Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you surrogacy is going to be liberalised thread 2

40 replies

VestaTilley · 01/04/2023 10:26

Hi everyone,

My original thread has run to 950 odd posts and 38 pages, so starting a new one. Thank you to all who have posted.

For those who didn’t see thread 1: the Law Commission are proposing to liberalise surrogacy laws in this country and make the commissioning parents - not the birth mother - the legal parents from birth.

I believe there are inherent problems with surrogacy and that it is a misogynistic and unethical practice. If you agree, please email your MP today and ask them to make representations to the PM and Health and Equalities Secretary against the new Bill.

https://www.lawcom.gov.uk/surrogacy-laws-to-be-overhauled-under-new-reforms-benefitting-the-child-surrogate-and-intended-parents/

Surrogacy laws to be overhauled under new reforms – benefitting the child, surrogate and intended parents - Law Commission

The Law Commission of England and Wales and the Scottish Law Commission have today published reforms for Government to improve outdated surrogacy laws. The use of surrogacy – where a woman becomes pregnant and gives birth to a child to be brought up by...

https://www.lawcom.gov.uk/surrogacy-laws-to-be-overhauled-under-new-reforms-benefitting-the-child-surrogate-and-intended-parents/

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Equalitea · 12/04/2023 07:05

OhHolyJesus · 11/04/2023 21:41

This is such a reasonable and balanced piece - from James Kirkup:

twitter.com/jameskirkup/status/1645744619634712581?s=12

Agreed!

OhHolyJesus · 11/04/2023 21:41

This is such a reasonable and balanced piece - from James Kirkup:

twitter.com/jameskirkup/status/1645744619634712581?s=12

parmesansally · 07/04/2023 22:09

Wow, thank you for bringing this to our attention. I have emailed my MP

L3ThirtySeven · 07/04/2023 21:45

Equalitea · 07/04/2023 20:34

It will not empower independent surrogates to have more control. From what I understand independent surrogates will retire in droves.

There’s already such a small pool of surrogates in the U.K., I know that some IPs are conceded that it will further reduce their chances of finding a match, the reforms aren’t likely to improve that.
However, obviously now the reforms suggest lifting a ban on advertising so I suppose there could be a recruitment drive 🤦‍♀️ Oh I forgot, it’s not a job and there’s no compensation, like with egg donation 😬

That particular aspect will empower surrogate mothers as it’s what some of them want as an option. It is based on numerous surveys such as this recent one:

https://academic.oup.com/lawfam/article/36/1/ebac030/6917125?login=false

”What are surrogates’ views on their experience with surrogacy, their understanding of the law, and views on legal reform? We conducted an online retrospective survey of women who underwent treatment as gestational surrogates in two UK-regulated IVF centres between March 2014 and October 2021. Forty-seven surrogates responded outlining their experiences with surrogacy in the England/Wales legal context, their understandings of the law, and thoughts on potential law reform.”

”When asked for their views, most surrogates did not think they should be the legal mother at birth, nor did they consider themselves the mother. Thirty-four said they did not think that a surrogate should be the legal mother at birth, seven were undecided and four said that they thought surrogates should be the legal mother (reasons in Table 3).”

On what basis do you say they will “retire in droves”?

Issue Cover

UK surrogates’ characteristics, experiences, and views on surrogacy law reform

Abstract. What are surrogates’ views on their experience with surrogacy, their understanding of the law, and views on legal reform? We conducted an online retro

https://academic.oup.com/lawfam/article/36/1/ebac030/6917125?login=false

Equalitea · 07/04/2023 20:34

It will not empower independent surrogates to have more control. From what I understand independent surrogates will retire in droves.

There’s already such a small pool of surrogates in the U.K., I know that some IPs are conceded that it will further reduce their chances of finding a match, the reforms aren’t likely to improve that.
However, obviously now the reforms suggest lifting a ban on advertising so I suppose there could be a recruitment drive 🤦‍♀️ Oh I forgot, it’s not a job and there’s no compensation, like with egg donation 😬

L3ThirtySeven · 07/04/2023 14:09

The important thing to understand is that the allowing the intended parents to be legal parents from birth is being added as an option for the surrogate mothers to take up only if they want to do so. It’s not automatic. It’s not replacing the current process.

It’s based on the feedback from surrogate mothers that the current process has no options for them to choose from. It currently is such that the surrogate mother has to be the legal parent for a minimum of six weeks after birth. Not all surrogate mothers want this. This reform will empower surrogate mothers to have more control over their surrogacy pathway.

L3ThirtySeven · 07/04/2023 13:26

Equalitea · 07/04/2023 11:01

There’s so much wrong with what you’ve said, but I cba.

One point I will make is that if you read the recommendations about the surrogate being able to withdraw consent up until birth, you’ll have seen that in order for the surrogate to withdraw consent she must notify the regulated surrogacy agency (RSO) and atleast one IP.

Out of hours and without specifying what evidence may be necessary for notification (will a read receipt be ok or will it need to be court served) pray do tell how that would be possible if she decided to do so in labour? Or 5 minutes before the baby was born but couldn’t reach anyone?

Not that it matters because the reform recommendations also state that they wish for a judge to be able to order a PO without a surrogates consent anyway.

So even if she has previously given consent and manages to navigate the minefield and isn’t manipulated and coerced by ‘non for profit’ RSOs who can pay salaries (potentially large ones!), of withdrawal and it being accepted a judge can over rule her anyway, despite the baby potentially being genetically related to her.

It is true the specific details as to how a surrogate mother may withdraw her consent during birth are not specified in the law, which is a good thing because otherwise it would be too prescriptive and thus restrictive. As it reads, it requires only that the RSO and one IP be “notified” this usually means in law that the message must be sent to them. It doesn’t require acknowledgement of notification. I’m sure that a HCP can be told verbally by a labouring surrogate mother and the HCP could then pass on the notification.

If you look closer that the reform that allows the court to issue a PO without the consent of the surrogate mother, it clearly states this would only be allowable if the welfare of the child depends on it. So it’s not a case of the intended parents’ wishes trumping the surrogate mother’s wishes.

I think the potential for manipulation and coercion will be reduced from where they currently are by the new safeguarding that these reforms will put into place and by having state regulated RSOs with tighter regulations regarding surrogacy agreements.

I don’t see how “high salaries” of the professionals would be a minus (and the reforms don’t dictate salaries, this is your speculation). But let’s say if salaries were fairly high then surely you want professionals working for these RSOs, so you would want them to be paid a decent salary? Otherwise there is potential for corruption- ie brown envelopes from intended parents to employees of the RSOs.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/04/2023 11:36

VestaTilley · 07/04/2023 09:10

I wonder how the mother of Tom Daley’s new baby is faring.

The what?

Oh - you mean the gestation unit.

Ok, I expect. It's just a body part after all. Quick wipe down with a damp rag - be as good as new. 😠

Equalitea · 07/04/2023 11:01

L3ThirtySeven · 07/04/2023 09:10

The reforms are not actually liberalising surrogacy laws imho. They do more tightening up than liberalising.

They are adding safeguards with a pre-conception screening process and closing loopholes that are allowing commercialisation by the back door. They are also giving children the right to trace their surrogate mothers. The intended parents becoming legal parents at birth is being added as an option subject to the surrogate mothers consent- which she can withdraw anytime until birth. It’s not automatic and not the only option as some intended parents may still need a court PO per the old (and only ) way we have now.

To expand on the reforms which are designed to make domestic surrogacy safe from exploitation and discourage British intended parents from using international surrogacy options due to the high risk of exploitation that comes with going abroad:

  • Adding pre-conception screening and safeguarding measures to support surrogate mothers to prevent exploitation/coercion. These safeguards will be overseen by a state-regulated and approved body.
  • Only if the right conditions are met from the above prescreening would there be the option for the intended parents be parents of the child from birth, and only if the surrogate mother consents to it although she still has the ability to withdraw her consent until birth.
  • A clearer set of rules governing the payments that can be made to surrogate mothers, under which “for profit” commercial surrogacy would continue to be strictly prohibited. This will close loopholes currently in existence that encourage commercialisation.
  • Creation of a Surrogacy Register which would allow surrogate children to trace their birth origins later in life ending the trauma of children not being able to trace their surrogate mothers.
All the above from the link in the OP.

There’s so much wrong with what you’ve said, but I cba.

One point I will make is that if you read the recommendations about the surrogate being able to withdraw consent up until birth, you’ll have seen that in order for the surrogate to withdraw consent she must notify the regulated surrogacy agency (RSO) and atleast one IP.

Out of hours and without specifying what evidence may be necessary for notification (will a read receipt be ok or will it need to be court served) pray do tell how that would be possible if she decided to do so in labour? Or 5 minutes before the baby was born but couldn’t reach anyone?

Not that it matters because the reform recommendations also state that they wish for a judge to be able to order a PO without a surrogates consent anyway.

So even if she has previously given consent and manages to navigate the minefield and isn’t manipulated and coerced by ‘non for profit’ RSOs who can pay salaries (potentially large ones!), of withdrawal and it being accepted a judge can over rule her anyway, despite the baby potentially being genetically related to her.

VestaTilley · 07/04/2023 09:10

I wonder how the mother of Tom Daley’s new baby is faring.

OP posts:
L3ThirtySeven · 07/04/2023 09:10

The reforms are not actually liberalising surrogacy laws imho. They do more tightening up than liberalising.

They are adding safeguards with a pre-conception screening process and closing loopholes that are allowing commercialisation by the back door. They are also giving children the right to trace their surrogate mothers. The intended parents becoming legal parents at birth is being added as an option subject to the surrogate mothers consent- which she can withdraw anytime until birth. It’s not automatic and not the only option as some intended parents may still need a court PO per the old (and only ) way we have now.

To expand on the reforms which are designed to make domestic surrogacy safe from exploitation and discourage British intended parents from using international surrogacy options due to the high risk of exploitation that comes with going abroad:

  • Adding pre-conception screening and safeguarding measures to support surrogate mothers to prevent exploitation/coercion. These safeguards will be overseen by a state-regulated and approved body.
  • Only if the right conditions are met from the above prescreening would there be the option for the intended parents be parents of the child from birth, and only if the surrogate mother consents to it although she still has the ability to withdraw her consent until birth.
  • A clearer set of rules governing the payments that can be made to surrogate mothers, under which “for profit” commercial surrogacy would continue to be strictly prohibited. This will close loopholes currently in existence that encourage commercialisation.
  • Creation of a Surrogacy Register which would allow surrogate children to trace their birth origins later in life ending the trauma of children not being able to trace their surrogate mothers.
All the above from the link in the OP.
L3ThirtySeven · 07/04/2023 08:50

lljkk · 02/04/2023 11:33

I support surrogacy as an option so thanks for the info so I know who to write to express my support for the changes.

I support the surrogacy reforms as well and have sent a letter saying that to my MP.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/04/2023 08:34

Not sure why have have given a son a middle name of Rose. At least it's the middle name

The Daley-Black surrogacy was the subject of our coffee morning yesterday. Even woman who take no interest in gender critical/ trans matters were angry about it and saying "He knows what a woman is when he wants to buy a baby", and "How do they know it's a boy?" etc People are definitely becoming more aware - slowly, but are getting there.

A couple mentioned that the infant's middle name was Rose, but others said it was initially announced as Rose but was changed to Ray. I haven't looked myself, so I don't know what the child's name is.

FannyCann · 05/04/2023 20:49

Noted @Clymene
Reports I have seen don't say whether the baby was obtained in the U.K. or USA.
Anyway they'll have to get a parental order either way. Dustin LB was outraged when they brought Robby to the U.K. and despite him having Californian birth certificate (and I assume USA passport) in Oder for him to be a British citizen it was necessary for them to go through the courts and obtain a PO.
So they'll have to do same again.
And I hope they have been grinding teeth that the LC recommendations will still require babies obtained overseas to go through the courts to settle PO.

Not sure why have have given a son a middle name of Rose. At least it's the middle name.

Clymene · 05/04/2023 18:01

Have we seen that the biggest names in moving U.K. surrogacy towards a U.S. model, Messrs Black and Daley, have bought themselves a new baby?

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/04/2023 13:40

BTW - those people who are reading this and haven't read the account - it isn't his deafness that makes him unfit. There is a whole lot more to the situation which is more than worrying. Those poor babies.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/04/2023 13:38

Nor I, @MavisMcMinty - I think she was wrong to do so, but for the judge to compound that wrong by surrendering the babies to such an unfit father (in fact, the surrogacy agency shouldn't have accepted him) was appalling. Surely he could have used the fact that the "father" had wanted them aborted, and had failed to pay what he was contracted to pay, to allow them to stay with their mother? It's disgusting - these are children, not random Amazon parcels.

I'm worrying about those babies now, and I don't know them.

MavisMcMinty · 05/04/2023 13:32

JFC. What a nightmare. Not sure I’d’ve agreed to give (sell) a baby to a single deaf man though. Those poor, poor kids.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/04/2023 13:16

OhHolyJesus · 05/04/2023 09:23

This provides some testimonials of surrogate mothers (and the families they leave behind in death).

A truly tragic catelogue. The last thread had some anecdotes from women who had been surrogate mothers who had regret in different ways but this brings together a list which shared some horrors of how women as surrogate mothers can be treated.

These are US stories but their experiences are still relevant to the U.K. with the concept of a 'breeder class' and the element of control of the commissioning parents. Once you have a baby inside your body that 'belongs' to someone else the dynamic changes, the money is a catalyst.

www.legalizesurrogacywhynot.com/stories

Just reading these now - this one in particular is chilling.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/04/2023 12:56

FannyCann · 04/04/2023 09:57

Emailed my MP, haven't had a response yet but I'm hoping to book to go and see him later this month.

Do post if you have had a response from your MP, it will be interesting to see what they have to say.
A lot of labour MPs support surrogacy, at least in public, due to having one of their number (Liz Kendall) obtain a baby via surrogacy. I imagine she will be in favour of the proposals and doing her but to support them.

I haven't even had the courtesy of an acknowledgement of my e-mail from my MP (female, Labour).

She's a waste of space on many issues - either fobs off with a generalised reply and ignores specific questions, or ignores the e-mails altogether. Never gets into a discussion.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/04/2023 12:27

Thank you for the second thread , Vesta

OhHolyJesus · 05/04/2023 09:23

This provides some testimonials of surrogate mothers (and the families they leave behind in death).

A truly tragic catelogue. The last thread had some anecdotes from women who had been surrogate mothers who had regret in different ways but this brings together a list which shared some horrors of how women as surrogate mothers can be treated.

These are US stories but their experiences are still relevant to the U.K. with the concept of a 'breeder class' and the element of control of the commissioning parents. Once you have a baby inside your body that 'belongs' to someone else the dynamic changes, the money is a catalyst.

www.legalizesurrogacywhynot.com/stories

FannyCann · 04/04/2023 09:57

Emailed my MP, haven't had a response yet but I'm hoping to book to go and see him later this month.

Do post if you have had a response from your MP, it will be interesting to see what they have to say.
A lot of labour MPs support surrogacy, at least in public, due to having one of their number (Liz Kendall) obtain a baby via surrogacy. I imagine she will be in favour of the proposals and doing her but to support them.

FannyCann · 02/04/2023 17:40

Yes the proposed measures are very punitive (to the surrogate mother) @Equalitea

Currently the Parental Order hinges on consent from the SM who must give her consent freely and unconditionally.

This is why the parental Order was overturned in a groundbreaking recent case as the SM gave her consent conditionally on the basis of a contact order (which was then ignored by the CPs).

If the court will have the right to award a PO without the consent of the surrogate mother why bother asking? Just deliver the baby and the paperwork and it's a done deal.

It's also worth remembering that in the UK about 1/3 of surrogacy is using the SM's own eggs - so called "traditional" surrogacy. It seems SM's like it as they can just have artificial insemination in a clinic or do DIY insemination at home and don't have to go through IVF and hormone injections etc. I assume CPs like it as it is a lot cheaper without buying eggs and paying for IVF. So these women are the mother in EVERY way, by birth and genetics. Literally handing over their own baby. Many of these mothers do want loose ongoing contact - honoured family friend status sort of thing with occasional meet ups and it appears to work well in quite a few cases - hence the posters who come here to say what a lovely thing it was to do and how happy they all are. There's lots of evidence that this works well for the child who knows where they came from and sees there mother as part of the extended family.

But when CP's try to take ownership, bully the SM and refuse contact then problems arise as happened in the court case where the SM has had the PO overturned.

I think this needs recognising - it's not on to override the mother and dish out a PO without her consent.

I think the type of woman who enthuses about the joy of giving the gift of life will get a nasty shock when she finds that CPs are exerting their rights and taking control, and assuming ownership of the baby from long before it is born. We can expect to see more sorry stories but the odds will be stacked against them should they go to court.

Swipe left for the next trending thread