Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why does the UK have such low productivity compared other advanced economies?

166 replies

Fifi1010 · 31/03/2023 09:37

Our economic productivity has grown 0.8 percent per year on average since 2008 compared with 2 percent before. Why is that? High productivity increases the tax receipts , money for schools and healthcare. If we don't improve productivity living standards will further decline. Where have we gone wrong? I know Brexit is a problem but this started 8 years before.

OP posts:
Bucketheadbucketbum · 31/03/2023 12:12

In the UK It doesn't pay to work more, loose benefits, hit higher tax bands etc

Itsbytheby · 31/03/2023 12:09

Kpo58 · 31/03/2023 11:14

Because the government:

  • refuses to make childcare available & affordable to everyone which pushes a good % out of the workforce
  • doesn't value education (hence why we have so many funding cuts and the further education is unaffordable)
  • doesn't value the health of the nation (hence the lack of preventative healthcare, being able to catch things early and they love allowing companies to put in random chemicals for in our food)
  • doesn't like people to have a stable home, which is why they don't like investing in housing and would much rather that people have to move every year or 2 if you are renting.
  • doesn't like people to have good mental health and would much rather that people worked all hours of the day in a small cupboard at home rather than actually talk to another human. They also like making public transport unusable and unaffordable outside large city centres. They also like making moral boost entertainment such as pubs, social clubs, etc to be unviable due to high taxes, rent and building rates. Building over all green spaces is an extra bonus in their eyes.

It turns out that an sick, stressed, unhappy and poorly educated workforce isn't actually very good at working effectively. Who would have known? 🤷‍♀️

this basically.

Takeitonthechin · 31/03/2023 12:09

sst1234 · 31/03/2023 09:40

Because of part time tax credits culture. The last labour government damaged the economy hugely by introducing tax credits and subsidizing low wages. Employers have no incentive to invest in productivity and automation because they can get cheap labour subsidized by the taxpayer. This is arguably the worst policy introduced by any government in the last 25 years, because of the long term irreversible damage it has caused, making the whole country poorer.

Exactly this, the poster is absolutely bang on with this.

Cornettoninja · 31/03/2023 12:07

It turns out that an sick, stressed, unhappy and poorly educated workforce isn't actually very good at working effectively. Who would have known? 🤷‍♀️

completely agree. I would only add that creation of innovation and business is hampered by lack of security socially (housing, col, transport etc.) which deters people from taking risks with their employment and education.

Neededanewuserhandle · 31/03/2023 12:02

One other issue is countries like the USA have a lot of raw materials and production and processing of those for export and domestic consumption gives and automatic productivity advantage over places like us. China continues to exploit their coal reserves to provide power - we shut down our coal industry despite having reserves remaining.

Kazzyhoward · 31/03/2023 12:01

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 31/03/2023 11:57

Most posts seem to mention lack of industry and produced items tbough.

But we're still 9th in the World in producing things though, i.e. manufacturing, which isn't bad at all considering the size of our relatively small country! We're clearly still doing something right!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 31/03/2023 11:57

sst1234 · 31/03/2023 09:57

Not sure you understand how productivity works. Service industry also contributes to ‘production’.

Most posts seem to mention lack of industry and produced items tbough.

Kazzyhoward · 31/03/2023 11:56

Tekkentime · 31/03/2023 11:47

We don't produce anything and most of our jobs aren't real jobs.

The UK is the ninth largest manufacturing nation in the World, so we're punching above our weight as we're not the 9th largest in terms of size, population, etc.

https://www.makeuk.org/insights/publications/uk-manufacturing-the-facts--2022#/

UK Manufacturing, The Facts 2022

Make UK's Manufacturing Facts 2022 card shines light on the latest UK manufacturing facts and statistics - Despite Covid & Brexit the UK Manufacturing sector remains strong keeping UK at the 9th largest manufacturing nation in the world.

https://www.makeuk.org/insights/publications/uk-manufacturing-the-facts--2022#/

Tekkentime · 31/03/2023 11:47

We don't produce anything and most of our jobs aren't real jobs.

Kazzyhoward · 31/03/2023 11:47

@CuteOrangeElephant

In the Netherlands: got a phone call, scheduled an appointment convenient to me, went to the specialist. Had all my investigations done in one morning (ultrasound, ECG, blood test, basic measuring/weighing, appointment with the consultant), was outside back on my way to work within 2 hours. Got the results via the phone.

So true. Inefficiency and a culture of not caring about waste, peoples' time, etc is endemic in the NHS and that causes lots of issues for workers, carers, etc.

When I first got hearing aids, it took 9 months, several appointments (starting with 3 appointments with the GP alone), one appointment in hospital A for a hearing test, another appointment in hospital B to see the consultant, another appointment in hospital C to have aids issued, then 2 more appointments for "tweaking" that apparently couldn't be done at the first issue! That was a lot of time off work, journeys, cost of parking, etc

When they needed replacement, I went private. Everything, literally everything done in one appointment, from checking the ears, through to hearing test, through to being handed the aids, and a very comprehensive "tweaking" to ensure they were set correctly when I left the room, all within an hour! There was an offer to go back for further "tweaking" but it wasn't necessary as she'd set them correctly!

Calling · 31/03/2023 11:44

A factor could be because there are far fewer manufacturing companies in the UK now and owners have moved plants abroad, removing jobs.

Also, several industries were closed down in the 1980s in the north

Kazzyhoward · 31/03/2023 11:42

We don't want our little darlings to get their hands dirty with manual work, trades, manufacturing, etc.! We'd far rather they went to Uni for 3 years to get a Mickey Mouse degree and then work in call centres, retail or hospitality on minimum wage!

CuteOrangeElephant · 31/03/2023 11:34

It's the lack of investment and vision.

Take for instance the house buying process. I don't think there is another western country where the process is so unsure and convoluted. A lot of time, money and energy goes into the conveyancing process, it just gets sucked in and produces nothing of value.

Healthcare. This is purely anecdotal. I have had the same cardiac investigations done in the UK and in the Netherlands.

In the UK: I had to take pretty much 3 days off work, just sat around the hospital awaiting different investigations, scheduled on different days, at inconvenient times.

In the Netherlands: got a phone call, scheduled an appointment convenient to me, went to the specialist. Had all my investigations done in one morning (ultrasound, ECG, blood test, basic measuring/weighing, appointment with the consultant), was outside back on my way to work within 2 hours. Got the results via the phone.

Now I bet the UK option is more efficient for the NHS, but in the overall picture the Netherlands wins.

duoplik · 31/03/2023 11:23

We also have wealth inequality

duoplik · 31/03/2023 11:20

Plus lack of investment in tech & education

duoplik · 31/03/2023 11:19

And crap wages & high rents propped up tax payers

duoplik · 31/03/2023 11:18

Never recovered from 08, QE, wage stagnation

CalistoNoSolo · 31/03/2023 11:16

Lack of investment in infrastructure, R&D and education. Its really that simple.

Kpo58 · 31/03/2023 11:14

Because the government:

  • refuses to make childcare available & affordable to everyone which pushes a good % out of the workforce
  • doesn't value education (hence why we have so many funding cuts and the further education is unaffordable)
  • doesn't value the health of the nation (hence the lack of preventative healthcare, being able to catch things early and they love allowing companies to put in random chemicals for in our food)
  • doesn't like people to have a stable home, which is why they don't like investing in housing and would much rather that people have to move every year or 2 if you are renting.
  • doesn't like people to have good mental health and would much rather that people worked all hours of the day in a small cupboard at home rather than actually talk to another human. They also like making public transport unusable and unaffordable outside large city centres. They also like making moral boost entertainment such as pubs, social clubs, etc to be unviable due to high taxes, rent and building rates. Building over all green spaces is an extra bonus in their eyes.

It turns out that an sick, stressed, unhappy and poorly educated workforce isn't actually very good at working effectively. Who would have known? 🤷‍♀️

Phineyj · 31/03/2023 11:10

www.makeuk.org/insights/publications/uk-manufacturing-the-facts--2022#/

We're 9th in the world (size of manufacturing sector).

My husband lectures in manufacturing and the vast majority of the students he trains are not from the UK, which tells you some about how the sector is perceived, however.

Phineyj · 31/03/2023 11:06

We do make things. We have a smaller manufacturing sector than comparable economies but it's not true to say we have none. Government policy on energy, trade, visas, transportation, education, housing (basically everything!) has made life hard for manufacturing though.

There are two UK specific issues to do with how productivity is measured. The financial services industry is one of the most productive industries in terms of value created. It has not recovered from 2008 and BREXIT has been a further blow. And propping up failing banks is hardly productive.

It is also harder to measure productivity in services as output is harder to quantify.

The main reasons I believe do lie in the labour market though, so previous posters have identified lots of relevant issues.

This is an accessible introduction to productivity:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/business-36497843

Sugarfree23 · 31/03/2023 10:59

We got rid of just about all industries, both heavy and light and became a service economy. You need to actually make and sell stuff to make money.

Go back 50 years, there were millions of men (usually) earning decent money in shipbuilding, steel works to serve the shipbuilding, and also motor manufacturing and lots of smaller businesses on the back of them. And thousands of men in mining.

There used to also be millions of women in light industries, electronic factories and in textiles. Those jobs are now mainly in China and places like India.

Not having a minimum wage pushed wages up, people would move to a different job for a 30p an hour more. Companies trying to retain staff would up the money. Now everyone pays the same so wages don't rise.

HungryMum101 · 31/03/2023 10:55

Lots of reasons, but I notice that hard work doesn’t pay like it used to. When assets make more money and are taxed less than salaries, it’s a shit show.

vinividivinci · 31/03/2023 10:49

Apologies for typos and errors, I am rushing a bot.

vinividivinci · 31/03/2023 10:47

It is a very interesting question, and probably one that people with a much better understanding of economics and the international marketplace will be a**ble to answer.

However, the story that I have heard of the decline of the British economy goes something like this.

Once, after being one of the first countries to industrialise, we became the 'workshop of the world', supplying and trading goods and resources inside and outside the 'Empire'.

Then, after over-expansion, and two world wars, the country and the economy was left in a much 'weaker' position in the world.

During the sixties, and seventies, many other countries modernised and rebuilt their economies much more thoroughly and successfully than Britain. Trad union and management relationships were disastrous in this country, perhaps due to militance and the relics of an archaic class system that make overt distinctions between 'workers' and 'management'.

As others have said, primary industries (e.g. mining) and secondary industries (e.g. manufacturing) were deliberately neglected, nationalised companies were sold and 'consumerism' and the service economy were prioritised.

The apparent GDP was falsely inflated by vastly inflated property prices, and the minority of super-rich people.

Welfare systems became over-burdened and under-resourced, due to the governments (of whatever shade) no investing in industry, innovation and productivity, but instead following the tenets of 'austerity' and penalising welfare claimants. In a sense, Liz Truss with her mantra of 'Growth, growth growth!' was correct, but the question of how do we grow when we may no longer have the foundations for growth? always remained.

So, the poverty of this country is nothing new. I will not rattle any cages by mentioning leaving the EU, however, leaving the largest trading group in the world, when we have so little to offer, was not a good idea, in my opinion.