Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government Behaviour Hub pushing zero tolerance in schools

259 replies

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 06:13

I've just been reading how the Behaviour Hub set up by the government has been pushing this idea of very strict behaviour policies and zero tolerance in schools. The sort rolled out by many of the academy chains. Does anyone know what the evidence base is for this?

The policies in many of these schools are highly restrictive - short lunch breaks, limited access to toilet breaks, consequences for minor mistakes. Many adults would find it stressful to be in an environment like this. I wonder if anyone has looked at the cost of these measures to the children in terms of their mental health, fostering independence and social skills etc.

Any insight, thoughts or links to research on this would be great.

OP posts:
pointythings · 01/04/2023 19:08

@Nimbostratus100 could you point me in the direction of some examples, please?

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 19:06

pointythings · 01/04/2023 19:04

What worries me is that the UK system seems to be an outlier in introducing this kind of thing, so what is it that is makinr UK kids so much more difficult and dangerous than kids in other countries? I mean, the obsession with every nitpicky detail of uniform is just weird.

no, we are not really, other countries have similar problems, and resolutions

pointythings · 01/04/2023 19:04

What worries me is that the UK system seems to be an outlier in introducing this kind of thing, so what is it that is makinr UK kids so much more difficult and dangerous than kids in other countries? I mean, the obsession with every nitpicky detail of uniform is just weird.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 19:03

ginniegingin · 01/04/2023 18:37

Someone explain the tracking bit of SLANT please. Does the child have to literally stare at the teacher at all times and move their eyes / head if the teacher moves? That's not normal human behaviour, surely?!

No, its worse than that, each child is required to turn around and stare at any other child who is speaking to the class - it is stupid, and intimidating, and of course, used as a an excuse to pull faces at the speaker, I hate it and forbid it totally, even when teaching in SLANT schools, where technically you should issue a warning or detention if it is not done

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 19:02

I was talking to my friend about this today and she's told me about a petition that's been set up about the behaviour hubs and zero tolerance - might be worth a look for anyone interested. I don't know if it quotes any research about it all though.

OP posts:
ginniegingin · 01/04/2023 18:37

Someone explain the tracking bit of SLANT please. Does the child have to literally stare at the teacher at all times and move their eyes / head if the teacher moves? That's not normal human behaviour, surely?!

pointythings · 01/04/2023 18:23

@Boudicasbeard as in any country there is socioeconomic inequality in the Netherlands and in Belgium - but it is far less extreme than it is in the UK. In the Netherlands you have people labelled as 'asocialen', which loosely correlates to the British 'chav' and no, as a group they do not engage with education - but the numbers are much smaller and so in any school as parents they will be the minority. If they kick up in the way British disengaged parents do, they are laughed at and not taken seriously. It also helps that there's no class system left in the Netherlands and in Belgium and yes, there is a culture of personal responsibility alongside a recognition that some people will always need extra help.

The majority of my fellow students worked their backsides off to avoid being left behind, it was a huge stigma for that to happen. Definitely motivated people.

When I was at school, we were expected to provide everything except books - those were on loan from the school and you had to look after them or pay for any damage (always small amounts). It was just how things were. And yes, we did lend each other pens and sheets of paper as needed.

I got detention once, for a whole class rebellion against a supply teacher who was both incompetent and unjust. The entire class got the detention and it was fine. So I got home late, told my mum (who was a secondary teacher) what had happened and it was fine.

Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 18:12

The Dutch and Belgian systems do sound interesting.

I have to ask: what is the parental attitude to this. Because my experience in the U.K. is that parents would see this as draconian. They expect us to provide pens, accept rudeness and accept students doing nothing. But then kick up a huge fuss if that child is failing a subject.

rivierliedje · 01/04/2023 17:58

Lovanna · 01/04/2023 17:30

Straight forward and builds accountability & responsibility. I'm in favour!

Unfortunately I think, the difference in England is the high pressure environment based on outcomes and results. Pressure from the DfE on school leaders. Ofsted. Parents.

In the UK system we daren't let a child get a zero, because the end results would be too low, risking the high pressure mentioned above

I grew up in Belgium and it was much like the previous poster in the Netherlands. But possibly a bit harsher in the sense that every single test and bit of homework was part of your final grade. Didn't do it, zero for you. Spelling mistakes on your biology paper, lose points, forgot an accent in French, lose half a mark, forgot your hair tie during chemistry, lose a mark for that. Didn't use the school headed paper for a test/homework lose marks for that.
And you can definitely still repeat years in Belgium.
I also don't understand the idea that if I child has forgotten a pen they either need a detention or the teacher has to fuss about it. Surely you just ask your friend to borrow one or you take no notes and suffer the natural consequences. No teacher I ever encountered would have done anything about you not having a pen. For PE kit you just borrowed manky stuff from lost and found, did it in your clothes or sat out and got zero. A missing book meant sharing with a friend (we had to buy all our books so were bringing them in and out of school).
My secondary school wasn't particularly strict, I barely remember anyone getting detention or any other form of punishment that wasn't a natural consequence of not doing the work.
It does massively help that schools aren't compared to each other officially, there are no league tables and no external exams.

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 17:44

Thank you for sending these, I'll take a look at these.

For reference, my DD has no bad marks apart from the detention a couple of weeks ago for not handing in her merit card. And her attendance is excellent.

L1ttledrummergirl · 01/04/2023 17:36

A compliant child will become a compliant adult.

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 17:32

Effingmagicfairy · 01/04/2023 17:24

@AM130674 We never had anyone knock at the door, nothing, which seems to me the school were brushing under the carpet, let the bullied child leave quietly ………just my thoughts.

Is it you refusing to send your DD or is she refusing to go. If my memory serves me correct the school have certain protocol to follow for DC refusing, you just tell them she won’t go, they have to act upon this (ours was useless) then apply for other schools, in my area you have to apply to find out where your position on waiting list. You are then actively trying to resolve your DDs attendance and if the LEA turn up on your doorstep you can tell them this. If you don’t get another school place in the first instance, appeal citing the bullying, mental health, etc, sometimes this is enough for a school to create a place.

The whole situation makes my blood boil, it was my DD that missed out on school through no fault of her own, the bullies won - they got to stay and moved on to some other poor soul, I wish I could have done more and created merryhell but seeing the state of my DDs mental health I just had to focus on getting her out and into a safe place.

Thank you this is so helpful.

DD is begging not to go back, she is terrified and rightly so. She cries and shakes even when I openly talk about the situation. She has been completely ostracised from her whole peer group. I will fight this with every bone in my body. I have reached out to LA for guidance and I have sent one application already. She has studied every day so far she has been home.

I am keeping a paper trail of everything and I am going to her current school for a meeting on 18th April as I want to understand how the rules allows the bullies a slap on the wrist.

Lovanna · 01/04/2023 17:30

pointythings · 01/04/2023 15:04

I grew up in the Netherlands and technically, we had zero tolerance in our school. No uniform, so no nonsense about that - but bullying was dealt with hard, disruptive behaviour in class was a same day detention.

Aside from that things were much more pragmatic. Teachers didn't mark homework outside of school unless it was a piece of work that counted towards your termly report. Not doing it meant a zero score, which pulled down your average grade. And because all termly reports counted (weighted) towards your end of year report, a zero score did damage. It was up to the individual pupil (and their parents) to take responsibility for that. In the Dutch system you could (and still can) be held back a year if your grades were not good enough.

Didn't have your pen and your equipment and couldn't do the work? You'd get left behind and increase your risk of a failing grade. Again, responsibility. Didn't have your PE kit? You had to use the hideous stuff in the Lost and Found (yes, it was washed) and do PE anyway.

No nitpicking and draconian rules needed.

Straight forward and builds accountability & responsibility. I'm in favour!

Unfortunately I think, the difference in England is the high pressure environment based on outcomes and results. Pressure from the DfE on school leaders. Ofsted. Parents.

In the UK system we daren't let a child get a zero, because the end results would be too low, risking the high pressure mentioned above

Effingmagicfairy · 01/04/2023 17:24

@AM130674 We never had anyone knock at the door, nothing, which seems to me the school were brushing under the carpet, let the bullied child leave quietly ………just my thoughts.

Is it you refusing to send your DD or is she refusing to go. If my memory serves me correct the school have certain protocol to follow for DC refusing, you just tell them she won’t go, they have to act upon this (ours was useless) then apply for other schools, in my area you have to apply to find out where your position on waiting list. You are then actively trying to resolve your DDs attendance and if the LEA turn up on your doorstep you can tell them this. If you don’t get another school place in the first instance, appeal citing the bullying, mental health, etc, sometimes this is enough for a school to create a place.

The whole situation makes my blood boil, it was my DD that missed out on school through no fault of her own, the bullies won - they got to stay and moved on to some other poor soul, I wish I could have done more and created merryhell but seeing the state of my DDs mental health I just had to focus on getting her out and into a safe place.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 17:09

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 15:57

God no i agree. My comment was in ammazement at response to the teacher that didn't feel able to build relationships with kids they saw 3 hours a week.

it is very easy to build up a relationship with kids you see 3 hours a week, as long as you have a chance to deal with them individually, or in pairs, not as a pack of children behaving in a feral manner, which precludes any meaningful communication.

If you have 10 classes, and packs of 5-10 in each class, that is 50-100 students using pack behaviour as a way of disrupting lessons and avoiding meaningful communication.

No, you cant get to know them and discuss their behaviour in these gangs. You need to have time for one-to-one conversation - so 50 - 100 children needing one-to-one conversations of say 10-15 minutes each...

so 8-25 hours a week just talking through their behaviour with them? and then all the time required to record and report the conversations?

Simply not possible. and also, not related to education!

You need a strict , structured, ordered school to prevent these packs forming, then you can get to know your students, through supporting and teaching them

ClosingTimey · 01/04/2023 16:23

You can use a right to choose nhs provider @RedToothBrush , to get a much quicker assessment. You might have to travel out of the county you are in, but some ADHD assessments can be done online.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 16:21

ancientgran · 01/04/2023 16:18

Not sure why the system would burn me out, I was never a teacher and I'm retired from the job I actually did do.

I don't think you were the one who said it. The you was more hypothetical

ancientgran · 01/04/2023 16:18

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 16:16

God no.

It was more being horrified that anyone could be in teaching and not build bonds with kids they see 3 hours a week every week.

If I can try, see value and very occasionally succeed with the number of kids I see perhaps once a fortnight I'm at a loss why you wouldn't think you couldn't with the limited number you see weekly.

At that point I do wonder if the system has burnt you out

Not sure why the system would burn me out, I was never a teacher and I'm retired from the job I actually did do.

Mischance · 01/04/2023 16:16

Funny places schools.

Let's stick children together in their hordes, which is totally against natural families which are multi-generational. Let's have so many children that draconian and petty rules become a necessity for the sake of everyone's protection. Let's value these petty rules over and above learning.

It's all a mess.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 16:16

ancientgran · 01/04/2023 16:09

Maybe it didn't come over how you meant it then. Sounded like you were doing something quite amazing with those conversations and relationships at a thousand a week.

God no.

It was more being horrified that anyone could be in teaching and not build bonds with kids they see 3 hours a week every week.

If I can try, see value and very occasionally succeed with the number of kids I see perhaps once a fortnight I'm at a loss why you wouldn't think you couldn't with the limited number you see weekly.

At that point I do wonder if the system has burnt you out

ancientgran · 01/04/2023 16:11

Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 16:06

@ancientgran

It’s called super teacher complex and there is a lot of evidence that it leads to toxic work environments. The teachers who think giving the kids what they want, instead of striking a balance between want and need, and end up setting kids up to fail.

I call it ‘But they’re well behaved for me’ syndrome.

You can be strict without being mean. You can have standards and not be an arsehole.

There is a very good book about it called Radical Candor.

Thanks for the explanation. I thought my maths was going off the rails and to be fair it wasn't my best subject and I left school 54 years ago and I don't suppose it has magically improved.

ancientgran · 01/04/2023 16:09

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 15:57

God no i agree. My comment was in ammazement at response to the teacher that didn't feel able to build relationships with kids they saw 3 hours a week.

Maybe it didn't come over how you meant it then. Sounded like you were doing something quite amazing with those conversations and relationships at a thousand a week.

Boudicasbeard · 01/04/2023 16:06

@ancientgran

It’s called super teacher complex and there is a lot of evidence that it leads to toxic work environments. The teachers who think giving the kids what they want, instead of striking a balance between want and need, and end up setting kids up to fail.

I call it ‘But they’re well behaved for me’ syndrome.

You can be strict without being mean. You can have standards and not be an arsehole.

There is a very good book about it called Radical Candor.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 15:57

ancientgran · 01/04/2023 15:54

So trying to talk and build a relationship with every child can come down to saying well done. I don't think that is particularly revolutionary, I'd be amazed if most teachers don't say at least two words to their pupils in the course of a week.

I think you are imagining you are doing something very different to other teachers.

God no i agree. My comment was in ammazement at response to the teacher that didn't feel able to build relationships with kids they saw 3 hours a week.

Swipe left for the next trending thread