Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government Behaviour Hub pushing zero tolerance in schools

259 replies

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 06:13

I've just been reading how the Behaviour Hub set up by the government has been pushing this idea of very strict behaviour policies and zero tolerance in schools. The sort rolled out by many of the academy chains. Does anyone know what the evidence base is for this?

The policies in many of these schools are highly restrictive - short lunch breaks, limited access to toilet breaks, consequences for minor mistakes. Many adults would find it stressful to be in an environment like this. I wonder if anyone has looked at the cost of these measures to the children in terms of their mental health, fostering independence and social skills etc.

Any insight, thoughts or links to research on this would be great.

OP posts:
ancientgran · 01/04/2023 15:54

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 15:23

The key word is try

Talk to. For some that might be well done nice work for others that might be a longer conversation. I've never been in a class where I haven't at least tried to say something positive to every child in that class.

With some kids i might not know their name but i know their trying to get an adhd diagnosis or that They dint want to borrow my "special pen" because thats too much pressure and they are worried theyll let you down

May not always succeed but you try. And when you fail you try and do better next time.

So trying to talk and build a relationship with every child can come down to saying well done. I don't think that is particularly revolutionary, I'd be amazed if most teachers don't say at least two words to their pupils in the course of a week.

I think you are imagining you are doing something very different to other teachers.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 15:23

ancientgran · 01/04/2023 14:25

I'm not a teacher but to me that sounds like you are teaching for 30 hrs a week? If you are teaching 1000 children that week it mean every hour you need to be talking and building a relationship with about 33 children. Is that right? I find it hard to believe you can have much interaction, I mean by the time they get settled and you find out their names how long would you have with each child in a class, one or two minutes and that would leave no time to teach anything.

My maths might be failing me so I'm happy for you to explain it for the hard of understanding.

The key word is try

Talk to. For some that might be well done nice work for others that might be a longer conversation. I've never been in a class where I haven't at least tried to say something positive to every child in that class.

With some kids i might not know their name but i know their trying to get an adhd diagnosis or that They dint want to borrow my "special pen" because thats too much pressure and they are worried theyll let you down

May not always succeed but you try. And when you fail you try and do better next time.

Goldenbear · 01/04/2023 15:20

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 11:20

coats in corridors is often a simple matter of logistics - you can get more students down a corridor safer and faster if they are not wearing coats. School corridors are often massively overcrowded at lessons change over time.

plus the time wasted if children arrive at the classroom in their coat, and start faffing around taking them off then and there

I did work in a support role in secondary school that didn't have much directly to do with children but this was only last year and I know what lesson change over time is like but schools are loud, dramatic places and the drama isn't only one way. I had an office(broom cupboard) near the loos, no other teachers or SLT had rooms/offices there so I heard and saw loads but from a perspective of a person that was previously in a very different sector of work (politics) I could see that lots of the drama about minor infringements just escalates stuff, especially with the children who are perhaps not getting much attention at home or the attention is negative. I would see an average, compliant pupil, quickly get their phone out to check it as they were going outside for lunch so not lesson time and a teacher behind would loudly pull them aside, give them a dressing down, a detention as no phones allowed. Same with coats on in the corridor, about to go outside in the rain and it would be sometimes like WW3 was about to break out over a coat! This doesn't get anyone prepared for working life unless you are going in to the army/police force! I left because it is incredibly poorly paid sector for the work I do but I don't know how anyone gets any work done in such a loud and aggressive environment. Work in other areas of life is just not like that. You show mutual respect. I have an almost 16 year old that is top group for everything and is well behaved, charismatic, I never feel the need to speak to him with no manners and both my DC say that this happens loads in their school. These are both very middle class schools with children that are not exactly that rebellious. I used to go to school in London in the 90s and it was akin to Grange Hill with the behaviour- proper fights breaking out on the playground and it was dealt with but not every child was spoken to like they were the teachers' adversaries, if you were pleasant and well mannered, it was reciprocated, it was proportionate and I definitely remember wearing my coat inside if I was about to go outside. I think lots of this is just a misuse of teachers' energy. I concur with a PP and found where I used to work if the cheeky children bust in to my office, some even fell in and rolled around momentarily play fighting, I would ask them to please get up and leave, I didn't do a dizzy dance, call SLT and create a massive crisis as that is what they want. I would disarm cheeky kids with an, 'are you ok? can I help you?' as they expected me to kick off about their rude entrance in to my office as that is what most teachers would do. These children were well known and they don't really expect you to say that, they expect you to be loud and negative as that is the attention they are after.

ginniegingin · 01/04/2023 15:05

"Are you suggesting that the boys at Westminster are not well behaved?
I live nearby and see them every day living around and going to sports- I have never seen any poor behaviour

(unlike another local independent school)"

@massivenamechnage I think the poster was referring to the House of Commons not the public school!

pointythings · 01/04/2023 15:04

I grew up in the Netherlands and technically, we had zero tolerance in our school. No uniform, so no nonsense about that - but bullying was dealt with hard, disruptive behaviour in class was a same day detention.

Aside from that things were much more pragmatic. Teachers didn't mark homework outside of school unless it was a piece of work that counted towards your termly report. Not doing it meant a zero score, which pulled down your average grade. And because all termly reports counted (weighted) towards your end of year report, a zero score did damage. It was up to the individual pupil (and their parents) to take responsibility for that. In the Dutch system you could (and still can) be held back a year if your grades were not good enough.

Didn't have your pen and your equipment and couldn't do the work? You'd get left behind and increase your risk of a failing grade. Again, responsibility. Didn't have your PE kit? You had to use the hideous stuff in the Lost and Found (yes, it was washed) and do PE anyway.

No nitpicking and draconian rules needed.

Macaroni46 · 01/04/2023 14:56

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 01/04/2023 12:46

Why in these discussions are the people who have to bear the brunt of your Little Rebel never considered. The kids who WANT to learn. The teachers who want to do a good job. Why is their education and their professionalism constantly compromised because Little Rebel doesn’t want to do something like tuck his shirt in.

Well said!

fliptopbin · 01/04/2023 14:50

I actually took my DCs out of a zero tolerance school when my son had racked up days in isolation for not being able to track the teacher with his lazy eye, and my 14 year old DD was desperate to go on the contraceptive injection because she was terrified of getting her period at school and not being allowed to go to the toilet.
They are now thriving at the new school (although they now have the problem of not having time to go to the toilet at lunchtime if they are doing activities.)

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 14:36

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 13:48

Why would you not still talk to these kids? Either individually or to the whole pack

You'd be amazed how surprised some of these kids are that you talk to them.

Students are spoken to constantly, I dont know where you get the idea that they are not.

fliptopbin · 01/04/2023 14:35

I was talking to my 16 year old DS about toilets at school, and he just said that everyone knows not to drink anything during the school day because there isnt time to use the toilets, and they are locked at lunchtime a lot of the time.
Yes it is good for compliance, but it isn't good healthwise. I guess you could argue that teachers do this, so it is good practise for adult life. (I did this as a teacher for 15 years and suffered chronic UTIs as a result. )

ancientgran · 01/04/2023 14:25

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 12:59

I supply. One week I may encounter over 1000 children.

I still try and talk to/build a relationship with every child I meet. Regardless of whether they disrupt my lesson or not, whether I know I am going to see them ever again or not

Some of the ones who are the most disruptive are the ones who are the most interesting to talk to and who need that interaction the most.

When they come up to you two weeks/month later as say remember me? And you do (sometimes with a little prompting of remind me) you know how much that means to them. They try a little harder, they may not succeed, but you're worth trying for.

The idea that you can't build a relationship with a child you see for 3 hours every week, however feral, is beyond me.

I'm not a teacher but to me that sounds like you are teaching for 30 hrs a week? If you are teaching 1000 children that week it mean every hour you need to be talking and building a relationship with about 33 children. Is that right? I find it hard to believe you can have much interaction, I mean by the time they get settled and you find out their names how long would you have with each child in a class, one or two minutes and that would leave no time to teach anything.

My maths might be failing me so I'm happy for you to explain it for the hard of understanding.

massivenamechnage · 01/04/2023 14:20

TooBigForMyBoots · 01/04/2023 12:32

Are they putting a Behaviour Hub in Westminster?

Are you suggesting that the boys at Westminster are not well behaved?
I live nearby and see them every day living around and going to sports- I have never seen any poor behaviour

(unlike another local independent school)

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 13:48

Why would you not still talk to these kids? Either individually or to the whole pack

You'd be amazed how surprised some of these kids are that you talk to them.

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 13:48

Effingmagicfairy · 01/04/2023 13:22

@AM130674 I could have written your post, same happened to my DD, most awful time, she’s through the other side, by moving to a slightly out of area school that fortunately had a space. I thought even though schools are oversubscribed you could appeal on bullying grounds/mental health. Be careful choosing one around the same area, social media means bullying can follow, hence our choice for out of area. My DDs bullies had already primed the bullies at the school they thought she would move to. We left an Academy that was very good at handing out consequences for minor behaviour but had absolutely no control on bullying, I never sent her back when the physical threats started happening, she was off for 5 weeks whilst getting a new place but this was when offices had staff off for Covid isolations. The school we left literally washed their hands off my DD when I refused to send her back, no work set, nothing. She’s doing well in her new school and on course for passing GCSE’s. I hope you and your DD have a lovely Easter break, being bullied is the most awful time for both child and parent, thinking of you both 💐

Effingmagic, thank you.

Can I ask how you dealt with the absence for those 5 weeks? Did you have the LA knocking at your door threatening with fines etc? I am worried about this.

My DD also mentioned some of the schools, she knows the circle of friends is wider and other local ish schools. Something I am conscious of avoiding.

So glad your DD has settled into new school.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 13:44

Hdhabvdhhebsb · 01/04/2023 13:35

You actually did throw NT children under the bus in what you said. I directly quoted what you said which is effectively they don't matter they will probably be ok.

Yes that is the reality of life currently.

And yes on the whole the NT kids will probably be OK.

Not that they dont matter, but they will be OK.

But however bad you think it is for NT kids, it is actually still the SEN kids that are thrown under a bus

Blu3Salv1a · 01/04/2023 13:36

Well I hope they sort out the crisis in mental health provision and the autism/ADHD diagnosis process first.

Yes thought not- CAMHs isn’t fit for purpose and some areas are now closing diagnosis waiting lists until kids are in crisis or relationship with school has broken down.

So what is going to happen to those kids?

Hdhabvdhhebsb · 01/04/2023 13:35

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 11:59

I never said it was OK. I just stated reality.

And it really isn't NT kids that suffer most from the arrangement

If I could organise and fully fund education my way, education would look nothing like it does now

You actually did throw NT children under the bus in what you said. I directly quoted what you said which is effectively they don't matter they will probably be ok.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 01/04/2023 13:30

I’m a strict-ish teacher. I have brilliant relationships with the kids I teach. Because good relationships start with good boundaries. I don’t tolerate being called a cunt by anyone in my life, so I’m not going to tolerate it from a pupil. I wouldn’t want any child I care about to be in a school where that sort of behaviour is considered normal. But in return, the kids I teach know that I care about them and want to help them learn. Time in detention is spent usefully rather than just punitively (eg doing the homework they missed, or discussing the potential consequences of throwing a glue stick across a science lab).

Behaviour in many schools at the moment is shocking. Something needs to seriously change, because way too many kids want to learn and can’t, just because the behaviour of a few is ruining it for the rest. Of course more funding would massively help, and so would properly resourced external agencies. Teachers are often working over 60hrs on a normal week and many more when there is mock marking, report writing or parents’ evenings to do. They just don’t have the time (or expertise) to fix all of the underlying causes of a child misbehaving. It is naive in the extreme to think that teachers are able to do this, and it represents a serious misunderstanding of what schools are for.

The rules in most schools are sensible and well thought-out. Not every rule, obviously, but the majority. Children need to bring a pen because without it they can’t complete the lesson and so will learn less. Children need to listen when a teacher is talking so that they understand the task they’re about to do. Children need to complete their homework so the teacher can mark it, offer feedback and plan the next lessons to tackle misunderstandings or stretch their thinking. Children need to use the toilet at the designated times whenever possible so that they are in lessons and learning during class time.

Finally, “zero tolerance” is very rarely actually zero tolerance. Bennett’s philosophy is that some rules need to be in place to ensure learning can happen, and those rules need to be enforced by all staff. Exceptions should be made, but they should be exceptional. I find that very difficult to argue against tbh.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 13:23

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 13:17

You are of course right. I do not have a relationship with every child i meet.

I said I will try and talk. If I sow a thousand seeds and a few grow, I'm happy.

But to not even try and sow those seeds because "there are too many" and they are "feral", I find inexplicable.

but of course everyone tries to "sow the seeds" of a relationship with as many students as possible, I am simply pointing out that it is not possible if the school behaviour policy is against you.

I have very rarely failed to establish a relationship with any child I have had an opportunity to speak to one to one - but when children are ranging through the schools and lessons in gangs, and you are trying to deal with 5-10 at once, it is simply not going to happen, especially when you add up how many of these packs you deal with in a single day

Effingmagicfairy · 01/04/2023 13:22

@AM130674 I could have written your post, same happened to my DD, most awful time, she’s through the other side, by moving to a slightly out of area school that fortunately had a space. I thought even though schools are oversubscribed you could appeal on bullying grounds/mental health. Be careful choosing one around the same area, social media means bullying can follow, hence our choice for out of area. My DDs bullies had already primed the bullies at the school they thought she would move to. We left an Academy that was very good at handing out consequences for minor behaviour but had absolutely no control on bullying, I never sent her back when the physical threats started happening, she was off for 5 weeks whilst getting a new place but this was when offices had staff off for Covid isolations. The school we left literally washed their hands off my DD when I refused to send her back, no work set, nothing. She’s doing well in her new school and on course for passing GCSE’s. I hope you and your DD have a lovely Easter break, being bullied is the most awful time for both child and parent, thinking of you both 💐

angstridden2 · 01/04/2023 13:21

I would be interested to know how many people commenting are actually teaching in huge state schools with a very mixed intake. It’s easy to criticise what seem to be fairly draconian steps such as denying toilet breaks without a pass if you don’t really know what’s going on in schools these days.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 13:17

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 13:11

if you are doing supply, you are in a different category. but even so, if you think you have a relationship with 1000 students a week, you are clearly very deluded!

yes, we can all attempt to build up relationships with as many students as possible, but sheer numbers make it completely impossible ,and wasting hours and hours on behaviour make it harder still

I would say even more ineffective than not having enough opportunity to build up relationships in your class would be fooling yourself that you have, when you have not.

I would suggest you have a perceived relationship with "a class" and have deceived yourself into thinking that you have a relationship with all the individuals in it, which you won't have, as a supply teacher, so the fact that you seem to think you do, would mean there is a huge amount happening that you are oblivious to.

A class is not a single entity

You are of course right. I do not have a relationship with every child i meet.

I said I will try and talk. If I sow a thousand seeds and a few grow, I'm happy.

But to not even try and sow those seeds because "there are too many" and they are "feral", I find inexplicable.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 01/04/2023 13:15

A school near us recently got taken over by a new academy (they were an academy already) after a shocking ofsted triggered by parent (and, I heard, teacher) complaints. They’ve gone in hard on the behaviour. In the first week some ridiculous percentage of children were in detention. Some of the infringements were minor - forgetting equipment, uniform, etc. I wasn’t sure I agreed with that, but then one of the teachers explained the impact of half the class rummaging around for missing equipment for the first 5-10 mins of every lesson. They don’t forget their phones, she pointed out. Honestly, given some of the stuff that was going on in that school (knives….the ofsted report said the children didn’t feel safe at school), I think the approach they’ve taken is sensible. I would however hope that over time as they get things under control that more discretion can be taken, along the lines of the pp who said she’d turn a blind eye to someone borrowing a glue stick when theirs unexpectedly ran out.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 13:13

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 01/04/2023 13:07

To a dozen pupils in one lesson? When do you actually, ya know, teach the curriculum?

Some of the best ways in are marking work and teaching them something they previously didn't get.

But it's not unusual for kids to stop behind in breaks and talk.

Either way it's better/more interesting than yelling at them to do as they're told.

OriGanOver · 01/04/2023 13:12

@Icedlatteplease same! If you're taking it personal then you're expecting validation and gratification from students.

However, if the school fosters a shit working environment and the management isn't supportive I can see why that's the tip of an iceburg.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 13:11

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 12:59

I supply. One week I may encounter over 1000 children.

I still try and talk to/build a relationship with every child I meet. Regardless of whether they disrupt my lesson or not, whether I know I am going to see them ever again or not

Some of the ones who are the most disruptive are the ones who are the most interesting to talk to and who need that interaction the most.

When they come up to you two weeks/month later as say remember me? And you do (sometimes with a little prompting of remind me) you know how much that means to them. They try a little harder, they may not succeed, but you're worth trying for.

The idea that you can't build a relationship with a child you see for 3 hours every week, however feral, is beyond me.

if you are doing supply, you are in a different category. but even so, if you think you have a relationship with 1000 students a week, you are clearly very deluded!

yes, we can all attempt to build up relationships with as many students as possible, but sheer numbers make it completely impossible ,and wasting hours and hours on behaviour make it harder still

I would say even more ineffective than not having enough opportunity to build up relationships in your class would be fooling yourself that you have, when you have not.

I would suggest you have a perceived relationship with "a class" and have deceived yourself into thinking that you have a relationship with all the individuals in it, which you won't have, as a supply teacher, so the fact that you seem to think you do, would mean there is a huge amount happening that you are oblivious to.

A class is not a single entity