Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable in thinking that we are suffering from a collective Stockholm syndrome re the NHS

306 replies

Newbutoldfather · 31/03/2023 18:49

This is inspired by another thread about a mother with a child in pain being kept hours without painkillers without being triaged, and the responses on that thread. However I have also had an awful experience with my own child over the last year.

it seems amazing to me that in one of the richest countries in the world (we still are), people are content to accept substandard care which would embarrass a country with 10% of our GDP.

In France, MRI’s are standard for muscular injury or complex fractures. They happen within a few days and, often, on the day. ( my reference is Paris btw, not sure about rural France). In addition, you always get a same day GP appointment, regardless of seriousness, no hassle, no waiting for an hour at 8AM.

Finally, although there are some real heroes in the NHS, my own experience (and that of the other poster) are that many lack compassion, which is about culture, not money.

I don’t know the ‘solution’. Any solution is multifaceted and will take time. However, if we don’t admit the scale of the problem and continue to say how marvellous free-at-the-point-of-use is, we will never get acceptable medicine in this country for any but the rich.

OP posts:
HotSauceCommittee · 02/04/2023 18:13

For those championing privatisation, I don't get it?
Look where privatisation got us with utilities.
The water companies are polluting our waterways with impunity and say it's too difficult to upgrade the systems. Yet they are still allowed to make a profit and pay dividends to shareholders. The gas and electricity firms are sucking the life out of people and making record profits.
These were public services, not for profit services and now look at the result of privatisation.
Another is public transport: look at the strikes, the expenses, the delayed and cancelled journeys.
I'd renationalise the lot. Greedy bloodsucking bastards. This country is on its arse.

Botw1 · 02/04/2023 18:12

@FallSpringing

Oh yeah.

I'd forgotten that part of the degree.

Yeah.

Let's scrap it

🙄

DdraigGoch · 02/04/2023 18:06

Shelefttheweb · 02/04/2023 14:15

They generally use algorithms for this, not just their own judgement.

Why does that not fill me with confidence?

DdraigGoch · 02/04/2023 18:04

GPTec1 · 02/04/2023 13:52

Whatever accounting methods were used, the NHS worked, you could see a GP either the same day or the next, Ambulances met their response times.

We had 100s of '000s on a waiting lists not approx 8m now and heading toward 10m.

We also did not have a shortfall of over 150k staff and 300k shortfall in Social Care.

Clever accounting on waiting lists and bullying exists now, just look at all the maternity and M/h scandals we have had in the last 15 years?

much of which have been covered up until exposed by the media.

This was far worse than just cooking the books (a lot of which went on too, including at Stafford). It was deliberately (and unsafely) overcrowding bays in order to keep the figures of patients waiting in corridors down. If a bay is designed to accommodate four beds, then that's how many oxygen, suction and defibrillation outlets will be installed, and that's how much room there will be for beds with space for staff to crowd around them in an emergency. Cram a fifth bed in (in response to demands from Labour Health Secretary Alan Milburn) and patients who could have been saved will (and did) die.

"Normally we take off the bed’s head so we can get round the patient to put lines in the blood vessels and a tube in the lungs. But we couldn’t move the bed forwards because it kept hitting the two other beds. At that time he was pink and warm. I was trying to do all the stuff we normally do. Then, he starts going blue in front of my eyes, bleeding in the gut and vomiting. We try to put the heart-tracing machine on, but we’ve got nowhere to plug it. We’re jumping up and down trying to keep this young guy alive. I use a piece of apparatus to expose his airway and, bang, I’m staring at a huge clot. I ask the nurses for suction. I put out my free hand. No suction. Where’s the suction? The suction tube is a certain length and it’s by another patient’s bed and won’t reach. So then I’m desperately trying to grab the clot with forceps, but they won’t reach. I’m thinking “If I push it down far enough, sacrifice one lung, we can give him oxygen and save him”, but we can’t get the oxygen to him either. I ask a nurse to go to the theatre to get a portable oxygen canister. This guy is now blue and his heart’s stopped. I ask for the defibrillator, but the wires won’t reach. I had to make a decision to wedge the clot down, but we had to wait five minutes before the portable oxygen came, by which time he’s so oxygen-deficient there’s probably very little to retrieve even if we had kept him alive."

The NHS did not work for the 35 year old patient. Nor for the next patient to die three weeks later. Milburn got to boast about reduced waiting times though. Target culture for its own sake kills people.

The trust blew tens of millions pursuing the whistleblower - a respected cardiologist - including fabricating 200 malicious allegations about him. Is it any wonder that people like a PP's daughter are too terrified to speak out about patient mistreatment when senior management will go to such desperate lengths to protect their own arses? Needless to say, the executive responsible for this loss of life, the ruination of a good doctor, and the waste of millions of pounds in legal fees (not to mention the GMC and WMP time wasted) not only got promoted but was awarded a CBE. He carried on harassing whistleblowers at his next position.

FallSpringing · 02/04/2023 18:02

Botw1 · 02/04/2023 09:17

@Newbutoldfather

Should we scrap all other health care related degrees too?

If nurses don't need a degree then neither do physios or OTs or dietitians

Nor do doctors

Pretty sure they could benefit from much more hands on learning and being less process based

They're different roles though aren't they, and better pay/progression usually. I'm also yet to hear of any physios/OTs/dietitians ignoring patients, being cruel, or standing around the nurses station gossiping.

Fluffypuppy1 · 02/04/2023 17:46

Shelefttheweb · 01/04/2023 11:00

And the NHS is still paying back the £80 billion it cost for their £13 billion PFI investment in the NHS. And will be doing so for decades.

It was also not in a ‘decent state’, if it were we would not be short of GPS and other staff now - their training needed to start when labour were in power.

The NHS was flawed from its set up due to the compromises needed to bring private doctors and hospitals on board.

This.

If Labour win the next election will they just do the same as they did last time and run up a huge amount of PFI debt which will take decades to pay off?

Fluffypuppy1 · 02/04/2023 17:42

MarshaBradyo · 01/04/2023 08:27

I’m sure not all are the same but geez that’s sad

Sadly, it’s nothing new. My DGP’s were very elderly/end of life 2006 - 2008 in two different health authorities and visiting times were horrendous. We would walk past the nurses station full of nurses chatting, and on the ward of around 8 patients there would be typically just one or two relatives visiting, and other patients needing water, the commode (around a 20 min wait) , and general confusion as to where they were etc. The nurses seemed to just clock off during visiting hours, and not bother at all with the patients. Having since then had a similar sub standard experience of NHS maternity services in 2010, I have since then been wondering if on the geriatric ward it wasn’t just a clocking off in visiting hours and more of a general standard on the ward.

OllieAggieNouse · 02/04/2023 16:32

Shelefttheweb · 02/04/2023 14:26

Agree with most of that except the bit about being removed from politics. What is politics for if not health, education and taxes necessary to pay for them?

That's why I was musing about a 'cross party' idea. I don't think anything can happen so long as one party decides to go one way and then the next party comes along and chucks more money at changing it again. I think both of the main parties have made a pig's ear of it - but it's not entirely surprising, when it's the whole basis of the system that is now wrong. No amount of money is going to solve this.

I think both parties are hampered, too, by popular sentimentality regarding the NHS. Neither of the main parties is going to want to be the one to cut the Gordian Knot and admit that the NHS is no longer fit for purpose.

TheSnootiestFox · 02/04/2023 16:24

hopeishere · 31/03/2023 19:45

How many staff have left? I see this mentioned a lot but is it loads! You get ones maybe but established consultants with families etc I can't see them upping sticks.

I agree that free means shit but it's FREE so we can't complain.

It's not free though, is it? Unless you pay absolutely no tax or NI.....

Dontevenstart · 02/04/2023 15:51

DdraigGoch · 02/04/2023 11:19

There should be no sacred cows. The NHS now occupies a status equivalent to the one the Catholic Church in Ireland used to hold. Making people and organisations immune from legitimate criticism is how scandals happen - whether it's priests abusing boys or nurses treating patients like animals.

Ok - I should clarify - I don’t believe anything should be immune from criticism.
That’s absolutely not what I meant.

justasking111 · 02/04/2023 14:28

Okay in Wales we're told use pharmacy, go to pharmacy who say nope, contact GP, contact gp by email who say use pharmacy. Tell them pharmacy sent me to you. Email reply try 111.

Shelefttheweb · 02/04/2023 14:26

OllieAggieNouse · 02/04/2023 14:15

That's bollocks.

There will be people on here who remember the NHS being a shit show under a Labour government in the 1970s.

The NHS is a political football and healthcare ought to be removed from party politics (as ought education, btw). The only way we will ever sort healthcare out is if there's a cross-party comprehensive dismantling of the NHS and the creation of an alternative system which actually meets the needs of our population now, not the needs which the NHS was set up to meet in 1948.

What astounds me is that so many people have bought into the group-think notion of "our NHS" and all the mawkishness that goes with it.

I don't want "our NHS". I want a healthcare system which functions anything from adequately plus.

Agree with most of that except the bit about being removed from politics. What is politics for if not health, education and taxes necessary to pay for them?

justasking111 · 02/04/2023 14:25

Shelefttheweb · 02/04/2023 14:15

They generally use algorithms for this, not just their own judgement.

111 in Wales use these algorithms, it's not working

Pluto46 · 02/04/2023 14:23

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 19:19

YANBU.

I also think the OTT “unsung heroes” attitude and moronic clapping during COVID didn’t help. We’ve elevated (sometimes incompetent and dangerous) staff to sainthood levels and it’s utterly bizarre.

I love that a PP thinks voting labour will solve the problem. The UK was a very different place when we were under Labour last time. We have too many people, too many public health problems, too few resources and a system utterly unfit for purpose.

I don’t agree with privatising but there has to be a middle ground where the talent of innovative medical can help alleviate problems whilst still retaining the “free at point of service” model.

This, 100%^

Freysimo · 02/04/2023 14:21

pjani · 31/03/2023 18:52

Vote Labour. It’s the party of public service and the NHS was in a decent state by the time they left.

Please see the state of the NHS in Wales under Welsh Labour.

Shelefttheweb · 02/04/2023 14:19

justasking111 · 02/04/2023 14:14

https://uk.indeed.com/m/viewjob?jk=20a66a823ef3d950&from=serp

This is our pharmacy!! £9.27 per hour

That is below minimum wage?

justasking111 · 02/04/2023 14:16

https://uk.indeed.com/m/viewjob?jk=2c8cbe99497242ac&from=serp

Aldi £11 per hour

Shelefttheweb · 02/04/2023 14:15

justasking111 · 02/04/2023 14:03

Our GPs have made it clear this week that receptionists will triage and decide whether we need a GP, pharmacy, minor injuries unit or a&e.

My mother was a receptionist for years, she wouldn't want to be making those decisions.

They generally use algorithms for this, not just their own judgement.

OllieAggieNouse · 02/04/2023 14:15

pjani · 31/03/2023 18:52

Vote Labour. It’s the party of public service and the NHS was in a decent state by the time they left.

That's bollocks.

There will be people on here who remember the NHS being a shit show under a Labour government in the 1970s.

The NHS is a political football and healthcare ought to be removed from party politics (as ought education, btw). The only way we will ever sort healthcare out is if there's a cross-party comprehensive dismantling of the NHS and the creation of an alternative system which actually meets the needs of our population now, not the needs which the NHS was set up to meet in 1948.

What astounds me is that so many people have bought into the group-think notion of "our NHS" and all the mawkishness that goes with it.

I don't want "our NHS". I want a healthcare system which functions anything from adequately plus.

justasking111 · 02/04/2023 14:14

https://uk.indeed.com/m/viewjob?jk=20a66a823ef3d950&from=serp

This is our pharmacy!! £9.27 per hour

justasking111 · 02/04/2023 14:10

justasking111 · 02/04/2023 14:03

Our GPs have made it clear this week that receptionists will triage and decide whether we need a GP, pharmacy, minor injuries unit or a&e.

My mother was a receptionist for years, she wouldn't want to be making those decisions.

https://uk.indeed.com/m/viewjob?jk=64086389cced4a0f&from=serp&prevUrl=https%3A%2F%2Fuk.indeed.com%2Fm%2Fjobs%3Fq%3DGP%2520Receptionist%26l%3DLlandudno%252C%2520Conwy%26from%3DsearchOnSerp%26sameQ%3D1

£10.90 per hour for this amount of responsibility??

justasking111 · 02/04/2023 14:03

Our GPs have made it clear this week that receptionists will triage and decide whether we need a GP, pharmacy, minor injuries unit or a&e.

My mother was a receptionist for years, she wouldn't want to be making those decisions.

GPTec1 · 02/04/2023 13:52

DdraigGoch · 02/04/2023 11:14

Did you see some of the tricks that management used to get them low though? Sticking five beds into a room only designed for four, which meant that the beds weren't properly in reach of oxygen and power outlets - not to mention that staff couldn't get around the beds properly for resus. A doctor who blew the whistle was bullied out of his job. That was at the height of the Blair years.

Whatever accounting methods were used, the NHS worked, you could see a GP either the same day or the next, Ambulances met their response times.

We had 100s of '000s on a waiting lists not approx 8m now and heading toward 10m.

We also did not have a shortfall of over 150k staff and 300k shortfall in Social Care.

Clever accounting on waiting lists and bullying exists now, just look at all the maternity and M/h scandals we have had in the last 15 years?

much of which have been covered up until exposed by the media.

DdraigGoch · 02/04/2023 11:19

Dontevenstart · 01/04/2023 08:59

The NHS is a sacred cow and bloody rightly so.
The only reason we’re having this discussion is because this Conservative government, in its various iterations since Cameron, has done what every previous Conservative government wanted to do but wasn’t stupid/callous/psychopathic enough to do and actually started the longed-for dismantling of the NHS.
They’re doing it with the backing of the mass media who will not report it for exactly what it is, because there’s so much money to be made out of it at every level - marketing, insurance & financing to name but three.

Vote these lying, corrupt, nepotistic bastards out of office, go to hustings and hammer your MP about the importance of making the NHS more fit for purpose and more efficient but above all keeping it free at the point of use, because we will never ever get it back if we lose it.
If we do lose it, there is no way this country will try a European model: it’ll be the American system 100% and that, as we all know, is the primary driver of inequality and it will make this country even more fucked than the bastard Tories have managed to make it thus far.

There should be no sacred cows. The NHS now occupies a status equivalent to the one the Catholic Church in Ireland used to hold. Making people and organisations immune from legitimate criticism is how scandals happen - whether it's priests abusing boys or nurses treating patients like animals.

DdraigGoch · 02/04/2023 11:14

MotherofPearl · 01/04/2023 08:50

Don't be silly.

Under New Labour, NHS waiting lists were the lowest they'd been for 40 years.

Did you see some of the tricks that management used to get them low though? Sticking five beds into a room only designed for four, which meant that the beds weren't properly in reach of oxygen and power outlets - not to mention that staff couldn't get around the beds properly for resus. A doctor who blew the whistle was bullied out of his job. That was at the height of the Blair years.

Swipe left for the next trending thread