Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aphantasia

283 replies

Newrumpus · 31/03/2023 22:28

Recently, I discovered that I am aphantasic. I had never heard of this until recently and after hearing about it I have become interested in the experiences of others.

To save anyone googling, aphantasia is mind blindness or lack of visual imagery. When someone says ‘Imagine an elephant’ I think of an elephant but I don’t see one in my mind.

Does anyone else have experience of this and how did you discover it?

OP posts:
FatGirlSwim · 01/04/2023 08:18

My mind is very busy. I just don’t think in pictures. I guess what’s in my head is like an internal narrator.

I could draw an elephant but it would be based on my knowledge of elephant. I wouldn’t be drawing what I see in my mind. I could describe an elephant.

I could describe a person I know, tell you they have long brown hair and twinkly eyes, and clear skin, that they’re tall and move gracefully like a dancer. I know those things without seeing pictures in my head.

FatGirlSwim · 01/04/2023 08:14

kimchifix · 01/04/2023 01:06

Ummm, how do you remember events that happened to you then? When you remember a holiday or a party or anywhere you have been don't you "see" it in your mind's eye / like looking at a photograph or a video? How do you remember someone's voice or laugh? I honestly find it hard to imagine all this blankness!!

There’s no blankness for me, I have quite a rich imagination and a good memory of events. I just don’t think in pictures.
With memories of events I can remember what was said, how I felt, I can describe it. I don’t need a mental image to do that.

A voice or a laugh isn’t a visual thing so I don’t think anyone would ‘see’ those.

I think in words a lot, like an internal monologue. And I can remember the detail of my life, just not in pictures.

I understand that some people have difficulty with autobiographical memory and have little memory of their life. I have a relative like this. That’s not me, it’s different from aphantasia.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 01/04/2023 07:55

kimchifix · 01/04/2023 01:06

Ummm, how do you remember events that happened to you then? When you remember a holiday or a party or anywhere you have been don't you "see" it in your mind's eye / like looking at a photograph or a video? How do you remember someone's voice or laugh? I honestly find it hard to imagine all this blankness!!

There is some suggestion that people with aphantasia are less likely to experience PTSD than those who visualise more vividly. This makes sense to me, I do tend to move on from things faster than family who visualise everything.

I have some sketchy images but they feel the equivalent of the feeling when something is on the tip of your tongue.

I think too there is a difference between being able to recall images of a house and recognise say a house. Just as if I asked you to recall what the word for something was in whichever MFL you studied you might struggle to recall it, but if I said the word you would know what it meant. I would recognise the house even if I can't imagine it.

Newrumpus · 01/04/2023 07:49

Want2beme · 01/04/2023 00:18

What's in your head then? What are you seeing all day long? I can't see images very clearly, but they're there in a murky sort of form.

I have thoughts in my head. They are not visual though.

OP posts:
Newrumpus · 01/04/2023 07:46

PippaF2 · 01/04/2023 00:47

Also OP, can you dream?

Despite my previous post, when I remember them I have very vivid dreams. Full on movie going on.

Yes, I have vivid visual dreams.

OP posts:
hoophoophooray · 01/04/2023 02:52

I see 3D images in my head and I can look all around them. I'm a structural engineer by training, and I can overlay drawings onto a building in my head - so if I'm looking at a roof, for example, I don't only see the tiles - I can "see" joists, purlins, insulation etc overlain in my head. It was only about 2 years ago that I realised this isn't something everyone does.

So your elephant for me is solid image and I can turn it round and round mentally to see different bits and zoom in and out.

freckles20 · 01/04/2023 01:30

I've had a thought. I am unusually good at the game show catchphrase. As in 'say what you see'.....

My husband cannot understand how I can get the correct answer almost instantly.

I've never been able to explain why but thinking about it I wonder if it is related to the fact that I 'see in words' so it's easier to 'say what you see' for me that someone who sees in images?

freckles20 · 01/04/2023 01:27

My drawing would be done from my internal monologue describing the elephant. So you'd get something big, grey, with a long trunk etc.

The end result would be appallingly bad but would have the main characteristics of the elephant.

So it would be like me describing an elephant to someone who had never seen one (or a photo of one) before. Then asking them to draw the elephant using using my words to go on. So their drawing would be pretty rubbish- like mine....

freckles20 · 01/04/2023 01:24

kimchifix · 01/04/2023 01:06

Ummm, how do you remember events that happened to you then? When you remember a holiday or a party or anywhere you have been don't you "see" it in your mind's eye / like looking at a photograph or a video? How do you remember someone's voice or laugh? I honestly find it hard to imagine all this blankness!!

Remembering a sound like a voice or a laugh is different. If doesn't require images.

I have a pretty poor memory of events TBH which is a shame. The memories that I do have are created using an internal monologue. So for me it's kind of like telling myself using words what happened at the event and what it was like, rather than picturing anything. When I see photos I am reminded of things that haven't made it into my memory bank.

GayforMoleman · 01/04/2023 01:23

I find that really strange! If I think about it, it's like my mind projects it over whatever I can currently see. In the same way I can imagine the size, physical movement and noise it would make. Like a visual and audio echo. Other people cant do that?!

BreviloquentBastard · 01/04/2023 01:17

How interesting, I never knew this was a thing. I've always had a very vivid "mind's eye" so to speak. Ever since I was little and first watched Fantasia I've loved listening to music and making up my own visual stories around it in my head. I can't imagine there just being... Nothing. It's so interesting how humans can be so very different.

With inner monologues, apparently I'm weird in that my monologue isn't my own voice - my husband thinks I'm an alien because of it. So who thinks with their own voice and who else thinks with a whole cast of different characters?

kimchifix · 01/04/2023 01:06

Ummm, how do you remember events that happened to you then? When you remember a holiday or a party or anywhere you have been don't you "see" it in your mind's eye / like looking at a photograph or a video? How do you remember someone's voice or laugh? I honestly find it hard to imagine all this blankness!!

freckles20 · 01/04/2023 01:05

bluebiro · 31/03/2023 22:59

I am curious to know if this affects mental arithmetic ability? I think I often work out sums using pictures in my mind - eg pictures of blocks adding up - I think I would struggle without images.

I can't see in pictures.

The mental arithmetic question is interesting to me as it is something I cannot do without using my fingers or jotting lines (or gates for 5s) down.

I can add up dominoes quickly because I use their spots. But I really struggle with playing cards.

WRT the elephant I sort of see it in words e.g. big, grey, trunk, tusks etc..

I am abominable at drawing and I think maybe for me this is linked to not being able to get any kind of picture in my head of what I'm trying to draw.

HighInfidelity · 01/04/2023 01:01

Want2beme · 01/04/2023 00:58

My thoughts are images. So, if I'm thinking of my garden, that's what I see in my head. It's not as clear as a photo image, but it's there, just not as clear. If someone mentions a person or Ithink of somebody, I see them as a whole, in a particular scenario, moving and talking.

Eg, my niece is coming to stay with me for the weekend and I'm imagining her journey from her home to mine and I see it like a film. Whatever I'm thinking of is generally part of a moving image. I have them in my head every second of the day.

Oh wow. My thoughts are literally just words and concepts so if my niece was coming to stay then I would have an internal monologue going on about that but no images at all. Do constant images not mess with what you’re actually seeing in any way? I can’t imagine it.

saraclara · 01/04/2023 00:59

saraclara · 01/04/2023 00:58

When my DF realised she had it, she did a lot of googling on the subject. And I think almost 1:10 people have it. We were both amazed that it was so common. And this thread bears that out..

My DD, rather

saraclara · 01/04/2023 00:58

When my DF realised she had it, she did a lot of googling on the subject. And I think almost 1:10 people have it. We were both amazed that it was so common. And this thread bears that out..

Want2beme · 01/04/2023 00:58

HighInfidelity · 01/04/2023 00:23

I only see what I’m actually seeing with my eyes, nothing inside my head. Do you have constant images in your head all day long? What are they of?

My thoughts are images. So, if I'm thinking of my garden, that's what I see in my head. It's not as clear as a photo image, but it's there, just not as clear. If someone mentions a person or Ithink of somebody, I see them as a whole, in a particular scenario, moving and talking.

Eg, my niece is coming to stay with me for the weekend and I'm imagining her journey from her home to mine and I see it like a film. Whatever I'm thinking of is generally part of a moving image. I have them in my head every second of the day.

Thighdentitycrisis · 01/04/2023 00:48

this is interesting ,
could you draw a pic of an elephant? And if so are you drawing from a verbal description memory?

PippaF2 · 01/04/2023 00:47

Also OP, can you dream?

Despite my previous post, when I remember them I have very vivid dreams. Full on movie going on.

PippaF2 · 01/04/2023 00:45

Are people frequently thinking in pictures? Like when you have a thought do you automatically see it? E.g you think - oh I fancy a coffee, do you see a picture of a coffee as automatic/standard?

Because I don't think in pictures. All my thinking is just a voice in my head. I don't see words and I don't see pictures, I sort of 'hear my thoughts' inside my head.

However, if someone said sit down and picture an elephant, I could just about do it. It's not easy, it flitters in and out, it's quite hazy but I could do it.

With my DC I could do it too. But I'd have to think hard and I'd have to try hard. I don't naturally think in pictures.

TheNextCaroleMiddleton · 01/04/2023 00:28

I literally found out about this the other day, I have a blind mind’s eye too. Didn’t realise that other people could create these images so vividly. However I’m pretty awesome with maths and have a close to photographic memory so I wondered if these are connected?

HighInfidelity · 01/04/2023 00:23

Want2beme · 01/04/2023 00:18

What's in your head then? What are you seeing all day long? I can't see images very clearly, but they're there in a murky sort of form.

I only see what I’m actually seeing with my eyes, nothing inside my head. Do you have constant images in your head all day long? What are they of?

HRTeatime · 01/04/2023 00:18

hopsalong · 31/03/2023 23:58

What an interesting thread. I've heard of this before but thought it was extremely rare, not something that many posters could relate to.

When you think of an elephant, what are you thinking of? If you think of your own house (while on holiday, say) are you thinking no. + street name, or £price paid, or 'three-bed semi'? Or would a picture come to mind then, with something you know better?

If no picture comes to mind, how can you think of your house as yours, assuming that (like my house) it's not an unusual or detached building, but one in a street of many. Only the small pictureable things (the chipped knocker, the heather growing in a pot outside, the curtains, the scooter in the porch) allow me to distinguish 'my house' from 'other houses on my road'.

Well, it’s like a book. I know my house has a red door (with a chip the bloody sofa took out of it). The internal doors are wonky as it’s so old. The kitchen has cream cupboards, the cooker is pale yellow, my dog is too. There. No picture to see, but I’ve given you a description. You might now see it in your mind as a picture, for me, it’s just a verbal description of what I see when I’m in it.

Want2beme · 01/04/2023 00:18

What's in your head then? What are you seeing all day long? I can't see images very clearly, but they're there in a murky sort of form.

saraclara · 01/04/2023 00:17

I can't picture people's faces at will, even my own family. If I do get a visual image of someone, it's always of a photo of them that I've looked at a lot, never a spontaneous or general image of them. I find myself taking alotof photos and looking back over them frequently.

My daughter does this, though she finds short videos even more helpful. She takes very short ones (maybe just ten seconds or so) on most occasions when we get together as a family. They're not to show anyone else, they're for her to recall us and happy times, because she has no other effective way of doing so. It's actually nice for the rest of us that she does this. She's recording our lives, basically. What an archive for my granddaughters/her nieces and her sister.