Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government Behaviour Hub pushing zero tolerance in schools

259 replies

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 06:13

I've just been reading how the Behaviour Hub set up by the government has been pushing this idea of very strict behaviour policies and zero tolerance in schools. The sort rolled out by many of the academy chains. Does anyone know what the evidence base is for this?

The policies in many of these schools are highly restrictive - short lunch breaks, limited access to toilet breaks, consequences for minor mistakes. Many adults would find it stressful to be in an environment like this. I wonder if anyone has looked at the cost of these measures to the children in terms of their mental health, fostering independence and social skills etc.

Any insight, thoughts or links to research on this would be great.

OP posts:
Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 09:43

@OriGanOver

You are assuming this is an issue with just a few students. When actually we are finding that in lessons change over we have fifty to a hundred or so students hanging around texting/ misbehaving/ truanting in the loos.

Have you ever tried to settle a class and start a GCSE lesson when ten different students are arriving from their ‘loo break’ at random intervals. It is incredibly disruptive to learning. And students, even good ones, catch on quickly that they can get away with it.

And for those talking about SEND students. We have a system of toilet passes for those who need them. But I also find that is is my SEND students who most appreciate a ‘warm but strict’ attitude and benefit most from a calm, controlled environment where they can concentrate.

In my experience it is not the SEND kids causing the disruptions and if they are it just requires a bit of intervention. There are many students now who spend all their time at home on devices and have not been patented recently who have no SEND needs and are just focused on not doing any work. These students actively destroy the learning of the rest of the class. should we just let them do this?

WarriorN · 01/04/2023 09:43

My son has gone to a middle school that appears to try to do this. So he's y5.

It's affected his mh. He always tries his best and is conscientious yet now spends a lot of his time being anxious about being told off for minor things. And as been overly and unreasonably reprimanded by one awful teacher who I had to make a complaint about - he was going out if his way to be helpful and she made negative assumptions and jumped to a conclusion without checking first. He then had panic attacks before school on the days he had her for some time afterwards.

I'm a teacher too and believe there's a balance. From what I can see half the staff hate it too and there seems to be a retention issue.

The irony is that it's really not a school full of badly behaved kids. I'd have loved to have taught those children when I was younger.

Spendonsend · 01/04/2023 09:42

I like a clear consistent behaviour policy. I struggle with zero tolerance for a few reasons

The penalties for things that are harmful are the same as the penalties for things like having the wrong shoes because you wore a hole in them that showed up last night and you had no money for the shops til pay day. You get sent to the internal exclusion room.

The impact on SEN. Obviously clear and consistent boundaries are needed by SEN pupils too but most schools use ehcps as a gateway for reasonable adjustments so you have children recieving detentions for having genuine issues.

I also think some children prefer the environment in the exclusion room anyway for some lessons so will just do something minor to be sent there but that would be the same zero tolerance or not.

My sons school is strict but it ditched zero tolerance and SLANT after a short period. Its now one warning then you are out as the teachers preferred it as they were sending out engaged pupils on the no warning ststem. I assume they are still zero tolerating violence though!

Hdhabvdhhebsb · 01/04/2023 09:40

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 07:53

It's a simple matter of figures.

It is cheaper to provide inadequately for SEN within a mainstream classroom whatever the detriment of the NT kids who will probably do sufficiently adequately regardless.

Excluding kids provides the evidence that a child cannot get an adequate (legal term) education in a mainstream environment. Therefore the government has to provide a more expensive education.

Which has not keep pace with growing levels of ASD/ADHD/SEN.

(Growing levels of any SEN are to be expected genetics, better neonatal care and general medical care.)

Zero tolerance is unaffordable. You would actually have to provide for the level of SEN that exists.

I'm laughing at the idea of seperating SEN/mental health difficulties, when talking about persistent "bad" behaviour. NT kids can comply with a zero tolerance approach (albeit there may be a person cost)

@Icedlatteplease I can't believe that you think it is ok to throw well behaved, keen to learn children under the bus 'whatever the detriment of the NT kids who will probably do sufficiently adequately regardless.' why should they be dragged down and create an ever increasing gap between state and private for the many children who can't afford to go private and will pay for it by not achieving the best they can at school which could then have lifelong consequences for them. Why should they have to opt for a lesser job/lesser pay/lesser lifestyle because of their school throwing their education under a bus as they 'will do adequately'.

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 09:36

Bollocks - going to the toilet should not be an issue for any pupil.

Making every pupil suffer because of poor behaviour in other students does nothing more than breed resentment towards the school.

Manage the behaviour in those pupils rather than draconian measures like no toilet breaks fgs.

nilsmousehammer · 01/04/2023 09:35

The other side of this shiny new fashionable coin being the major problem with the number of children with MH needs and with Autism who are out of school or school refusing because it is such a stressful and traumatising place to be with constant sensory overwhelm and inflexible demands. And that the govt also want to stop pouring money into meeting SEND needs, because its becoming a black hole - in part because mainstream schools with the high speed, pressured gallop primary education has become, is steadily less able to meet their needs without more staff and individual teaching, and without having to frequently pick up the pieces of meltdowns. Many of these are academically able children, the environment is just not accessible to them.

You can do this kind of thing with the kids that can, but the side effect is that other types of schools are then going to need to be built to provide for the increasing numbers of kids who can't, who need different approaches and environments to achieve to their full capacity. And staffed by people who know what they are doing and properly understand how to meet those needs, and do something very different for those kids as opposed to just provide the One Right Model in smaller groups. Or staff them with cheap NQTs who have no experience of SEND provision.

Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 09:31

I forgot the drinking in the toilets. Bringing knives to school, using toilet breaks to interrupt lessons by constantly asking to go and then hanging around I their first twenty minutes with friends to get out of doing any work.

A clear policy is fair and gives consistency.

Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 09:29

Hi OP

Schools don’t want to enforce these measures but we also don’t want children at risk of violence.

Since returning from lockdown violent behaviour has increase dramatically. Some of the behaviours we’ve seen in the past year are wildly dangerous. But these students also have a right to an education and a right to be in school.

How do you suggest we deal with the following issues:

Students using social media to arrange violent revenge attacks at break and lunch (we have had five incidents like this since Sept)

Students using the toilets to sell/ consume drugs and vapes.

Students sexually assaulting each other in toilets (we have a mix of gender neutral and sex segregated because of DEI policies)

Students defacing toilets with swear words and graphics pornography.

Students destroying school property (we have had to replace all the doors in the boys toilets three times this year because they’ve been ripped from their hinges).

Toilet breaks are also being used to send nudes/ inappropriate social media posts which then cause knock on behaviour incidents.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 09:28

Merryoldgoat · 01/04/2023 09:23

I’ve never understood why ‘strict’ supposedly equals ‘good’.

Most jobs don’t have ridiculously strict uniform standards and most jobs you can go to the loo when required.

I don’t know what they think they’re preparing people for.

nobody who has witnessed "low level" disruption hampering every stage of a lesson is ever going to argue that "unstrict" is good.

A teacher can do nothing, individually, they only get to use the discipline policy of the school, and if that policy is right, then the teacher can tap straight into it, with minimal disruption to the lesson, and learning can proceed - which is in the interests of everyone, including the children who are behaving badly

I have seen it taken too far, I agree, it can end up being soul destroying, for staff and students if every little misdemeanor has to be picked up on, I have refused to give detentions for "not sitting up straight enough" for example.

But there is a happy balance, and that is very definitely on the strict side of the line

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 09:28

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 09:21

dont get suckered into "controlled research" in education - you can't control for all factors, as you say, and the people who call educational research "research" are frequently without the skills or literacy to even define what "research" is!

Never the less, if you look across the board, at schools results before and after strict behaviour policies are introduced, then you will see an marked improvement in over 80% of schools

You are literally plucking made up statistics out of thin air and presenting them as fact which is not helping your argument at all.

Strugglingtodomybest · 01/04/2023 09:28

My sons are out of secondary school, thank god.

My observations are that a lot of my friend's daughters ended up with mental health problems in their teens (mainly eating disorders but also OCD, depression, anxiety, perfectionism) and whilst their homelife may have played a part too, it's my opinion that the pressure to conform and produce good results at school played a big part in this.

My personal experience with my boys was that they went into secondary as happy kids and were worn down by the nit-picking to the point where they hated school. My eldest used to beg me to home school him, which I couldn't do.

What I saw was kids who weren't bad, being made out to be bad because they'd forgotten their pen, or had the wrong shoes on, therefore turning them against the school and the teachers, whilst the truly disruptive, bullies, weren't dealt with effectively.

I don't blame the teachers for this, I blame the government.

chosenone · 01/04/2023 09:27

Please be careful about dismissing toilet visits as a small issue. Unmonitored toilet visits lead to hours of lost learning. Some kids asking to go every period of the day and wandering to and fro. Arranged meets in the toilet for vaping/ tik toking etc. Toilets then can become intimidating places for students and a place for on site truancy which has increased nationally since the Pandemic.

massivenamechnage · 01/04/2023 09:27

In most schools the approach is pretty much the same as when many parents would have gone to school

Show Respect
Follow the rules
Expect consequences if you don't

I am in my 50s and the approach is certainly no more draconian than when `I was in secondary (both state and independent)

we had a uniform that was checked
stood up when adults entered the room
had to get a toilet pass to leave a lesson
had report cards if you didn't do homework
lunchtime detention if no PE kit
etc etc

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 09:26

I don't think it's parental.

Behaviour is much better today than in the 90s. That's a fact. Look at drug taking, pregnancy etc etc. Teenage attitudes have changed in this aspect for the better. I do think overall respect in the way teenagers talk/expect has changed negatively, but I don't think that's just parental. We live in a different world with social media, name brands and parents who grew up not having a lot giving a lot to their dc. They are more in charge now and that is the opposite to boundaries but it's time for schools to catch up.

Instead of hammering petty discipline home it's time for schools to reform. Have dc making more decisions, get them involved. Stats prove that teenagers making decisions and participating in their outcomes leads to better results.

Stop working on them and work with them.

No more petty rules, I'd do away with uniform and minor infractions. It's just causing conflict for conflicts sake. No more unnecessary power struggles.

Relationship building to manage classrooms and behaviour.

More natural consequences - you chuck a chair that dents a wall you stay after school to fill the dent, you then sand it and paint it. Detentions, points and isolations don't work. Do something that does. Oh and you apologise to the class, your actions have consequences and you scared people.

What schools are doing isn't working and there's only so much parent blaming they can do. Parenting has changed from back in the day and schools need to change too.

Merryoldgoat · 01/04/2023 09:23

I’ve never understood why ‘strict’ supposedly equals ‘good’.

Most jobs don’t have ridiculously strict uniform standards and most jobs you can go to the loo when required.

I don’t know what they think they’re preparing people for.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 09:23

Plut · 01/04/2023 09:14

There have been a number of studies which focus on small things like uniform which conclude that strict policies around that seem to translate to higher results

Is there? Showing causation?

I don't see how that can be the case given the UK system has such bad outcomes compared to schools in other countries where there is no uniform at all.

again, be very wary of international comparisons, as every country chooses who to put forward for comparing in a different way.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 09:21

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 08:55

How would I know it’s the behaviour policies and not other factors? What schools? There must be some controlled research you said it was blatantly obvious.

dont get suckered into "controlled research" in education - you can't control for all factors, as you say, and the people who call educational research "research" are frequently without the skills or literacy to even define what "research" is!

Never the less, if you look across the board, at schools results before and after strict behaviour policies are introduced, then you will see an marked improvement in over 80% of schools

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 09:20

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 09:17

I have no problem at all with schools being strict on proper disruptive, bullying, violent behaviour. I think that is essential for a good school.

It is the strictness on minor infractions that really don't undermine the school or detract from learning. This can cause a lot of stress for children (Sen or non Sen) who are generally well behaved but make a minor mistake.

Yep, the only bad mark against my daughter is a detention for not handing in her merit card? A whole hour detention.

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 09:19

And I agree with the problem of inconsistencies with this. I.e really strong consequence for forgetting your pe kit, while bullying isn't properly dealt with.

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 09:18

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 09:17

I have no problem at all with schools being strict on proper disruptive, bullying, violent behaviour. I think that is essential for a good school.

It is the strictness on minor infractions that really don't undermine the school or detract from learning. This can cause a lot of stress for children (Sen or non Sen) who are generally well behaved but make a minor mistake.

I agree, I have seen it taken to far, but in principle, strict, properly upheld behaviour policies benefit learning for everyone

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 09:17

I have no problem at all with schools being strict on proper disruptive, bullying, violent behaviour. I think that is essential for a good school.

It is the strictness on minor infractions that really don't undermine the school or detract from learning. This can cause a lot of stress for children (Sen or non Sen) who are generally well behaved but make a minor mistake.

OP posts:
Plut · 01/04/2023 09:14

There have been a number of studies which focus on small things like uniform which conclude that strict policies around that seem to translate to higher results

Is there? Showing causation?

I don't see how that can be the case given the UK system has such bad outcomes compared to schools in other countries where there is no uniform at all.

Plut · 01/04/2023 09:07

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 07:47

My daughter goes to an academy.

I have just removed her as she was being seriously bullied. The bullies have destroyed her reputation within her peer group. She's been threatened with violence and had several comments from wider group to kill herself.

Once a confident 13 year old, she is now a shadow of herself, too scared to leave the house alone and is so anxious, too scared to ever go back to that school.

The bullies, all of whom are already on final warnings for bad behaviour? All got a slap in the wrist and reminded on the school rules on bullying. My daughter is now expected to go back. The school sanctions do not work.

The school refuse to authorise her absence and so won't provide work for her, even though I have made it very clear I will facilitate her education, just not in that toxic environment.

The school have completely failed her, all other schools in the area are over subscribed, so what do I do?

That is horrific, your poor DD.

This is the problem. Fussing about uniforms etc but doing nothing about truly appalling behaviour. Bullying should mean instant exclusion, just as it would in a work environment if dealt with properly.

Plut · 01/04/2023 09:05

how many people think that a zero tolerance approach is a good thing?

It depends what they mean by that. Enforcjng arbitrary rules about uniform or expecting people to ask permission to go to the toilet, no, that's pointless. However, disruption, violence should be zero tolerance and bullying should mean expulsion.

bellac11 · 01/04/2023 09:03

There have been a number of studies which focus on small things like uniform which conclude that strict policies around that seem to translate to higher results

I dont know if the research is designed in a way to elicit that result or how that translates to other countries where they may not have a uniform policy.

My preference would be a focus on actual behaviour, smaller schools, specialist and different settings.

I do also think the insistence that SEN children either cant benefit from, or shouldnt be asked/required to behave well is hugely insulting to anyone with different needs or with MH issues.