Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aphantasia

283 replies

Newrumpus · 31/03/2023 22:28

Recently, I discovered that I am aphantasic. I had never heard of this until recently and after hearing about it I have become interested in the experiences of others.

To save anyone googling, aphantasia is mind blindness or lack of visual imagery. When someone says ‘Imagine an elephant’ I think of an elephant but I don’t see one in my mind.

Does anyone else have experience of this and how did you discover it?

OP posts:
fdgdfgdfgdfg · 01/04/2023 17:37

bluebiro · 31/03/2023 22:59

I am curious to know if this affects mental arithmetic ability? I think I often work out sums using pictures in my mind - eg pictures of blocks adding up - I think I would struggle without images.

Huh, I have aphantasia. Learned it was a thing about 5 years ago but never thought to link it to why I'm so crap at mental arithmetic despite being really good at maths!

Nonimai · 01/04/2023 17:27

I have this. I didn’t realise that other people can see their loved ones in ‘ their mind’s eye. I can’t visually imagine my children or my husband. I know what colour and length their hair is, because I know, but I can’t visualise them if they aren’t with me. I was really shocked when I found that other people could.

FatGirlSwim · 01/04/2023 17:25

MelroseGrainger · 31/03/2023 23:20

I don’t understand. What do you mean by a strong imagination if you don’t see things? Imagination is surely what you’ve described yourself as lacking?

No, I definitely have a vivid imagination. I just don’t have a visual imagination. I imagine things in words and feelings, not pictures.

CreateAUsername2023 · 01/04/2023 17:22

@SchoolTripDrama I'm afraid you're wrong there.

The visualisation of the information is one way. 'Photographic' is a colloquial word for what is actually named an Eidetic Memory.

Yes, some people with this can physically 'see' the information, others such as @FlyingHighFlyingLow and myself just 'know' the information.

faffadoodledo · 01/04/2023 17:18

Omg @SchoolTripDrama so is there any upside? How are you academically for instance? Can you just learn verb tables and pull them down alla Sherlock when you're speaking a foreign language? Or do you have to 'rummage' in your brain like the rest of us?

FatGirlSwim · 01/04/2023 17:18

SchoolTripDrama · 01/04/2023 16:52

I'm not convinced that this is a thing. What I think is happening, is that people who think they can’t imagine what others can, are presuming that the rest of us actually see that thing in front of us with our eyes.....

So using the Elephant example, when I imagine one, I see it on my mind! Not in front of me. I'm happy to be told I'm wrong but that's my theory until told otherwise.

Also, to those who claim not to be able to imagine anything, how do you describe something/someone? For example if you were asked to describe somebody you knew, how would you recall the fact that, say, your brother has 'short but floppy brown hair, dark blue eyes, about 6ft tall & quite well built' Surely you must be able to 'see' his hair, eyes & stature in your mind??

It’s definitely a thing. I know you don’t mean that you see images with your eyes. I don’t see mental images. I can’t visualise images, only ideas and words.

I can describe people or things, I know what characteristics they have. But I don’t see a picture of them in my mind.

I couldn’t describe their face, because I have prosopagnosia too, and I don’t recognise my own family if they change their hair. But I think that without this I’d be able to describe a face in the same way.

SchoolTripDrama · 01/04/2023 17:18

freckles20 · 01/04/2023 17:04

@SchoolTripDrama wrt a photographic memory you make an extremely good point.

I have adhd and my the workings of my memory are a constant puzzle to me.

I do feel that I have an excellent memory wrt things that I hyper-focus on (or have hyper focused on in the past). Examples include dog breeds, dog facts, geology, some types of plumbing, plant biology. All v random!

I might use the term 'photographic' memory to describe my memory of these things but to be fair there is no imagery involved at all. I just recall the facts.

You sound like you have a perfectly usual & normal photographic 'snapshot' memory like me

SchoolTripDrama · 01/04/2023 17:15

faffadoodledo · 01/04/2023 17:08

This fries my brain. I can imagine in detail what a real or cartoon elephant looks like but can't actually SEE it. Can some people actually see one in front of their eyes?

No it s not in front of my eyes it's in my mind

myveryownelectrickitten · 01/04/2023 17:15

Queenofscones · 31/03/2023 23:13

So when people say they see pictures of an elephant, what do they see? A real elephant in amazing detail? A cartoon elephant? Still or moving? A clip from an Attenborough-type film?

Ask me if I can see an elephant in my mind's eye and the first image that jumps up is Dumbo, then a very stylised embroidered elephant from an Indian cushion I owned for some years. I have to work harder to 'see' a real elephant, and even then it's a bit sketchy because I've never really studied images of elephants in great detail. And now I'm thinking about it I'm getting ghosts of dozens of images of elephants I've seen over the years. But a lot of them are very sketchy indeed. Is this familiar to others or do you have on clear elephant images that always crops up?

I don’t “see” an elephant in my mind’s eye as if it’s in front of my eyes. It’s more like it’s a flash of a pseudo-image in the back of my mind somewhere, if that makes sense. Not as visual as if I was asked to close my eyes and imagine something in the front of my mind/eyelids. I can do both but for me the “mind’s eye” is like an involuntary flash of visuality somewhere behind, I can’t look directly at it in any way iykwim.

I had a photographic memory when young, but that was more a sense of “snapshots” too, iirc. I have mild synaesthesia and also mild face blindness, weirdly, but I think that isn’t actually connected with my visual memory as it seems to be something different. Can’t explain how!

SchoolTripDrama · 01/04/2023 17:14

I have a fully photographic memory and can see images of words written down, I can even recall things in such detail that I can tell you what everyone was wearing, where we were & where I was sat but it's not by choice. My mind takes lots of snap shots.

My earliest memory is sitting up in my navy blue Silver Cross coach pram, being pushed by my Grandma in her red dress with white polka dots & bright red lipstick! I can even see which path we were on and the water tower behind us. I was about 6 months old.

Sadly most of my snapshots from my childhood are of me being beaten up or worse. Perhaps that's why they're so vivid?
I can also play episodes of my fave to shows that I've watched so many times that I can recall it all, such as Only Fools & Horses and Frasier.

However... As above, the downside to this ability, is some of my vivid memories replay back in my mind involuntarily if my memory is 'triggered' by something (perhaps that's where that term originates?) I can be doing the washing up or even having a conversation and BANG there it is. Just like on tv when they depict someone daydreaming or having flashbacks.

To give a slightly different example, my YouTube is set to auto play and after a video ended yesterday, a very random & graphic documentary came on about engineers in the USA who climb masts and how many have fallen to their deaths in recent years.
Well, ever since, I've been having these 2/3 sec long visions of me falling from one. I can 'see' everything vividly, the ground moving towards me at speed, I can feel the weightlessness & pure terror. Then I snap back before I hit the ground.
So yeah, I just thought I'd point out that it's not necessarily a good ability to have!

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 01/04/2023 17:12

Also, to those who claim not to be able to imagine anything, how do you describe something/someone?

Badly! I can give bland descriptions but I just recall lists of things others feel are relevant. I know that for family members. I couldn't tell you what colour eyes even close friends have, could probably have a guess based on what I think their hair colour might be. I do get worried before say meeting someone in a cafe that I won't recognise them. If I see them every few weeks I generally will recgnise them. Someone I see once or twice a year I might not recognise.

charliegirl86 · 01/04/2023 17:11

faffadoodledo · 01/04/2023 17:08

This fries my brain. I can imagine in detail what a real or cartoon elephant looks like but can't actually SEE it. Can some people actually see one in front of their eyes?

I can't see it in front of my eyes. It's not in the room or in the same eye line as anything else. But it's just, in my head?! I don't know, it's like I can look at photos and watch videos in my brain? I suppose I'm staring into space as I do it though, like I have to look to the side at a blank area to focus on looking at the thing in my head rather than what's in front of me. Can't do both at once

charliegirl86 · 01/04/2023 17:08

But saying that I can't recognise people from their photos or describe someone I've just met

faffadoodledo · 01/04/2023 17:08

This fries my brain. I can imagine in detail what a real or cartoon elephant looks like but can't actually SEE it. Can some people actually see one in front of their eyes?

charliegirl86 · 01/04/2023 17:05

Queenofscones · 31/03/2023 23:13

So when people say they see pictures of an elephant, what do they see? A real elephant in amazing detail? A cartoon elephant? Still or moving? A clip from an Attenborough-type film?

Ask me if I can see an elephant in my mind's eye and the first image that jumps up is Dumbo, then a very stylised embroidered elephant from an Indian cushion I owned for some years. I have to work harder to 'see' a real elephant, and even then it's a bit sketchy because I've never really studied images of elephants in great detail. And now I'm thinking about it I'm getting ghosts of dozens of images of elephants I've seen over the years. But a lot of them are very sketchy indeed. Is this familiar to others or do you have on clear elephant images that always crops up?

Ask me to picture a elephant and I can see an Attenborough type clip of an elephant in the wild

freckles20 · 01/04/2023 17:04

@SchoolTripDrama wrt a photographic memory you make an extremely good point.

I have adhd and my the workings of my memory are a constant puzzle to me.

I do feel that I have an excellent memory wrt things that I hyper-focus on (or have hyper focused on in the past). Examples include dog breeds, dog facts, geology, some types of plumbing, plant biology. All v random!

I might use the term 'photographic' memory to describe my memory of these things but to be fair there is no imagery involved at all. I just recall the facts.

charliegirl86 · 01/04/2023 17:04

This is crazy that people can't see images in their head. When I read a book and I'm really into it it's more like
Watching a movie cos im watching the characters (my imagined version of them) and the scenes playing out

freckles20 · 01/04/2023 16:58

SchoolTripDrama · 01/04/2023 16:52

I'm not convinced that this is a thing. What I think is happening, is that people who think they can’t imagine what others can, are presuming that the rest of us actually see that thing in front of us with our eyes.....

So using the Elephant example, when I imagine one, I see it on my mind! Not in front of me. I'm happy to be told I'm wrong but that's my theory until told otherwise.

Also, to those who claim not to be able to imagine anything, how do you describe something/someone? For example if you were asked to describe somebody you knew, how would you recall the fact that, say, your brother has 'short but floppy brown hair, dark blue eyes, about 6ft tall & quite well built' Surely you must be able to 'see' his hair, eyes & stature in your mind??

I know how hard it is to process when your experience is so different.

I would describe people using words and my memory of their appearance is formed using words.

Is there anything that you might recall without visualising it? Maybe a poem, or a list, or a vague memory? If so that's is sort of similar- as you're describing it without seeing it if that makes any sense.

Newrumpus · 01/04/2023 16:55

SchoolTripDrama · 01/04/2023 16:52

I'm not convinced that this is a thing. What I think is happening, is that people who think they can’t imagine what others can, are presuming that the rest of us actually see that thing in front of us with our eyes.....

So using the Elephant example, when I imagine one, I see it on my mind! Not in front of me. I'm happy to be told I'm wrong but that's my theory until told otherwise.

Also, to those who claim not to be able to imagine anything, how do you describe something/someone? For example if you were asked to describe somebody you knew, how would you recall the fact that, say, your brother has 'short but floppy brown hair, dark blue eyes, about 6ft tall & quite well built' Surely you must be able to 'see' his hair, eyes & stature in your mind??

There is scientific research to show that this is a thing. Nobody is claiming not to be able to imagine something but to have no internal visual imagery.

OP posts:
freckles20 · 01/04/2023 16:55

@Saracen that has reminded me that when I was 18 I had a car accident. It wasn't my fault, someone turned out of a side road into my path because they took the turn too wide.

We exchanged details. A few days later I had to fill in a form by hand and couldn't describe the driver or the car other than it's colour.

Then weeks later there turned out to be a complication as witnesses said a woman was driving with a male passenger, but the other party insisted that the man was driving with the woman as a passenger.

Someone related to the insurance company interviewed me in person and I was absolutely no use what so ever. It was very awkward. I never found out what happened but their insurance did pay for my repairs.

SchoolTripDrama · 01/04/2023 16:55

CreateAUsername2023 · 31/03/2023 22:40

I have this!
I also have a partially photographic memory, but I don't 'see' the image, I just sort of 'know' it. I can read whole books from memory this way.

If you cannot see images in your head then you do not have a photographic memory! 😂 That's literally what it is

SchoolTripDrama · 01/04/2023 16:54

CapturedLeprechaun · 31/03/2023 22:37

I have this! I know what an elephant looks like - big, grey, long trunk. So if someone says "picture an elephant" - I can't, there's nothing there in my mind. But the words "big, grey, long trunk" are there.

It's a bit like a work colleague had a shaven head pic in his teams pic, that I see daily. Someone asked me to describe him and I said "shaven head". Turns out he has had a full head of hair for over a year (and I see this man many times a week!) but I can't picture this at all, only the description my brain has of him.

Equally, my toddler fell and bashed her face. Her teeth were a bit jagged after and I looked at her and thought "have your teeth always been like that?" but genuinely had no image in my mind of what they used to be like, so didn't know. Took her into nursery and her keyworker said "OH MY GOD WHAT HAPPENED TO HER TEETH". So it was something that was instantly blatant to literally everyone else, but I had no idea because I can't hold a picture in my mind of what my own child looks like. Now I study every inch of my kids and say things to myself like "wonky eyebrow. Freckle over top lip. Tiny pointy nose", so even though I can't picture my kids when they aren't in front of me, I could accurately describe them, or notice if someone covered the freckle now etc as I've told myself about it so often.

Does that make sense?!

Omg the teeth incident 😳 I'm genuinely not trying to be a dick but that's really concerning :(
How are her teeth now? Or don't you know?

SchoolTripDrama · 01/04/2023 16:52

I'm not convinced that this is a thing. What I think is happening, is that people who think they can’t imagine what others can, are presuming that the rest of us actually see that thing in front of us with our eyes.....

So using the Elephant example, when I imagine one, I see it on my mind! Not in front of me. I'm happy to be told I'm wrong but that's my theory until told otherwise.

Also, to those who claim not to be able to imagine anything, how do you describe something/someone? For example if you were asked to describe somebody you knew, how would you recall the fact that, say, your brother has 'short but floppy brown hair, dark blue eyes, about 6ft tall & quite well built' Surely you must be able to 'see' his hair, eyes & stature in your mind??

freckles20 · 01/04/2023 16:50

kimchifix · 01/04/2023 16:42

This is really fascinating! Whoever made the point about PSTD earlier - makes so much sense.

Yes this! I've witnessed and been part of some really difficult things which have caused ongoing difficulties but I've not had ptsd or had to deal with reliving the moment visually which is a blessing.

Years ago I sadly found an elderly lady on my paper round who had died whilst wandering around in the night. I can remember the details, especially what she was wearing but I can't (and never could) picture her face, or what I saw afterwards.

Describing the scene to police afterwards was also tricky. They didn't push it which was probably because I was 14.

freckles20 · 01/04/2023 16:46

Newrumpus · 01/04/2023 15:39

Have you used graphic organisers?

I use graphic vocabulary to teach new words/concepts and visual word maps. Definitely watch the play/film, make visual multicoloured mind maps.

Thank you for your advice. I've never even heard of a graphic organiser!!! Off to google thank you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread