Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government Behaviour Hub pushing zero tolerance in schools

259 replies

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 06:13

I've just been reading how the Behaviour Hub set up by the government has been pushing this idea of very strict behaviour policies and zero tolerance in schools. The sort rolled out by many of the academy chains. Does anyone know what the evidence base is for this?

The policies in many of these schools are highly restrictive - short lunch breaks, limited access to toilet breaks, consequences for minor mistakes. Many adults would find it stressful to be in an environment like this. I wonder if anyone has looked at the cost of these measures to the children in terms of their mental health, fostering independence and social skills etc.

Any insight, thoughts or links to research on this would be great.

OP posts:
Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 08:03

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 07:59

She and I want her to stay in school, just not that school. She wants friends, these bullies were friends, or so she thought until they lost use of her and turned on her.

If there are sufficient threats to break the legal threshold you can go down the police route which may force the school to take action.

The school has no sanctions that can stop your DD being bullied. They cannot expel easily if at all.

megletthesecond · 01/04/2023 08:03

It would cause a miserable amount of stress to my DD. She's well behaved and too scared to do anything that might get her told off. At least she only has two years to go.

RainyReadingDay · 01/04/2023 08:02

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 07:47

My daughter goes to an academy.

I have just removed her as she was being seriously bullied. The bullies have destroyed her reputation within her peer group. She's been threatened with violence and had several comments from wider group to kill herself.

Once a confident 13 year old, she is now a shadow of herself, too scared to leave the house alone and is so anxious, too scared to ever go back to that school.

The bullies, all of whom are already on final warnings for bad behaviour? All got a slap in the wrist and reminded on the school rules on bullying. My daughter is now expected to go back. The school sanctions do not work.

The school refuse to authorise her absence and so won't provide work for her, even though I have made it very clear I will facilitate her education, just not in that toxic environment.

The school have completely failed her, all other schools in the area are over subscribed, so what do I do?

In this instance I would consider deregistering immediately for your DD's mental health. That sounds an appallingly toxic place for her to be trying to get an education at. Look into every possible complaints you can make, tell the school, tell Ofsted, tell your MP, everyone you can think of. But first of all, let your DD recover. The LA has to help you over this. There are alternatives too, like home education, and you'd find local support groups on Facebook, where people with lots of experience about this can help you. Schools can be awful toxic places and can destroy your mental health if situations aren't dealt with properly.

Daffodilwoman · 01/04/2023 08:02

Dh only has 30 minutes for lunch and he works 9 hour shifts.
When I worked for an academy the staff were told what they could and could not wear and it was ridiculous. They were more relaxed with the pupils than the staff. You should see the state of the parents and how they were allowed to wonder around yet staff had to be covered up and treated like prisoners.
When I was at school we did not have a uniform. The school turned out some very artistic and sporty kids. Discipline was good but that was back in the day when teachers were in control and the idea of swearing at a teacher was incomprehensible.

mamnotmum · 01/04/2023 08:01

Dacadactyl · 01/04/2023 06:37

I've no idea of the evidence base, nor about what a behaviour hub is. However, my thoughts (going by what you've written) is that this is a good thing.

Kids deserve to be able to learn and unfortunately too often (round these parts anyway) others who won't behave, ruin it for them.

I'd love every school to have a zero tolerance approach tbh. Schools know who the troublemakers are I'm sure.

High standards in small things (things you might think minor, like uniform) lead to high standards in major things (like results)

I pretty much agree with this (maybe apart from the last paragraph - not sure the high standards in little things is overly important) but ....

My daughter describes her school environment 'like a zoo'. She wants to learn but the disruption by other kids is unreal.

Every lesson is disrupted and I'm not talking a little bit of chatting, I'm talking kids throwing things, tipping desks over, running around, shouting and teachers having to spend time dealing with this. Every lunchtime there's a fight or a drama about something.

The behaviour in secondary schools in digesting and something needs to be done. I don't know what these government measures are but I'd welcome something that gives my kids the opportunity to learn uninterrupted!

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 07:59

She and I want her to stay in school, just not that school. She wants friends, these bullies were friends, or so she thought until they lost use of her and turned on her.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 07:56

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 07:47

My daughter goes to an academy.

I have just removed her as she was being seriously bullied. The bullies have destroyed her reputation within her peer group. She's been threatened with violence and had several comments from wider group to kill herself.

Once a confident 13 year old, she is now a shadow of herself, too scared to leave the house alone and is so anxious, too scared to ever go back to that school.

The bullies, all of whom are already on final warnings for bad behaviour? All got a slap in the wrist and reminded on the school rules on bullying. My daughter is now expected to go back. The school sanctions do not work.

The school refuse to authorise her absence and so won't provide work for her, even though I have made it very clear I will facilitate her education, just not in that toxic environment.

The school have completely failed her, all other schools in the area are over subscribed, so what do I do?

If you have money get a provide psychiatry assessment to say she is too traumatised/scared to obtain an adequate education in school. Apply for EOTAS package probably for online schooling such as interhigh

chosenone · 01/04/2023 07:56

As far as I’m aware the govt behaviour hubs programme is based on Tom Bennett’s behaviour theories, he’s the DFE behaviour guru. He pushes for consistency whatever the rules are rather than being prescriptive about the actual rules. He does advocate SLANT to ensure that students are sat up, listening, answering questions, nodding along and tracking the teacher. I think this is too prescriptive and possibly very difficult to monitor. It is annoying when kids are slouched on the desk, doodling etc but this can come under being respectful.

bellac11 · 01/04/2023 07:55

Fooshufflewickjbannanapants · 01/04/2023 07:25

Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha yeah cos that's gonna happen.

Society needs to have the political and ideological will to make this happen though. Voting for parties who recognise that specialist provision is necessary for one, not everyone believes that children with specialist needs should be educated within different provisions, the drive for inclusiveness simply means that the one size fits all approach is taken to the extremes

Also schools are too big in my opinion, again something the public and political will could change but it chooses not to

But they are separate issues to whether and what expectations are required in a school. We have an anti education culture, its not cool to be good at school or achieve in society.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 07:53

Dacadactyl · 01/04/2023 07:23

To all those saying about SEN, what about all the kids who don't have these needs? Why should the SEN kids trump the others? Genuinely curious.

Putting aside the issue of SEN children, how many people think that a zero tolerance approach is a good thing?

I mean, there is such a thing as bad behaviour without SEN coming into it.

It's a simple matter of figures.

It is cheaper to provide inadequately for SEN within a mainstream classroom whatever the detriment of the NT kids who will probably do sufficiently adequately regardless.

Excluding kids provides the evidence that a child cannot get an adequate (legal term) education in a mainstream environment. Therefore the government has to provide a more expensive education.

Which has not keep pace with growing levels of ASD/ADHD/SEN.

(Growing levels of any SEN are to be expected genetics, better neonatal care and general medical care.)

Zero tolerance is unaffordable. You would actually have to provide for the level of SEN that exists.

I'm laughing at the idea of seperating SEN/mental health difficulties, when talking about persistent "bad" behaviour. NT kids can comply with a zero tolerance approach (albeit there may be a person cost)

bellac11 · 01/04/2023 07:50

MediocreOne · 01/04/2023 07:04

Horrific way to treat children.

Horrific?

Horrific is being neglected, abused, not having access to education full stop, not having access to food and water

Not being asked to be respectful of others, committed and motivated to learning

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 07:47

My daughter goes to an academy.

I have just removed her as she was being seriously bullied. The bullies have destroyed her reputation within her peer group. She's been threatened with violence and had several comments from wider group to kill herself.

Once a confident 13 year old, she is now a shadow of herself, too scared to leave the house alone and is so anxious, too scared to ever go back to that school.

The bullies, all of whom are already on final warnings for bad behaviour? All got a slap in the wrist and reminded on the school rules on bullying. My daughter is now expected to go back. The school sanctions do not work.

The school refuse to authorise her absence and so won't provide work for her, even though I have made it very clear I will facilitate her education, just not in that toxic environment.

The school have completely failed her, all other schools in the area are over subscribed, so what do I do?

Forever42 · 01/04/2023 07:34

My NT but very quiet child goes to a school like this. She is truly miserable and has developed horrible anxiety about school. There must be a middle ground between anarchy and prison camp.

Strictly1 · 01/04/2023 07:31

Dacadactyl · 01/04/2023 06:56

@Icedlatteplease that's a separate issue though. If a child has SEN and can't cope in a mainstream environment, then they should have access to specialist provision.

There is no capacity. You can’t exclude due to SEN (quite rightly) but you can’t get the help/support they need either. The system is breaking at the seams.

Fooshufflewickjbannanapants · 01/04/2023 07:25

Dacadactyl · 01/04/2023 06:56

@Icedlatteplease that's a separate issue though. If a child has SEN and can't cope in a mainstream environment, then they should have access to specialist provision.

Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha yeah cos that's gonna happen.

Dacadactyl · 01/04/2023 07:23

To all those saying about SEN, what about all the kids who don't have these needs? Why should the SEN kids trump the others? Genuinely curious.

Putting aside the issue of SEN children, how many people think that a zero tolerance approach is a good thing?

I mean, there is such a thing as bad behaviour without SEN coming into it.

MediocreOne · 01/04/2023 07:21

WinterMermaid987 · 01/04/2023 07:13

Read the things Naomi Fisher has to say she’s an educational psychologist / prior to having my second child I too would have said yep have strong discipline etc. then I had my DD2, and saw a whole different side when you have a child that doesn’t fit in that square rigid box the education and send provision is very broken!

Absolutely, Dr Fisher is amazing. Having a child who is currently not attending school, partly due to severe anxiety, more rules would be hell. The system is very very broken, and not the fault of teachers.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 07:20

VikingVolva · 01/04/2023 07:10

However there's also another if pupils can use up rebellious energy against rules on things like uniforms, they won't need to escalate to get attention.

Yeah I've never believed the rebellion theory.

What you are seeing is an increasing number of "good enough" kids. kids who are bright enough to achieve just enough to get them to the next stage of what they want to do and won't do an inch more. They are quite happy talking to their mates/watching their phone thank you very much. the input required to do better for doing betters sake is not worth the effort/reduction in happiness.

Often bright, polite and articulate, they are clearly capable but have actively made the choice they aren't going to do the work beyond a 6-7. It simply isn't worth the stress/unhappiness

One school where this a specific phenomenon has just bemoaned their poor English mock gcses. Their brightest students simply aren't attaining to capacity because they are chosing not too

WinterMermaid987 · 01/04/2023 07:13

Read the things Naomi Fisher has to say she’s an educational psychologist / prior to having my second child I too would have said yep have strong discipline etc. then I had my DD2, and saw a whole different side when you have a child that doesn’t fit in that square rigid box the education and send provision is very broken!

VikingVolva · 01/04/2023 07:10

However there's also another if pupils can use up rebellious energy against rules on things like uniforms, they won't need to escalate to get attention.

malificent7 · 01/04/2023 07:10

I was just going to say there will probably be an increase in home schooling.

Ex teacher here. Bain of my life was not being allowed to let students go to the loo. It's a human right.

I know some kids might meet there to smoke, do drugs, plot terror attacks. ( partly joking) but put cctv up there and only let 1 out at a time.

But the government want obedient, robotic workers to oil the capitalist machine so they can make yet more profit for their mates whilst bleeding public services, like education, dry

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 07:06

Girasoli · 01/04/2023 07:01

I wonder if it will lead to an increase in home schooling amongst those who can afford it...if all my local schools were like that and I had a child I don't feel could cope with it (due to mild SEN/anxiety etc.) I think I would opt for homeschooling (and paying extra for tutors/a way to do science etc.)

Your already seeing a rise in funded expensives EOTAS packages from those with any money/capacity. Yes including private tutoring and or Internet schooling

AxolotlOnions · 01/04/2023 07:06

I think constantly nit-picking over the small stuff will make some children think, 'fuck it' and behave REALLY badly, they're going to get into trouble anyway! Or even get anxiety because they'll get into trouble as their parents can't afford to keep them up to date on all the petty, expensive uniform rules.

I remember reading about a school that decided to ditch uniform. They thought if they didn't have to spend so much time policing minor uniform infractions, they'd have more actual teaching time. They are now rated outstanding.

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 07:04

Most who can't comply in a classroom have undiagnosed, untreated and unmanaged ADHD or significant mental health difficulties. I can walk into a classroom especially in deprived areas and almost instantly spot 3-4 undiagnosed and therefore untreated SEN. Funnily enough they are rarely compliant, frequently in and out of theur chair and often in hoodies (reduces sensory input) with an ear bud in (again reduces sensory input)

If you exclude you still have to educate by law. Educating excluded children is inherently more expensive regardless what the difficulty is.

MediocreOne · 01/04/2023 07:04

Horrific way to treat children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread