Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government Behaviour Hub pushing zero tolerance in schools

259 replies

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 06:13

I've just been reading how the Behaviour Hub set up by the government has been pushing this idea of very strict behaviour policies and zero tolerance in schools. The sort rolled out by many of the academy chains. Does anyone know what the evidence base is for this?

The policies in many of these schools are highly restrictive - short lunch breaks, limited access to toilet breaks, consequences for minor mistakes. Many adults would find it stressful to be in an environment like this. I wonder if anyone has looked at the cost of these measures to the children in terms of their mental health, fostering independence and social skills etc.

Any insight, thoughts or links to research on this would be great.

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 01/04/2023 13:10

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 08:08

I am going to speak to GP over the Easter break, I am very worried about her mental health. If the GP signs her off and refers for counselling, surely the school then have to authorise her absence and provide work?

Have a look at managed moves.

I did this with ds.

Best thing ever for him

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 13:10

If I wanted to be a teacher I would.
I was asked to say how I would do it and I gave my answer.

I really doubt teaching is anymore stressful than social work - I think my job is the third highest in the ranks of most stress so yes teaching would be a step down for me!

Anyway, I'm off to lunch. Have a nice weekend and try to reflect on why zero tolerance might work for you but it doesn't work for the pupils.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 13:09

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 12:56

There is absolutely nothing to stop you setting up a school or training as a teacher

Please please do it!

The whole education system is desperate for any fresh meat living body prepared to try their hand at standing up in front of a classroom for a short while

At worst, we get an extra body in front of a class, possibly avoiding having to combine classes in the gym for lack of teachers, maybe for a year or possibly two until you burn out!

At best it turns out you really do have all the answers that nobody, even with decades of experience has ever thought of before, and you transform the whole system overnight!

win win situation all round!

( who cares about being called an interfering cunt? Do you actually think this is the low bar of abuse staff are subjected to daily?)

But tbh I'm always at a loss when I teacher is upset by being called an cunt.

It's not about you. It's about the fact you are trying to make them do something they don't want to do or can't do.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 01/04/2023 13:07

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 13:05

It's not about being besties

But you can talk to them about the reasons why they aren't on task, what they are aiming for, self strategies for management of ADHD, what they got in their mocks etc.

All very teacher-esque subjects

To a dozen pupils in one lesson? When do you actually, ya know, teach the curriculum?

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 13:05

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 01/04/2023 13:01

Oh FGS. Some of you have watched too many episodes of Glee. Teachers aren’t there to be Bessie mates with pupils - they have no obligation to get cosy with the little turds who interrupt lessons and life for others, for whatever reason.

It's not about being besties

But you can talk to them about the reasons why they aren't on task, what they are aiming for, self strategies for management of ADHD, what they got in their mocks etc.

All very teacher-esque subjects

itsgettingweird · 01/04/2023 13:01

High standards in small things (things you might think minor, like uniform) lead to high standards in major things (like results)

No they don't.

Both zero tolerance schools near have been downgraded recently and have the lowest progress 8 schools.

Incidentally the 2 that have the relaxed uniform (polo and sweatshirt) have highest progress 8 and remain the best schools in the area and over subscribed.

Tackling behaviour is necessary. Sanctions are necessary and parental support is absolutely a game changer.

But being afraid to make a simple mistake is bad for MH.

Any adult would feel the same in a workplace where they couldn't relax or were afraid. In fact they'd be told to quit.

Forgot a pen? Why a sanction and massive deal rather than teach children to ask to borrow one and other children to lend one. It's basic human nature.

One of the schools near me does uniform inspections into every lesson. The wasted learning time is inexcusable imo. The teachers also hate it. It hasn't done anything to,change behaviour if those who don't care (for whatever reason) had done lots to damage the mental health of many young pupils there and the leaving rate of pupils in year 7 and 8 is very high.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 01/04/2023 13:01

Oh FGS. Some of you have watched too many episodes of Glee. Teachers aren’t there to be Bessie mates with pupils - they have no obligation to get cosy with the little turds who interrupt lessons and life for others, for whatever reason.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 12:59

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 12:40

you are hopelessly, hopelessly ill-informed. You cannot "build relationships" with a gang or 5-10 feral teens in a class you see 3 hours a week, when there is another gang the same size in the class after, and another gang the same size in the class after, and another gang the same size in the class after that.

I have some days in my career ended the day with a list of over 50 parents I should technically be ringing and discussing their child's behaviour with - and many of them will want to argue over the details, and complain that I cant remember the exact details of that exact misdemeanor, when I have dealt with dozens of others since then

In this situation, no education happens at all. You need a well ordered , strict classroom, to start to build relationships with anyone

I supply. One week I may encounter over 1000 children.

I still try and talk to/build a relationship with every child I meet. Regardless of whether they disrupt my lesson or not, whether I know I am going to see them ever again or not

Some of the ones who are the most disruptive are the ones who are the most interesting to talk to and who need that interaction the most.

When they come up to you two weeks/month later as say remember me? And you do (sometimes with a little prompting of remind me) you know how much that means to them. They try a little harder, they may not succeed, but you're worth trying for.

The idea that you can't build a relationship with a child you see for 3 hours every week, however feral, is beyond me.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 12:56

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 12:49

I don't believe you need a well ordered and strict classroom to build relationships with teenagers.

I would laugh at someone calling me an interfering cunt (have been called a lot worse in my career from yp).

I do agree that Ofsted has created an environment in schools where it's impossible to do anything that they don't believe is the right way. It's the same in social work where the LA gets inspected and funding for social care is based on Ofsted. It means that no one does or tries anything differently and all we do is tick the latest boxes. It de-skills workers.

I still think nim, that expecting dc to have this zero tolerance approach and thinking it's a good thing is completely wrong.

Children can't learn when their nervous system is out of wack. Regulate their emotions within the school environment and you'd have much better results with happier dc.

There is absolutely nothing to stop you setting up a school or training as a teacher

Please please do it!

The whole education system is desperate for any fresh meat living body prepared to try their hand at standing up in front of a classroom for a short while

At worst, we get an extra body in front of a class, possibly avoiding having to combine classes in the gym for lack of teachers, maybe for a year or possibly two until you burn out!

At best it turns out you really do have all the answers that nobody, even with decades of experience has ever thought of before, and you transform the whole system overnight!

win win situation all round!

( who cares about being called an interfering cunt? Do you actually think this is the low bar of abuse staff are subjected to daily?)

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 12:49

I don't believe you need a well ordered and strict classroom to build relationships with teenagers.

I would laugh at someone calling me an interfering cunt (have been called a lot worse in my career from yp).

I do agree that Ofsted has created an environment in schools where it's impossible to do anything that they don't believe is the right way. It's the same in social work where the LA gets inspected and funding for social care is based on Ofsted. It means that no one does or tries anything differently and all we do is tick the latest boxes. It de-skills workers.

I still think nim, that expecting dc to have this zero tolerance approach and thinking it's a good thing is completely wrong.

Children can't learn when their nervous system is out of wack. Regulate their emotions within the school environment and you'd have much better results with happier dc.

ancientgran · 01/04/2023 12:48

It is hard to balance the needs of all children, children who want to work get frustrated by constant disruption, children with special needs struggle to do what is expected. Better provision across the board seems to be the sensible solution but the government don't want to fund it so children struggle.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 01/04/2023 12:46

Why in these discussions are the people who have to bear the brunt of your Little Rebel never considered. The kids who WANT to learn. The teachers who want to do a good job. Why is their education and their professionalism constantly compromised because Little Rebel doesn’t want to do something like tuck his shirt in.

Florenz · 01/04/2023 12:44

I 100% support zero tolerance. These are the rules, whether you follow them or not is up to you, but if you don't follow them, you won't be allowed to disrupt the education of those that do. Go home to your parents and tell them any further education you receive will be arranged by them at their own expense.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 01/04/2023 12:42

Frankly it worries me that the generation who will look after me in their old age ante being brought up to believe they can behave however they like, and that society MUST fix whatever problem they get into and the consequences are something that shouldn’t be considered.

’What if PRUs are full’ - well perhaps think about that before you support your little darlings right to be rebellious

jessycake · 01/04/2023 12:42

Once the troublesome kids understand they can't be waterboarded and the very worst is exclusion , they have lost the argument .

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 12:40

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 12:35

@Boudicasbeard

You don't need control. You need to build relationships. If those disruptive dc were given some control over their schooling, some real and not tokenistic responsibility to go with their rights, I would bet they wouldn't be so disruptive.

If you find that offensive it's because it's a radical shift from your perceived power in the teacher pupil relationship you currently have. You expect them to obey, to be grateful to learn, to not make you look bad with the judgements of others. Cast that shit aside. Pass them the control and see what happens. You obviously imagine a shit show but it wouldn't be.

you are hopelessly, hopelessly ill-informed. You cannot "build relationships" with a gang or 5-10 feral teens in a class you see 3 hours a week, when there is another gang the same size in the class after, and another gang the same size in the class after, and another gang the same size in the class after that.

I have some days in my career ended the day with a list of over 50 parents I should technically be ringing and discussing their child's behaviour with - and many of them will want to argue over the details, and complain that I cant remember the exact details of that exact misdemeanor, when I have dealt with dozens of others since then

In this situation, no education happens at all. You need a well ordered , strict classroom, to start to build relationships with anyone

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 01/04/2023 12:40

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 12:33

Children who dont comply go into the exclusion room, and if it keeps happening, they are expelled, and picked up by the local PRU

The thing is it’s NEVER just ‘a kid won’t hand over their phone’. That’s the tip of the iceberg. It’s always more - the kids who don’t follow rules, and won’t change despite repeated sanctions, are doing so because they think they’re above all that. Which can go hand in hand with being unkind to others. Meanwhile mummy and daddy don’t think Diddums ever puts a foot wrong because they come home and say “They want to suspend me all I did was not hand my phone over”.

I wish my DD’s school took a zero tolerance approach to bullying then maybe she wouldn’t be the quivering mess she’s turned into after being a secure and confident child for so long.

Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 12:38

@OriGanOver

Offensive, yet again you are making huge assumptions. Most teacher I know spend a lot of time and effort building relationships with kids. With some students it is just not possible. They are not open to it.

How much of the learning time for the rest of the class should I be using to understand why little Toby called me an ‘interfering cunt’ to the whole class?

Maireas · 01/04/2023 12:36

@Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 - this. In a nutshell.

Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 12:36

And @OriGanOver why not save some of your ire for Ofsted, which has downgraded four schools on my area to RI for corridor behaviour. There is a lot of pressure on schools and teachers from all angles.

But of course we are all just ‘on a power trip’.

Exl · 01/04/2023 12:36

“High standards in small things (things you might think minor, like uniform) lead to high standards in major things (like results)”

I find it so hard to believe that anyone can think this way. It’s total nonsense. Stressing children about doing up the top bottom of their shirt (which by the way is physically painful for children with thick necks) and punishing them for being forgetful does not create ‘high standards’ in anything. It leads to large numbers of children with anxiety and mental health problems and eventually to stressed and aggressive adults, much like you see all over Britain today.

Meanwhile the many many countries that don’t bother with the nonsense of ‘school uniform’ have much better child mental health.

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 12:35

@Boudicasbeard

You don't need control. You need to build relationships. If those disruptive dc were given some control over their schooling, some real and not tokenistic responsibility to go with their rights, I would bet they wouldn't be so disruptive.

If you find that offensive it's because it's a radical shift from your perceived power in the teacher pupil relationship you currently have. You expect them to obey, to be grateful to learn, to not make you look bad with the judgements of others. Cast that shit aside. Pass them the control and see what happens. You obviously imagine a shit show but it wouldn't be.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 12:34

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 12:33

Children who dont comply go into the exclusion room, and if it keeps happening, they are expelled, and picked up by the local PRU

And when those are full?

Macaroni46 · 01/04/2023 12:34

Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 12:28

@OriGanOver

You told me I was on a power trip because I was outlining why there needs to be some tough rules in school.

You are blaming schools and teachers for trying to get some control over the increasingly disruptive behaviour that is making life miserable for staff and the majority of students.

Having worked in schools is not the same as having taught. You have no idea what it is like to stand in front of a class of 35 and tired desperately to get some learning done while three students do everything in their power to ruin the lesson. And then felt the weight of judgement from the rest of that class when you cannot get that behaviour under control.

Two badly behaved, demotivated students are enough to grind a lesson to a halt. And unlike in a work place, we can’t sack them. They have a right to an education and we have to make it work, somehow.

I find your ideal insulting because you imagine that we are’t trying our best for the kids or that strict rules are a power trip. Why not try imagining trying to get a class of 30 kids with an average reading age of 11 years old through an English GCSE.

Agree with everything you say.
It's the same in primary.
Low level disruption all day long on a good day. But the children are all little darlings in their doting parent's eyes. It's always someone else's fault or only a bit of chatter. Multiply 'only a bit of chatter' by 30 and you get an unruly class and minimal learning done. Also leads to further disruption hence the need to stamp on 'only a bit of chatter' from the outset.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 12:33

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 12:20

You do realise society needs all types of people for balance.

Turning out only compliant non questioning clones is not a recipe for a healthy society. Just ask the Nazi party.

And you still have to have a strategy for getting rid of those who can't or won't comply.....

Seriously what do you intend to do when the kid simply refuses to hand over their phone?

Expel them?

Then what do you do with them?

Children who dont comply go into the exclusion room, and if it keeps happening, they are expelled, and picked up by the local PRU

Swipe left for the next trending thread