Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think kennels are a bit cruel?

105 replies

yoshithe · 31/03/2023 17:49

I don't think cruel in the sense that it's some kind of abusive thing to do but wasn't sure how else to word it. Our dog is 11 months old and DH really wants to go to New York for his birthday, so far we have taken our dog with us to UK getaways and did drive with him to the Netherlands.

We don't have any friends or family that would look after our dog for the time we are away, so it feels like our only option is kennels. I've seen dog boarding but I'm actually unsure if that's also difficult for a dog? Just being taken to a new home environment.

Kennels seem particularly sad though, aren't they enclosed in their "room" most of the time with only human interaction a couple times a day? He's obviously quite young still as well.

Personally, I don't really want to leave him, would rather do another suitable getaway that involves him, but DH really wants to go.

The title is less about me judging kennel use and more about hearing he's going to be perfectly okay if we put him in one!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
shutthewindownow · 01/04/2023 09:56

Ours goes back to the rescue kennel where he came from once a year for a week. They arnt ideal and no home comforts but he lives the life of luxury most of the time and we deserve a holiday. I would suggest getting him used to it by booking In for 24 hrs to start with to get him used to it. Do this a few times before you go and build up the time. He will then trust that you are returning Also make sure he is vaccinated against kennel cough before he goes

Delatron · 01/04/2023 09:41

lifeturnsonadime · 31/03/2023 19:31

@Delatron where is that, it sounds perfect for my dog who also wouldn't suit boarding for similar reasons.

It’s in South Bucks called Greendale Farm. They don’t mix the dogs. Which I like as my dog is reactive! They insist you come and look round before you book in which is a good sign and recommend an overnight trial.

WiddlinDiddlin · 31/03/2023 23:42

I would use a pet sitter who stays in your home. For the dog, for all dogs really (barring those who can't handle strangers at all but in that case, no other option suit them either), this is the best option.

With the best will in the world, the nicest facilities, the exercise paddocks, play groups, lovely food, warm kennels etc etc...

In kennels, your dog is spending the vast majority of the day and night alone in a small space.

Now if your dog spends all day at home alone and sleeps in a utility room or kitchen or outshed all night alone (or indeed, lives in an outdoor kennel at home), and is genuinely fine with that, they may well cope just fine, in fact they may be getting more interaction than they do at home.

For most dogs however, outside of an hours exercise and when they're fed and cleaned out, they're alone, with fuck all to do but hope you return for them.

If they're used to all day or most of the day with you, sleeping in your room or on your bed, snuggling up on the sofa, training and games every day... they're going to have a shitty time in kennels. Safe, basic needs met, yes.. but shitty nonetheless.

Kennels will absolutely tell you they're fine, they'll tell you they were quiet, had loads of fun... and for a tiny handful of dogs that might be true but for the majority, it isn't. It's simply what you need to believe and what the kennels need you to believe. (Similarly when the vet tells you your dog was fine all morning waiting in a crate for surgery... regardless of whether they howled their heads off or actually went to sleep.)

Even the nicest of kennels - and I have been to and worked in (not for, just on the premises) some REALLY nice ones - is a stressful, barky, frustrating and often scary experience.

I know generally confident happy dogs will drag you in, its an exciting environment full of new people and interesting smells. That doesn't mean that two hours later they're still boinging around having a doggy party!

If you have to use them, visit first and discount any that won't let you visit within their normal opening hours WITHOUT an appointment. Pre-arranged appointments are no good, if they need prior warning of your visit during the hours they should be on site and available, you do not want your dog staying there at all!

Check that they are licenced with the local authority, check their insurance and find out exactly what that covers too.

But if you can, use a reputable, fully insured and experienced live-in dog sitter.

Paddingtonthebear · 31/03/2023 23:02

I mentioned earlier I use a home dog boarder. We use this company. I wouldn’t use anyone not inspected, insured etc. I also wouldn’t use anyone who takes in different dogs from different homes at the same time, unfortunately there are a lot of those people about.

https://www.petstay.net/

PetStay Home Dog Boarding & Dog Sitting | Alternative to Kennels

PetStay, established in 2005 provides dog sitting and home dog boarding services throughout the uk, offering the perfect loving alternative to kennels.

https://www.petstay.net/

Frogdoglog · 31/03/2023 21:42

I used kennels for a previous dog and he seemed happy enough to go, was capable of making his feelings about going to the vet VERY clear so I assume if he had felt similarly about kennels we would know. Current dog hadnt been in kennels but a family emergency necessitated a last minute booking at a different kennels.

I assumed she would be fine as had no issues with separation anxiety etc and was very friendly and well socialised, but we received a call on the second day saying she was apparently so aggressive that the man who ran the kennels couldn’t get near her to get her out for a walks/ toilet trips so was sitting in her own filth for 2 days (came home early to pick her up). She was so traumatised It took YEARS for her get over the fear of strangers and she still isn’t good with men. Every persons she knew before the kennels she was fine with but was terrified of anyone new she met after.

A Trainer we had worked with since dog was a puppy was shocked by how traumatised she was by the experience, she was a completely different dog. I guess it was just the stress of being left and the fact that the owner didn’t take any time to try and reassure her. I’m not sure if he tried to punish her for behaving aggressively or not as he claimed her to have been unable to get near her so had no contact with her at all while she was there but I’m not convinced and only he and my poor dog know what really happened while she was there.

mrsjoyfulprizeforraffiawork · 31/03/2023 21:37

I have a Battersea dog. When I adopted her, Battersea made me promise I would never put her in kennels as they found she could not tolerate them and became very distressed. They had to send her home each night with a staff member because of this. For her and my previous dog I have always used people who board them in their own homes. I got their names from other dog owners or the local vets. A good boarder will give your dog a trial half day and/or night to see if they and the dog get on.

GreekDogRescue · 31/03/2023 21:24

Many kennels are shocking.
I paid 10k for a year to a Berkshire kennels (near Bracknell I think) so that a rescue I support could kennel their rescues and it was a shocking place.
we discovered that the kennel maids never let the dogs out and didn’t even let them have the dog beds their owners left.
if you love your dog don’t use a place like this.

MajesticWhine · 31/03/2023 21:19

Dogs going to kennels is totally fine. Obviously do your due diligence and check the place out that it's clean and comfortable and there is enough exercise time for the dog. And it's better to put them in when they are quite young so that get used to it.
Mine share and have each other for company when they go - it's one advantage of having two dogs.
They sometimes go to their dog walker for boarding and get thoroughly spoilt, but if he doesn't have space they go to a larger kennels and it's fine.

SuperfastJellyfish · 31/03/2023 21:08

Dog boarder all the way. I think it depends on the dog but my dog is an anxious dog who loves home comforts and I couldn't bear the thought of her in a kennel. I use a couple of different boarders where she lives in the house as part of the family.

sonjadog · 31/03/2023 21:07

I used a kennel with my dogs for years. It really depends on the dog and the kennel. I visited several before choosing the one I used. It was a small-holding in the countryside, only ten dogs maximum, lots of outdoor space to run around and lots of attention. My dogs loved it there, and after a while it became like a second home to them. But they were very secure and social, and I had had them from puppyhood and they thought the whole world revolved around them. My current dog I would not put in the kennel as he is rehomed to me and is very shy and timid and would hate a kennel. So I use home boarding for him instead or he goes and stays with a friend when she has time.

MathsNervous · 31/03/2023 21:06

Often there are at least a few other boarders too.

MathsNervous · 31/03/2023 21:05

Our breeder does boarding so we have used her so the dogs all sleep together in the living room and play together. Our dog doesn't like coming home!! It's very homely. Often ther

SallyWD · 31/03/2023 21:00

fromageallday · 31/03/2023 20:54

Another one here recommending trustedhousesitters. I'm a sitter via the site and it works really well from this side of the table.

Having fostered tens of dogs, I agree it's all down to the dog/kennel match up. Some dogs will never thrive in kennels; others will have the best time in a fantastic place.

Highly recommend Trusted Housesitters too. We've used them many times. All the house sitters are absolutely lovely. It seems to attract the best people.

fromageallday · 31/03/2023 20:54

Another one here recommending trustedhousesitters. I'm a sitter via the site and it works really well from this side of the table.

Having fostered tens of dogs, I agree it's all down to the dog/kennel match up. Some dogs will never thrive in kennels; others will have the best time in a fantastic place.

LoveWillGetYouThere · 31/03/2023 20:52

I worked in rescue and then in boarding. In boarding we had regulars who were in on and off a few times a year.
It sounds daft but the atmosphere at the boarding kennels was different to the rescue kennels. I used to tell owners that the regulars knew they were going home which rubbed off on the others. Obviously we had some dogs who hated it but as dog lovers we did everything to make sure that they had a good stay. We even rang emergency contacts to pick up two dogs who were really struggling. Most of our dogs were social and enjoyed seeing what was going on. I never felt like the dogs were sad whereas in rescue you could see dogs struggling.
I had two rescue dogs who both went into kennels. They were ok there and both got lots of attention from the staff.
One was particularly stressed in rescue but handled the kennels fine. In our second dogs later years I used a kennel that let the dogs mix during the day. She couldn't care less about mixing but it made me feel better.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 31/03/2023 20:43

I did once hear of someone who refused for many years to put their dog in kennels but eventually (for a reason I can’t remember) they did need to go abroad, so when the dog was at least 10, he went in kennels for the first time - but very sadly pined away and died before they returned.

That's incredibly sad but it's not like kennels are the only option if you want to go abroad - many people have family or friends who can help, or would pay double to use a home boarder or sitter as an alternative to kennels.

Maybebabyno2 · 31/03/2023 20:38

My family won't use kennels but they have a bloke who looks after thir dog in his house. The dog loves it there and they get loads of pictures throughout his stay. Dog gets to play with the other dogs and the bloke has a huge garden they spend most of the day in (when weather is suitable). I would look to see if you had something like that locally over kennels.

I have friends who pay people to come and stay at their house but its not something I would be comfortable with.

bloodywhitecat · 31/03/2023 20:32

Sometimes it is the only option.

Shamsterdam · 31/03/2023 20:30

Probably depends on the dog and the kennels. Mine absolutely loves going to hers, but she is very social and never had any anxiety. I see that when I drop her off she goes off with the staff very happily, not a backward glance at me! They have a lovely big room, a bed, a play area all to themselves, plus a large enclosed play area and field for 1-1 playtime with staff, plus country walks. I definitely don't think kennels are cruel as a concept but it's not for every dog of course.

PurpleNebula84 · 31/03/2023 20:26

Sorry, not read all the posts - there are some people who can come and look after your dog in your home.

Fuctifin0 · 31/03/2023 20:26

I would use a kennel over a home boarder or dog sitter any day of the week.
The amount of people who home board and aren't licensed is astonishing. You may assume your dog is safe but the amount who go missing from home boarders is too high a number.

Our kennel of choice walk the dogs 5 times a day and they have exercise in the paddock.
They must be doing something right as they were fully booked for this year's school holidays in November.

My dogs are stupidly excited to go in and seem to genuinely love the owner. I get photos sent regularly whilst I'm away.

Lou670 · 31/03/2023 20:21

All kennels operate differently. Go around a few to have a look and ask them how they are run. I know some kennels 'buddy up' your dog to another (stranger) dog and use the reason it is better for the dogs. They shouldn't do this. If one of the dogs vomit in the kennel there is no way of knowing which dog it was. You are paying for the kennel and not a share of one. Alternatively is to use a pet sitter that would either visit your home several times a day or board in your home. Perhaps you could do a trial run before you actually go on holiday and book for one or two nights for your dog to go to a boarding kennel and see how it goes. That way you are there to collect if need be. Most dogs do settle though and if you start now when young they will get used to it.

Coffeeandcrocs · 31/03/2023 20:16

PIL use a dog sitter who comes and stays at your house and looks after your dog there

MarieInternette · 31/03/2023 20:14

We have used TrustedHousitters.com several times, as have friends, and all had excellent experiences. It’s kinder to the pets and having someone looking after the house is also reassuring. References come from previous sits so they can’t just make up their own references and you only pay an annual subscription, regardless of how many times you use the site. You don’t pay the sitter. It’s a fab arrangement, and much less stressful for your pets.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 31/03/2023 20:11

They were essential for us, given the sort of family holidays we enjoyed and that there was nobody we could leave our dog with.,

When she was still very young I put her in just for a couple of days at first, to get her used to it before booking a fortnight - and to understand (I hoped) that we’d be coming back for her.

I asked our vet (who had dogs) which he used, and stuck to that one.

She was always fine when we collected her -but somewhat hoarse from barking her head off with nobody telling her to be quiet! I dare say she’d rather have been at home, but she had never lost weight or suffered in any way that we could see.

I did once hear of someone who refused for many years to put their dog in kennels but eventually (for a reason I can’t remember) they did need to go abroad, so when the dog was at least 10, he went in kennels for the first time - but very sadly pined away and died before they returned.
So if you think you’re ever going to need to, maybe as well to get your dog accustomed to kennels, for a few days at least.