Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely furious/heartbroken about SILs baby name choice?

805 replies

CarinaBee · 01/04/2023 19:10

I set up a new account for this, lots of identifying points here but here goes. I am fully prepared to be told that I have no right to influence the name someone chooses for their baby. but to preface, I feel sick to my stomach over this.

my DH is a twin. His sister is known to be somewhat difficult in the family. Bit of a diva, tends to get her own way. She’s 38. We get on ok but she’s quite possessive of DH and likes to see him alone every now and then. Fine by me but does get a little tiring to hear how being a twin eclipses everything and you couldn’t possibly understand if you don’t have one. I can let a lot slide - the fairly frequent requests for money from DH for one thing. They have 2 other brothers. I get on very well with MIL but we’ve had previous incidents where SIL has been jealous because I’ve seen MIL without her for example. They’re close and good luck to them, I’m not trying to ‘steal’ your Mum from you.

DH’s family are a very close supportive unit and I admire that. By comparison, I had one sister and our mother was an unpleasant alcoholic. Mercifully I had my sister who was 7 years older than me and filled every gap left where Mum didn’t.

long story short, she died after a short but awful illness in 2006 leaving behind 2 very small children. I lived with her during her illness and was finally able to repay the devotion, love and care she always showed me. until my daughter came along 2 years ago, I don’t think I have ever matched the love I feel for her and I will long for her until the day I die.

my SIL has had a baby girl and she’s chosen the same name as my sister. I won’t share it here because it is identifying but know that it is not a common name by any stretch of the imagination. She has 2 sons and now “finally has her girl” and has apparently always wanted to use this name. first I’ve heard of it.

DH told me after he got off the phone and it made me sick to my stomach. He wasn’t prepared to say anything but I didn’t ask him to. Disappointed he didn’t though. I said to MIL that I am devastated but didn’t make a fuss and said I wouldn’t mention to SIL. She told her and all he’ll broke loose. It was 20 years ago, I need to let go and I don’t own the name.

dH and I have been having problems lately and frankly this feels like the final straw. I am the least demanding person - actually probably lean towards being more of a people pleaser, prefer an easy life. But this is too much. I have never shaken the feeling of how cheated my beautiful sister was in life and it’s just so hurtful. There are endless girls names to choose from.

OP posts:
Nandocushion · 02/04/2023 04:12

I also feel - though obviously I wasn't there - that the conversation you report about not wanting to use the name, sounds exactly that - a conversation about why YOU didn't want to use the name. Not a statement on your part about why no one else should use it, not even SIL. I'm sorry OP. I agree with a PP that grief counselling can be a big help.

Nandocushion · 02/04/2023 04:06

Aquamarine1029 · 01/04/2023 19:33

Sorry, op, but I don't see how Camilla is so unusual and why it isn't possible that your SIL has always loved the name. I know two adult Camilla's and two who are children. One of whom was just born this past November.

Obviously, your sister-in-law doesn't have the emotional connection to your sister that you do, and may not have realised it would be such an issue. I do think your reaction has been influenced by your relationship with her, because it's clear you don't like this woman to begin with. I'm very sorry about your sister.

I also don't want to rub salt into your wounds OP but I actually knew four Camillas when I lived in the UK. It was absolutely a common name, at least in my circle, and it wouldn't occur to me to think anyone had named their child that for any reason except that they liked it and it was regular.

lemmein · 02/04/2023 03:33

What a weird thread. Not you OP, I can understand your feelings, however I think you're massively overreacting, though I can understand why. But the posters calling your SIL a bitch and a cunt - WTF? It's highly unlikely she has named her baby Camilla to spite you, women...mums don't do that, they don't saddle their newborn with a name they're not fussed on just to piss off an in-law.

I lost my brother when he was 29. I doubt my in-laws would even know his name - if he was ever mentioned in their circle (which I doubt he ever has been) it would be 'lemmeins brother' - not by his actual name. I would never expect my in-laws, or anyone really to have the same associations with his name as I do.

I think your feelings towards your DH's twin is probably heavily influencing your feelings on this - do you really believe she has named her precious baby just to annoy you? Or do you think it's more likely that she just didn't think? If she wasn't in your life when your sister was alive it's likely your sister doesn't even enter her head when she hears the name.

I too think you would benefit from some grief counselling on this, you're not being unreasonable, you feel how you feel, you can't help that - but it does sound like it's still very raw for you despite the years that have past.

I'm truly sorry for your loss - it's nearly 20 years since we lost my brother, it still stings Flowers

JudgeRudy · 02/04/2023 03:26

Whilst l feel sorry that you're devastated I'm struggling to work out why. I don't understand why you wouldn't want anyone to use that name? Or is it just your SIL? At what stage will the name become available again? It's not dishonering your sister and SILs not insinuating it's linked in any way to her. It's not a common name but it's hardly rare. I know 2 Camillas, one around 50, one around 30, plus Queen Camilla herself. I bet the name will see a rise in popularity for a bit.

I think you're being unreasonable. Also I would imagine your BIL (SILs OH) has a say in this too and they're both agreed on the name. Did you even know your SIL when your sister was alive? There's no link at all. They just like the name. You weren't aware she liked the name, why would you be. Are you are of the names your other SIKs might like? This is something you generally discuss with a partner you're planning on having a baby with, possibly in ousting with a school friend.
Do you genuinely think your SIL has deliberately chosen a name she ordinarily wouldn't have chosen simply to get one over on you? Do you see how that sounds? Or maybe you feel as a relative shecshould not choose a name you haven't approved?
As I said, I'm sorry you feel this way and I'm sorry your sister died but that's yours to deal with.

HoppingPavlova · 02/04/2023 03:01

@EnterChasedByAMemory And did those posters who were rushing to say that it’s just a name, not see the part where OP mentioned that her SIL personalised items of clothing in a different name which was why even OP’s MIL was confused because obviously anyone would think when seeing the personalised items clothing that that is the name her SIL is going to choose? And then suddenly she’s done a U-turn and is saying a completely different name is the name she has chosen and the one she wanted all along.

And? Who cares? Maybe she had a name initially but with all the coronation hoo haa, though ‘hmmm, actually, I like Camilla better’. Why isn’t someone entitled to do that? A lot of people tend to lived one’s graves and whatnot. That doesn’t equate to no one ever mentioning that name in their presence. I can’t imagine how/why OP’s DH would ‘have a word’ with his sister.

user1492757084 · 02/04/2023 02:52

No wonder you are upset.
Your SIL has brought back sad memories.

Though because Camilla has been the name of a person in the press and is a very lovely name it is quite possible that your SIL has always been aware of it and loved it. I could believe that.
She, as you said, discussed whether you would ever use the name and you replied 'no'.
Your SIL doesn't have the same sad connection to your beloved sister's beautiful name.

The baby niece has a truly terrific name and you really have no choice but to welcome her into the family and learn about her and love her.
There will be many Camilla's in coming years in recognition of King Charles and his chosen Queen Camilla. (who has proven to be interested in and supportive of many charitable women's causes.)

EnterChasedByAMemory · 02/04/2023 02:34

Some posters on here are really something. I know this is on AIBU, but still Sad

Yes nobody owns a name and everyone deals with difficult memories and experiences differently. And did those posters who were rushing to say that it’s just a name, not see the part where OP mentioned that her SIL personalised items of clothing in a different name which was why even OP’s MIL was confused because obviously anyone would think when seeing the personalised items clothing that that is the name her SIL is going to choose? And then suddenly she’s done a U-turn and is saying a completely different name is the name she has chosen and the one she wanted all along.

Also, OP mentioned that her in-laws know that she mentions putting flowers etc on her sister’s grave and even has her sister’s picture in her living room so surely her SIL would know that of all names, she would avoid the name that will hurt OP the most?

It’s not like others cannot use the name but when it’s her DH’s twin sister who shows she’s very close to her brother, then of course it will hit different.

OP, as said before, perhaps your DH can speak to his sister? She might have a chance of heart.

HoppingPavlova · 02/04/2023 02:24

You are being over the top ridiculous. There are going to be tens of thousands of girls with that name coming along and you are going to hear it endlessly via the press. It’s just a name, it’s not the person you love.

I have someone very close and dear to me die around fifty years ago now, I was an older teen at the time. I’m still gutted all this time after as they were my world. All this time later, I’d be lucky to have a week where I didn’t shed a quiet tear in private because I still miss them so much. But they didn’t own a name. That name is not all they were. A young family member gave the name to their child within the last decade, not as a tribute but it’s a name they liked, and I think it’s fabulous and it always makes me smile when I hear it. You are going to be in for a hard life if you try and control people like this.

BertaHoon · 02/04/2023 02:23

Unfortunately Camilla is not that unusual.

As well as Queen you have Camilla Cabello. Camilla from Love Island 🙄 and I know of 2 at DDs school.

I expected to hear it was something almost unheard of. So yes YABU on one hand, however YANBU for feeling hurt.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 02/04/2023 02:07

allmyliesaretrue · 02/04/2023 01:45

Her husband is!!

The responses here show so clearly how sadly selfish and entitled society has become!! Camilla is not a 'mainstream' name - I'm 60 and I've ever only known one, at school!! Not sure I'd want the connotations around the same either?

If the new Camilla's parents don't care about the upset it causes you following the loss of your sister Camilla - then you need to do whatever it takes to enable you to deal with it x

I’m absolutely failing to see why blood matters. If SIL is a cunt surely BIL is a cunt for the same reasons of insensitivity? Very weird to suggest eh isn’t because he isn’t blood related to anyone.

Camilla is very much a well known name and growing in popularity

McSlowburn · 02/04/2023 02:04

OP I've stayed up late reading your posts and it's almost had me in tears.

I'm so, so sorry you're in this awful situation and you absolutely have every right to feel devastated.

There are a number of posters strongly siding with you who's numbers are too much for me to quote, but of course YANBU. You've unfortunately married into a family with a completely toxic SIL.

My advice is to stand your ground - it's just very important IMO that, for the sake of your future relationship with your in-laws, that you make it very clear that what your SIL has done is completely unacceptable. Good luck Flowers

Fifi1010 · 02/04/2023 01:58

allmyliesaretrue · 02/04/2023 01:45

Her husband is!!

The responses here show so clearly how sadly selfish and entitled society has become!! Camilla is not a 'mainstream' name - I'm 60 and I've ever only known one, at school!! Not sure I'd want the connotations around the same either?

If the new Camilla's parents don't care about the upset it causes you following the loss of your sister Camilla - then you need to do whatever it takes to enable you to deal with it x

The thing is how close is OP and the SIL really? I wouldn't know a thing about SILs siblings or deep family history we aren't close at all. I don't know their names we don't really communicate if I decided to call a baby the name of SILs relative who passed 20 years ago it would because I liked the name not because of evil motives. It's a DH problem really he should be saying to his sister that OPs sister was called the same name and she's finding it difficult with this and it's brought back memories etc.

Fifi1010 · 02/04/2023 01:53

BignBootiful · 01/04/2023 23:44

Even if the name wasn't unusual, say if it was Anna, it would still to my mind be a rogue move by the SIL. It would be disrespectful and insensitive. I can't imagine myself doing such a thing. Would you?

I'm not even sure of my SILs siblings names we aren't close.

DoggoCEO · 02/04/2023 01:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

allmyliesaretrue · 02/04/2023 01:50

Names can be fraught and are best kept to yourselves until baby is born.

My parents had chosen a name for their DS (not that they knew it was going to be a DS in the 70s). My mum stupidly told her friend and of course, friend's DS was born first and got the name my parents wanted. Sadly our sibling died as an infant. We all considered naming our children after our late baby brother but none of us did.

allmyliesaretrue · 02/04/2023 01:45

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 02/04/2023 01:36

SIL isn’t a blood relative to OP or her sister.

Her husband is!!

The responses here show so clearly how sadly selfish and entitled society has become!! Camilla is not a 'mainstream' name - I'm 60 and I've ever only known one, at school!! Not sure I'd want the connotations around the same either?

If the new Camilla's parents don't care about the upset it causes you following the loss of your sister Camilla - then you need to do whatever it takes to enable you to deal with it x

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 02/04/2023 01:36

allmyliesaretrue · 02/04/2023 00:47

He clearly is, but he's not a blood relative!

SIL isn’t a blood relative to OP or her sister.

EnterChasedByAMemory · 02/04/2023 01:28

CarinaBee · 01/04/2023 19:59

MIL called me and said “I’m so sorry, I thought she was calling her ** and she even had personalised items made in that name”. It was at this point that I admitted it had really thrown me.

She died at 26 - it was harrowing and unfathomable, taking 6 months from diagnosis. I have a photo out of her in our lounge and she is young and vibrant in it and it is shocking, everyone remarks on it when they visit because death at a young age when you are most ‘alive’ is particularly poignant. I famously pop flowers on her grave every Xmas morning (and every significant date) and join the family afterwards. it’s not a secret that she was once alive and is actually a real person and SIL is just not aware.

At first I wasn’t sure because the name isn’t that uncommon and all Royal Family members names are usually quite popular and fairly commonplace.

But after reading this, it seems to me that that your DH needs to talk to his twin sister. She clearly dotes on him and may listen to him.

It’s odd to personalise items of clothing in one name and then decide to name a baby a different name that clearly has sentimental values and impacts someone so emotionally and then say that is the name they wanted all along. Then why personalise things in an another name? Confused

pizzaHeart · 02/04/2023 01:25

Aquamarine1029 · 01/04/2023 19:33

Sorry, op, but I don't see how Camilla is so unusual and why it isn't possible that your SIL has always loved the name. I know two adult Camilla's and two who are children. One of whom was just born this past November.

Obviously, your sister-in-law doesn't have the emotional connection to your sister that you do, and may not have realised it would be such an issue. I do think your reaction has been influenced by your relationship with her, because it's clear you don't like this woman to begin with. I'm very sorry about your sister.

agree with this^ .
I’m really sorry about your sister. It’s a big tragedy when someone is leaving so young and so full of life. And it’s very very unfair.
But it’s nothing to do with your SIL and her baby girl. I think you are unfair to her.
You’ve asked where you draw the line. Some people in your situation would choose the name for their children, some don’t. Everyone remembers differently. The line is that it’s a personal choice and no one is allowed to judge. However your SIL is out of this equation completely.

AngeloMysterioso · 02/04/2023 01:16

CarinaBee · 02/04/2023 00:25

Yes I tolerate her coming for money when she’s squandered hers irresponsibly on handbags and Louboutins when she has children to feed. Yes I tolerate her flying off the handle when I take my MIL for a birthday lunch because she wasn’t invited even though she was at work. Yes I tolerate her when she takes my husband out on his actual birthday when surely I might want to spend time with him and we might have plans?

I’m good at ‘tolerating’!

So, you’re allowed to have a birthday lunch with her mother but she isn’t allowed to have a birthday lunch (on what is also her birthday) with your DH- who could presumably have declined if you had plans? Oh but whereas you’re an easy-going people pleaser you generously describe your DH (also a people pleaser) as “spineless”. So it’s ok when you do it but when she does it becomes another example in the lengthy list you’ve given us of reasons why she’s a crappy person.

My point is, you want her to care enough about you and value you enough that she wouldn’t choose a name she loved for her child, and treat it as “sacred” and off-limits for your sake. Whereas you only “tolerate” her and have gone to some lengths to describe her many faults and failings without saying one single positive. You clearly look down on her and dislike her a great deal and you still would even if she hadn’t chosen that name. If anything, it sounds like you’d be glad of an excuse to chop her out of your life for good. Personally I think it would be a real pity if something like a baby’s name becomes the thing that results in a wedge being driven into a family.

allmyliesaretrue · 02/04/2023 01:08

I posted yesterday about my bitch SIL who after a family relationship with her for very many years, and having been married to her brother (her only sibling) for more than 20 years, as well as being the mother of her only blood nephews, nieces, and with her having insisted on being bridesmaid at our wedding before we had a chance to ask her, chose not to invite me to her wedding making the excuse of small numbers (although she never shared that with me) while inviting their cousin and her husband, who hadn't been in the family for a fraction of the time that I had. H was invited, but not me, and not our children. Still hold it against H many years later that he didn't see the snub, and he went.

I didn't give a shit about not going - I'd long seen her for what she is - but it was the principle of the thing, and the fact that H didn't, and still can't, see the snub against me and our children,

Considering all my experience and what I've read here, I am done. I've always felt obligated to 'like' all the FB posts about their wonderful late mother (she wasn't wonderful to me or to her grandchildren!!) or all the look at me posts, tagging herself at X or Y hospital, and waiting for the "omg are you ok hun?" messages!

LunaTheCat · 02/04/2023 01:06

OP I have lost a much loved sister in her 40’s… I know the pain and sadness and total feeling disbelief.
Others can sometimes be thoughtless… their pain is not yours and they are removed a bit.
it is not this child’s fault.. nor is it MIL.
When something occurs which I feel hurt about I ask myself “ What would she do” ? She was a person full of grace and love and I would want to honour that.
I don’t want to hold onto anger because I want to honour her memory.
Maybe think about honouring your sister too and doing something lovely in her memory.
Much love to you.

SerafinasGoose · 02/04/2023 01:05

CarinaBee · 02/04/2023 00:29

And yes I tolerate her accusations that I visit their elderly widowed aunt who lives alone that she “will be left out of the will” with heavy undertones that these are my motives.

i could go on and on. But it’s not helpful. I’m not here to drip feed because those examples don’t really matter, I am incredibly skilled at rising above bullshit that doesn’t serve me. But this is a step too far.

thanks so much for all the comments, greatly appreciate it. I won’t be posting again.

I'm so sorry about the tragic loss of your beautiful sister 💕

toomuchlaundry · 02/04/2023 00:55

I’d be moving and not seeing them that often

Cookiecrumblepie · 02/04/2023 00:51

OP your SIL is very insensitive. Please stop being so nice to her in future and just go completely cold. Don’t help with her children, don’t go over all the time, grey rock her and focus instead in your own life and happiness. Let her spent 100% of her time with your husband if she wants it. Just cut her out emotionally and move on with your life. Never share anything personal with your SIL or MIL in future, speak only of the weather and food.

Swipe left for the next trending thread