08:58

Novatherova · 01/04/2023 20:55

Hi I currently have one female pedigree cat who is 2. She is the light of my life who I love very much.

She was on Royal Canin Intense Beauty wet and dry food which was £13.50 for 12 pouches and then the dry when I ran out.

Due to cost of living Pets at Home put Price up to £16.49 for 12. My DP asked me to change the food due to how expensive.

I put her on Purina One and then Purina Mon Petit. For 48 pouches it was £18 on another website.

Since changing her coat has gone downhill and she now also has dandruff. Her fur looks shabby and I feel v guilty.

I want to put her back on Royal Canin. I also pay fee 22 per month to vets for all consultations, flea, vacs etc plus 17 for insurance. So it all adds up.

I pay it all out my wages. If I put her back on Royal Canin I won't be able to adopt a cat.

Wedding and baby on the way so I need to minimise costs. But I can't justify cutting her food that makes her healthy. When she was on it she glowed.

But my DP is adamant. I will ignore him and do what I want as I say its my money. But want other opinions??

My two love this Purina and the vet always comments on the quality of their coats https://www.petsathome.com/shop/en/pets/gourmet-natures-creations-wet-cat-food-chicken-and-turkey-multipack-8x85g?weight=680g?utmsource=google&utmmmedium=cpc&utmcampaign=googleeshopping&cmmmc=GoogleeCPCPC--%20googleeshopping--googleeshopping&ita=1976&ito=googleshopping&istCompanyId=7255ccad-a1fc-4729-af31-478f79e5071c&istFeedId=385e6b9a-8b03-4076-a8bb-e4737df8549c&istItemId=imrxmlapm&istBid=t&cqqsrc=googleads&cqqcmp=19029649874&cqterm=&cqqplac=&cqnet=g&cqqplt=gp&gclid=Cj0KCQjwz6ShBhCMARIsAH9A0qWB9YOfoC3e4dfcjLbH4XGFZPJttBU49gvj8EWfPp1wfxysqEJfuUaAlO6EALw_wcB&gclsrc=aw.ds

TheGoogleMum · 02/04/2023 08:42

Can I jump on to this thread to ask if there's a good food for overweight cats? On vets advice we feed purina veterinary obesity (I do buy from zooplus, we have tried some of the lesser known brands but my cats got very fat!). My cats are indoor, we have some hairball issues that aren't too bad with current food, and in the summer they sometimes struggle with cystitis.
I like the idea of the subscription ones but not sure they are specialist enough?