Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government Behaviour Hub pushing zero tolerance in schools

259 replies

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 06:13

I've just been reading how the Behaviour Hub set up by the government has been pushing this idea of very strict behaviour policies and zero tolerance in schools. The sort rolled out by many of the academy chains. Does anyone know what the evidence base is for this?

The policies in many of these schools are highly restrictive - short lunch breaks, limited access to toilet breaks, consequences for minor mistakes. Many adults would find it stressful to be in an environment like this. I wonder if anyone has looked at the cost of these measures to the children in terms of their mental health, fostering independence and social skills etc.

Any insight, thoughts or links to research on this would be great.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OneInEight · 02/04/2023 11:55

But there is already a 2 tier system. Cope in mainstream and have the opportunity to have a full range of GCSE's and choices. Do not cope in mainstream and get shipped off to the local EBD secondary and have the opportunity to do a maximum of 3 GCSEs (our local provision).

fUNNYfACE36 · 02/04/2023 11:39

I t us a bit hard on kids with sen I guess, but schools can't have a 2 tier system.That would not be fair any more than a two tier legal system would be, So they just have to go what us best for most pupils and accept there will be a little collateral damage.

Boudicasbeard · 02/04/2023 09:21

@Georgeandzippyzoo

The problem is that all children need to feel safe at school. Should we allow kids with complex issues to lash out at children and staff with no consequences? Is it fair on the other children in the class to allow constant disruption?

There are ways of doing zero tolerance sympathetically and in a way that makes students feel supported.

Unfortunately, schools aren’t equipped to deal with complex behaviour problems. That is what the PRUs used to be for. But they are either full or parents refuse the help. Social services are on their knees and can’t help. Ed Psych bare exists anymore and CAHMS won’t do a referral these days unless there is a suicide attempt.

So these policies are sometimes a schools only method of getting a handle on some of the deeply unsafe, violent, disruptive behaviour that is becoming an every day occurrence.

I would happily go back to less strict rules, if that didn’t lead to more serious incidents.

But I am not convinced giving kids the power over rules would stop them- taking drugs on site, self harming in the loos, sending nudes, getting drunk between lesson, taking upskirt photos in the dinner queue, violently attacking each other and sexually assaulting other students.

The SLANT thing is too much. But asking them to be kind, considerate and hard working is hardly asking for the earth. It is quite obvious to me that if we didn’t try to teach this at school then some kids would never learn it.

Because a growing percentage of children are brought up by unrestricted screen time. They are watching porn and violent videos. They are making contact with inappropriate adults on social media and generally being taught that being a snarky, nasty arsehole is what being an adult looks like.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 02/04/2023 01:46

Dacadactyl · 01/04/2023 06:37

I've no idea of the evidence base, nor about what a behaviour hub is. However, my thoughts (going by what you've written) is that this is a good thing.

Kids deserve to be able to learn and unfortunately too often (round these parts anyway) others who won't behave, ruin it for them.

I'd love every school to have a zero tolerance approach tbh. Schools know who the troublemakers are I'm sure.

High standards in small things (things you might think minor, like uniform) lead to high standards in major things (like results)

But what is a troublemaker? Friends son has severe background trauma, he goes jnto school on 'High alert. If a teacher raises their voice /changes their tone, his body goes into figth/flight, he needs to be out of the class and will misbehave to get sent out.
He is not a troublemaker but school eefuse to work with him and punish him every time.

A child with asd shuts down and refuses to answer /do.work. school punish him.

Brothers who are young carers get detentions because they don't do their homework because they don't have time. Now starting to act up at school because.its totally unfair

Schools cannot have a 'one size fits all' behabiour policy UNLESS all children are starting from a level.playing field and some are at a much lower level than the 'average ' kid through Jo fault ofctgeir own but they are continuously punished by academies,/schools with zero tolerance crap.

BlackeyedSusan · 02/04/2023 00:35

Sirzy · 01/04/2023 08:21

In my dream world the school system would be one which has a variety of different settings to help young people find the right one for them. Some children will thrive in a very strict and structured environment others need a lot more flexibility. Some thrive with academic pathways others need different routes.

the issue with the current system is it tries for a one size fits all approach which doesn’t work.

They'd have to sort out admissions though. We only got a choice of two schools for ds and one was because DD was already in due to church attendance, otherwise it was one and tough luck.

Neither of mine can do slant, being autistic and hypermobile and anxious and dysregulated. Slant is positively dangerous for DD, could knock herself out.

homeeddingwitch · 02/04/2023 00:17

As an ex teacher who took her own DC (& herself) out of state school to home educate, reading this thread just reminds me why I am so glad we are not part of this system any longer.
It saddens me to say that as I’m a great believer in education just not school. Especially when I hear of incentives such as ‘slant’ 😞 poor kids.

Noicant · 01/04/2023 22:32

I preferred a school uniform, my parents didn’t like buying us clothes and when they did they were never “normal”. I would have been bullied even more than I was.

All the claims that strict schooling makes children into compliant adults is a bit nonsense isn’t it. Functioning in society and in the workplace require us to be able to adhere to norms. Children are learning those norms and that there is a difference between home/school/ with your mates. Most lessons will have discussions where your child will be free to dissent or proffer an opinion. Wearing a uniform and following the rules of a particular place isn’t going to dampen their individuality or freedom of thought.

Some of the eye tracking stuff is a bit insane and I wouldn’t go that far but it’s reasonable to expect kids to be able to tuck a shirt in, sort out their bags be quiet for five minutes. Low level disruption can persistently hamper other students. It’s like low level crime, no-one dies but it makes loads of normal peoples lives a bit miserable.

I feel for teachers, I really do.

NotMeNoNo · 01/04/2023 22:27

As a parent of two boys with SEN we had a very bad experience with a zero tolerance school. They refused to make any adjustments. They literally said proudly "we give the sanction first and pastoral support second".

As a last resort for DS's safety, we moved to a different school, it was another world. They also had high behaviour standards but it was managed with support and kindness, year heads and teachers took time to get to know the children and build up relationships of trust so that any sanctions were delivered positively with a "let's improve" message.

I now say to people looking at secondary schools , get them to show you the student support/pastoral area and the isolation/detention room. You'll soon see where they put their emphasis. If they won't show you, what are they hiding?

The thing is many DC only show up SEN in secondary school and the process of diagnosis is glacially slow. So a child can fall foul of the behaviour system in a couple of terms before anyone has really figured out their issues.

Florenz · 01/04/2023 22:25

Useless parents having children and then not raising them leads to even more inequality as they are unable to cope in life.

pointythings · 01/04/2023 22:23

@Florenz I agree with you, but so much of that is tied into the way our society is structured. You see far less of this in societies where socioeconomic inequality is less. The problems in the education system are also a symptom - of an utterly dysfunctional society where inequality means whole swathes of people feel that no matter what they do, they will get nowhere. So they give up trying. Add to that the way support systems have been cut away in the past 13 years (Sure Start, anyone?) and you have a recipe for disaster.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 22:18

pointythings · 01/04/2023 22:02

@Nimbostratus100 I actually have nothing against strict - but be strict where you're going to achieve something. Detentions over socks achieve nothing. Chatting in class is completely different. My mum was a teacher in the Netherlands and disruptive behaviour was something she never tolerated. The school backed that up. Be tough on bullying, be tough on disruption, if parents moan about their precious darlings getting detention for chatting in class - tough.

But equally, support ND kids, allow kids to breathe and be human - so no stupid rules about silent corridors for the sake of it. The rules should be there for a clear and obvious reason. The current drive towards ever stricter leads to rules which are petty for the sake of being petty.

I agree with you, I have definitely seen schools take strictness too far, so that it becomes an obstruction to relationships and education.

Detention for red writing on the sole of a black sock! ridiculous. just pretend not to notice, why would you want to cause an issue, the boy clearly thought it would be safely covered by his shoe all day, it isn't open defiance, is it.

Needing permission to take off your blazer on a hot day - I disagree totally that we have the right to enforce the wearing of heavy clothing in heat

Sitting up so straight it hurts your neck! I didn't join teaching to hurt children

Strictness is needed, but within reason!

Florenz · 01/04/2023 22:13

There are a lot of useless parents nowadays, who do little to no actual parenting, expect schools to do it for them. Kids getting to school age unable to use knives and forks, tell the time, sit at a table, speak coherently, even wipe their own arse in some cases. This is not acceptable and should not be tolerated, there's no reason for it and it only causes more and more problems the longer it is allowed to go on.

Stuckrecord · 01/04/2023 22:04

are supported by their idiot breeders.

Wow! I really hope you aren’t a teacher. What a disgraceful thing to say.

pointythings · 01/04/2023 22:04

@ancientgran well, none of that nonsense would have been necessary if there hadn't been a uniform. My parents went to school in the '50s in Holland. No uniform, no nuns, no nonsense.

Also no corporal punishment - the Dutch abolished it in schools in 1835.

pointythings · 01/04/2023 22:02

@Nimbostratus100 I actually have nothing against strict - but be strict where you're going to achieve something. Detentions over socks achieve nothing. Chatting in class is completely different. My mum was a teacher in the Netherlands and disruptive behaviour was something she never tolerated. The school backed that up. Be tough on bullying, be tough on disruption, if parents moan about their precious darlings getting detention for chatting in class - tough.

But equally, support ND kids, allow kids to breathe and be human - so no stupid rules about silent corridors for the sake of it. The rules should be there for a clear and obvious reason. The current drive towards ever stricter leads to rules which are petty for the sake of being petty.

JudgeJ · 01/04/2023 21:59

Yes that may result in a quieter classroom generally, better for those who can comply.

It also allows those who want to work and learn to do so, too much teacher time is wasted on those who don't want to learn and are supported by their idiot breeders.

ancientgran · 01/04/2023 21:58

pointythings · 01/04/2023 21:47

So the trend has been and still is to get stricter and stricter and stricter - and things are not getting better.

What was that thing Albert Einstein said about the definition of insanity?

Well it isn't as strict as when I was at school in the 50s and 60s. I remember the nuns standing a boy on a desk and turning his long trousers into shorts as he wasn't following the uniform rules. Can't imagine schools doing that now.

Pattypop · 01/04/2023 21:58

AM130674 · 01/04/2023 07:47

My daughter goes to an academy.

I have just removed her as she was being seriously bullied. The bullies have destroyed her reputation within her peer group. She's been threatened with violence and had several comments from wider group to kill herself.

Once a confident 13 year old, she is now a shadow of herself, too scared to leave the house alone and is so anxious, too scared to ever go back to that school.

The bullies, all of whom are already on final warnings for bad behaviour? All got a slap in the wrist and reminded on the school rules on bullying. My daughter is now expected to go back. The school sanctions do not work.

The school refuse to authorise her absence and so won't provide work for her, even though I have made it very clear I will facilitate her education, just not in that toxic environment.

The school have completely failed her, all other schools in the area are over subscribed, so what do I do?

I really feel for you. Same here. The head teacher said some kids have a (police) charge sheet as long as his arm and he cannot remove them from the school regardless of what they get up to. He just has to try to keep the rest of the pupils safe from violence. It’s failing everyone, and is truly terrible. The bullies have all the rights and good kids have none. It’s just so fuckedup

pointythings · 01/04/2023 21:57

@Nimbostratus100 thank you. I'm not sure that China or the US are models we want to follow in any way, and from what I know, the Australian system isn't unlike the British one. I'm very on the fence about the practice of making students repeat a year - in my experience of the Dutch system, students do worse in the repeat year than they did originally, but on the other hand letting someone move on when they haven't got a solid foundation to build on isn't good either. A friend of mine had to repeat Year 12 by the skin of her teeth (it's done purely on numbers in the Netherlands) and she did very well when she got to Yr 13, but she really hated it and was quite disaffected with school.

I'm 100% with you on your hatred of SLANT. It's ridiculous.

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 21:55

pointythings · 01/04/2023 21:47

So the trend has been and still is to get stricter and stricter and stricter - and things are not getting better.

What was that thing Albert Einstein said about the definition of insanity?

but things do get A LOT better when a school becomes stricter, as long as it doesn't become extreme.

And as to uniform or not, well I have taught in schools with uniform and schools without uniform ,and there are more arguments about clothing in schools without uniform, between staff and students, and between students and students

Mischance · 01/04/2023 21:53

pointythings · 01/04/2023 21:39

I never said it was an easy way to do this. There isn't an easy way to fix the UK system. Uniform is a symptom, not a cause.

The UK education system is obsessed with data, metrics and appearances. There's an old saying: you don't fatten a pig by weighing it. All we do is weigh the pig.

  • We don't respect teachers. We pay them badly, overload them with work and give parents and bureaucracy power over them rather than trusting them to do their work.
  • We think a pretty uniform equals good teaching.
  • We don't fund education - it's 2023 and adjusting for inflation we still haven't returned to 2010 per child funding levels. You get what you pay for.
  • We focus on academics and do not recognise that there are many children whose talents do not lie in this direction - and we do nothing to develop them.

We should be looking at what other countries are doing and see what we can learn - taking into account that we are culturally a Western European country. I'm reluctant to recommend more reform after the Great Gove Cockup, but equally we can't go on like this.

You have summed it all up neatly pointythings.

IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 01/04/2023 21:51

Icedlatteplease · 01/04/2023 06:31

Unless you have places for the kids that can't or don't want comply to comply it's a completely unenforceable and unworkable concept

This. I work in a "kind" PRU that takes on a lot of kids who've fallen foul of this kind of system in schools. They're almost all much happier and able to focus in our environment which is small, has access to animals and creative arts and has a strong ethos of kindness, talking and sharing feelings. It ain't rocket science.

Begin cynicism But punitive environments with harsh rules and no breaks are cheaper to roll out en masse. Which is convenient as we have very few teachers right now and can't keep the ones we have end cynicism

fUNNYfACE36 · 01/04/2023 21:51

Usedtodance · 01/04/2023 06:54

I'm not advocating bad behaviour by any means. Just wondering why it is necessary to sweat the small stuff to such a degree. It must cause a lot of anxiety and distraction. Why not focus consequences etc on proper misbehaviour not mistakes like forgetting kit.

If I was worrying about if/when I could go to the toilet, whether I'd got my spare pen, and the colour of my socks it would make me much more stressed at work and much less able to concentrate on what I was meant to be doing/learning.

The small stuff, as you describe it, is very disruptive.The sanctions for small mistakes are not comparable to sanctions in a workplace

Nimbostratus100 · 01/04/2023 21:50

pointythings · 01/04/2023 19:08

@Nimbostratus100 could you point me in the direction of some examples, please?

well, just off the top of my head, some of the countries I have come across where there is the worst reputations for poor behaviour in schools, USA/ Spain/China/ Australia, and some of the systems with the harshest regimes, particularly when it comes to failing and having to resit a year Germany/Japan. Most countries do not require teachers to mark books, and of course, in many countries, a child turning up to school without a pen won't be allowed onto the premises

Mischance · 01/04/2023 21:50

So the solution to kids not wearing proper uniform is to not have uniform at all, so they can't get in trouble for not wearing it?

Indeed - that is exactly the solution.

School uniform becomes an unnecessary focus for conflict when teachers should be focussing on good teaching and good child safeguarding from bullying.

If they is no school uniform, then teachers can concentrate on what they are there for and trained for - teaching.

How is it that those of my children who went to schools with no uniform have a string of degrees and post-graduate qualifications? How did the absence of uniform hold their education back?

Swipe left for the next trending thread