Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government Behaviour Hub pushing zero tolerance in schools

259 replies

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 06:13

I've just been reading how the Behaviour Hub set up by the government has been pushing this idea of very strict behaviour policies and zero tolerance in schools. The sort rolled out by many of the academy chains. Does anyone know what the evidence base is for this?

The policies in many of these schools are highly restrictive - short lunch breaks, limited access to toilet breaks, consequences for minor mistakes. Many adults would find it stressful to be in an environment like this. I wonder if anyone has looked at the cost of these measures to the children in terms of their mental health, fostering independence and social skills etc.

Any insight, thoughts or links to research on this would be great.

OP posts:
pointythings · 01/04/2023 21:47

So the trend has been and still is to get stricter and stricter and stricter - and things are not getting better.

What was that thing Albert Einstein said about the definition of insanity?

Heatherjayne1972 · 01/04/2023 21:44

Our school is very strict on the tiniest little infraction
Eg the kids have to be there by 8.28 am
have exactly the right uniform
exactly the right equipment
plus lots of other things
detentions are handed out far too easily and are hugely counterproductive ( in my opinion)

and the kids ? Well they’re currently running a competition amongst themselves to see who can get the highest number of detentions

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 21:42

Schools should be doing and publishing parent surveys (parent view is good but doesn’t ask all the right questions) every year not just when an ofsted is due.

pointythings · 01/04/2023 21:39

Florenz · 01/04/2023 21:28

"But there have been examples of schools which have abandoned uniform and seen results improve in the UK."
So why haven't more schools done this? The main thing schools care about is improving results, if having no uniform was an easy way to do this, you'd think more schools would do it.

I never said it was an easy way to do this. There isn't an easy way to fix the UK system. Uniform is a symptom, not a cause.

The UK education system is obsessed with data, metrics and appearances. There's an old saying: you don't fatten a pig by weighing it. All we do is weigh the pig.

  • We don't respect teachers. We pay them badly, overload them with work and give parents and bureaucracy power over them rather than trusting them to do their work.
  • We think a pretty uniform equals good teaching.
  • We don't fund education - it's 2023 and adjusting for inflation we still haven't returned to 2010 per child funding levels. You get what you pay for.
  • We focus on academics and do not recognise that there are many children whose talents do not lie in this direction - and we do nothing to develop them.

We should be looking at what other countries are doing and see what we can learn - taking into account that we are culturally a Western European country. I'm reluctant to recommend more reform after the Great Gove Cockup, but equally we can't go on like this.

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 21:38

For me the measure of a good school is a caring environment where children achieve the best outcome for their own individual circumstances. Where all members of the school community are treated fairly and with respect. Surely the best measure is parental and young persons feedback not league tables.

Re the uniform thing, the argument is that a uniform is a leveller and can be cost effective. I get that, but apply the policy flexibly and as long as the uniform is “good enough” then don’t get too upset with minor infractions.

Florenz · 01/04/2023 21:28

"But there have been examples of schools which have abandoned uniform and seen results improve in the UK."
So why haven't more schools done this? The main thing schools care about is improving results, if having no uniform was an easy way to do this, you'd think more schools would do it.

Florenz · 01/04/2023 21:27

So what is the measure of a good school?

pointythings · 01/04/2023 21:27

Florenz · 01/04/2023 21:23

Why doesn't a school do away with uniform, sore up the league tables and set an example with other schools for to follow?

Parental pressure, fear, the UK obsession with style over substance - who knows. But there have been examples of schools which have abandoned uniform and seen results improve in the UK.

The point I'm trying to make here is that there are better ways to do this and we should explore them. My DDs went to our local 6th form, which was completely non-uniform. No 'business suits', just the freedom to wear what you wanted as long as it was clean, not ripped and free of offensive language. Good results, good behaviour all round. And no, our town isn't wealthy and leafy by any means.

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 21:26

Florenz · 01/04/2023 21:23

Why doesn't a school do away with uniform, sore up the league tables and set an example with other schools for to follow?

League tables aren’t the only measure of a good school and can be manipulated by some of the poor practices some of the academies have been found to do.

Florenz · 01/04/2023 21:23

Why doesn't a school do away with uniform, sore up the league tables and set an example with other schools for to follow?

pointythings · 01/04/2023 21:17

Florenz · 01/04/2023 21:13

So the solution to kids not wearing proper uniform is to not have uniform at all, so they can't get in trouble for not wearing it?

Yes, exactly. Like they do in many countries which have better educational outcomes than the UK. I don't see why people don't understand this.

You don't need uniform to have good educational outcomes. You don't need it to prevent bullying - you tackle the bullying itself directly. You don't need it to prepare for the world of work (as evidenced by all the countries where there is no uniform and yet young people manage to move into the world of work perfectly well).

Focus on behaviour. Don't preventively assume all students are bad, act when they bisbehave and do it thoroughly. It really isn't rocket science and I don't understand why British schools can't manage it.

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 21:17

No the solution is not to get your knickers in a twist about whether someone has the wrong socks on or not. It’s ridiculous and petty and sanctioning a kid for that kind of thing just undermines respect for teachers not strengthens it, because both parents and children think the teacher is a dick for enforcing it!

Florenz · 01/04/2023 21:13

So the solution to kids not wearing proper uniform is to not have uniform at all, so they can't get in trouble for not wearing it?

pointythings · 01/04/2023 21:12

@Florenz and the solution there is to not have uniform, and to have standard sanctions for disruptive behaviour which are fairly and predictably applied. If you don't make kids wear blazers but instead have somewhere that coats can be placed, you avoid the problem altogether.

Florenz · 01/04/2023 21:08

nofilteronme · 01/04/2023 20:41

DS goes to an academy school like this.

I completely agree with discipline for disruptive behaviours, rudeness, fighting etc.

But DS was given a negative behaviour point because his socks weren't totally black, they had the day of the week written in red along the sole and he had forgotten he had drama so would need to take his shoes off. My friends son was given a negative point because his blazer fell off the back of his chair twice in one lesson. Absolutely ridiculous! And it's gotten worse since these incidents because they now follow 'SLANT' and other such strategies.

Why is it ridiculous? A negative behaviour point seems perfectly reasonable. Nothing will happen if they don't keep getting negative behaviour points.

Do you not think that some kids will deliberately wear the wrong uniform or "accidentally" knock their blazer off their chair to cause disruption/get attention?

pointythings · 01/04/2023 20:57

@Florenz I have no problem with same day detentions for disruptive behaviour in class. I have no problem with exclusions for bullying and violence. I do have a problem with the endless petty nonsense about uniform infractions. Just get rid of it already. Hosts of countries across the North Sea manage to maintain achievement and good behaviour without it - because not faffing about with a student's socks or tie means you can focus on tackling behaviour and bullying. All these new draconian rules over petty things are just papering over the cracks of a system that is failing for far more fundamental reasons.

nofilteronme · 01/04/2023 20:41

DS goes to an academy school like this.

I completely agree with discipline for disruptive behaviours, rudeness, fighting etc.

But DS was given a negative behaviour point because his socks weren't totally black, they had the day of the week written in red along the sole and he had forgotten he had drama so would need to take his shoes off. My friends son was given a negative point because his blazer fell off the back of his chair twice in one lesson. Absolutely ridiculous! And it's gotten worse since these incidents because they now follow 'SLANT' and other such strategies.

Nepmarthiturn · 01/04/2023 20:40

Florenz · 01/04/2023 20:39

What do you all imagine schools are supposed to be doing to prepare kids for the working world?

Excluding them immediately for violence, threatening behaviour or bullying would be a good start.

Florenz · 01/04/2023 20:39

What do you all imagine schools are supposed to be doing to prepare kids for the working world?

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 20:26

A lot of these concepts are cultish and bear no resemblance to life in the real world. I don’t turn and stare at my colleagues in meetings, sometimes I write notes, i doodle, I may even look out the window. No one puts me on a disciplinary if my top button isn’t done up or my coat isn’t black or I ask to go to the loo. I think a lot of teachers have no clue what “real world” is like because they’ve spent their whole adult lives working in schools. Most the teachers I know can barely log into Facebook so how on earth they can be expected to understand how kids interact with social media I really don’t know. Schools aren’t there to churn out robots or young people riddled with anxiety but they are doing a great job of trying to achieve this.

pointythings · 01/04/2023 20:19

@Florenz there are ways of instilling this that aren't about forcing creepy constant tracking on people. Being attentive in class is a completely different thing from speaking in front of an audience. Generations of children all over the world have managed to behave, pay attention and learn without SLANT. It's just another educational fad, and one that is damaging to a subset of students.

Florenz · 01/04/2023 20:13

How do people who don't like to be looked at cope with work meetings? Tell co-workers, managers etc not to look at them?

Being able to speak confidently in front of an audience of people looking at you is an important life skill. School is the place where kids are supposed to learn life skills.

pointythings · 01/04/2023 20:13

Florenz · 01/04/2023 19:24

What is wrong with teaching kids that it is polite to look at the person who is speaking?

Well, if the class is set out in rows, it would mean people constantly having to turn round in their seats, which wouldn't feel creepy at all to anyone speaking, especially an introvert.

Even the man who invented SLANT has now modified it because he admits it wasn't fit for purpose.

megletthesecond · 01/04/2023 19:48

Maybe the speaker doesn't want to be looked at. Speaking in class was terrifying enough as it was.

SLANT sounds like it's designed for extroverts and to hell with everyone else.

Florenz · 01/04/2023 19:24

What is wrong with teaching kids that it is polite to look at the person who is speaking?