Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government Behaviour Hub pushing zero tolerance in schools

259 replies

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 06:13

I've just been reading how the Behaviour Hub set up by the government has been pushing this idea of very strict behaviour policies and zero tolerance in schools. The sort rolled out by many of the academy chains. Does anyone know what the evidence base is for this?

The policies in many of these schools are highly restrictive - short lunch breaks, limited access to toilet breaks, consequences for minor mistakes. Many adults would find it stressful to be in an environment like this. I wonder if anyone has looked at the cost of these measures to the children in terms of their mental health, fostering independence and social skills etc.

Any insight, thoughts or links to research on this would be great.

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 01/04/2023 12:32

Are they putting a Behaviour Hub in Westminster?

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 12:32

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 12:11

Youth work is not a new fad. It's been around since the victorian times. It worked then and can work now.

Nim - you don't sound like a good teacher anymore. You sound bitter and fustrated. Your approach isn't working. Time for a new job that you're able to enjoy. One where your empathy levels can start to regrow. I'd absolutely hate it if you were one of my dcs teachers, I really hope you're not.

My argument is not null, it would work very well. It's not based on theoretical concepts but actual hard evidence and theories that have proven themselves when working with yp.

of course youth work is not a new fad - it is the content and principles that are constantly new fads, there is no quality qualification that you are describing, and you have no idea at all of behaviour in schools.

I am a very successful teacher. You know nothing about teaching or education at all, and it does nothing for your credibility to start being personally insulting, when people point out you have no idea what you are talking about. If your kids have me as their teacher, they are lucky

RedToothBrush · 01/04/2023 12:31

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 11:30

Absolutely. And then parents feel no other option to seek a EHCP because that’s the only legal way to force the support being put in place that should be there already.

DS is in primary. He's been referred for ADHD assessment. He has quite pronounced behavioural quirks but he's well behaved generally. We were told that because he's achieving expectations it wasn't typical for them to refer even if there was an obvious problem. Because in essence there's rationing of diagnosis going on and local authorities don't want to have too many diagnosis. The school has to actively demonstrate that DS is significantly underperforming and that he will benefit. It therefore isn't a coincidence that the school have taken it seriously in yr3 after DS didn't hit where they thought he should in his yr2 SATS. Any child who had similar issues but wasn't on the cusp of a grade difference is screwed by this. There is clearly one of DSs friends who falls into this and is being labelled as a problem despite displaying obvious signs of ADHD.

At the moment their primary has restorative justice (which quite frankly doesn't work) but it's likely both will go to an academy which is super strict. I'm pretty sure that shit will hit the fan at that point for this boy. It's really depressing to see. He is one of four which is likely to make it much more difficult for his parents to act on.

Even now, there are no guarantees with DS as to how his referral is going to go. We've been told that he wont be prioritised and the local authority will try and knock him back so to manage our expectations.

His teacher thinks he has a real issue and it's proving hard for him to manage. If he doesn't get local authority support it makes it harder to get medication if that was appropriate to him, because they don't want the funding headache.

It's all about budgets and rationing.

If there really is an increase in SEN kids and there are legitimate reasons for a natural increase rather than purely a diagnosis increase due to 'fashion' then of course there's going to be a bottleneck and issues with behaviour at high school.

One of the key points we've been finding with DS is how there are a bunch of kids with conflicting issue which is leading to constant issues as one sets off all the others in some way in a domino effect.

If they dealt with that by funding early and appropriately, I'd question the need for such strict ideology in classrooms at high school level.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 01/04/2023 12:30

TBH it all makes me wonder what kind of parents advocate for the right of their child to misbehave.

Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 12:28

@OriGanOver

You told me I was on a power trip because I was outlining why there needs to be some tough rules in school.

You are blaming schools and teachers for trying to get some control over the increasingly disruptive behaviour that is making life miserable for staff and the majority of students.

Having worked in schools is not the same as having taught. You have no idea what it is like to stand in front of a class of 35 and tired desperately to get some learning done while three students do everything in their power to ruin the lesson. And then felt the weight of judgement from the rest of that class when you cannot get that behaviour under control.

Two badly behaved, demotivated students are enough to grind a lesson to a halt. And unlike in a work place, we can’t sack them. They have a right to an education and we have to make it work, somehow.

I find your ideal insulting because you imagine that we are’t trying our best for the kids or that strict rules are a power trip. Why not try imagining trying to get a class of 30 kids with an average reading age of 11 years old through an English GCSE.

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 12:20

@Boudicasbeard I have worked in a school, then a youth worker and now a social worker. Schools do need a complete shift. If you feel the need to defend that, then it's striking a nerve.

I know social work is shit atm, and there needs a radical shift in that, too. I wouldn't be hunkering down and defending social work as a whole because it's obvious that it's not working. If I ever become so bitter and blame the YP for their behaviour rather than look at the wider system and what I'm doing I've lost my reflexive practice.

Schools aren't working - although I do believe behaviour is much better than what it was. The teachers at my school were absolutely terrorised in the 90s. Think things like - locked in cupboards, spat on, urinated on, houses and cars smashed up. I don't ever read about that type of behaviour anymore.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 12:20

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 11:33

sorry, but this is ignorant in the extreme - you are dealing all day with children who have been brought up to defy authority and kick back against instructions - there is no opportunity for engaging these students in the way you describe.

These students can destroy the chance of education for everyone

You cant change the students in front of you, you have to educate them as they are.

There is no such thing as a "youth work degree" which is relevant for schools, or teaches anything other than the current fad, which will be out of date within two years

spare supplies in every room will need fully replacing every week

There is already masses of movement breaks, learning away from the classroom and learning through different modes

Your idea of "working to fix what is broken" completely ignores the fact that the teacher will firstly have to invest hours in finding out who broke it, getting into conflict with students and parents while doing it, and then the parents will likely kick off about the "natural consequences"

sorry, but you know and understand nothing whatsoever

Your house is forfeit

You do realise society needs all types of people for balance.

Turning out only compliant non questioning clones is not a recipe for a healthy society. Just ask the Nazi party.

And you still have to have a strategy for getting rid of those who can't or won't comply.....

Seriously what do you intend to do when the kid simply refuses to hand over their phone?

Expel them?

Then what do you do with them?

Macaroni46 · 01/04/2023 12:14

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 12:11

Youth work is not a new fad. It's been around since the victorian times. It worked then and can work now.

Nim - you don't sound like a good teacher anymore. You sound bitter and fustrated. Your approach isn't working. Time for a new job that you're able to enjoy. One where your empathy levels can start to regrow. I'd absolutely hate it if you were one of my dcs teachers, I really hope you're not.

My argument is not null, it would work very well. It's not based on theoretical concepts but actual hard evidence and theories that have proven themselves when working with yp.

Actually I agree with @Nimbostratus100 who is being realistic.
Seeing as you have such wonderful ideas @OriGanOver, why don't you train to be a teacher and see how you get on? I think you'd be eaten alive after one lesson!

Macaroni46 · 01/04/2023 12:13

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 12:11

Youth work is not a new fad. It's been around since the victorian times. It worked then and can work now.

Nim - you don't sound like a good teacher anymore. You sound bitter and fustrated. Your approach isn't working. Time for a new job that you're able to enjoy. One where your empathy levels can start to regrow. I'd absolutely hate it if you were one of my dcs teachers, I really hope you're not.

My argument is not null, it would work very well. It's not based on theoretical concepts but actual hard evidence and theories that have proven themselves when working with yp.

Actually I agree w

Macaroni46 · 01/04/2023 12:11

@OriGanOver
You say "I could not imagine not being able to go to the loo when I needed to. Yes I might hold to the end of a meeting but if I needed to go I could give everyone a 5 minute break, it would be my decision. Not having autonomy over my bodily functions would be awful."

Try being a nurse or a teacher. They can go hours without getting a chance to go to the loo. Probably lots of other jobs too.

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 12:11

Youth work is not a new fad. It's been around since the victorian times. It worked then and can work now.

Nim - you don't sound like a good teacher anymore. You sound bitter and fustrated. Your approach isn't working. Time for a new job that you're able to enjoy. One where your empathy levels can start to regrow. I'd absolutely hate it if you were one of my dcs teachers, I really hope you're not.

My argument is not null, it would work very well. It's not based on theoretical concepts but actual hard evidence and theories that have proven themselves when working with yp.

Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 12:02

@OriGanOver

That is a lovely ideal. You should try setting up and free school and implementing it.

I can’t take anything you say seriously because you are starting from the position that teacher don’t generally have the well being of their students first in mind. And that we are less well informed about teen development than they average youth worker.

You obviously have no idea what goes on in schools. It’s insulting.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 11:59

Hdhabvdhhebsb · 01/04/2023 09:40

@Icedlatteplease I can't believe that you think it is ok to throw well behaved, keen to learn children under the bus 'whatever the detriment of the NT kids who will probably do sufficiently adequately regardless.' why should they be dragged down and create an ever increasing gap between state and private for the many children who can't afford to go private and will pay for it by not achieving the best they can at school which could then have lifelong consequences for them. Why should they have to opt for a lesser job/lesser pay/lesser lifestyle because of their school throwing their education under a bus as they 'will do adequately'.

I never said it was OK. I just stated reality.

And it really isn't NT kids that suffer most from the arrangement

If I could organise and fully fund education my way, education would look nothing like it does now

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/04/2023 11:57

This sounds harsh and there’s probably a middle ground but as a teacher in a state school, something needs to be done. The behaviour is growing steadily worse, there are no consequences that teaching staff are really allowed to put in place, the support from the parents is minimal. The expectation of mainstreaming for all is crushing schools and other children are missing out as a result. There are days I feel more like a referee than an educator. And I know this isn’t just my school or my council - I follow a couple of UK wide teacher pages on FB and see situations much worse than mine every day. Violence in schools is ridiculously high, people are assaulted at work daily, as are other children. I don’t know what the answer is 😢

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 11:42

TooBored1 · 01/04/2023 11:40

Borrow from a classmate for the day?

tbh, when someone does this, I would just pretend not to notice- as there is actual problem has been resolved

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 11:41

pickledandpuzzled · 01/04/2023 11:39

I'd be interested to see what happens, if you can get a zero tolerance expectation established then school becomes safer for most kids and harder for a few. If you have a supportive set up to work with the few then I can't see why it wouldn't work.

At the moment we expect children to survive in massive unruly schools where their peers pick on them and there is little supervision to prevent it.

Few adults would work in settings where peers can verbally abuse you, sexually assault you, and mess about on the job with few consequences.

exactly - once a strict behavioural policy is in place and working, then relationships between students and staff can really blossom -

but again, it is all about balance- there is a line which can be crossed making teachers appear too strict, and unapproachable

I have seen schools that are too lenient, schools that are too strict, and schools that get the balance right

TooBored1 · 01/04/2023 11:40

Borrow from a classmate for the day?

pickledandpuzzled · 01/04/2023 11:39

I'd be interested to see what happens, if you can get a zero tolerance expectation established then school becomes safer for most kids and harder for a few. If you have a supportive set up to work with the few then I can't see why it wouldn't work.

At the moment we expect children to survive in massive unruly schools where their peers pick on them and there is little supervision to prevent it.

Few adults would work in settings where peers can verbally abuse you, sexually assault you, and mess about on the job with few consequences.

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 11:35

You don’t seem to like children very much @Nimbostratus100

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 11:33

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 10:58

In an ideal world..

Young people actually being involved in the school, how it works for them, what they want from it. Participation at the highest level and not a tick box exercise.

What rules do they think their school needs? What behaviour plans do they think work? I would foster a sense of responsibility in the pupils of how they want their school to be ran. Young people would be consulted and listened too.

I'd get rid of uniform and have spare supplies in every room. Equipment shouldn't be in the way of learning and punishing dc for not having it is so alien to a work place that it doesn't make sense for schools to not provide it. It punishes those with chaotic homes and SEND.

I'd put all the teachers through a youth work degree to disemble the notion of strict and zero tolerance approach works best. Realise abuse of power that does happen and learn how building relationships work in managing behaviour.

I'd put more physical activity and learning through doing things. Sitting in a classroom if you're not a classroom person/learner is tough. The more bored dc are the more trouble they get into.

Natural consequences, you break something you work with the care taker to fix it.

Regulating behaviour, free breakfast club, free tea and toast at break. Longer breaks with more lunchtime clubs/football. We used to have an hour, now dc get 40 minutes, they need breaks.

We know that a child/adolescent brain is developing. There is a natural rebellious state that it goes through, there is a natural risk taking state again that it goes through. I'd stop forcing hours of boring classroom work by going back to longer breaks, outside classroom learning and PE. Taking away zero tolerance for uniform, kit, toilet breaks would remove a lot of conflict that escalates.

Also, I'd take away responsibility from the teachers and put it back on the yp. You can't force dc to do well. By the time they're 14 they know that if they don't pass their GCSEs life will be harder. I don't think it's healthy to have exam results as a way to measure schools - but I'd bet my house if I could run a school like that the natural result would be better attendance, less exclusions and good grades.

sorry, but this is ignorant in the extreme - you are dealing all day with children who have been brought up to defy authority and kick back against instructions - there is no opportunity for engaging these students in the way you describe.

These students can destroy the chance of education for everyone

You cant change the students in front of you, you have to educate them as they are.

There is no such thing as a "youth work degree" which is relevant for schools, or teaches anything other than the current fad, which will be out of date within two years

spare supplies in every room will need fully replacing every week

There is already masses of movement breaks, learning away from the classroom and learning through different modes

Your idea of "working to fix what is broken" completely ignores the fact that the teacher will firstly have to invest hours in finding out who broke it, getting into conflict with students and parents while doing it, and then the parents will likely kick off about the "natural consequences"

sorry, but you know and understand nothing whatsoever

Your house is forfeit

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 11:30

Absolutely. And then parents feel no other option to seek a EHCP because that’s the only legal way to force the support being put in place that should be there already.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 11:25

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 11:21

That’s the problem though in a nutshell. If school can’t afford spare glue, what hope do they have to recruit enough decent teachers? Education is undervalued and therefore underfunded in the Uk. I can’t believe teachers are just so accepting of a situation where they aren’t given proper tools to do their jobs - classroom supplies fgs!

yes, most of the problems being discussed here to do with SEND are actually funding problems, The reason SEND children dont get the support and resources they need is to do with funding - they should get them, even in a strict school- but there are none

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 11:24

Mammillaria · 01/04/2023 09:55

Regarding successful super-strict schools like the Michaela school, is there an element of selectiveness in the intake? I know the applications process itself is non-selective, but these very successful super-strict schools always seem to be in areas where parents have a choice of schools to apply to, presumably meaning that only parents who have high aspirations for their children and children who are likely to do well in that environment apply. Do schools like this work in small towns and rural areas where there is no alternative school?

Another thought about the Michaela school (not sure if this applies to other successful super-strict schools); it is known for being super-strict but this is only one aspect to its approach. It also has a huge emphasis on gratitude and student/teacher relations which are reinforced daily in things like 'family lunch'.

I am not convinced that simply implementing a zero tolerance policy in a struggling school will in itself make a huge impact. Although I do agree that something needs to change.

I hate family lunch - who forces a regulated topic of conversation onto teenagers in their lunch time? and monitors and sanctions anyone going off topic. I count that as way over the top

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 11:21

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 11:16

what do you suggest the teacher does with a child without glue? The school cant afford glue, the child either doesn't do the work that requires the glue, or the teacher pays for it out of their own pocket.

It is perfectly reasonable for a school to expect a child to be equipped with glue

That’s the problem though in a nutshell. If school can’t afford spare glue, what hope do they have to recruit enough decent teachers? Education is undervalued and therefore underfunded in the Uk. I can’t believe teachers are just so accepting of a situation where they aren’t given proper tools to do their jobs - classroom supplies fgs!

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 11:20

Goldenbear · 01/04/2023 09:53

How do uniform infringements equate to disruption? Wearing a coat in a corridor for example is not going to lead you to be sacked in most workplaces. Meanwhile unkindness such as heckling your peers in the corridor or on lunch, excluding peers deliberately via mocking goes unchecked, that sort of behaviour in workplaces far more likely to get you sacked!

coats in corridors is often a simple matter of logistics - you can get more students down a corridor safer and faster if they are not wearing coats. School corridors are often massively overcrowded at lessons change over time.

plus the time wasted if children arrive at the classroom in their coat, and start faffing around taking them off then and there

Swipe left for the next trending thread