Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anybody else renting feel constant pressure to buy

63 replies

Canyoureadmymind · 01/04/2023 10:41

I'm in my early 30s and I feel anxiety most days about the fact that I don't yet own a house. I'm saving but I've currently got £400 in my savings, that's not going to get me very far. It'll be a good few years before I could even own something very small or a shared ownership property. Then, it's actually being accepted for a property.
I feel like I 'should' be owning by this age which is stupid, but most of my peers seem to be, apart from the ones that live in London.
There are constant cries of what will you do in retirement. So that's another stressor, worrying that I might end up homeless.
There's a chance I could inherit property/gain an inheritance at some point in the distant future.
I'm sick of feeling this constant pressure and anxiety. I wish renting were more socially acceptable and viable long term.

OP posts:
Abyss23 · 01/04/2023 14:49

@goldenotter your friends don't sound like very nice people. Might be time to find some new friends who don't make you feel like this.

goldenotter · 01/04/2023 14:48

@Mypatioisminging I've moved on from many of those people now TBH, life is too short. Couldn't handle it anymore. I felt there was a "let them eat cake" situation going on, constantly judged and made to feel less of a person for not having the same amount of money as them. Really sad - they were really stuck in their paradigm of entitlement belittling me because I didn't own a property and was poor. I suspect there was also some judgement because I am a single parent as well - and I work harder than anyone I know! :(

whirlyhead · 01/04/2023 14:46

I’m in the process of selling my house, moving overseas and renting. I’m quite happy not to own a house for a while. I don’t have any kids to leave anything to so that’s not an issue. At certain periods in your life renting works.

I replaced my boiler ten years ago and it cost about £6000. When you have to move pipe work etc it does get very expensive.

Greenfairydust · 01/04/2023 14:44

But I think there are many reasons why renting is not general seen as a good option in this country.

  • we have a lack of affordable, social housing so most people have to rent from private landlords
  • private renting comes with a lot of issues: more renters than available properties so competition is fierce; landlords don't always maintain their properties well; you have no long term security as your landlord might decide to sell at any time; you can't decorate as you wish and often you cannot have pets
  • renting is ridiculously expensive in so many places. I am about to buy a house after selling my flat and renting while the purchase process takes place. My mortgage on a terraced house will be less than what I currently paid in rent on a 1 bed flat which is frankly bonkers...

I think people who are making these comments to you are just being realistic: you really don't want to be at the mercy of landlords & letting agents all your life and find yourself in trouble as you get older and don't have a secure roof over your head.

In many other countries renting is a perfectly good, normal option but in the UK the rental market is too much of a minefield.

Mypatioisminging · 01/04/2023 14:43

goldenotter · 01/04/2023 14:39

@Abyss23 so many comments, about how "studenty" my flat is, looking down their noses at my (admittedly horrible) woodchip etc... snidey comments etc. I am not bitter about their handouts just upset that they don't get that I haven't had the same opportunity to buy that they have but they are insinuating that I have somehow passed up the opportunity when the truth couldn't be more different. Almost like it's somehow a choice that I haven't bought, never recognising that they only did it due to help from their parents and couldn't have without. Unless you've been in the situation I guess you wouldn't understand. I'm glad that you don't look down your nose at friends.

I think it’s just really unfortunate that’s your social circle. I’m mine not one person had a parental handout. It’s the opposite. You must socialise with folks who come from very wealthy backgrounds if their families are all giving them these massive handouts.

Gwenhwyfar · 01/04/2023 14:40

"Tenants barely have any rights in the UK. It's all welIl and good thinking you've got a cushy set-up, but what happens if you're given two months' notice to leave? Then you're suddenly at the mercy of the rental market. It's a completely insecure way to live."

This never bothered me when I lived in the UK. I would have just found somewhere else and in many years of renting I never had major problems with landlords.
I now live in a country with much stronger tenants' rights. I can only be thrown out if the LL decides to occupy the place himself and the rent can only be increased in line with inflation. Even so, state pensions are not high enough to pay rent and have a life so I'm still going to have to ask the bank whether they'll give me a mortgage despite having absolutely no interest in things like maintenance or making improvements. I'd be a reluctant owner, but I think it's probably the right way to go.
I'm much older than you though OP and it's now or never for me.

goldenotter · 01/04/2023 14:39

@Abyss23 so many comments, about how "studenty" my flat is, looking down their noses at my (admittedly horrible) woodchip etc... snidey comments etc. I am not bitter about their handouts just upset that they don't get that I haven't had the same opportunity to buy that they have but they are insinuating that I have somehow passed up the opportunity when the truth couldn't be more different. Almost like it's somehow a choice that I haven't bought, never recognising that they only did it due to help from their parents and couldn't have without. Unless you've been in the situation I guess you wouldn't understand. I'm glad that you don't look down your nose at friends.

Mypatioisminging · 01/04/2023 14:38

Gwenhwyfar · 01/04/2023 14:36

" A pp said the would rather save or put the money into a pension than pay a mortgage, but for many a mortgage would be less than the rent,"

Exactly. It's not as if renters have loads of money to invest in other things.

Exactly, generally people rent as they can’t afford to buy. Not always but in the majority, the rent nearly always costs more than the mortgage, so what money is the poster referring to in the main. Unless they think there is a lot of wealthy renters who rent as a lifestyle choice

Gwenhwyfar · 01/04/2023 14:36

" A pp said the would rather save or put the money into a pension than pay a mortgage, but for many a mortgage would be less than the rent,"

Exactly. It's not as if renters have loads of money to invest in other things.

Mypatioisminging · 01/04/2023 14:36

I think I saw on the news that private rental properties were now down 30 percent as in 30 percent less available and rent was up 11 percent.

more and more people when they face eviction can’t find another property in their location or budget. It’s very rare a private rental is a home for life, at some point eviction will occur, it’s 100 percent guaranteed. It is not if, it is when.

council houses are different, folks are given them as they are unable to afford to rent a suitable property privately, and they are secure tenancies in the main for that reason. Private rental is a very different animal.

so buying is the more secure option, every single time. Not completely secure because you still need to be able to pay the mortgage, but your destiny is in your own hands and not at the whim of a landlord and there decision to sell or not.

in addition once the mortgage is paid off, it’s likely the money has been recouped in equity increase. So the net cost is really the cost to maintain, in your own home you need to pay, in a rental it’s built into the rental costs and you pay whether it’s spent in the time of your tenancy or not.

pixie5121 · 01/04/2023 14:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

pixie5121 · 01/04/2023 14:21

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Mypatioisminging · 01/04/2023 14:19

Bonjovispjs · 01/04/2023 13:41

I'm 56 and have always rented. I read recently about a new boiler costing £8000 to replace and just thought thank God I don't own a place and have to fork out for things like that. I've been in my current flat for almost 11 years, my landlady is absolutely lovely and has never put the rent up in that time and I've had a new boiler that didn't cost me a penny 😊 As long as you're happy where you are OP, then don't take any notice of what anyone else says.

Even for a high end boiler it’s about 2 or 3 grand max, you do and have paid for the boiler, it’s not a gift. It comes out of your rent. The rent covers all costs , and makes the landlord a profit or pays their mortgage, that’s why it costs more to rent than a mortgage, the additional costs are to cover all costs to maintain inc new boiler etc, decoration, carpeting, whatever .

its great your happy but it’s important the information isn’t misleading.

Pottedpalm · 01/04/2023 14:18

Ok, so renters don’t fork out for the new boiler, but neither do they ever own the property. A pp said the would rather save or put the money into a pension than pay a mortgage, but for many a mortgage would be less than the rent, it’s often getting the deposit together that is the problem.
It really grieves me that DD rented properties for 13 years, paying up to £1400 a month for a one bed flat.so thats in excess of £150,000 that could have been paying for a property she would own. Renting should be avoided at all costs, in my opinion.

Keepthefaith99 · 01/04/2023 14:17

I’m early 40s and rent a house in an area I could never afford to buy in. I have no children but love my life here… I couldn’t afford to buy anything like where I live so enjoying it while I can!
Yes, I get the ‘oh are you still renting?’ comments. I usually find nodding and smiling sees them off.

RudsyFarmer · 01/04/2023 14:13

When I was renting I never felt like I was throwing away my money. I was buying a roof over my head and had the advantage of others being responsible for repairs.

i could also move away from bad neighbours, redevelopments that stole my view, towards jobs and fun. I thought it was a plus to be honest!!

WeAreAllLionesses · 01/04/2023 14:10

I looked at my pension forecast recently and my first thought was thank god we weren't renting as mortgage will be paid off by then.

So yes, good for those people with decent landlords. But it doesn't change the fact that a) you'll still be paying out to live somewhere well after you retire and b) despite all those months / years / decades of payments, you still won't own anything.

For me it would be a nightmare scenario. I appreciate that's not the same for everybody though.

Abyss23 · 01/04/2023 14:02

I feel pretty judged by friends tbh. All of them had handouts from parents to help them buy, partners in on the mortgage etc and wouldn't have been able to do it without the handouts. But I still feel they are insinuating I am somehow responsible for that fact that I don't own yet. If I'd had a handout things would be different.

Do you have any examples of your friends justifying you? Anything concrete or is it just you thinking that there's an insinuation? I'd certainly never judge any friend that was renting. What difference does it make to me?

If you don't mind me saying, you sound a little bitter about the "handouts" etc.

MidnightMeltdown · 01/04/2023 13:56

Bonjovispjs · 01/04/2023 13:41

I'm 56 and have always rented. I read recently about a new boiler costing £8000 to replace and just thought thank God I don't own a place and have to fork out for things like that. I've been in my current flat for almost 11 years, my landlady is absolutely lovely and has never put the rent up in that time and I've had a new boiler that didn't cost me a penny 😊 As long as you're happy where you are OP, then don't take any notice of what anyone else says.

The trouble is, for every story like this, there are stories about people being evicted from homes that they've lived in for years, struggling to find places, and facing soaring rents during retirement.

Some people (particularly those with kids) don't earn enough to save, and are stuck, but if you do, then I don't think that burying your head in the sand is a good strategy.

I don't rent, but I was renting at 30, and the only people who pressured me to buy were my parents. You are interpreting it as judgemental, but it's more likely coming from a place if concern.

goldenotter · 01/04/2023 13:47

Oh and i really wish that I could have more control over the decor. I have woodchip paper and horrid gross carpets that I can't change. That for me is one of the worst things. So depressing but the landlord won't change them.

goldenotter · 01/04/2023 13:45

yes definitely but as a single parent on one part time wage and tax credits in a very expensive area I am not sure that it will be possible any time soon. I've tried to accept it. Doesn't mean that I find it easy.

I feel pretty judged by friends tbh. All of them had handouts from parents to help them buy, partners in on the mortgage etc and wouldn't have been able to do it without the handouts. But I still feel they are insinuating I am somehow responsible for that fact that I don't own yet. If I'd had a handout things would be different.

A lot of inequality when it comes to housing in this country. Usually due to the inequality of wealth in our society as well as the low wage culture plus expensive housing unless you get inheritance or big deposits from mum and dad. Meaning some of us are pretty much shafted. Not to mention rent more expensive than buying in most cases making even harder to save.

Bonjovispjs · 01/04/2023 13:41

I'm 56 and have always rented. I read recently about a new boiler costing £8000 to replace and just thought thank God I don't own a place and have to fork out for things like that. I've been in my current flat for almost 11 years, my landlady is absolutely lovely and has never put the rent up in that time and I've had a new boiler that didn't cost me a penny 😊 As long as you're happy where you are OP, then don't take any notice of what anyone else says.

Girasoli · 01/04/2023 13:03

I feel so much pressure to buy (35, with 2DC) but it's pressure I put on my self, not anyone else pressuring me.

Tanaria · 01/04/2023 12:25

I wouldn't put people recommending to own in the UK down as snobbery and from what you've said, you feel a lot of (internal) pressure yourself to own, and that is down to you. You also made it clear that you couldn't own right now, so of course you are a bit defensive.

I come from a country in which renting is the norm and didn't want to own when I first came over to this country, but since then I've changed my mind, because I have been VERY unlucky with renting here - landlords who didn't do their jobs in maintaining the property, constant rent increases driving us out, in several cases section 21s (because I needed things fixing that never got done even though it was agreed or because they wanted to sell). It was never secure and in some cases unsafe. Every rental change came with more fees/ charges and every house move ended up costing around £1000; it was draining.

So I, too, wouldn't recommend to rent. Perhaps you were luckier. But if you were my friend I'd also recommend that you buy, simply because I've seen just how bad renting can be over here.

Canyoureadmymind · 01/04/2023 12:17

Thank you this has helped me so much. I'm sick to death of being made to feel that I'll be homeless or in poverty when I'm retired if I don't own.

OP posts: