Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government Behaviour Hub pushing zero tolerance in schools

259 replies

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 06:13

I've just been reading how the Behaviour Hub set up by the government has been pushing this idea of very strict behaviour policies and zero tolerance in schools. The sort rolled out by many of the academy chains. Does anyone know what the evidence base is for this?

The policies in many of these schools are highly restrictive - short lunch breaks, limited access to toilet breaks, consequences for minor mistakes. Many adults would find it stressful to be in an environment like this. I wonder if anyone has looked at the cost of these measures to the children in terms of their mental health, fostering independence and social skills etc.

Any insight, thoughts or links to research on this would be great.

OP posts:
Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 11:18

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 10:58

In an ideal world..

Young people actually being involved in the school, how it works for them, what they want from it. Participation at the highest level and not a tick box exercise.

What rules do they think their school needs? What behaviour plans do they think work? I would foster a sense of responsibility in the pupils of how they want their school to be ran. Young people would be consulted and listened too.

I'd get rid of uniform and have spare supplies in every room. Equipment shouldn't be in the way of learning and punishing dc for not having it is so alien to a work place that it doesn't make sense for schools to not provide it. It punishes those with chaotic homes and SEND.

I'd put all the teachers through a youth work degree to disemble the notion of strict and zero tolerance approach works best. Realise abuse of power that does happen and learn how building relationships work in managing behaviour.

I'd put more physical activity and learning through doing things. Sitting in a classroom if you're not a classroom person/learner is tough. The more bored dc are the more trouble they get into.

Natural consequences, you break something you work with the care taker to fix it.

Regulating behaviour, free breakfast club, free tea and toast at break. Longer breaks with more lunchtime clubs/football. We used to have an hour, now dc get 40 minutes, they need breaks.

We know that a child/adolescent brain is developing. There is a natural rebellious state that it goes through, there is a natural risk taking state again that it goes through. I'd stop forcing hours of boring classroom work by going back to longer breaks, outside classroom learning and PE. Taking away zero tolerance for uniform, kit, toilet breaks would remove a lot of conflict that escalates.

Also, I'd take away responsibility from the teachers and put it back on the yp. You can't force dc to do well. By the time they're 14 they know that if they don't pass their GCSEs life will be harder. I don't think it's healthy to have exam results as a way to measure schools - but I'd bet my house if I could run a school like that the natural result would be better attendance, less exclusions and good grades.

Can you come and run my children’s school please?

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 11:16

bluechameleon · 01/04/2023 10:05

I know two people who went to the first Mossbourne in its early days, which was one of the first of these types of school. High achieving, motivated people who went on to do well academically. Both say they were damaged by the culture and atmosphere - constant anxiety about getting something wrong and being punished, total lack of respect for the young people. They also say that the middle class kids who went into the school with all the advantages were the ones who survived; the ones from the chaotic homes, who already had disadvantages piled up at 11, often ended up excluded or managed out.
As a different example, I was on a course the other day with a woman who received a text message from her daughter's school notifying her of a demerit because her glue had run out.
In my opinion, it is fundamentally wrong to treat children/young people in this way. We need to show respect and compassion. In the philosophy of Ross Greene, kids do well if they can, and if they aren't doing well, we need to identify what skills they lack and teach them those skills. None of us would accept a situation at work where we have to be constantly behaving 'perfectly' (i.e. in the way some neuro-majority people have decided we should) and are publicly shamed if we don't. I don't find eye contact easy and concentrate better if I'm fiddling. I'm also occasionally a couple of minutes late, or forget to do something I've agreed to, or have a pen run out during a meeting, and I would quit my job immediately if I got penalised for these things.

what do you suggest the teacher does with a child without glue? The school cant afford glue, the child either doesn't do the work that requires the glue, or the teacher pays for it out of their own pocket.

It is perfectly reasonable for a school to expect a child to be equipped with glue

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 10:58

In an ideal world..

Young people actually being involved in the school, how it works for them, what they want from it. Participation at the highest level and not a tick box exercise.

What rules do they think their school needs? What behaviour plans do they think work? I would foster a sense of responsibility in the pupils of how they want their school to be ran. Young people would be consulted and listened too.

I'd get rid of uniform and have spare supplies in every room. Equipment shouldn't be in the way of learning and punishing dc for not having it is so alien to a work place that it doesn't make sense for schools to not provide it. It punishes those with chaotic homes and SEND.

I'd put all the teachers through a youth work degree to disemble the notion of strict and zero tolerance approach works best. Realise abuse of power that does happen and learn how building relationships work in managing behaviour.

I'd put more physical activity and learning through doing things. Sitting in a classroom if you're not a classroom person/learner is tough. The more bored dc are the more trouble they get into.

Natural consequences, you break something you work with the care taker to fix it.

Regulating behaviour, free breakfast club, free tea and toast at break. Longer breaks with more lunchtime clubs/football. We used to have an hour, now dc get 40 minutes, they need breaks.

We know that a child/adolescent brain is developing. There is a natural rebellious state that it goes through, there is a natural risk taking state again that it goes through. I'd stop forcing hours of boring classroom work by going back to longer breaks, outside classroom learning and PE. Taking away zero tolerance for uniform, kit, toilet breaks would remove a lot of conflict that escalates.

Also, I'd take away responsibility from the teachers and put it back on the yp. You can't force dc to do well. By the time they're 14 they know that if they don't pass their GCSEs life will be harder. I don't think it's healthy to have exam results as a way to measure schools - but I'd bet my house if I could run a school like that the natural result would be better attendance, less exclusions and good grades.

Milksheikha · 01/04/2023 10:47

I don't see the point of keeping unengaged students in school. The UK lacks drivers, tradespeople and low skill workers. Make compulsory trade apprenticeships or employment an option instead of academics.

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 10:42

@nilsmousehammer absolutely agree. My autistic Ds is super compliant at school - a teachers dream. They would be anyway because they will follow all rules anyway. But the warm/strict policies are causing huge anxiety and meltdowns at home.

But similarly there are friends with NT kids who previously had no trouble with school and are now struggling with school and anxiety over the rules, the pressure and the homework.

OP posts:
Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 10:37

@OriGanOver

I’m all ears. What do you suggest?

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 10:36

Can you really not apply any critical thinking to the way classrooms are managed and the zero tolerance approach?

Of course children and yp will rebel against draconian approaches. Coming down harder on petty shit doesn't work, if it did would. That doesn't equal no rules 🙄

Clutterbugsmum · 01/04/2023 10:31

I can only go by my experience.

My children go to an academy (One left, 1 yr10 & 1 yr9) and yes they are strict around expected behaviour. They don't let the 'little' things go because if you do then the 'little' things just get bigger as the children will keep pushing boundaries all the time.

My friends children go to another local school who did let the 'little' things go and now the school has now has a terrible reputation with bullying and children disrupting learning.

The only difference is my children's school has a strong committed leadership team and teachers who are committed to both teaching and helping the children get the best possible results for the child. Where as my friends children's school has a weak leadership and it shows with the teaching being given and the lack care shown towards the children.

nilsmousehammer · 01/04/2023 10:23

When I hear that warm, firm approaches work for all SEND kids I cringe. Because what that means basically is 'that kid presents me with no management problems' and that's it.

The school refusal numbers are rocketing and many are nice and academically able kids with SEND who mask at school, then go home and disintegrate. Over confident teachers and the insistence that every round peg will fit a square hole if you insist, and so long as the kid doesn't actively cause you a problem in your time with them who cares if they trash the house and try to hurt themselves all night in fear of coming back to school in the morning, is a big part of the problem. Inclusion (you can come here) isn't the same as access (we get your needs, can meet them, and this is a place where you are able to learn to your full capacity). And even outstanding teachers who do have a lot of SEND knowledge and work flat out to make their classroom accessible are then trying to manage hugely diverse groups and meltdowns because it's a situation that does not provide quality for anyone.

We really do need a lot more specialist schools and specialist staff.

Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 10:18

@OriGanOver

Can you really not understand the difference between a university classroom with a selected intake of those who like to learn and a comprehensive school with a non-selective intake.

You have no idea.

I would happily move to the system you suggest. But only if I could put on my exam analysis ‘Ori’s child failed their GCSE because they spent twenty minutes of every lesson this year in the toilets and gossiped over the lesson instructions for the entire course’.

If you are fine with allowing kids to fail and not holding teachers responsible for the results of kids who can’t be bothered then I would happily move to no rules culture that you think would be better.

I have a great idea. Let’s allow them to be on their phone all the time too. Because that is great for mental health.

Obviously the greatest stressor in the life of a teen is planning their loo breaks. Not the average of ten hours a day they spend on social media.

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 10:10

Your issue is the control/power you feel you need @Boudicasbeard

Radical, perhaps, but I believe if you gave free reign for toilet breaks and actually built great relationships, you'd manage unnecessary toilet breaks by the relationship and not making them a thing. Universities manage with students popping out for toilet breaks, not sure why you can't?

What schools are currently doing isn't working. You can't get anymore strict without physical punishment and it's still not working. Try things that do work! Evidenced methods of working with children and young people rather than the draconian bollocks that's currently being sprouted.

inigomontoyahwillcox · 01/04/2023 10:07

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 07:47

My daughter goes to an academy.

I have just removed her as she was being seriously bullied. The bullies have destroyed her reputation within her peer group. She's been threatened with violence and had several comments from wider group to kill herself.

Once a confident 13 year old, she is now a shadow of herself, too scared to leave the house alone and is so anxious, too scared to ever go back to that school.

The bullies, all of whom are already on final warnings for bad behaviour? All got a slap in the wrist and reminded on the school rules on bullying. My daughter is now expected to go back. The school sanctions do not work.

The school refuse to authorise her absence and so won't provide work for her, even though I have made it very clear I will facilitate her education, just not in that toxic environment.

The school have completely failed her, all other schools in the area are over subscribed, so what do I do?

I feel for you, we've just been through almost exactly the same with our DD (14) with the added complication of her having ADHD. Her schoolwork has plummeted and mental health has taken a huge hit.

We're incredibly fortunate that my parents are prepared to fund her going to a small private school with a very good reputation for supporting SEN kids (not an SEN school) and having a nurturing and adaptable environment. She has 2 taster days lined up at the beginning of next term.

I noticed that the pupils are not required to wear uniform but comfy clothes, and are allowed to go to the toilet and get water when they need to. Of course, being a small school that's a lot more manageable, but there must be a middle ground for larger schools? At present DD is only allowed to go at break times or in between lessons, but some lessons are so far apart that this would make her late and end up with her getting into trouble.

bluechameleon · 01/04/2023 10:05

I know two people who went to the first Mossbourne in its early days, which was one of the first of these types of school. High achieving, motivated people who went on to do well academically. Both say they were damaged by the culture and atmosphere - constant anxiety about getting something wrong and being punished, total lack of respect for the young people. They also say that the middle class kids who went into the school with all the advantages were the ones who survived; the ones from the chaotic homes, who already had disadvantages piled up at 11, often ended up excluded or managed out.
As a different example, I was on a course the other day with a woman who received a text message from her daughter's school notifying her of a demerit because her glue had run out.
In my opinion, it is fundamentally wrong to treat children/young people in this way. We need to show respect and compassion. In the philosophy of Ross Greene, kids do well if they can, and if they aren't doing well, we need to identify what skills they lack and teach them those skills. None of us would accept a situation at work where we have to be constantly behaving 'perfectly' (i.e. in the way some neuro-majority people have decided we should) and are publicly shamed if we don't. I don't find eye contact easy and concentrate better if I'm fiddling. I'm also occasionally a couple of minutes late, or forget to do something I've agreed to, or have a pen run out during a meeting, and I would quit my job immediately if I got penalised for these things.

Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 10:01

@OriGanOver

You are an adult. Teenagers do not have the same self regulation and need a framework to work within to help them learn self control.

Do you know how much work would happen in my Yr10 lesson if I let them wander in and out to the toilets? None

Can you run a meeting where you are giving key information while people are talking over you? How about if every five minutes someone got up and noisily left and then came back? How well would that meeting go?

Swimminginthelake · 01/04/2023 09:59

Zero tolerance is such a horribly puinitive way to run a school. It's assuming the worst about all the kids and effectively treating them like prisoners. A school near us puts kids in isolation for the whole day for forgetting a pen. What about the missed learning for these otherwise 'good' kids. And how on earth do we expect our kids to come out of schools like this with a love of learning or respect for elders or authority? It just breeds contempt.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 09:56

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 09:48

@Boudicasbeard I can't believe anyone would disagree with the examples you give being dealt with strictly.
I'm talking about detention for lost pe kit or pen. Detention for not following slant and sitting in the correct way. This is totally over the top and punishes minor mistakes disproportionately

I disagree with the behaviour you are lumping together as equally minor. What is a teacher supposed to do with a student that comes without their kit or their stationary?

In schools where this is allowed, I have typically ended up spending around £50 a term on stationary to be made available for students, frequently lending out pens, calculators, rubbers, pencils etc and not getting them back, getting them back deliberately broken, or even getting them back having been ostentatiously carried back up to the teachers desk between the bum cheeks of the student.

And is a child can't participate in a lesson because they done have the proper clothes, the teacher then has to make other arrangements, and sometimes still have them in the room, without safety equipment, ( in the example of DT, or science) and that impedes everybody.

These things have a massive effect on the education of everybody in the room.

I do agree, that detentions for not following SLANT can be way over the top , and I always ban the staring at the pupil who is speaking, anyway, as I find it intimidates children and is not helpful

Mammillaria · 01/04/2023 09:55

Regarding successful super-strict schools like the Michaela school, is there an element of selectiveness in the intake? I know the applications process itself is non-selective, but these very successful super-strict schools always seem to be in areas where parents have a choice of schools to apply to, presumably meaning that only parents who have high aspirations for their children and children who are likely to do well in that environment apply. Do schools like this work in small towns and rural areas where there is no alternative school?

Another thought about the Michaela school (not sure if this applies to other successful super-strict schools); it is known for being super-strict but this is only one aspect to its approach. It also has a huge emphasis on gratitude and student/teacher relations which are reinforced daily in things like 'family lunch'.

I am not convinced that simply implementing a zero tolerance policy in a struggling school will in itself make a huge impact. Although I do agree that something needs to change.

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 09:54

@Boudicasbeard

Lots of people work in offices and manage to go to the loo and settle back into work even if there are 50 or so leaving their desks and then returning spread out over the building.

Denying toilet breaks is awful. Schools expect dc to act mature but yet police things like this.

I could not imagine not being able to go to the loo when I needed to. Yes I might hold to the end of a meeting but if I needed to go I could give everyone a 5 minute break, it would be my decision. Not having autonomy over my bodily functions would be awful.

Schools need to get over their power trips.

Goldenbear · 01/04/2023 09:53

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 09:28

nobody who has witnessed "low level" disruption hampering every stage of a lesson is ever going to argue that "unstrict" is good.

A teacher can do nothing, individually, they only get to use the discipline policy of the school, and if that policy is right, then the teacher can tap straight into it, with minimal disruption to the lesson, and learning can proceed - which is in the interests of everyone, including the children who are behaving badly

I have seen it taken too far, I agree, it can end up being soul destroying, for staff and students if every little misdemeanor has to be picked up on, I have refused to give detentions for "not sitting up straight enough" for example.

But there is a happy balance, and that is very definitely on the strict side of the line

How do uniform infringements equate to disruption? Wearing a coat in a corridor for example is not going to lead you to be sacked in most workplaces. Meanwhile unkindness such as heckling your peers in the corridor or on lunch, excluding peers deliberately via mocking goes unchecked, that sort of behaviour in workplaces far more likely to get you sacked!

WarriorN · 01/04/2023 09:50

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 09:48

@Boudicasbeard I can't believe anyone would disagree with the examples you give being dealt with strictly.
I'm talking about detention for lost pe kit or pen. Detention for not following slant and sitting in the correct way. This is totally over the top and punishes minor mistakes disproportionately

It's ridiculous and it's going to create a nation of very mentally unwell children and then adults.

WarriorN · 01/04/2023 09:49

It's a simple matter of figures.

It is cheaper to provide inadequately for SEN within a mainstream classroom whatever the detriment of the NT kids who will probably do sufficiently adequately regardless.

Excluding kids provides the evidence that a child cannot get an adequate (legal term) education in a mainstream environment. Therefore the government has to provide a more expensive education.

Which has not keep pace with growing levels of ASD/ADHD/SEN.

(Growing levels of any SEN are to be expected genetics, better neonatal care and general medical care.)

It's absolutely this. My setting is supposed to be for MLD and autism. We are increasingly getting pupils who need SLD settings. But we lack the provision and are having to rewrite the curriculum and upskill staff to better accommodate needs. With much less budget than we had even 6 years ago.

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 09:48

@Boudicasbeard I can't believe anyone would disagree with the examples you give being dealt with strictly.
I'm talking about detention for lost pe kit or pen. Detention for not following slant and sitting in the correct way. This is totally over the top and punishes minor mistakes disproportionately

OP posts:
OneInEight · 01/04/2023 09:46

I honestly don't know if my ds's would have coped better in zero tolerance schools. They certainly did not cope in non zero tolerance behaviour schools and whilst it was their behaviour that was extreme enough to warrant exclusion it was nevertheless low level disruptive behaviour in others that was a trigger often.

I do think that with any policy like this you need to have a plan for what support can be given to pupils who can not cope with this regime that does not involve throwing them on the scrap heap. Educational outcomes are dire for permanently excluded pupils. Support them at school age or basically you will be supporting them for life.

WarriorN · 01/04/2023 09:45

Dacadactyl · 01/04/2023 06:56

@Icedlatteplease that's a separate issue though. If a child has SEN and can't cope in a mainstream environment, then they should have access to specialist provision.

This isn't happening though. There's no spaces and mainstream are catering for children who would have been in SEND 10 years ago. But they're shit at it.

I'm a SEND teacher and I can't believe what I'm hearing from fellow parents of send pupils in some mainstream schools.

Ehcps have increased by roughly a third in 10 years. But no extra send settings.

bellac11 · 01/04/2023 09:45

Plut · 01/04/2023 09:14

There have been a number of studies which focus on small things like uniform which conclude that strict policies around that seem to translate to higher results

Is there? Showing causation?

I don't see how that can be the case given the UK system has such bad outcomes compared to schools in other countries where there is no uniform at all.

I cant remember the details I just remember feeling quite surprised at the information. I doubt you would ever see causation because its research rather than a study per se

I dont know what biases were involved.

And I also referenced in my post about how that translates to other countries with no uniform but then we do have a different social set up, as I said in a preivous post the problem in the UK is that we are anti education, we teach children as a society that its not cool to be clever, motivated, aspirational.