Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I'm making life difficult for myself, or is parenting just this hard??

133 replies

AliceAbsolum · 31/03/2023 11:18

DD is 4 months next week. Ebf. Every evening after about 5pm she's very unsettled. Screams the house down. I think she would happily go to bed at 6pm because she's over tired, but 1, it's against SIDs advice to have her upstairs and 2, she can never fall asleep alone anyway. If she's not in the pram or carseat she will only breastfeed to sleep.
So I end up going to bed at 7pm just to stop the screaming. But I don't like it as I want to actually see DH and have an evening. Let alone when it's going to be light and warm outside.
What would we do if we had other kids?
Am I missing something here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Snowfairyxx · 05/05/2023 19:12

I think 4 months is a hard age and they start wanting to feed more in the evenings. I can remember sitting breastfeeding mine for hours sometimes trying to get them to sleep. It was awful at times when you just wanted a break in the evening. It will pass soon and hopefully they will start feeding better and sleeping more during the night. Could you try a bottle on an evening to get them to have more milk and hopefully to go sleep better? If you can leave them upstairs I don't think it is a terrible thing if you have a monitor and check on them regular.

TheseThree · 05/05/2023 18:02

Four months is still early. It’s draining. I have a 14 y/o, almost 3 y/o and a 14 month old. Infants are draining. Toddlers are exhausting. Teens are an entirely different type of work.
As this is your first, I understand wondering why it’s so hard and what you’re doing wrong. It doesn’t sound like you’re doing anything wrong. It sounds like you have a 4 month old and are doing your best to meet her needs. (Remember, being close to you is a need for such a young infant.)
Things will change. She’ll eventually let you put her down to sleep. She’ll eventually sleep for longer stretches. She’ll eventually go to sleep without needing to nurse. I won’t tell you to “enjoy this stage” or that “you’ll miss it” because not all of us do, but I will tell you sound like a wonderful loving mother.

Jane1284 · 03/04/2023 16:37

Hardbackwriter · 31/03/2023 13:56

I think this massively overstates the risk. Around 200 babies a year in the UK (out of around 700,000) die of SIDS; of course that's 200 too many but that has to be seen in context. The huge contributing risk factors within maternal control are smoking (present in nearly 90% of SIDS cases) and the baby sleeping in unsafe positions or on unsafe surfaces. Sleeping alone all night - let alone for a portion of it - is actually considered to be a risk factor because of quite a weak correlation, and there is only a hypothetical mechanism for why this might be - no one actually knows that it does increase the risk and if so why.

If people want to be absolutely as cautious as they can be, and they find that for them that's compatible with good maternal mental health (which is actually a known and proven huge factor in child outcomes) then great and good, but I think it's really alarmist to say that not doing so is 'gambling with your child's life'.

This 100%.

Maternal mental health is so important and saying someone is gambling with their baby's life is downright nasty and completely over the top. We all love our children and make the best decisions for them. Using a sleep pod or leaving a baby to sleep in their own room at 5 months with a monitor- if it allows the mother to have some time to rest- is not going to cause your baby to die.

SleekMamma · 01/04/2023 08:58

It's normal and it's a phase. Just do your best to get through it.

Twizbe · 01/04/2023 07:43

Both mine had witching hours from around 7-10pm every night where they just screamed. Very normal for newborns and not linked to feeding method.

Around 4 months it got better and we could start putting them to bed in the evening. We did a bath and bedtime routine and put them to sleep in their cot in their room. Then DH would bring them in to our room at 10pm for a feed before we went to bed.

We don't smoke and I was breastfeeding so our risk of SIDS was already really low. Eldest also had a dummy which reduced his risk even more.

TwoShades1 · 01/04/2023 07:38

Mine was similar and I just just fed her then held her while she slept and I would watch tv. Or you could put her in a wrap or carrier and just carry her about. Totally depends how you want to do it. If you really want her to go to sleep without you there you will probably need to tough it out with some other settling techniques until she isn’t used to be fed anymore.

TomatoFrog · 01/04/2023 07:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

SoFED · 01/04/2023 06:59

Dim your living room lights and TV on low…a baby senses when they’re alone so in this situation they’re not. They can still hear your voice, smell you and know you’re near. What I will say though is one side of our sofa has a permanent dent lol from where DH and I spent hours just holding out eldest sitting, the months go quick OP. Mine are older now and one is up to my chin! When I hold them I still think of when they were so so tiny that I could just hold them against me for hours on end.

MagpieSong · 01/04/2023 06:11

3WildOnes · 31/03/2023 18:48

I dont the rules on safety, the consultant paediatricians do. I'm just a therapist.

This may well be because it’s more realistic to achieve that and they need time in the evening for housework or therapy or similar. It’s highly unlikely a high number of babies at a mother and baby unit are breastfed and often things are done differently. For example, in a rehab facility, nursery is often key to give parents time to attend therapy, prove time keeping/organisational effort and give staff a chance to observe how baby is developing. At home with a parent without concerns, this isn’t a key, unmissable part of life at the same young age (though obviously lots of babies are in nursery as mum is at work). I don’t know what type of unit you work in (assessment re neglect concerns, drugs or for another reason), but recommendations are often different within a situation like this. At home in a standard situation in the UK, mums are told not to leave babies unattended due to SIDS and encouraged to keep them in the same room.

MagpieSong · 01/04/2023 06:03

My eldest slept downstairs with us or went in the sling. My youngest wouldn’t use a sling or sleep/settle without dark and quiet and I lost my evenings completely. You’ll get the evenings back though, it just takes time. I tried to make the most of the early nights and watched something quietly with subtitles for a short time or read a book (usually on my phone as only one hand free, though I prefer actual books) and then go to sleep early as she fed often in the night.

elodiesmith · 01/04/2023 04:28

I sleep trained mine at 3.5 months. Avoided sleep regressions.
From then on he fell asleep by himself and would only cry when he wanted a night feed, or vomited.

WitheredandOld · 31/03/2023 21:18

At that age ours had a third nap around four pm for 45 minutes. It got them through to seven pm without being too cranky.

We had a breathing monitor with sensors etc. so they slept in their rooms from 7pm. Day sleeps were in the wicker basket until they outgrew it.

3WildOnes · 31/03/2023 18:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I dont the rules on safety, the consultant paediatricians do. I'm just a therapist.

WonderingWanda · 31/03/2023 17:28

I had one like that, she cluster fed between 7 and 9 and then we went to bed together.

FrenchTrellis · 31/03/2023 17:04

DC2 is also 4 months and a NIGHTMARE to get to sleep in the evenings currently. It's a really recent thing so pretty sure it's some developmental thing. She settles for naps during the day like a dream. I've just got her to sleep now with no effort at all... Yet come 6:30/7pm she's wailing. Doesn't want a feed (breast or bottle), will sometimes take her dummy, definitely wants walking round but not in a sling 🙄 calpol or gripe water sometimes work, sometimes don't. Me and my husband are having to tag team her while the other does bedtime for my older child. If she'll settle on DH (usually after 9pm) then I'll just go up to bed to grab a couple of hours undisturbed sleep. Sometimes I just get in bed with her and wait out the crying.
I am missing evenings with DH but I know it doesn't last.

gotmychristmasmiracle · 31/03/2023 17:00

We had this every evening up until 6 months, it's really awful 😞 but it will pass soon, no idea how you do it with another child don't want to try it tbh Xx

Peppadog · 31/03/2023 16:39

7Worfs · 31/03/2023 15:24

There are ways and marketing gimmicks to separate young baby from mother, but ultimately we are mammals and our young want to feed and snuggle into our arms, and get to sleep feeling warm and safe.

It’s inconvenient and boring for the mother, but when it passes, it’s often missed. Try and enjoy it, power through the boring bits, it will get easier soon enough.

Totally agree. By my third child I knew how precious those early times are and just rolled with it. He sleeps in my bed every night and I'm loving it. I don't feel that need to 'get back to normal' as much this time.

Albiboba · 31/03/2023 16:35

AlltheFs · 31/03/2023 13:56

This thread is a great example of why breastfeeding rates are so dreadful.

4 month old breastfed babies are meant to behave like this in the evenings. It’s not a problem to be fixed.

It does get better @AliceAbsolum it’s linked to a sleep regression and growth spurt phase. It does pass.

I actually think it’s comments like yours that I found the most unsupportive while BFing.

If a mother is struggling is absolutely is a problem to be fixed.

The ‘well too bad this is a baby, such it up’ is unhelpful not to mention actually unsupportive.
Luckily there have been some useful comments here because it’s not normal for a baby to scream for hours every evening.

honeylulu · 31/03/2023 16:25

Mine really preferred being put to bed in the dark and quiet. No noise, no lights. My eldest used to get cross and glare at me if I stayed in the room. I was wary about sids advice and used to sit in the doorway just out of sight. Younger one preferred me to stay in the room but I had to be very still and quiet or she would squawk at me. Once they were asleep i could sneak in and out to have my dinner, have a quick bath etc. I'd also watch/ read stuff on my tablet so i felt like i was "getting an evening". I did breastfeed but was advised to NOT feed to sleep (I was going back to work before 6m both times so I needed them to not rely on my boots being a human dummy!) I'm just saying this because staying downstairs for the evening while you do normal stuff is not what all babies are happy with. Also an early evening bedtime establishes a good habit.

MrsMullerBecameABaby · 31/03/2023 16:20

AliceAbsolum · 31/03/2023 11:32

But how did you get them to sleep in the living room? If we put her down she screams her head off!

I just used to carry them about/ sit with DH on the sofa with them on my chest/ give them to DH when not feeding.

I have 3 kids and DH worked away from when the older two were nearly 2 and nearly two months, and I just kept DC2 in a wrap carrier when looking after DC1/ doing her story etc and putting her to bed (dc2 was coincidentally my best night time sleeper despite not being put down for naps or to bed until I went to bed).

I started bedtime routines and putting to bed and coming back downstairs for each child at around the time they became mobile - around 7-8 months.

Coyoacan · 31/03/2023 16:03

My mother helped me to train my dd out of being breastfed to sleep. We used to take turns walking around with her in our arms singing to her all the time to get her to sleep. It took about 3 nights and then she was fine.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 31/03/2023 15:55

The walk in the fresh air would do wonders.

carriedout · 31/03/2023 15:45

AliceAbsolum · 31/03/2023 11:32

But how did you get them to sleep in the living room? If we put her down she screams her head off!

We just held them, put them to bed when we went up.

The one holding the baby got waited on Grin

KaleFairy · 31/03/2023 15:42

We did a swing/rocker in the living room where she would happily sleep while we watched TV, checked her frequently, and never left her unattended. I know rockers are controversial but it worked well for us.