Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government Behaviour Hub pushing zero tolerance in schools

259 replies

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 06:13

I've just been reading how the Behaviour Hub set up by the government has been pushing this idea of very strict behaviour policies and zero tolerance in schools. The sort rolled out by many of the academy chains. Does anyone know what the evidence base is for this?

The policies in many of these schools are highly restrictive - short lunch breaks, limited access to toilet breaks, consequences for minor mistakes. Many adults would find it stressful to be in an environment like this. I wonder if anyone has looked at the cost of these measures to the children in terms of their mental health, fostering independence and social skills etc.

Any insight, thoughts or links to research on this would be great.

OP posts:
Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 01/04/2023 09:02

Parenting and instilling boundaries and discipline is being left to schools in many cases by which time it is often too late. Parenting, setting boundaries, teaching basic manners and respect should begin at home right from the very early years but in many cases it just is not happening because parents cannot be arsed and it is so much easier to give in for a quiet life. Hence by school age instead of being ready to learn and teachers being able to teach they are having to spend their time just trying to keep order because kids only want to do what they want and have never been taught to sit still and listen and to do what is asked of them. I also believe giving kids technology so young and parents always having a phone in their hand has contributed massively too. It is easier to blame teachers and schools though than take a good hard look at ourselves and our parenting skills though isn’t. I mean everything is always someone else fault it seems these days.

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 08:55

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 08:52

It is very easy, just look at the GCSE results in any school, before and after zero- tolerance is introduced

How would I know it’s the behaviour policies and not other factors? What schools? There must be some controlled research you said it was blatantly obvious.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 08:54

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 08:44

Wow just wow. We are never going to agree.

I haven't met one child in any school that persistently behaves badly because it is fun.

seriously? You have either met zero children, or have had the wool well and truly pulled over your eyes constantly.

Of course many children are going to behave badly if it is more fun than behaving well.

And for many years in many schools, it has been a lot more fun

Littlecamellia · 01/04/2023 08:54

Zero tolerance in schools is only a sticking plaster to try and alleviate the social problems that exist in society. Watch YouTube 'Living on the Breadline ' to see just how many children have really desperate home lives.

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 08:52

Consistent boundaries without petty rules and building relationships with pupils - yes, yes this is exactly what I want from a school and what I see the best teachers at my son’s school doing (to the best of their ability within the myriad petty rules they are expected to enforce).

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 08:52

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 08:41

you are completely wrong in a number of ways - strict behaviour policies leads to higher educational achievement, that is blatantly obvious.

Could you point me to the evidence for this please as I’d like to do some reading up on this topic.

It is very easy, just look at the GCSE results in any school, before and after zero- tolerance is introduced

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 08:46

I'm really interested in this. Not the strict behaviour code but how schools are becoming super strict. My ds goes to a school where you get one warning (say for turning your head and saying something to your friend) and second warning is straight to withdrawal room - yet consistent bullying and fighting behaviour from other students gets a half day suspension and it carries on. I find it ridiculous that you can have to spend 5 lessons in the withdrawal room not learning because of minor infractions - yet really bad behaviour continues.

I used to run youth clubs, I know it's not the same as teaching (they choose to be there for one), but I ran youth clubs in rough areas with dc with lots of emotional and behavioural challenges. I didn't need to be strict to manage the behaviour, I built relationships and didn't use the power of being the adult to overrule. I always had rap music on (rap actually calms the nervous system, the beats soothe without them realising) and kept consistent boundaries by not having loads of petty rules and having that relationship with the YP. Schools aren't working at the moment and I do wonder what would happen if the government used all the experienced youth workers they decommissioned in Cameron days and put them in charge of how schools should be set up to manage behaviour/what behaviour even needs to be managed.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 08:44

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 08:39

you are completely wrong in a number of ways - strict behaviour policies leads to higher educational achievement, that is blatantly obvious.

No, SEN is not behind most bad behaviour - most children who behave badly do it simply because it is more fun than behaving well, so you make it less fun, and behaviour improves.

Children removed from the classroom because of their behaviour go into exclusion for a short time before coming back, and also serving detentions, in 99% of cases.

Children with SEN have adjustments made for them

Children who refuse to comply will be expelled - as they should be

You can go to far with strictness, but in general it is a step in the right direction. It isn't fair to see children denied an education by the behaviour of their classmates

Wow just wow. We are never going to agree.

I haven't met one child in any school that persistently behaves badly because it is fun.

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 08:41

you are completely wrong in a number of ways - strict behaviour policies leads to higher educational achievement, that is blatantly obvious.

Could you point me to the evidence for this please as I’d like to do some reading up on this topic.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 08:39

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 06:50

High standards in small things (things you might think minor, like uniform) lead to high standards in major things (like results)

No it doesn't.

It allows schools a pretext to exclude quicker those who can't comply however they may have achieved.

Yes that may result in a quieter classroom generally, better for those who can comply.

However that excluded child also has a right to an education. The cheapest way to provide that education is currently in the mainstream sector. The SN sector has precious few spaces already.

Any kids whose with the money will pay for a private diagnosis (because whether we like it or not there is always a reason for kids behaviour) and medication. They will also fight for expensive SEN provision costing the government significantly more.

Those who are reliant on the NHS will end up shoved and excluded from every "zero tolerance" school. Pretty soon will have the scandal of the kids who aren't receiving their right to education.

Zero tolerance is actually very expensive and completely unworkable

you are completely wrong in a number of ways - strict behaviour policies leads to higher educational achievement, that is blatantly obvious.

No, SEN is not behind most bad behaviour - most children who behave badly do it simply because it is more fun than behaving well, so you make it less fun, and behaviour improves.

Children removed from the classroom because of their behaviour go into exclusion for a short time before coming back, and also serving detentions, in 99% of cases.

Children with SEN have adjustments made for them

Children who refuse to comply will be expelled - as they should be

You can go to far with strictness, but in general it is a step in the right direction. It isn't fair to see children denied an education by the behaviour of their classmates

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 08:37

Thank you, that is very helpful. I will look into this.

Thank you to all those that responded. It has helped to actually gain some perspective and know I am doing the right thing.

I am really stressed over this, which isn't helping her. I have the next week off, so I just need to spend time with the DC and try not to think about this, give her time to breathe again, see if I can get her to leave the house.

Second week of half term I'll start with the GP and go from there.

winewolfhowls · 01/04/2023 08:37

Sirzy · 01/04/2023 08:21

In my dream world the school system would be one which has a variety of different settings to help young people find the right one for them. Some children will thrive in a very strict and structured environment others need a lot more flexibility. Some thrive with academic pathways others need different routes.

the issue with the current system is it tries for a one size fits all approach which doesn’t work.

When I started teaching about 15-20 years ago there was much more of a personalised offer. Many more kids at 14-16 could access lower level apprenticeships, do entry level courses, worked an afternoon at a local farm etc. However the funding for the courses and staff just isn't there anymore. Because students were on a more suitable pathway behaviour was better across the school generally and there was more freedom allowed to teach how you wanted ( e.g going outside for a lesson), doing fun stuff that wasn't on the exam spec, more trips.

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 08:37

Schools are suffering from a lack of funding. Not enough staff, too many children in old crappy buildings with not enough resources for decent extra curricular activities in many cases. Sen is particularly under funded. It’s easier to superficially deal with behaviour problems with draconian rules that make you look like you are doing something when really you are just sweeping the problems under the carpet. The only people who can get help are those with resources. These draconian rules create (as someone said upthread) the opportunity to get rid of the ‘problem kids’ with their ‘persistent disruptive’ behaviour and palm them off on someone else to deal with. Children and families in the meantime are being traumatised in the pursuit of league table places and an outstanding ofsted.

FloatingBean · 01/04/2023 08:32

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 08:08

I am going to speak to GP over the Easter break, I am very worried about her mental health. If the GP signs her off and refers for counselling, surely the school then have to authorise her absence and provide work?

The school don’t have a duty to provide education for those unable to attend school. That duty is the LA’s under s.19 of the Education Act 1996. This should begin once it becomes clear DC will miss 15 days. The days don’t need to have already been missed or consecutive. If this applies to DD and isn’t being provided email the Director of Children’s Services. If that fails email again threatening judicial review. If that doesn’t work contact SOSSEN for help with a pre-action letter.

Don’t deregister, parents often find it easier (although not easy) to get support when on a school’s roll even if their DC can’t attend. Bluntly, you are someone’s problem and it is harder to brush needs under the carpet. If DD can’t attend the LA must provide provision, but if you EHE you relieve the LA of their duty.

If DD is off because of her MH the school should be authorising the absence now.

MediocreOne · 01/04/2023 08:31

bellac11 · 01/04/2023 07:50

Horrific?

Horrific is being neglected, abused, not having access to education full stop, not having access to food and water

Not being asked to be respectful of others, committed and motivated to learning

Exactly, all children have the right to an education but if schools become even more rigid then many many children will not attend. There are tens of thousands of children who are persistently absent as they cannot fit into the current education system.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 08:24

@AM130674 yes talk to the LEA. But you need medical evidence your DD is too traumatised to attend school

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 08:22

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 08:17

But it will give us time to do so. Education is so important for children. She has worked every day she has been home. Some teachers have sent through work even though the school said no?

I can't afford to home Ed and I worry it would be too isolating.

I plan to complain to the governors, the Trust and seek guidance from the LA and I'm guessing local MP?

I have absolutely no idea where to go. I'm also terrified of getting into trouble myself too. I'm a stickler for rules.

The advice I would give really does depend on your financial circumstances. What needs to be done is the same either way, but if you can't throw some money at it the support you can get to do it is better.

You can complain to the MP. But unless the government starts funding SEN education properly and fully funding a educational psychiatrist, psychiatrist and mental health team in school, its probably a waste of your effort

Sirzy · 01/04/2023 08:21

In my dream world the school system would be one which has a variety of different settings to help young people find the right one for them. Some children will thrive in a very strict and structured environment others need a lot more flexibility. Some thrive with academic pathways others need different routes.

the issue with the current system is it tries for a one size fits all approach which doesn’t work.

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 08:17

But it will give us time to do so. Education is so important for children. She has worked every day she has been home. Some teachers have sent through work even though the school said no?

I can't afford to home Ed and I worry it would be too isolating.

I plan to complain to the governors, the Trust and seek guidance from the LA and I'm guessing local MP?

I have absolutely no idea where to go. I'm also terrified of getting into trouble myself too. I'm a stickler for rules.

winewolfhowls · 01/04/2023 08:15

chosenone · 01/04/2023 07:56

As far as I’m aware the govt behaviour hubs programme is based on Tom Bennett’s behaviour theories, he’s the DFE behaviour guru. He pushes for consistency whatever the rules are rather than being prescriptive about the actual rules. He does advocate SLANT to ensure that students are sat up, listening, answering questions, nodding along and tracking the teacher. I think this is too prescriptive and possibly very difficult to monitor. It is annoying when kids are slouched on the desk, doodling etc but this can come under being respectful.

I've been to a talk with Tom Bennet and tbh he was alright. A lot of what he said made sense , I didn't connect it in my mind with the type of severe system which is the topic of this thread.

I've done short stints of supply in a couple of strict schools and they were miserable to work in, and SLT treated the staff like the kids. It's like a cult and your face and teaching style has to fit them and their prescriptive model rather than the different teaching approaches and activities that make a school day varied and interesting. Although to be fair this judgement is based on visiting a few schools for a short time.

I just couldn't enforce toilet rules etc it seemed so cruel. I would much prefer to work in a school with a more relaxed approach where there is low level distractions but a caring ethos.

I am of the opinion that most of the problems in schools can be solved with better funding and more staff who can then be a constant and visible presence on the corridors and in the outdoor spaces. I would also go back to actually having LSAs in secondary school,they are like good dust now. Thus you solve the minor behaviour problems and have more support for all students.

mamnotmum · 01/04/2023 08:15

Idinindop - I think that would be a great idea. Schools with a vast amount of money going into them with experienced teachers and excellent facilities for those who struggle with a mainstream school environment. Not so much a 'special school' but more a nurturing environment. Where kids with additional needs and conditions can learn in an environment more suitable to their needs.

Then the more mainstream schools won't be failing these students because there isn't time/facilities etc to support them but also the kids in the mainstream school can have stricter rules and more focus put on to learning instead of behaviour management.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 08:11

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 08:08

I am going to speak to GP over the Easter break, I am very worried about her mental health. If the GP signs her off and refers for counselling, surely the school then have to authorise her absence and provide work?

Yes absolutely. But she will be expected to return.

If other local schools are oversubscribed she will need to return to the same school as the bullies.

Please do look with an open mind at alternative provisions. Your DD will make new friends

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 08:08

I am going to speak to GP over the Easter break, I am very worried about her mental health. If the GP signs her off and refers for counselling, surely the school then have to authorise her absence and provide work?

IndiganDop · 01/04/2023 08:08

Dacadactyl · 01/04/2023 06:56

@Icedlatteplease that's a separate issue though. If a child has SEN and can't cope in a mainstream environment, then they should have access to specialist provision.

Just think about what you are saying here.

If schools adopt these highly rigid zero tolerance approaches, they are ruling by fear - forcing children into compliance. It's the equivalent of "you will stay at this table until you have cleared your plate, even if you are sitting here all evening".

You are advocating a system that will produce a cohort of kids who would have been compliant anyway, anywhere (as most are); a cohort of children who do manage to comply, but at great cost in terms of increased anxiety and mental health problems; and a system where much higher numbers do not manage and have to, apparently, go to specialist school. Do you genuinely think a system that rejects any child who has learning difficulties, autism, ADHD, dyspraxia, complex home circumstances, fetal alcohol syndrome, etc and sends them out of mainstream is best for either cohort? For mainstream kids to only ever meet compliant peers? To not need to learn tolerance, negotiation, patience, adaptability? And for kids with virtually any kind of SEN to have to be educated away from their local community - because you'd have a much wider band of kids who "can't cope in a mainstream environment" where that environment is not about relationships but about ruling by fear.

ProbablyNotAGoodIdea · 01/04/2023 08:04

I'm guessing this is a backlash against the (largely horribly implemented) restorative behaviour systems so many schools have had in place in the past few years. Unfortunately, the way a lot of SLT interpreted that kind of system was to decide that disruptive students needed a friendly chat and a hot chocolate, and that bad behaviour was always the teacher's fault for not meeting their needs. While said teacher is stretching themselves 35 different ways trying to meet the often conflicting needs of an overcrowded classroom that has fewer chairs than learners, no support and 'aspirational' targets on which their pay prog depends. Neither that system or zero tolerance is any good for kids or teachers. But it's all a distraction from underfunding. Schools have been forced to do so much more with so much less year on year and education is broken, completely broken. I left teaching and took my kids out of state education because I felt absolutely helpless in the face of how overwhelmingly bad things had got. But the system can work - it just needs a government that will fund it adequately and not try to create distractions around this kind of nonsense. A new behaviour strategy will not fix the issues. Zero tolerance is just as hideous as the hot-choc-pat-on-the-head stuff. Either way, children's needs are not going to be met.