Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you surrogacy is going to be liberalised thread 2

40 replies

VestaTilley · 01/04/2023 10:26

Hi everyone,

My original thread has run to 950 odd posts and 38 pages, so starting a new one. Thank you to all who have posted.

For those who didn’t see thread 1: the Law Commission are proposing to liberalise surrogacy laws in this country and make the commissioning parents - not the birth mother - the legal parents from birth.

I believe there are inherent problems with surrogacy and that it is a misogynistic and unethical practice. If you agree, please email your MP today and ask them to make representations to the PM and Health and Equalities Secretary against the new Bill.

https://www.lawcom.gov.uk/surrogacy-laws-to-be-overhauled-under-new-reforms-benefitting-the-child-surrogate-and-intended-parents/

Surrogacy laws to be overhauled under new reforms – benefitting the child, surrogate and intended parents - Law Commission

The Law Commission of England and Wales and the Scottish Law Commission have today published reforms for Government to improve outdated surrogacy laws. The use of surrogacy – where a woman becomes pregnant and gives birth to a child to be brought up by...

https://www.lawcom.gov.uk/surrogacy-laws-to-be-overhauled-under-new-reforms-benefitting-the-child-surrogate-and-intended-parents/

OP posts:
Equalitea · 02/04/2023 16:37

It’s so frustrating that news paper articles are stating that the surrogate could refuse consent up until the birth. This isn’t actually true, the bill states to withdraw consent the surrogate would need to do this via notifying the Regulated Surrogacy Organisation and one of the intended parents. If she decided 5 minutes before birth then how would this happen? What evidence would be necessary that both had been notified? Would read receipts be ok? A sent email? Would it need a bailiff to service papers like in other courts proceedings? The bill also states that unlike now where a surrogate must consent to the parental order the reform would give the judge to order without the surrogates consent. So even if consent was withdrawn the judge could still order it anyway 🤷‍♀️

The current system gives the surrogate 6 weeks before she can consent to the parental order, anoke time to consider things after the birth and if she doesn’t consent a parental order can’t be issued by a judge!

Equalitea · 02/04/2023 16:22

I came here looking for this, glad to see the template has already been posted.

FannyCann · 02/04/2023 13:07

Is it too hard to use google to find your MP? @lljkk

The last couple of paragraphs are fixed and can't be changed so if you use the template even if you cut and paste the final message will be to oppose the measures.
But do go ahead and add your voice to those who oppose the proposals.

lljkk · 02/04/2023 11:33

I support surrogacy as an option so thanks for the info so I know who to write to express my support for the changes.

OhHolyJesus · 02/04/2023 11:09

Here is media coverage on this to start us off on the right foot.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/apr/02/child-best-interests-not-desires-of-adults-should-be-at-heart-of-surrogacy

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/4535801e-cd70-11ed-adc8-dcfa63cb4163?shareToken=0c8a5360b7af820b8a23f630904c72b9

news.sky.com/story/couples-could-become-legal-parents-of-surrogate-babies-at-birth-under-new-proposals-12844591

As much of the ethical issues have already been discussed on thread 1, I'm going to try to stick to the content of the proposals and not get too distracted by pro-surrogacy lobbyists or those who are invested in the surrogacy industry and come with an agenda, but, as I said on the last thread, I welcome their thoughts on this as much as anyone else's.

nothingcomestonothing · 02/04/2023 09:59

I posted this towards the end of the last thread so it may have been missed, I was wondering if @Markasread would be able to respond?

But to take away PR automatically diminishes their power straight after delivery. This is not usually an issue - in the overwhelming majority of cases, the hours post birth are what the surrogate has done the entire pregnancy to see. They have the opportunity to witness the family they've created and it's a very special time. Once they've done that, they want to go back to their own families. They don't want to do any baby care whatever - I have never heard of or met anyone who does. However rarely surrogates find that there is an issue in the relationship between themselves and the ips. This doesn't mean they don't want to hand the baby over or necessarily that they regret the surrogacy. They really don't want to be in a position, in that rare outcome, where they feel like ips can just walk out of the room with the baby. They want the power to hand the baby over themselves when they feel ready to do so. It may sound like a small thing but the there is nothing a surrogate would hate more than not being in control of the timings post birth in the event that the relationship had become tense. The only thing they'd hate more would be the ips not turning up to collect the baby - hence the push for PR from birth for IPs.

So surrogates (if we assume they all feel the same) simultaneously want to retain PR and control the handover, and want the purchasers to have PR so they can't refuse the baby once it's born?

That makes no sense to me - if the purchasers have PR from birth, the surrogate will not then have control over the handover - the purchasers have PR, they can take the baby whenever they like. If that is what surrogates want, it's not possible under the law as I understand it - you have PR or you don't. If the purchasers have it, the surrogate cannot control the handover.

FannyCann · 02/04/2023 09:42

The template letter is very good imo as it speaks to the humanity of women, and the realities of pregnancy and childbirth.

It's a big topic and with a huge report and draft bill it can get overwhelming and difficult to focus on key issues. I think for MPs who haven't really thought about it much and for people generally who have been fed a diet of fluffy feel good stories via the media it's important to take a look at the other side to start thinking more deeply about the issues.

There are quite a few reasons why I oppose surrogacy but number one is that I feel so furious that this is something only women do, women are coached/expected to be kind and share the love. Who is being kind and thinking about what women go through to do this?
There's a podcast I have posted elsewhere featuring an Irish woman who was told at age 17 by her gynaecologist that she would never be able to have a baby. She didn't go into the reason but it would seem to be some congenital disorder. Anyway in the next breath the gynae (I think a female one) asked "have you any sisters?" before saying (I paraphrase) "well that's all right then, you can still have babies".

It filled me with rage. The nerve. How dare that woman assume the sisters will do this? I'll find the link and post it somewhere.
I have two daughters, as it happens neither of them show much likelihood of ever considering this level of a kindness to each other 😅 but I have told them under no circumstances to ask or to offer. A loving friend or sister wouldn't want to put their sibling/best friend at risk of harm in this way (including emotional harm). Don't tell me women aren't emotionally coerced within families to do this.

coffeeshopmusic · 02/04/2023 09:26

Clymene · 02/04/2023 09:06

Nordic Model Now have published their guidance to getting in touch with your MP

https://nmnow.org/supportwomen/finddyourmp

This is a better link (sorry I didn't see the post 🙈)

coffeeshopmusic · 02/04/2023 09:24

Just adding this link too that @FannyCann helpfully added in the last thread.

StopSurrogacyNowUK: stopsurrogacynowuk.org/

It includes template letters to send to your MP.

Clymene · 02/04/2023 09:06

Nordic Model Now have published their guidance to getting in touch with your MP

https://nmnow.org/supportwomen/finddyourmp

VestaTilley · 01/04/2023 17:48

No worries all! Am assuming the old one is now maxed out. I’ll be back tomorrow. Currently wrecked after DS’ birthday party 😂

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 01/04/2023 15:53

Thanks for the new thread

Clymene · 01/04/2023 15:49

Thanks for new thread Vesta

FannyCann · 01/04/2023 14:27

Thank you for the new thread Vesta

BlüeöysterCunt · 01/04/2023 13:18

Thanks for the new thread! Will continue to read with interest/disgust...