Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aphantasia

283 replies

Newrumpus · 31/03/2023 22:28

Recently, I discovered that I am aphantasic. I had never heard of this until recently and after hearing about it I have become interested in the experiences of others.

To save anyone googling, aphantasia is mind blindness or lack of visual imagery. When someone says ‘Imagine an elephant’ I think of an elephant but I don’t see one in my mind.

Does anyone else have experience of this and how did you discover it?

OP posts:
Newrumpus · 02/04/2023 13:54

A34 · 02/04/2023 09:36

OH has a number cube in his 'mind's eye' and uses it to do multiplication. He can multiply 3 figure numbers almost instantaneously. We understand it is a variant of synesthesia.

That cube sounds awesome!

OP posts:
WhisperingAutistic · 02/04/2023 12:57

PerrinAybara · 02/04/2023 11:12

I have aphantasia (also ASD). It was a revelation a few years ago when I discovered other people could actually see things in their mind. I'd always put it down to a figure of speech.

It did explain all the times people asked me whether people/places in TV/film adaptations matched how I'd imagined them. Because I never did imagine them and was confused by the question.

It also explained the problems I'd had in hypnotherapy when I was told to visualise something. I just mentally told myself what I was supposed to be imagining but didn't see it.

I also don't smell or hear things in my mind either. I get songs in my head, but I don't hear them. It was only a few days ago that I discovered that some people do.

Interestingly DD also has aphantasia, so I guess there could be a genetic element.

What do you mean, you get songs in your head but you don't hear them?

PerrinAybara · 02/04/2023 11:12

I have aphantasia (also ASD). It was a revelation a few years ago when I discovered other people could actually see things in their mind. I'd always put it down to a figure of speech.

It did explain all the times people asked me whether people/places in TV/film adaptations matched how I'd imagined them. Because I never did imagine them and was confused by the question.

It also explained the problems I'd had in hypnotherapy when I was told to visualise something. I just mentally told myself what I was supposed to be imagining but didn't see it.

I also don't smell or hear things in my mind either. I get songs in my head, but I don't hear them. It was only a few days ago that I discovered that some people do.

Interestingly DD also has aphantasia, so I guess there could be a genetic element.

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 02/04/2023 11:01

bluebiro · 31/03/2023 22:59

I am curious to know if this affects mental arithmetic ability? I think I often work out sums using pictures in my mind - eg pictures of blocks adding up - I think I would struggle without images.

I think I sort of feel it like shapes, the shapes of 37 and 63 fit together to make a 100 e.g. or if you were trying to work out 8x8 I'd know it was 4 lots of 4x4. But I wouldn't see a picture really I'm currently trying to figure out if I have it too.

HippeePrincess · 02/04/2023 10:36

the number line and particularly the cube sounds awesome, I’d like one but sadly don’t have anything like that. I wonder if it’s why I can’t do mental arithmetic.

Newname221 · 02/04/2023 09:48

AnuSTart · 02/04/2023 09:01

Oh just reading other posts, I was a very early reader and I imagine words to 'see things'.
When I am presenting I see the words in front of me.
I am a lawyer and can pick words and sentences apart very easily. Ask me to find my way to work in the morning. Doomed.

Out of curiosity, do you also struggle to learn new languages?

I was early with the English language, but can’t grasp any other languages. Although interestingly as a baby I did pick up equal amounts of the local language where I lived (non English speaking country) and English. I lost all this as we moved away. I also used to be obsessed with watching the Gaelic tv shows when I was younger and I’d tell my parents what the news report was about, although I couldn’t actually speak any Gaelic.

I think I’m maybe quite a rigid thinker when it comes to language and the reason I struggle with foreign languages are because they don’t fall into my rigid (English centric) rules of language. I think this made learning English easy but others hard.

A34 · 02/04/2023 09:36

HippeePrincess · 02/04/2023 03:55

What do you mean by numbers being spatially located?

OH has a number cube in his 'mind's eye' and uses it to do multiplication. He can multiply 3 figure numbers almost instantaneously. We understand it is a variant of synesthesia.

GreenMarigold · 02/04/2023 09:29

Random789 · 02/04/2023 08:26

The angle of the incline changes. Preey flat in the negative sequence and in the early part of the positive sequence, then steepening sharply up to twenty and staying steep until the eighties and getting a bit less steep around 100

I don’t experience this with individual numbers but I do with decades - lines at various angles - and the months of the year are located around an oval sort of shape, with extra space given to the months that have more importance due to family birthdays etc.

I’m not totally aphantastic but I can’t hold an image in my head for more than a tenth of a second or something. It is there but it is fleeting to do anything with. I always wondered if I could train my brain to hold onto images for longer.

I am terrible at drawing. Is this something common to aphantasia or a poor mind’s eye? Ask me to draw an elephant and I know facts about it - trunk, 4 legs, big ears - but I can’t really imagine the whole thing to be able to draw it.

mrcow · 02/04/2023 09:12

SchoolTripDrama · 01/04/2023 16:52

I'm not convinced that this is a thing. What I think is happening, is that people who think they can’t imagine what others can, are presuming that the rest of us actually see that thing in front of us with our eyes.....

So using the Elephant example, when I imagine one, I see it on my mind! Not in front of me. I'm happy to be told I'm wrong but that's my theory until told otherwise.

Also, to those who claim not to be able to imagine anything, how do you describe something/someone? For example if you were asked to describe somebody you knew, how would you recall the fact that, say, your brother has 'short but floppy brown hair, dark blue eyes, about 6ft tall & quite well built' Surely you must be able to 'see' his hair, eyes & stature in your mind??

I often don’t recognise people I know just on sight (e.g. when unexpectedly bumping into them).

My own sister of 50 years knocked on my door and I didn’t know who it was until she started speaking. It’s difficult to describe. I just have no means of retaining imagery in my mind.

AnuSTart · 02/04/2023 09:10

I didn't think I have face blindness but maybe I do to an extent. When I see photos of my loved ones on my phone, I see them and remember them. When not in front of me, I kind of forget.
My daughter had a party the other day, 7 girls all looking the same. Awful. I've known these girls for years, but I can't tell them apart. They all have long blond hair. My DH thinks it's awful

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 02/04/2023 09:09

I have this too.

I think it is more common than we think it just doesn't really come up in conversation, so I suspect the autism link is overstated because people don't normally discuss how their imagination works.

I had a conversation with a sports coach who had struggled with something during CPD where they were being asked to visualise something and he couldn't. Both me and his next client were the same.

The example I think illustrates it is how you would remember what to get from the shops without writing it down. Lots of people visualise their trip round the shop, or how the things look in the trolley, that's what my husband would do, but I memorise the words and repeat them in my head.

mrcow · 02/04/2023 09:03

I have this too, and face blindness which can be embarrassing at times, and for which, as a school teacher, I have to really try and build coping strategies for.

Recognising I had it came as such a relief!

AnuSTart · 02/04/2023 09:01

Oh just reading other posts, I was a very early reader and I imagine words to 'see things'.
When I am presenting I see the words in front of me.
I am a lawyer and can pick words and sentences apart very easily. Ask me to find my way to work in the morning. Doomed.

AnuSTart · 02/04/2023 08:57

I have this.
An elephant to me is sort of a fuzzy grey blob.
When I imagine people I just think of sticks with no faces.
I can't 'see' things.
I don't drive and I learnt from childhood to orient myself by memorising lists, left, left, right, pub, tree, garage. Etc.
It's only in recent years I don't feel ashamed and realised that it's ok. That it isn't that odd.
I am highly intelligent and at the top of my game career-wise and last week had an interesting 1:1 with one of my team who is a physicist. We realised when talking that we both have it. It was so cool to meet someone in real life that has this.
We are so cool 😎

Random789 · 02/04/2023 08:36

@Queenofscones I told you it was dull! Grin
No, I don't think it is based on a chart. It's not like a picture. But I do think that, for people of my generation, number-colours might be influenced by the old Cuisenaire rods they used to use to teach maths.

ReneBumsWombats · 02/04/2023 08:32

I can't match/co-ordinate colours for shit. Now I wonder if that's related to a strong mind's eye.

Funny, you'd think it would be the other way round!

Queenofscones · 02/04/2023 08:29

Random789 · 02/04/2023 08:21

@HippeePrincess When I think about the number sequence (1, 2, 3, ...) I see a left-to-right line of numbers inclining slightly upwards and proceding from white light towards darkness, clearly segmented into bands of ten and then blurring out to vagueness at around 100. Negative numbers (proceeding leftwards from zero are kind-of brown and the sequence there is very short before disappearing.

That inner perception is so familiar and dull that I literally hadn't paid it any attention until the questionnaire turned my mind's eye towards it. And even then I thought 'this can't be what they mean' because it seemed so impossible to me that it should be absent for some people.

Is that based on a chart you've seen at some time? Because it sounds like a very standard way of presenting numbers.

Newrumpus · 02/04/2023 08:26

Siameasy · 01/04/2023 22:59

I am almost exactly like you (being assessed for both) but I have no picture!

However I’m really good at stuff like colour matching, interiors, putting an outfit together etc creative stuff

If I’m to think of an elephant I will have to try really hard to recall a particular elephant. So, typically, I thought of Elmer. 😂

Apparently there is a link between aphantasia and good colour-matching skills!

OP posts:
Random789 · 02/04/2023 08:26

The angle of the incline changes. Preey flat in the negative sequence and in the early part of the positive sequence, then steepening sharply up to twenty and staying steep until the eighties and getting a bit less steep around 100

Random789 · 02/04/2023 08:21

@HippeePrincess When I think about the number sequence (1, 2, 3, ...) I see a left-to-right line of numbers inclining slightly upwards and proceding from white light towards darkness, clearly segmented into bands of ten and then blurring out to vagueness at around 100. Negative numbers (proceeding leftwards from zero are kind-of brown and the sequence there is very short before disappearing.

That inner perception is so familiar and dull that I literally hadn't paid it any attention until the questionnaire turned my mind's eye towards it. And even then I thought 'this can't be what they mean' because it seemed so impossible to me that it should be absent for some people.

HippeePrincess · 02/04/2023 03:55

Random789 · 01/04/2023 21:22

I always wonder whether some people who experience themselves as being aphantastic simply misconstrue or exaggerate what it is like to 'see' things in their mind's eye and, as a result, fail to acknowledge their own inner visual experience.

My reason for thinking this way is that once, when completing a questionnaire about synaesthesia, I saw the question "Do you experience numbers as being spatially located" and my instant reaction was to think 'What? No! Of course I don't,' before realising shortly afterwards that I do, and it is simply so normal, so everyday, so unstriking, that I just hadn't noticed it.

It is like someone asking you 'Do you pass a post box on your journey from the railway station to your house?.' The likelihood is that you do and that you haven't noticed, precisely because it is so very familiar.

What do you mean by numbers being spatially located?

saraclara · 02/04/2023 00:02

My daughter could read before she was three, and has aphantasia.

I'm now wondering about my DGD ( her niece) who is also reading at just three.

WhisperingAutistic · 01/04/2023 23:35

infinityminusone · 01/04/2023 22:37

Finding out that other people could actually see pictures in their head was a pivotal moment for me. I couldn't have been more shocked if someone had told me aliens had landed! A previous poster mentioned early reading and aphantasia. Perhaps later readers have longer exposure to using their internal visual imagination than early readers who move quickly to having ideas presented to them in an external written format and that's why the later readers' visual imagination develops so strongly. I also read that trauma can cause it. It's the brain's way of protecting us from seeing what we don't want to see. This makes sense to me.

I don't think that's true about early readers.
I have great visual minds eye and am hyperlexic. I taught myself to read around 3 years old.
My eldest taught himself at 2 and also has a minds eye (and is also autistic like me).

happyumwelt · 01/04/2023 23:07

Siameasy · 01/04/2023 22:59

I am almost exactly like you (being assessed for both) but I have no picture!

However I’m really good at stuff like colour matching, interiors, putting an outfit together etc creative stuff

If I’m to think of an elephant I will have to try really hard to recall a particular elephant. So, typically, I thought of Elmer. 😂

This is so interesting to me! I also have a strong eye for colour. I definitely have a mind's eye but I do wonder how good it is really - ask me to picture Harry Potter and I get Daniel Radcliffe, I'm not sure what HP looked like before DR! I can see him, in my head, but I guess it could be argued that he has been given to me, rather than I have thought of him by myself.

Siameasy · 01/04/2023 22:59

happyumwelt · 01/04/2023 21:29

I find this bonkers and also fascinating. I think it is amazing how we all have such different inner worlds and it makes me wonder how differently we perceive the outer world too. I have ADHD (possibly ASD too, but not diagnosed) and have a vivid mind's eye and constant inner monologue - I think in words more than images, but can instantly conjure a picture on demand. My mind is never quiet - I'm always on the edge of fight or flight, even when sleeping and dreams are vivid, feel real and I remember a lot of them - I wake up with a brain full of ideas (but it is mush after a day in the real world).

I am almost exactly like you (being assessed for both) but I have no picture!

However I’m really good at stuff like colour matching, interiors, putting an outfit together etc creative stuff

If I’m to think of an elephant I will have to try really hard to recall a particular elephant. So, typically, I thought of Elmer. 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread