Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 8hrs of study a day is unnecessary

167 replies

sillistudi · 01/04/2023 08:28

School newsletter says year 13s study for forthcoming a-levels should be aiming for 8 hours of study a day over the Easter holidays. Really???! Seems excessive to me! My DC are a couple years off a-levels but I can't see how that is necessary... so I'm interested, those with dc at that stage or just through it, is that level of study really needed?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jonei · 17/04/2023 08:19

Mirabai · 16/04/2023 22:41

It’s very English the idea that hard work somehow might be in conflict with happiness, well-being, with a good approach to life.

That seems to be how it is now, but it wasn't always the case.

Mirabai · 16/04/2023 22:41

It’s very English the idea that hard work somehow might be in conflict with happiness, well-being, with a good approach to life.

L1ttledrummergirl · 16/04/2023 21:26

I have no idea of what results she will come out with. What I do know is that she is happy, has good mental health and a wonderful approach to her life.

Having had one of ds1 friends from school die through suicide due to the stresses of expectation and pressure following covid, my dc mental health is my priority.

I also know that we took the same approach with ds1 during his A levels. As I said up thread, he is just finishing vetmed and he has a brilliant work life balance so I'm happy with our approach.

nighthawk99 · 16/04/2023 19:43

DD haS probably done about that over the Easter holiays.she is doing maths FM biology and chemistry Alevels and wants 4 A*

NormaTheWife · 16/04/2023 19:11

Again depends on person and subject.

Mirabai · 16/04/2023 18:36

But if she’s super clever and already put a lot of work in, it’s not impossible.

Mirabai · 16/04/2023 18:33

Well, quite. 😉

GoldenRetriever4 · 16/04/2023 17:15

@Mirabai

In my view it is unlikely that anyone could achieve 3A*s with such limited revision.

Mirabai · 16/04/2023 16:50

L1ttledrummergirl · 16/04/2023 16:19

Dd week has been much more relaxed.
Wake up around 10am, leisurely breakfast, a couple of hours work, lunch, countdown (something we both enjoy), a couple more hours work, dinner, then either her sport/fitness training or we do a board game/cards/something as a family, then another hour or so. She aims to sleep around midnight.

A couple of days through each week she has gone out with friends or spent the day with her grandparents, helping to entertain her cousins. She's spent time with her aunt and kept up her friendships. It's been a good balance and a lovely break from routine.

If she can get 3 A*s on that, why not.

GoldenRetriever4 · 16/04/2023 16:48

@L1ttledrummergirl

Me and DH wouldn’t be happy with the DSs following your daughter’s schedule. In our view, the time for gallivanting about is in the summer once exams are over. Now is time to get noses to grindstones.

We set an 8 hour per day baseline for the Easter holidays and both DSs stuck to/exceeded this.

L1ttledrummergirl · 16/04/2023 16:19

GoldenRetriever4 · 16/04/2023 12:02

@moveoverye

A level and GCSE students shouldn’t be gallivanting about in the few weeks before their exams. This is the time to really focus on serious study and revision.

Obviously it is important to have some balance and walks are good, but DC also shouldn’t be spending time gaming or on social media. DS has done at least 10 hours’ revision every day over Easter and still has time for balance. This has been his schedule:

6.30am- wake up and breakfast
7am- walk/gym
8am- 5 one hour revision sessions with breaks
1.30pm- lunch
2pm- 4 one hour revision sessions with breaks
6.30pm- dinner
7pm- last one hour revision session
8pm- TV/relaxation time
10pm- bed

Yes, it is intense but it is possible to have balance with self-discipline. For example, both DSs have handed in their phone until after exams to avoid wasting time.

Dd week has been much more relaxed.
Wake up around 10am, leisurely breakfast, a couple of hours work, lunch, countdown (something we both enjoy), a couple more hours work, dinner, then either her sport/fitness training or we do a board game/cards/something as a family, then another hour or so. She aims to sleep around midnight.

A couple of days through each week she has gone out with friends or spent the day with her grandparents, helping to entertain her cousins. She's spent time with her aunt and kept up her friendships. It's been a good balance and a lovely break from routine.

Mirabai · 16/04/2023 12:51

That was to @moveoverye

Mirabai · 16/04/2023 12:51

Simply that the workload is lighter thus less revision time was needed. It’s about 2.5 A levels. Similarly I did 4 but my 4th was music which has a performance component so I considered it as 3.5 A levels.

In fact, STEM subjects needs less revision than humanities ime.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 16/04/2023 12:48

One thing to bear in mind about the current Y13 is that they didn't sit GCSEs and had a massively disrupted KS4. Many of them came into sixth form with huge gaps in their GCSE level knowledge, which means teachers have to go through the course more slowly and leaves less time for revision at the end of the course.

Many of them don't have the effective revision strategies that students in Y11 now will be developing for GCSE, and I think a lot of them still believed even up to about February that their exams weren't really going to happen.

I'm not sure it's useful to compare the current Y13 with other year groups and what they needed/didn't need to do. IMO, as teacher, I think they've had really poor preparation for their A-levels, and could do with some kind of special consideration like Y13 got last year. Don't forget, as many students take gap years, they'll be competing with students for uni places who were given advanced information. They'll be competing with students in the job market who got TAGs, which we all know were inflated.

I do think schools have to find a balance, and of course it's not a good idea to put too much pressure on students BUT equally, if schools went down the route of "don't worry, it'll all be fine", they would be letting the students down. Especially this specific cohort of students.

FWIW, our expectation at sixth form is an average of 4 hours of study outside of lesson time per subject each week. The students have 6 hours a week of contact time in school- so that's 30 hours for 3 subjects, plus travel time etc. They also have tutor sessions etc in school. So it's probably normal for them to spend about 8 hours a day on school related activities, and it's sensible to keep this up over Easter.

Yes, students need breaks- and I encourage my students to take a few days off BUT they shouldn't take the whole easter holidays, or may bank holidays, or half term off revising as it is nominally "holiday"! They will have 3-4 months away from academic work over the summer, after all!

I teach a science subject, and there is so much content to remember, and the mark schemes are incredibly picky. To get an A/A*, you really do need to be self motivated, and I know my most motivated students will be doing more than 8 hours a day. Ultimately, A-levels are competitive, and in most subjects there is no short cut around doing the work.

moveoverye · 16/04/2023 12:39

Mirabai · 16/04/2023 12:24

@moveoverye You wouldn’t have been able to do drama A level at my school as wasn’t considered academic enough. My nephew is doing it and his written paper is only 40% of the marks. 30% is a created piece of theatre submitted well in advance of the exams, and the other 30% is live performance. So it’s not like doing 3 essay subjects. In fact he’s doing it because while very bright he struggles with academics due to ADHD.

That’s interesting but I’m not sure what your point is? I readily acknowledge that I probably did less revision than my classmates doing STEM.

My Drama A Level didn’t stop me getting a 1st Class English Literature degree from Durham, so I don’t suppose my essay writing skills suffered too much.

Mirabai · 16/04/2023 12:24

@moveoverye You wouldn’t have been able to do drama A level at my school as wasn’t considered academic enough. My nephew is doing it and his written paper is only 40% of the marks. 30% is a created piece of theatre submitted well in advance of the exams, and the other 30% is live performance. So it’s not like doing 3 essay subjects. In fact he’s doing it because while very bright he struggles with academics due to ADHD.

SquidgersMummy · 16/04/2023 12:23

For a levels on a weekend I literally studied 8-6. On school It's the hardest, most time intensive. After a levels I thought a degree was easier.

IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 16/04/2023 12:17

BitOutOfPractice · 01/04/2023 08:44

I did. My dd1 did.

I still believe A levels were the hardest exams I ever did (I have a degree!) and with the most pressure on them. This close to the exams I’d expect a good student to be putting the hours in tbh.

Agree. I've got a degree, a Masters and a PGCE and A Level History and Eng Lit were the hardest exams/courses I've ever taken. One of my EL exams was 3.5hrs long!

moveoverye · 16/04/2023 12:11

GoldenRetriever4 · 16/04/2023 12:02

@moveoverye

A level and GCSE students shouldn’t be gallivanting about in the few weeks before their exams. This is the time to really focus on serious study and revision.

Obviously it is important to have some balance and walks are good, but DC also shouldn’t be spending time gaming or on social media. DS has done at least 10 hours’ revision every day over Easter and still has time for balance. This has been his schedule:

6.30am- wake up and breakfast
7am- walk/gym
8am- 5 one hour revision sessions with breaks
1.30pm- lunch
2pm- 4 one hour revision sessions with breaks
6.30pm- dinner
7pm- last one hour revision session
8pm- TV/relaxation time
10pm- bed

Yes, it is intense but it is possible to have balance with self-discipline. For example, both DSs have handed in their phone until after exams to avoid wasting time.

😳
What can I say, I really hope they get the grades they want and that looking back it all will have been worth it.

Personally I’m more of a ‘seize the day’ and live in the moment sort of person, but if this works for your sons all power to them.

GoldenRetriever4 · 16/04/2023 12:02

@moveoverye

A level and GCSE students shouldn’t be gallivanting about in the few weeks before their exams. This is the time to really focus on serious study and revision.

Obviously it is important to have some balance and walks are good, but DC also shouldn’t be spending time gaming or on social media. DS has done at least 10 hours’ revision every day over Easter and still has time for balance. This has been his schedule:

6.30am- wake up and breakfast
7am- walk/gym
8am- 5 one hour revision sessions with breaks
1.30pm- lunch
2pm- 4 one hour revision sessions with breaks
6.30pm- dinner
7pm- last one hour revision session
8pm- TV/relaxation time
10pm- bed

Yes, it is intense but it is possible to have balance with self-discipline. For example, both DSs have handed in their phone until after exams to avoid wasting time.

DedicatedFollowerOfFashion84 · 16/04/2023 11:43

Tarantellah · 01/04/2023 13:28

These kids are a couple of months away from the most difficult exams of their lives. Yes it is harder than a degree! So it’s reasonable to work the equivalent of a full time job for approx 6-8 weeks. They’re going to have 2-3 months holiday over the summer to recover.

The most difficult time of their lives? Surely that’s a bit exaggerated… the idea of putting that amount of pressure on teens, especially when their brains aren’t fully developed until the age of 25 is just shocking. Ditto GCSEs. Education can be obtained at any stage of life . We don’t serve our young people well by making them think their A levels are life or death. No wonder there are such high rates of anxiety and depression among teens.
mans FWIW, the most difficult time of my life we’re family bereavements, my child falling seriously ill, dealing with adult life stressors. A levels doesn’t even hit the top ten of “difficult times”

moveoverye · 16/04/2023 11:35

moveoverye · 16/04/2023 11:18

I didn’t. I probably did 4 hours or so on a good day. But I expect it depends on your subjects. I did English History and Drama. No doubt the Chemistry students were doing more than me!

Oh and I got straight As, I’m not that bright, but I enjoyed my subjects. I think if you pay proper attention throughout the year, intense cramming is less necessary.

moveoverye · 16/04/2023 11:32

thatsn0tmyname · 01/04/2023 12:10

Our year 13s have been advised to do this, too.
8 hours sleeping.
8 hours free time.
8 hours studying.
They won't have school or travel to school so is more manageable.

It’s not 8 hours free time really is it though.

8 hours of sleep probably becomes 9 hours if they take half an hour to drop off and to get up in the morning. Take away another hour for shower and breakfast. Another at lunchtime for eating, esp if they help prepare / wash up. Another in the evening for dinner. Half an hour in the evening getting ready for bed, and half an hour elsewhere in the day just for little things that crop up.

So it’s actually more like 3 hours free time. Which is enough for a walk or to read a book or watch TV, or pop to the shops, but not really to take a trip out to do anything fun or different, which I think is such a shame. Young people are only young once, they shouldn’t have to be sacrificing their holidays to this extreme, they should be out enjoying themselves.

I don’t think we are teaching our children what a healthy work-life balance looks like, no wonder there are so many youngsters today suffer from stress and anxiety.

AbbaG12 · 16/04/2023 11:24

Absolutely unnecessary as anyone studying that much won't be optimising revision techniques. Studies have shown that active recall with spaced repetition is far better than constantly recalling information.

Active recall - basically questions to the topics instead of reading books/passive studying.

Spaced repetition - increasing the time between recalling information. Used correctly it increases how long you ca retain the information.

Studying 8 hours a day is just constantly recalling information. Theyre far more likely to forget what they've learnt quicker than using optimised revision. Revising properly they shouldn't need to spend that much time revision and have better recall.

moveoverye · 16/04/2023 11:18

I didn’t. I probably did 4 hours or so on a good day. But I expect it depends on your subjects. I did English History and Drama. No doubt the Chemistry students were doing more than me!